ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

Disagree if you wish. However, I'd say for one that has 4 computers in the shack, two different versions of Windows operating systems, two monitors, and specifically; " I have a Win-11 box that is dedicated to ham radio. It has one main general logging program, a few contest loggers, it is connected to my IC-7610 for HF and 6m, and it is connected to my IC-905 for 2m-70cm-23cm-13cm-5cm-3cm work. It has one huge 32-inch x 14-inch flat-panel monitor that can display my logger and FL-DIGI or WSJT-X side-by-side. It is presently working meteor scatter on 50.260, we are at the peak period of the Geminids shower today. About the only outside WEB connections to this one is SOTA, POTA, LoTW and QRZ." Frankly and candidly, That is a LOT of DANG applications one is expected to run at the same time. Specially for one that claims " Because I know I don’t know Jack when something goes wrong,......". To me, that's like throwing a lit match at a bucket of gasoline and hopping it doesn't explode.

I have one DELL Optiplex 7020 with dual HD's, one solid state and one mechanical, and 32 GB of RAM, It runs everything........successfully. And yes, I run two applications of WSJT-x controlling 2 different radios, on two different bands at the same time.


I'll look for you on 6M and 2M MSK-144.

73

Bob, K4TAX



On 12/13/2024 11:11 AM, Mike Olbrisch wrote:

No Bob � I disagree on one portion below. There is a third group � and I might qualify for president of that group. Call us Group-C. We are the folks who know damn well we haven’t a clue. It’s like this. Software is magical, and I am no magician. Because I know I don’t know Jack when something goes wrong, I do my very best to not screw it up. I rely on Norton to pull me through a lot of stuff. I actually have 4 computers in the shack.

FACT: If it wasn’t for NORTON and PEOPLE LIKE YOU the stuff this old retired soldier plays with might not be working. I’m pretty certain I can safely say us Group-C people really appreciate the help you Group-A people throw at is. It’s a solid fear of screwing something up that makes me hesitate in every move or change!


I have one “main� computer, the one I am on at the moment. It is Win-10, and says it is not upgradable to Win-11. I use it for E-mail, and all MS-OFFICE functions, spreadsheets and documents, photos�. The usual stuff. It has two bit 27-inch curved monitors and 16-GB ram�.. wish it had more ram! Because this computer is used for nearly everything, it is the most in danger of giving me issues.

The 2nd, I have a Win-11 box that is dedicated to ham radio. It has one main general logging program, a few contest loggers, it is connected to my IC-7610 for HF and 6m, and it is connected to my IC-905 for 2m-70cm-23cm-13cm-5cm-3cm work. It has one huge 32-inch x 14-inch flat-panel monitor that can display my logger and FL-DIGI or WSJT-X side-by-side. It is presently working meteor scatter on 50.260, we are at the peak period of the Geminids shower today. About the only outside WEB connections to this one is SOTA, POTA, LoTW and QRZ.

The 3rd computer is an ASUS lap-top dedicated strictly to SOTA-POTA-PORTABLE operations. It is configured to connect to a Wi-Fi hotspot that also connects to my Icom IC-705, and I can wirelessly operate the radio and all digital and logging data is shared between them. This one will run 8 to 12 hours on a single charge. Connections again limited to SOTA, POTA, LoTW and QRZ.

The 4th is an older ASUS net-book. It is dedicated to the old AX-25 Packet Terminal on a 2-w VHF radio. It is not connected to the web, and it was recently upgraded to Win-11, but other than checking for updates is not normally connected to the Wi-Fi. It was the former portable computer until battery life started to get shorter.

Today � right this moment � everything is functioning perfectly. E-mail is coming in and out, the spreadsheet I am working on is functioning, and the other computer has snagged AZ, CA, TX and UT on meteor scatter so far this morning. But the day is young. Plenty of time to screw something up and still make it to dinner on time.

THANK YOU � all you GROUP-A folks, from group-C folks like me. I have many skills, but software ain’t one of them. Your input is greatly appreciated!

Vy73 - Mike - KD5KC.

El Paso, Texas - DM61rt.

SOTA W5T-Texas Association Manager.




From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Bob McGraw - K4TAX
Sent: Friday, December 13, 2024 9:31 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

If the issue is with the installer or setup application, CCleaner won't fix that. If the issue is with the computer having corrupted files, junk files, etc. CCleaner will most likely correct that.

The issue with blaming Microsoft Windows for issues is really not a MS issue. I don't see nor understand how MS can be assured every application ever written in the world will run with MS Windows. Think about it. It is the responsibility of the writer of the application to assure it runs correctly with MS Windows. If MS updates Windows, it is again the responsibility of the computer operator, or the writer of the application to assure the system is updated and compatible with MS Windows.

Many, many, many issues are largely due to improper computer configurations, conflicting applications (which is a big one) and generally poor computer maintenance. I've harped on this more than once. You do perform regular computer back ups don't you? You do scan for broken file links, unused links, fragmented files, and such on a regular basis don't you? You do run a in-depth Malware scan on a regular basis, or do you sit back and expect the computer and its applications to do this for you. Ha! It ain't gonna happen. One has to perform some regular computer house cleaning on a regular basis. If not, you are just muddling around in a pile of trash code with most likely unknown outcome and of course, blaming it on something else. Well, if one wants to blame it on something else, go look in the mirror.

Now if you read this far, there are two kinds of folks: (a) those that know what they are doing, and (b) those that think they know what they are doing. Please seek assistance if you are in the (b) group, presuming you know you aren't in the (a) group.

I've updated this computer to the latest release of FLDIGI V4.2.06.14. The setup works by a simple double click. At least mine does, so why doesn't yours? It creates its own sub-directory (oh you changed that????) and ICON on the screen to launch the application. If I can use Windows 10 Pro 64 bit, and the released version of FLDIGI successfully, what do you suppose might be the issue? If you add something and it doesn't work, then back out and do something different. Adding more and more and changing this and that is likely to cause more issues and not resolve the initial issue. I've asked more than one person, what did you do before you did that? They seemingly changed and changed and changed and have no clue as to why or what. The more one adds to the problem solving issue, the more complex things get in resolving problems. KISS is the better motto.

Now, if you've read this far, if I can easily make the application install, load and run correctly, so can you. Can't you?

73

Bob, K4TAX

P.S. - If what I wrote upsets you......so be it. Do I need to explain where the DELETE key is located?

On 12/13/2024 12:05 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

The problem was not fixed by CCleaner or Revo. Others have had this problem so it is not limited to me (see: [email protected] | Double-clicking setup.exe does nothing)

The way I see it, the problem is with the installer. If it was a normal .ZIP file, I doubt there would be any issues. Right-click it, select Extract All, run setup.exe, done.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 8:29 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

I second Bob (K4TAX) on CCleaner. It has saved my bacon many times when things get gnarly like your install woes.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 5:29 PM, Bob McGraw - K4TAX wrote:

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".

I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX

On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

                
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

                
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

                
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

                
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

                
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

                  
I don't see that at all.

                  
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

                  
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

                  
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                  

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

              

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

You are living in a very dangerous and uncertain world of computers. If something changes on my computer, I WANT TO KNOW ABOUT IT!

73

Bob, K4TAX



On 12/13/2024 10:54 AM, Steve K4RVA via groups.io wrote:

One of the first things that I do when I install Windows is to turn off that "feature". That way I get to decide what I install on my computer, Windows does not.


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

No Bob � I disagree on one portion below. There is a third group � and I might qualify for president of that group. Call us Group-C. We are the folks who know damn well we haven’t a clue. It’s like this. Software is magical, and I am no magician. Because I know I don’t know Jack when something goes wrong, I do my very best to not screw it up. I rely on Norton to pull me through a lot of stuff. I actually have 4 computers in the shack.

FACT: If it wasn’t for NORTON and PEOPLE LIKE YOU the stuff this old retired soldier plays with might not be working. I’m pretty certain I can safely say us Group-C people really appreciate the help you Group-A people throw at is. It’s a solid fear of screwing something up that makes me hesitate in every move or change!


I have one “main� computer, the one I am on at the moment. It is Win-10, and says it is not upgradable to Win-11. I use it for E-mail, and all MS-OFFICE functions, spreadsheets and documents, photos�. The usual stuff. It has two bit 27-inch curved monitors and 16-GB ram�.. wish it had more ram! Because this computer is used for nearly everything, it is the most in danger of giving me issues.

The 2nd, I have a Win-11 box that is dedicated to ham radio. It has one main general logging program, a few contest loggers, it is connected to my IC-7610 for HF and 6m, and it is connected to my IC-905 for 2m-70cm-23cm-13cm-5cm-3cm work. It has one huge 32-inch x 14-inch flat-panel monitor that can display my logger and FL-DIGI or WSJT-X side-by-side. It is presently working meteor scatter on 50.260, we are at the peak period of the Geminids shower today. About the only outside WEB connections to this one is SOTA, POTA, LoTW and QRZ.

The 3rd computer is an ASUS lap-top dedicated strictly to SOTA-POTA-PORTABLE operations. It is configured to connect to a Wi-Fi hotspot that also connects to my Icom IC-705, and I can wirelessly operate the radio and all digital and logging data is shared between them. This one will run 8 to 12 hours on a single charge. Connections again limited to SOTA, POTA, LoTW and QRZ.

The 4th is an older ASUS net-book. It is dedicated to the old AX-25 Packet Terminal on a 2-w VHF radio. It is not connected to the web, and it was recently upgraded to Win-11, but other than checking for updates is not normally connected to the Wi-Fi. It was the former portable computer until battery life started to get shorter.

Today � right this moment � everything is functioning perfectly. E-mail is coming in and out, the spreadsheet I am working on is functioning, and the other computer has snagged AZ, CA, TX and UT on meteor scatter so far this morning. But the day is young. Plenty of time to screw something up and still make it to dinner on time.

THANK YOU � all you GROUP-A folks, from group-C folks like me. I have many skills, but software ain’t one of them. Your input is greatly appreciated!

Vy73 - Mike - KD5KC.

El Paso, Texas - DM61rt.

SOTA W5T-Texas Association Manager.




From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Bob McGraw - K4TAX
Sent: Friday, December 13, 2024 9:31 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

If the issue is with the installer or setup application, CCleaner won't fix that. If the issue is with the computer having corrupted files, junk files, etc. CCleaner will most likely correct that.

The issue with blaming Microsoft Windows for issues is really not a MS issue. I don't see nor understand how MS can be assured every application ever written in the world will run with MS Windows. Think about it. It is the responsibility of the writer of the application to assure it runs correctly with MS Windows. If MS updates Windows, it is again the responsibility of the computer operator, or the writer of the application to assure the system is updated and compatible with MS Windows.

Many, many, many issues are largely due to improper computer configurations, conflicting applications (which is a big one) and generally poor computer maintenance. I've harped on this more than once. You do perform regular computer back ups don't you? You do scan for broken file links, unused links, fragmented files, and such on a regular basis don't you? You do run a in-depth Malware scan on a regular basis, or do you sit back and expect the computer and its applications to do this for you. Ha! It ain't gonna happen. One has to perform some regular computer house cleaning on a regular basis. If not, you are just muddling around in a pile of trash code with most likely unknown outcome and of course, blaming it on something else. Well, if one wants to blame it on something else, go look in the mirror.

Now if you read this far, there are two kinds of folks: (a) those that know what they are doing, and (b) those that think they know what they are doing. Please seek assistance if you are in the (b) group, presuming you know you aren't in the (a) group.

I've updated this computer to the latest release of FLDIGI V4.2.06.14. The setup works by a simple double click. At least mine does, so why doesn't yours? It creates its own sub-directory (oh you changed that????) and ICON on the screen to launch the application. If I can use Windows 10 Pro 64 bit, and the released version of FLDIGI successfully, what do you suppose might be the issue? If you add something and it doesn't work, then back out and do something different. Adding more and more and changing this and that is likely to cause more issues and not resolve the initial issue. I've asked more than one person, what did you do before you did that? They seemingly changed and changed and changed and have no clue as to why or what. The more one adds to the problem solving issue, the more complex things get in resolving problems. KISS is the better motto.

Now, if you've read this far, if I can easily make the application install, load and run correctly, so can you. Can't you?

73

Bob, K4TAX

P.S. - If what I wrote upsets you......so be it. Do I need to explain where the DELETE key is located?

On 12/13/2024 12:05 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

The problem was not fixed by CCleaner or Revo. Others have had this problem so it is not limited to me (see: [email protected] | Double-clicking setup.exe does nothing)

The way I see it, the problem is with the installer. If it was a normal .ZIP file, I doubt there would be any issues. Right-click it, select Extract All, run setup.exe, done.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 8:29 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

I second Bob (K4TAX) on CCleaner. It has saved my bacon many times when things get gnarly like your install woes.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 5:29 PM, Bob McGraw - K4TAX wrote:

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".

I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX

On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:
I don't see that at all.
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: fldigi 4.2.06.15 developmen t version availabe for testing

 

Tobias,

I am a little concerned about the difference between pathsim and linsim emulation results. I retested using my favorite 'Jabberwocky' text. I ran emulaltions for zero db AWGN, two path disburbed with 7 msec path two delay, and then with the disturbed and AWGN combined. The resulting wav and text files are attached in the compressed archive. Pathsim was run on a Linux machine using the Windows emulator, Crossover. I normalized the output audio files to -3 dB peak. Pathsim and Linsim give a slightly different output level. I use my own program, comptext, on the Linux machine to make the text file comparisons. The text files were cleaned up by removing leading and trailing trash characters.

TEST
Pathsim Errors
Linsim Errors
0 dB AWGN
0
0
Disturbed 7 msec
1
1
Combined
6
0

Later today I will review the linsim code to be sure that the combination of multipath and AWGN is coded correctly.

David

On 12/12/24 16:12, T² via groups.io wrote:


Hello David,

Great thanks for all the work you've put into this new version!


Attached are my simulation results so far.


In a nutshell, there's light and shadow, as they say...


The 1st spreadsheet 'LinSim+PathSim_Comparison_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_THOR25_2024-12-12.xls' has a new 1st sheet 'PathSim NVIS THOR25 v4.2.06.15' which actually contains a LinSim and a PathSim result side by side.

While a LinSim created file returned the text flawlessly (!) twice, PathSim has produced even a few more errors than with the previous FLdigi test version v4.2.06.14.


For all simulations, I use the same definition, see 'T_LinSim+PathSim_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_AWGN_SNR_0dB_THOR25_1500Hz_2024-12-12.png', I hope that's correct.

When looking at the resulting average spectrum (ignoring the first and last about 5 seconds to stay well within the THOR25 signal), LinSim appears to produce a spectrum with about 1 dB less noise (I just selected the lowest and highest THOR25 frequency peak in both cases for the table), relative to the signal peaks. See the 2 screenshots made in Audacity. This doesn't appear that much, and I would not assume that this could explain the differences in the results.


In the 2nd sheet 'SNR LinSim NVIS THOR25 v.06.15', the SNR and FEC evaluation over time is shown for the LinSim result. It does look a lot less 'disturbed' than in the 3rd sheet.


In the 3rd sheet 'SNR PathSim NVIS THOR25 v.06.15', the same is evaluated for the PathSim result. It has more and partly higher FEC error rates than the LinSim result.
Also, the average SNR is 1 dB lower than in LinSim, which is in phase with the average Audacity results mentioned above.

=> So maybe better just give up on the PathSim method?


- - - - - -


An extra test and evaluation was run, using the same long DL0BS intro text, but a more severe scenario with AWGN set at -6 dB instead of the 'standard' 0 dB used before.

The results are shown in the 2nd attached spreadsheet 'U_LinSim_+_PathSim_Comparison_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_at_-6dB_AWGN_THOR25_vs_MFSK32_2024-12-12.xls'.

Unfortunately, despite the slower transfer speed in THOR25, the error rate turned out significantly higher than in the noticeably faster MFSK32 mode. Admittedly, for MFSK32, the best case was chosen, with no decoding center offset. But it will tolerate a few Hz up or down and still do the job.


- - - - - -


Well, I certainly cannot explain why there remains such a difference between the LinSim and PathSim methods that should, I would assume, produce nearly equivalent results. I do lean towards using LinSim from now on, but still have a tendency to test the PathSim result as well, just to have full comparability with any previous evaluations.

And, even more importantly, the difference between MFSK32 and THOR25 still puzzles and concerns me.


- - - - - -


Signal shaping: I have kept the '100' default and cosine-shaped ramps are present at both ends now. Brilliant!


- - - - - -


Increase AFC low pass filter range to 500: great, this really slows down the AFC speed!

But well, I just tried it, set at 500, on the 'severe' -6 dB MFSK track simulated earlier (in cont. loop), set it to 1506 and activated AFC.
After a little while, it started creeping toward 1500, but then it didn't stop (!) but continued moving off all the way to 1492 (still decoding!), and then slowly returned upwards, all the way up to 1509, before reversing again. It then went down until 1485, barely decoding any more, and then moved up again, quickly regaining the decoding threshold. And then further up beyond 1500 again. I hope this will be visible in the log file. As I type this, it has reached 1518 Hz and lost decoding again, yet still moving up...
Now beyond 1520 Hz, I'll stop the test shortly. Seconds later, at 1530 Hz, and still moving further up, I close FLdigi and look at the log file.
Yes, the logfile has tracked much of the variations (until decoding failed entirely), see 'MFSK32_AFC_Test_@...':

Unfortunately, this does not really look as if the AFC did, at least within certain offset limits, lock on to the signal in any way. But maybe, hopefully, with a received RSID and shorter messages, and a better signal, the slow AFC may help keep the offset at bay...?


- - - - - -


That wraps up my investigation for tonight, and I hope it's not too frustrating as a tester feedback...


Thanks again David!


73s Tobias
.-.-.
Am Donnerstag, 12. Dezember 2024 um 18:13:49 MEZ hat Dave <w1hkj@...> Folgendes geschrieben:


Posted at

Most recent three changes to the program:

commit ad817413f9d517a88b9156d48cc28f3a0b53c92c
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Mon Dec 9 15:05:42 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* Increase AFC low pass filter range to 500.

commit 68e700918a9517b6825c94365037ae07fbb57fd3
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Thu Dec 12 09:23:27 2024 -0600

THOR-25

* add new THOR modem with following characteristics
. symlen = 320
. samplerate = 8000
. flushlength = 20
. bandwidth = 460
. IEEE coefficients for viterbi encode/decode algorithms
THOR_K15 15
K15_POLY1 044735
K15_POLY2 063057
. objective to provide highest baud within 500 Hertz bandwidth for
European amateurs
* assigned secondary RsID code 691 to THOR-25
* increased flush length for all THOR baud rates
* added configurable start and end of signal shaping to these modem types:
. dominoEX
. psk
. mfsk
. rtty
. thor
. selectable on configuration tab Modem/General

commit 8aa6a3ea07596d0c61e57462c8ffe1bae939339b
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Wed Nov 27 15:49:26 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* add configuration item allowing user to adjust the decay
averaging of the AFC tracking.

73, David
W1HKJ



Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

One of the first things that I do when I install Windows is to turn off that "feature". That way I get to decide what I install on my computer, Windows does not.


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

If the issue is with the installer or setup application, CCleaner won't fix that. If the issue is with the computer having corrupted files, junk files, etc. CCleaner will most likely correct that.

The issue with blaming Microsoft Windows for issues is really not a MS issue. I don't see nor understand how MS can be assured every application ever written in the world will run with MS Windows. Think about it. It is the responsibility of the writer of the application to assure it runs correctly with MS Windows. If MS updates Windows, it is again the responsibility of the computer operator, or the writer of the application to assure the system is updated and compatible with MS Windows.

Many, many, many issues are largely due to improper computer configurations, conflicting applications (which is a big one) and generally poor computer maintenance. I've harped on this more than once. You do perform regular computer back ups don't you? You do scan for broken file links, unused links, fragmented files, and such on a regular basis don't you? You do run a in-depth Malware scan on a regular basis, or do you sit back and expect the computer and its applications to do this for you. Ha! It ain't gonna happen. One has to perform some regular computer house cleaning on a regular basis. If not, you are just muddling around in a pile of trash code with most likely unknown outcome and of course, blaming it on something else. Well, if one wants to blame it on something else, go look in the mirror.

Now if you read this far, there are two kinds of folks: (a) those that know what they are doing, and (b) those that think they know what they are doing. Please seek assistance if you are in the (b) group, presuming you know you aren't in the (a) group.

I've updated this computer to the latest release of FLDIGI V4.2.06.14. The setup works by a simple double click. At least mine does, so why doesn't yours? It creates its own sub-directory (oh you changed that????) and ICON on the screen to launch the application. If I can use Windows 10 Pro 64 bit, and the released version of FLDIGI successfully, what do you suppose might be the issue? If you add something and it doesn't work, then back out and do something different. Adding more and more and changing this and that is likely to cause more issues and not resolve the initial issue. I've asked more than one person, what did you do before you did that? They seemingly changed and changed and changed and have no clue as to why or what. The more one adds to the problem solving issue, the more complex things get in resolving problems. KISS is the better motto.

Now, if you've read this far, if I can easily make the application install, load and run correctly, so can you. Can't you?

73

Bob, K4TAX

P.S. - If what I wrote upsets you......so be it. Do I need to explain where the DELETE key is located?


On 12/13/2024 12:05 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

The problem was not fixed by CCleaner or Revo. Others have had this problem so it is not limited to me (see: [email protected] | Double-clicking setup.exe does nothing)

The way I see it, the problem is with the installer. If it was a normal .ZIP file, I doubt there would be any issues. Right-click it, select Extract All, run setup.exe, done.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 8:29 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

I second Bob (K4TAX) on CCleaner. It has saved my bacon many times when things get gnarly like your install woes.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 5:29 PM, Bob McGraw - K4TAX wrote:

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".

I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX

On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

              
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

              
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

              
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

              
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

              
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

                
I don't see that at all.

                
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

                
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

                
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

                

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

            

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob Morrow
 

The problem was not fixed by CCleaner or Revo. Others have had this problem so it is not limited to me (see: [email protected] | Double-clicking setup.exe does nothing)

The way I see it, the problem is with the installer. If it was a normal .ZIP file, I doubt there would be any issues. Right-click it, select Extract All, run setup.exe, done.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 8:29 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

I second Bob (K4TAX) on CCleaner. It has saved my bacon many times when things get gnarly like your install woes.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 5:29 PM, Bob McGraw - K4TAX wrote:

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".

I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX

On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:
I don't see that at all.
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

I second Bob (K4TAX) on CCleaner. It has saved my bacon many times when things get gnarly like your install woes.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 5:29 PM, Bob McGraw - K4TAX wrote:

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".


I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX


On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

            
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

            
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

            
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

            
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

            
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

              
I don't see that at all.

              
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

              
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

              
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

              

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

          

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

I suggest one needs to "clean their computer".


I use CCLeaner to scan for broken links, registry issues the results of programs being installed and then uninstalled. I find VERY OFTEN the uninstall application associated with a program will leave a good bit of trash on the system. The version I used is a paid version but the FREE version will likely do what is needed. Some say that CCleaner causes issues, well yes it can erase your entire hard-drive if you command it to do so. But if it is used as intended and it is VERY simple and straight forward to use, it does wonders without damaging any files or applications. I've been using it for years, and doing regular computer maintenance, and experience ZERO issues with Windows 10 and any application including FLDIGI.

If you are NOT doing regular computer maintenance, thny you leave the door wide open for issues.

73

Bob, K4TAX


On 12/12/2024 2:08 PM, Bob Morrow wrote:

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

          
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

          
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

          
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

          
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

          
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

            
I don't see that at all.

            
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

            
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

            
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

            

          

          

          

          

          

          

          

          

          

          

          

        

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: FLrig Remotely Accessed Scanning Script

 

Charles,

I used to have a python based xmlrpc script to do this, but I cant find it. If I do find it I will share it.

That said if you DO have hamlib, you can easily use rigctl to talk to FLrig to achieve the same results.

For hamlib/rigctl you need to use driver # 4.

So something like this as simple as placing in a cron task in linux:

/usr/local/bin/rigctl -m 4 -r 127.0.0.1:12345 F 14106500 

Where as that argument for '-r' is the flrig instance.

73 n9seo


RF Spectrum of new alpha mode THOR25 with Fldigi

 

THOR 25


Here is the RF Spectrum of the new (alpha) mode THOR25

sent on 441.525 simplex FM with no PL tone


Rig: Icom 2820 (set to 1200 baud) and Masters Communications DRA SR sound card


Deviation set to about 2.2 kHz (since amplitude of pair of first sidebands = carrier amplitude)

Recorded on RSP duo hardware and RSP Spectrum Analyzer software


Let's test this new (alpha) mode soon on the HF SSB nets (Pa NBEMS and MidAtlantic NBEMS) and on local county FM 2m/70cm

source: w1hkj.com/alpha


Dec 12 2024

de k3eui



Re: fldigi 4.2.06.15 developmen t version availabe for testing

 


Hello David,

Great thanks for all the work you've put into this new version!


Attached are my simulation results so far.


In a nutshell, there's light and shadow, as they say...


The 1st spreadsheet 'LinSim+PathSim_Comparison_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_THOR25_2024-12-12.xls' has a new 1st sheet 'PathSim NVIS THOR25 v4.2.06.15' which actually contains a LinSim and a PathSim result side by side.

While a LinSim created file returned the text flawlessly (!) twice, PathSim has produced even a few more errors than with the previous FLdigi test version v4.2.06.14.


For all simulations, I use the same definition, see 'T_LinSim+PathSim_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_AWGN_SNR_0dB_THOR25_1500Hz_2024-12-12.png', I hope that's correct.

When looking at the resulting average spectrum (ignoring the first and last about 5 seconds to stay well within the THOR25 signal), LinSim appears to produce a spectrum with about 1 dB less noise (I just selected the lowest and highest THOR25 frequency peak in both cases for the table), relative to the signal peaks. See the 2 screenshots made in Audacity. This doesn't appear that much, and I would not assume that this could explain the differences in the results.


In the 2nd sheet 'SNR LinSim NVIS THOR25 v.06.15', the SNR and FEC evaluation over time is shown for the LinSim result. It does look a lot less 'disturbed' than in the 3rd sheet.


In the 3rd sheet 'SNR PathSim NVIS THOR25 v.06.15', the same is evaluated for the PathSim result. It has more and partly higher FEC error rates than the LinSim result.
Also, the average SNR is 1 dB lower than in LinSim, which is in phase with the average Audacity results mentioned above.

=> So maybe better just give up on the PathSim method?


- - - - - -


An extra test and evaluation was run, using the same long DL0BS intro text, but a more severe scenario with AWGN set at -6 dB instead of the 'standard' 0 dB used before.

The results are shown in the 2nd attached spreadsheet 'U_LinSim_+_PathSim_Comparison_Mid-Latitude_Disturbed_NVIS_at_-6dB_AWGN_THOR25_vs_MFSK32_2024-12-12.xls'.

Unfortunately, despite the slower transfer speed in THOR25, the error rate turned out significantly higher than in the noticeably faster MFSK32 mode. Admittedly, for MFSK32, the best case was chosen, with no decoding center offset. But it will tolerate a few Hz up or down and still do the job.


- - - - - -


Well, I certainly cannot explain why there remains such a difference between the LinSim and PathSim methods that should, I would assume, produce nearly equivalent results. I do lean towards using LinSim from now on, but still have a tendency to test the PathSim result as well, just to have full comparability with any previous evaluations.

And, even more importantly, the difference between MFSK32 and THOR25 still puzzles and concerns me.


- - - - - -


Signal shaping: I have kept the '100' default and cosine-shaped ramps are present at both ends now. Brilliant!


- - - - - -


Increase AFC low pass filter range to 500: great, this really slows down the AFC speed!

But well, I just tried it, set at 500, on the 'severe' -6 dB MFSK track simulated earlier (in cont. loop), set it to 1506 and activated AFC.
After a little while, it started creeping toward 1500, but then it didn't stop (!) but continued moving off all the way to 1492 (still decoding!), and then slowly returned upwards, all the way up to 1509, before reversing again. It then went down until 1485, barely decoding any more, and then moved up again, quickly regaining the decoding threshold. And then further up beyond 1500 again. I hope this will be visible in the log file. As I type this, it has reached 1518 Hz and lost decoding again, yet still moving up...
Now beyond 1520 Hz, I'll stop the test shortly. Seconds later, at 1530 Hz, and still moving further up, I close FLdigi and look at the log file.
Yes, the logfile has tracked much of the variations (until decoding failed entirely), see 'MFSK32_AFC_Test_@...':

Unfortunately, this does not really look as if the AFC did, at least within certain offset limits, lock on to the signal in any way. But maybe, hopefully, with a received RSID and shorter messages, and a better signal, the slow AFC may help keep the offset at bay...?


- - - - - -


That wraps up my investigation for tonight, and I hope it's not too frustrating as a tester feedback...


Thanks again David!


73s Tobias
.-.-.
Am Donnerstag, 12. Dezember 2024 um 18:13:49 MEZ hat Dave <w1hkj@...> Folgendes geschrieben:


Posted at

Most recent three changes to the program:

commit ad817413f9d517a88b9156d48cc28f3a0b53c92c
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Mon Dec 9 15:05:42 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* Increase AFC low pass filter range to 500.

commit 68e700918a9517b6825c94365037ae07fbb57fd3
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Thu Dec 12 09:23:27 2024 -0600

THOR-25

* add new THOR modem with following characteristics
. symlen = 320
. samplerate = 8000
. flushlength = 20
. bandwidth = 460
. IEEE coefficients for viterbi encode/decode algorithms
THOR_K15 15
K15_POLY1 044735
K15_POLY2 063057
. objective to provide highest baud within 500 Hertz bandwidth for
European amateurs
* assigned secondary RsID code 691 to THOR-25
* increased flush length for all THOR baud rates
* added configurable start and end of signal shaping to these modem types:
. dominoEX
. psk
. mfsk
. rtty
. thor
. selectable on configuration tab Modem/General

commit 8aa6a3ea07596d0c61e57462c8ffe1bae939339b
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Wed Nov 27 15:49:26 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* add configuration item allowing user to adjust the decay
averaging of the AFC tracking.

73, David
W1HKJ


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob Morrow
 

I downloaded the latest, it still didn’t work. I did get the blue screen complaining about it being uncommon software (which I probably got with the earlier version and Windows simply remembered my answer on subsequent attempts to run it), said ‘run anyway�, got the UAC alert, then nothing.

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 12:27 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ

On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.
The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.
Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.
Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:
I don't see that at all.
They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing
Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ

--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

Bob,

I will have to punt on this question now because I have never seen this behavior. I have 3 windows machines: 2 desktop (one 10 and one 11) and a laptop. They all work exactly the same way that I described.

As a last resort to try, I would use a software uninstaller like Revo, check to see if there is any trace of Fldigi anywhere - installation files, code, registry, or configuration files. Make sure you have not given fldigi some sort of application security permission if so revoke it. Eliminate all of remaining traces and reboot.

Download the alpha setup that Dave used from: (fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe)

Go through the install as Dave and I suggested and tell us if you see "better" behavior. After that I have no other suggestions. Dave might be aware of something else to try.

Jack - KD4IZ
On 12/12/2024 10:50 AM, Bob Morrow wrote:
Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

I don't see that at all.

They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ





















--
/i /b Jack Spitznagel, DDS PhD Science River LLC Parkton, MD /b /i


fldigi 4.2.06.15 developmen t version availabe for testing

 

Posted at

Most recent three changes to the program:

commit ad817413f9d517a88b9156d48cc28f3a0b53c92c
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Mon Dec 9 15:05:42 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* Increase AFC low pass filter range to 500.

commit 68e700918a9517b6825c94365037ae07fbb57fd3
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Thu Dec 12 09:23:27 2024 -0600

THOR-25

* add new THOR modem with following characteristics
. symlen = 320
. samplerate = 8000
. flushlength = 20
. bandwidth = 460
. IEEE coefficients for viterbi encode/decode algorithms
THOR_K15 15
K15_POLY1 044735
K15_POLY2 063057
. objective to provide highest baud within 500 Hertz bandwidth for
European amateurs
* assigned secondary RsID code 691 to THOR-25
* increased flush length for all THOR baud rates
* added configurable start and end of signal shaping to these modem types:
. dominoEX
. psk
. mfsk
. rtty
. thor
. selectable on configuration tab Modem/General

commit 8aa6a3ea07596d0c61e57462c8ffe1bae939339b
Author: dave-w1hkj <w1hkj@...>
Date: Wed Nov 27 15:49:26 2024 -0600

MFSK afc

* add configuration item allowing user to adjust the decay
averaging of the AFC tracking.

73, David
W1HKJ


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

The Windows setup exe file is built on a Linux computer, but that should not make any difference to the target machine. I just did the following on a Windows 11 computer with the most recent OS version, updated this morning.
  • computer only uses Microsoft OS with no other virus or malware protection software. I have never had either on any of my Windows computers. I do not visit questionalble sites.
  • opened Edge and browsed to this page:
  • double clicked on the file, fldigi-4.2.06.15_setup.exe and downloaded to the Windows 11 machine
  • Windows Defender / Edge did question the integrity of the downloaded file. I reported the file and web page as safe to Microsoft.
  • opened the File Explorer to the downloads folder and double clicked the newly downloaded setup file
  • jumped through the usual number of burning hoops to insure the OS that I really wanted to open the file
  • normal installation ensued.

73, David, W1HKJ


On 12/12/24 09:50, Bob Morrow wrote:

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

I don't see that at all.

They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack 
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ























Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob Morrow
 

Yes, 4.2.06_setup.exe was what I used.

The other questions:
1 - no
2, 3 - not getting that screen, so no. It goes straight to the Windows UAC prompt.
4 - Windows' UAC did show up, I clicked on Yes.
5 - I didn't see anything after the UAC prompt. Nothing.
6 - Taskbar is not minimized, ribbon is not minimized to the window. I didn't see anything. I do have the taskbar set to show up at the TOP of the screen, but that shouldn't matter.
7 - no aftermarket antivirus or other security stuff. All of the Windows security stuff is at the default settings, I think.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 9:15 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Interesting. Are you trying to install using:
fldigi-4.2.06_setup.exe
-which is the latest non-alpha or beta code?
1. Are you getting a blue pop-up screen trying to stop you?
2. Are you selecting “More options� on that screen?
3. When you do that, do you get another blue screen that gives you the choice of backing out or selecting “Install anyway�?
4. When you do the install anyway, you should get the standard Window UAC panel asking you to confirm installation- 5. If you say yes, you will next get the fldigi installer panel and can select some install options and complete the install.
6 If you don’t see that “permissions� panel in 4 above, then look to see if the window is minimized to your Taskbar and open it, then proceed.

Let us know where what you see deviates from that sequence. It should work unless you have a 3rd party security app and/or the Windows security stuff cranked up and blocking everything.

Jack - KD4IZ
On Dec 11, 2024, at 20:30, Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> wrote:

I don't see that at all.

They should make it a regular .zip file. The help files are, so the executable should be as well.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Jack
Spitznagel (KD4IZ)
Sent: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 5:57 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [winfldigi] double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar ribbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.
If you don’t see it in the taskbar, check the task manager. Either way, you should be able to bring it up onscreen and tell it to finish the installation.
Jack - KD4IZ











Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

This is an important point regarding W11. I don't see it often on W10, but I am regularly wondering what happened to my installation...then when I check the taskbar, I find it in the 'background'. It took me months to develop the habit of checking the taskbar when my installation dialog 'disappeared'. Now it's my go to.

On 2024-12-11 19:57:, Jack Spitznagel (KD4IZ) wrote:

Bob,
On both my Win11 box and my now deprecated Win10 box I get the same “apparent� result� however, if you look in the taskbar riibbon, you will see an icon for the minimized installer waiting for you to OK the installation.


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 

You can't please all the people all the time <grin>. Not sniping. I have been supporting fldigi users for years, and I never recommend using the installer. Our local ARES group publishes a zip file that provides a complete installation when it is unzipped...an installation tailored to our needs. Unzip it where you want it.

But I still get folks who ask why it needs to be so complicated...unzipping an archive, that is...sigh...little is as simple as unzipping a file in the computer world. They ask "Why can't we just install it?" They can. But that brings its own ~potential~ for headaches, as we see here. One of the local hams has created an installer package that unzips the local zip file !!!! and places a shortcut on the desktop, or summat. I havna seen it yet.

It's not uncommon for an installer to be an exe that can be unzipped. For me, it's the best of both worlds. YMMV, for sure.

So in summary, fldigi is both a 'normal' zip file, but with an 'exe' extension, AND an installer. I havna looked at the fldigi docs lately to see what it says right up front about this, but OTOH, I think that the docs ~should~ address this on page 1, and OTO, I realize that most folks just want to download a file and run it, without reading anything...and then spend the time figuring out what they did. It's pretty much what we see everywhere...and I even get feedback from companies I contact about user docs that says exactly that...they find that most folks don't read the docs at all, even when they have a problem. Much easier to post the same question for the 99th time on some forum, without even searching the forum for answers, than it is to read anything.

I taught HS thru uni from 1990 to 2015, and I was surprised at first to hear students...top students, at that...say right up front that they don't read their textbooks. Too much trouble. They figure that faculty will spoon-feed them everything in class that they could have already learned from their texts. In fact, I was 'reviewed' in one of my uni classes after many complaints from students. The department head then called me in to discuss the results. "Prof Messeder expects us to read the text out of class." He just looked at me stunned. How can a uni student ~actually~ write this, he wondered? They were pretty much all like that. (BTW, it was spot on...I don't teach the text. I teach the material. Students are responsible for reading and understanding the text, because they will be tested on it.)

Oops...lots of social commentary there, but that's the state of the state, so to speak.
~R~

On 2024-12-11 19:53:, Bob Morrow wrote:
Now, why isn't the fldigi Windows file a 'normal' .ZIP file?


Re: double-clicking setup.exe does nothing

 


Hello Bob,

Glad this was helpful.

I still 'live' in a happy Win7 World that actually helps users achieve their goal rather than trying to trick them out and make them feel like doing something wrong.

I did try Win10 before and know very well what you complain about.

I assume it is a matter of how the cross-compiler (remember FLdidi is developed on Linux!) into Windows compiles the setup.exe.

As here on Win7, it used to work just fine like a genuine Windows installer program, but M$oft has been infamous of ever more deviating from their good old previous 'standards' and thus just does not do anymore, what used to be 'normal' and expected by their users.

Keeping up with ever changing behavior this from another operating system is more than hard hard, I would assume.

So I have kind of put up with such oddities (to be very polite) and try find my ways to circumvent them best I can.

Zip-like exe files are not unusual, and quite a few other setups and even normal program applications can be opened via 7zip. Not all make sense this way, but luckily FLdigi setup does...


Good luck and enjoy FLdigi and Ham Radio ;-)


73s from Bavaria
SWL Tobias
.-.-.

Am Donnerstag, 12. Dezember 2024 um 01:53:39 MEZ hat Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> Folgendes geschrieben:


Tobias-

Thanks, that fixed the problem!

Now, why isn't the fldigi Windows file a 'normal' .ZIP file? I'm sure there are many more like me with this problem. (I don't expect you to know the answer; kind of wondering out loud there.)



On 12/11/24 2:32 PM, T² via groups.io wrote:

Hi Bob,

Never mind, it's the 'usual' Windows 'Double Trouble'.

But yes, it's an archive.


Please get yourself the free and (IMHO) most versatile 7zip (7z) archive manager, and with it, you can right click and open the setup.exe as an archive and copy the updated files to your respective FLdigi folder. Check it out at .


This is what most FLdigi users do anyway, because you actually see and decide, what will be copied where. Much better than a 'blind' update in the background!


Hope this helps.


73s Tobias
.-.-.
Am Mittwoch, 11. Dezember 2024 um 22:03:27 MEZ hat Bob Morrow <bobmorrow@...> Folgendes geschrieben:


I have the very same problem described here: [email protected] | Double-clicking setup.exe does nothing but I can’t seem to post there.

I’m running Win 10 pro 64-bit. When I click on setup.exe, I get the Windows user account control warning about running an app from an unknown publisher, I say Yes to it, and nothing happens. This happens on another Win 10 Pro 64-bit unit as well.


It is not a zip file either. I right-click it and there is no ‘extract all� option. Even if I select ‘run as administrator�, I get that UAC warning, click on Yes, and nothing happens.

The file I’m using is fldigi_4.2.06_setup.exe from

--

Bob N7PTM

“Number 7 Pegs The Meter�