Re: The skirl of the pipes
Blimus!
At last. Someone who does not display any sign of
being a cretin. Senility perhaps......
Cheers
Rich
--- Alan Reynolds <gfy07@...> wrote: >
Colours, Pipes, Drums, Whistles
By
richardclarkerli
·
#68
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Colours, Pipes, Drums, Whistles and Bugles were all about command and
control. The introduction of radio nets improved the battalion/company
co-ordination but not the Platoon/section situation.
The
By
Alan Reynolds <gfy07@...>
·
#67
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
However getting into national characteristics is what
the rules are about. We use a number of factors to
differentiate each nation, giving certain bonuses,
using different numbers of Big Men to
By
richardclarkerli
·
#66
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Lards
I think that to us Anglo-Saxons (although on my mother's side I am
quite Norman) the pipes would probably mean less than to a Scot (or
even a celt, as the Irish had them as well). It would
By
richardclarkerli
·
#64
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Lards
I tend to agree with Dazza, getting into national characteristics is a
minefield. We can find similar descriptions for other troops eg Ghurka's who
didn't need pipes for the bad guys to be
By
mikeqchromeuk@...
·
#65
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Forgive this long piece, but as the wife is out tonight, I've been
looking online at bagpipes in combat (and will move on to the more
interesting websites that Noddy told me about later). Most of what
By
nick.skinner@...
·
#63
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Being a rabid Anglo-Saxon, I think you're overdoing the effect here.
With only a musket in hand, I can perceive the morale impact. With
automatic weapons, I'm not so sure.
And imagine how hard it
By
therugdoctor2003 <greens@...>
·
#62
·
|
Re: Game report
Ken
Good news. When we started writing the rules (actually the Charlie
Don't Surf set for Vietnam, more on that later) we used quite small
forces with once card per section in 20mm scale. Indeed,
By
richardclarkerli
·
#61
·
|
Game report
We tried the rules again at our school club yesterday evening. I
spoke to the boys first, as I mentioned, about how plans were one
thing but reality another. I used a couple of examples from the
By
philips107s2003 <[email protected]>
·
#60
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
"How are things near Sonmou?"
He's nowhere near Sonmou! Probably could ne pas get to Sonmou if nous
came out avec un axi for him. Il est too busy blubbing dans his
bratwurst and regardez les nice
By
nick.skinner@...
·
#59
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Sidney
That is an issue. I would be keen not to overlegislate in the rules
for every occurence. Losing the aforementioned advantages would seem
sufficient for me. For a start the co-ordination
By
richardclarkerli
·
#58
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Given that the Scots would be inspired by the sound of the peeps, should not the morale effect of the piper being a casualty also be considered.....? To hear only the first few bars of "Cock of the
By
Adam Blakemore
·
#57
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Nick
The movement thing reflects the fact that while the piper pipes
people will keep moving, in the same way that troops did in previous
centuries. It does NOT make people shoot better, and,
By
richardclarkerli
·
#56
·
|
Re: The skirl of the pipes
Rich
Not "The Devils in Skirts"!! Where's Terry Scott!?
My initial feeling is that you've given too big a bonus for the pipes.
Insted of enabling the CO to move every section, which does give
By
nick.skinner@...
·
#55
·
|
Re: WWii rules
Nick
A very quick reply as I am doing assembly in quarter of an hour!
I have given consideration to Richard's comments the other day, and
you confirm these with your remarks. Actually the news of
By
philips107s2003 <[email protected]>
·
#54
·
|
The skirl of the pipes
Before Nikkos gets overexcited with his lusty young lads (?), I have
painted up some Jock officers and pipers this weekend, Camerons and
Black Watch if you're interested, for my 1940 bash.
By
richardclarkerli
·
#53
·
|
Re: WWii rules
Ken,
It'd be interesting to know what size are the actions you are fighting.
I hate to say anything in their favour but both the illustrious doctor
(Dazza) and my fellow lardy are right. I'd be
By
nick.skinner@...
·
#52
·
|
Re: La Lard Sacre
I have a niece who works in general practice, but I didn't think she
spent her time stopping routing units. Maybe my sister should send her
to Karbala!
therugdoctor2003 wrote:
By
nick.skinner@...
·
#51
·
|
Re: WWii rules
Thank you for your comprehensive answer. I appreciate what you are
saying, I think perhaps the youngsters at school are probably not
quite so keen on the simulation aspect as they are on the game.
By
philips107s2003 <[email protected]>
·
#50
·
|
Re: La Lard Sacre
Not being there on Tuesday I don't know what happened and I think I've only used the rules and cards once - however I think there should definitely be an incentive to require commanders to rally
By
Harpers
·
#49
·
|