¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io
Date   
Will you please help? 16
I have been fortunate at times to have garnered insights from this group. I am now again hoping to get some guidance once more, in my quest to assist my teenage son. We are fixing up our home, something my son is very excited about. We are building terraces to continue to grow our fruit trees, our veggies and our grape vines. We will have a plan of how to proceed, and then he will do the complete opposite. These are not just wants as much as they are things to insure structural integrity. A different example is. I have asked him not to throw food bags off the balcony. The reason is that it attracts ants and rodents. (I have offered to gladly take the bags down if he doesn't want to.) He agrees. Then the next time, he throws it over the railing. He will then first say my ideas are always ridiculous, then he will say he is sorry, and will next time put it in the trash can. Then the next time, he throws it over once more. I want to continue to encourage him to think and figure things out. The problem is me...is there any room for my thoughts regarding our home? How do i reconcile these two things? Thank you for any ideas you can proffer to help me. I am most appreciative.
Started by M Person @ · Most recent @
Typical Days, Socialization 3
Thank you Sandra, for all the work you¡¯ve done over the years¡ªmountains of it¡ªfor the rest of it. Even though our family didn¡¯t end up unschooling, I read deeply in my son¡¯s early years everything you and the voices around you shared. I ended up choosing keeping the family together, based on some of your advice and some deep soul searching, rather than insisting on unschooling, but I still keep up with your work a decade later. The principles underlying radical unschooling have blessed our family and grown me over the years. And I keep learning. Anyway, I wanted to thank you from my heart for the love, abundance, and joy you share and grow through your writings/conversations/collections/ work. Much love, Anna -- Honolulu, 96815 [Anna, I edited the footer to take your full name and phone number off. And THANK YOU. ¡ªSandra]
Started by Anna Dondur @ · Most recent @
Something or nothing 5
This was written in 2001. I told the story of the 18s more lightly in an article called "King's X from the Math Monster." I didn't know "King's X" was a regional kids'-game term, but that's another thing. ___________________________ I thought some people would be amused or reassured. If you can gain both, that's even better. ___________________ By *SandraDodd* on *Monday, July 16, 2001 - 08:37 pm* : I figured I would use this folder to post something that's about everything in general. It's how "nothing" turns into something cool: Kirby, Marty and Brett (all unschooled kids 14, 12, 15) are in the other room playing a game. They just returned from hours of gaming at the shop where Kirby works. Brett only played an hour and a half; before that he was at driver's ed. Anyway, Kirby was telling the other boys a story about a schooled-kid they all know whose name is not Bob--I'm borrowing that name for him. _________ "Bob has learning disabilities so he spells and writes worse than we do, but today we were figuring out the scores from [some game phase I didn't catch] and I was telling him how to figure it out by 8, and 9, and multiplying by 18 I told him just treat it like 20, and the subtract two for each one, so he had four, and that was 80 and he took out the eight and had 72. He said, 'Oh, okay! I get that.' "And [adult who works there] said, 'KIRBY, where did you learn that?' and I said"... ::dweebish geek voice::..."'I'm homeschooled.' And he said no, really, did you make that up? And I said 'Yeah! I'm homeschooled!'" _____ The story and the reactions to it from the other two illustrated that Kirby wasn't aware not everyone had figured out how to multiply by 18 in their heads and he didn't know an adult would be so impressed, or that a kid who claims on his own to have learning disabilities wouldn't just get it, and having just gotten it would actually appreciate it. But our kids' lives are just kind of like that. Brett was critiquing my driving on the way home, using the acronyms they'd learned in class so far. He was very complimentary. I didn't know I was doing all those fancy processes. I thought I was just driving! He was very analytical, which proved he understood what he's been hearing this week and last, and which gave my boys a chance to learn some stuff AND to appreciate my driving! Good afternoon! I was about to hit send and heard: Brett to Kirby: If you weren't a gamer, what would you be? Kirby: A computer geek. What about you? Brett: I don't know. Kirby and Marty in combination told him he would be a jock. Marty, they decided, would be a skater. Brett has played baseball as much as possible, Marty has skated (roller blades at the skate park and ice hockey) a fair amount, and Kirby spends a lot of time on the computer. So they do have secondary skills to fall back on if the gaming thing doesn't work out. Sandra The original is here, but I should probably save it on my site, too. Help!! Our unschooling seems like 'doing nothing'. ( https://web.archive.org/web/20021223152733/http://www.unschooling.com/discus/messages/401/2708.html?WednesdayOctober920021205pm ) Sandra, in 2022, with those boys all grown and parents
Started by Group Moderator @ · Most recent @
A jewel in this forum
Once a lunatic wrote to me, and we all discussed it in this group. I did ask if he was insane. It didn't seem to be the writing of a female, but let me know if you can perceive male or female clues from it, if you are so inclined. /g/AlwaysLearning/message/52108 It's mostly about TV, but of course it's about parental fears and irrational behavior and learning and safety and all the good stuff. As the discussion unfolded, Deb Lewis wrote a beautiful long list of things her son was inspired to learn because of TV. I said I was going to save it somewhere. I don't know if I ever did, not counting in this forum and in the rescued archive Vlad Gurdiga created just in case the migration from yahoogroups to groups.io failed. https://sandradodd.com/archive/AlwaysLearning/topic/52206/ (if you would rather read it there, most or all the posts of the topic I'm linking are also on my site) In this group here, Deb's response is /g/AlwaysLearning/message/52138 There was a bit more Deb wrote in a subsequent post, and that (and my response about the safety and advantage to a teen being home instead of out destroying the neighborhood) now is here: Safe on the Couch ( https://sandradodd.com/couch ) Be well and safe and appreciate when you not only know where your kids are, but they are where you can bring them a drink and some food. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @
Teen Depression 16
(sent for anonymous posting) I¡¯ve been reading¡ªa LOT¡ªat your site lately, with a heavy focus on happiness and peace. I¡¯m trying to keep my head up as my oldest (18) takes another tour through depression. There have been so many quotes in different places where I have this vague ¡°*that*¡ªwe don¡¯t have THAT,¡± or ¡°this isn¡¯t happening over here¡­,¡± always in an ephemeral, can¡¯t quite nail it down kind of way. But today I read on the radical unschooling FB group a quote (from a few weeks back, from Jo Isaac, to a mom who wrote in): ¡°Is she happy? Is she thriving?¡± And I thought, THAT! That¡¯s it. No. No, he¡¯s not. So if I can pose a question to the Always Learning group (honestly, I might have asked before¡­..I know I¡¯ve sought answers in various places over the years; I don¡¯t THINK I¡¯ve asked here): How do you unschool a teen through depression? When so little lights them up and interests them; when there¡¯s so little they¡¯re passionate about? When I hear (repeatedly) how exercise will help, but I can¡¯t force him to exercise? (Or get outside in the sunshine¡ªanother example.) We do still have a truly good relationship¡ªI¡¯m the soft spot for him to land in all this, and I¡¯m grateful that he¡¯s willing to open up to me and thankful I can be there for him through all the yuck. But I want to do more to help than simply be a steadying presence (even if that is a good thing to be). I want to help bring him back to enjoying life, if that¡¯s possible. Brief answers to potential questions: yes, he¡¯s on meds; no, hasn¡¯t seen a counselor in awhile (tho he used to); and there are two younger siblings who are thriving (which I sometimes think makes things worse, as he watches them have so much fun in their days). Any thoughts? ________________ end of quote; reminder that it's another mom, not my own question _______________________
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
objection to the "school sucks" phrase 27
I got three e-mails announcing or promoting a site called "School Sucks." they were nearly the same, but not identical, and came to me personally, and as moderator of one yahoo list and owner of another. So I wrote and said it was too negative for my tastes (and I had looked at the webpage too; negative and dark). The person who had sent those turned out not to be the site owner or podcast-maker, or whatever. We had a few e-mails back and forth, and then came a wonderfully inept/un-apt analogy. This is the e-mail I sent back this morning: =========================================== -=-You can't heal a wound by ignoring it, right?-=- It quite depends on the severity of the wound. You can't heal a scrape by rubbing dirt in it. You can't heal a cut by pulling it open every day and looking in there. If you have bug bites, you could potentially pick and pick and pick at them until you have a roaring infection. A knife to the abdomen is going to need surgery, and a broken bone needs to be set. I know school can cause damage. Living in the past causes damage, too. Most wounds can heal themselves if the person is at peace and healthy. Natural learning can happen if the person is at peace and healthy and the environment is good for it. I'm not saying the page shouldn't exist. I was asking a question based on the blanket advertising of it, some saying homeschool and some saying unschool, and was explaining why I don't want to advertise the project on my discussion lists, or link it from my site. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Site news
New on my site Parenting Peacefully, Fact, Food Usually I try to save up three similar or related pages, but this one is long and important. In January 2022 I have added to the page called Parenting Peacefully, a list that Alex Arnott wrote. It's the fourth item or so. https://sandradodd.com/parentingpeacefully That page is long, solid, rich, and has a sound file you can hear there, or download and keep. New to the site: Fact/Fallacy/Opinion (from The Big Book of Unschooling) https://sandradodd.com/fact New page, sound and pictures, about FOOD and unschooling https://sandradodd.com/foodlisten photo (a link) by Lydia Kolta
Started by Sandra Dodd @
Reading, thinking, avoiding fear
A "greatest hits" moment. Me, my page on facebook, 2017. Five years later? Worse but there's still hope. :-) ____________________ ______________________________________________ __________________________ I wrote this in June 2016: ___________ Please, anyone, everyone, don¡¯t believe anything you¡¯ve only read once, especially in a forum like this, or on facebook. In all my life I¡¯ve never seen as big a flood of falsehood and nonsense as I¡¯ve seen in 2016 so far. The second worst was 2015. Next year should be worse. BE CAREFUL what you get excited about or fearful of. ___________ The "forum like this" is Always Learning, a yahoogroups discussion I created in 2001, which is still active. It's one of the best discussions ever, and STILL no one should believe anything they read there just because they read it. WHO wrote it, and why? Does it make any sense? Thinking is fair. Thinking should be required, but who could require and enforce it? I wish only people who were good at thinking and had just recently DONE some would write in public, but wishes are just wishes. If possible, require thinking of yourself. Don't believe anything you've only read once. Don't write things that you can't or won't back up. Not writing anything is vastly better than writing crap. __________ and me, a comment there: __________ P.S. That wasn't written about politics at all. It was about dental advice and strident parenting, but did I call it or what? 2017 has been worse already than any year before for the volume and speed of the sharing of falsehood and twisted confusion. The original is here: /g/AlwaysLearning/message/76938 The reminder to step back, and to think clearly, seemed worth bringing back. It's a rough time, but there are still kids building memories, learning, needing a safe and secure unschooling home. Protect yourself from twisted fright as well as you can, so you can keep your kids happy and learning in peace. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @
Radical Unschooler becoming an International Baccalaureate student 6
He has decided he wants to become an International Baccalaureate student, Levi is not an impulsive person, this plan has developed over time and with We are currently learning French together on DuoLingo (his I have brief experience with IB studies with my oldest daughter back in He has done research on the IB program itself, and we believe it is an ¡°in-person" program. I am just beginning my own research, which naturally leads me here. I¡¯m bringing this here because I know we have many people with grown Would you please share any perspectives you may have with a big transition Anything about IB studies? alternative paths taken for children who wanted Concerns you can think of? Preparing for ¡°formal education¡±? I¡¯m still in my brainstorming stage, and y¡¯all always have so much to offer. > Thank you Embracing His grace, Dena *Deuteronomy 28:12* *"The LORD will open for you His good storehouse, the heavens,* *to give rain to your land in its season and to bless all the work of your hand;*
Started by Dena Morrison @ · Most recent @
Testing (try not to) and some history of homeschooling
I moved this section of an article to another page. Well, duplicated it. I wrote it in 2003: There is a group of homeschoolers that generally tries not to test their children at all. Because a test score is never ignored, tests affect the relationship between parent and child, and many unschoolers want to preserve their child's journey to adulthood unmeasured, uncompared, and whole. It might seem crazy from the outside, but the disadvantage of testing is real. Each tree grows from a single seed, and when a tree is growing in your yard what is the best thing you can do for it? You can nurture it and protect it, but measuring it doesn't make it grow faster. Pulling it up to see how the roots are doing has never helped a tree a bit. What helps is keeping animals from eating it or scratching its bark, making sure it has water, good soil, shade when it needs it and sun when it needs it, and letting its own growth unfold peacefully. It takes years, and you can't rush it. So it is with children. They need to be protected from physical and emotional harm. They need to have positive regard, food, shade and sun, things to see, hear, smell, taste and touch. They need someone to answer their questions and show them the world, which is as new to them as it was to us. Their growth can't be rushed, but it can be enriched. Where it was and still is: https://sandradodd.com/thoughts Changing the World--Some Thoughts on Homeschooling Where it also is, now: Testing Unschoolers? https://sandradodd.com/testing/tests Sandra -- (If this doesn't look like Sandra Dodd's e-mail, it is one. "AElflaed" is my medieval-studies/SCA name.)
Started by Sandra Dodd @
When you can see all directions, for a moment 6
This was sent to me, for sharing, by someone who understands unschooling well. She wrote it carefully so as not to be identified, so it's not about who it is. There are ideas to help anyone, at any level of unschooling, and the writing is nice. _______________________________________________________________ The kids (ages 12 and 14) and I have been watching ¡°The Goldbergs¡±. We all love the show and as someone who grew up in the 80¡¯s (the show is set in the 80¡¯s) it¡¯s been so fun and nostalgic. My dad has generously been doing work on our house for the last 9 days. He¡¯s about half way done. He prefers to work without our help. This afternoon the kids and I were watching The Goldbergs in front of the fire on the couch (that we so carefully picked out for the ultimate coziness and snugliness. It¡¯s a corner sectional with a chaise.) We have lots of blankets and pillows and our gas fireplace throws the coziest light. I was crocheting. We had popcorn and fruit and cookies and seltzer. This is a very typical at home day for us. Yesterday we were out all day with friends, as we will be tomorrow. This is the rhythm of our life. When my dad came down from upstairs earlier, to the scene of pure connection and peacefulness it occurred to me he¡¯d probably never seen a family live this way before. Not just a life without school¡ªbut a family who is so calm and loves being together so much. A dad who doesn¡¯t need or want a man cave, but instead pops out of his home office any chance he gets to hang out with his family. My childhood was harmful, chaotic, and dysfunctional. In all honesty it was abusive. I¡¯m not mad at my parents anymore. I now understand that they really were doing the best they could. My parents divorced when I was in my late twenties. The cool thing about my dad is that even though he¡¯ll surely judge some of what he saw today as laziness and other negativity, I know he was grateful to see how much peace has come to our family. That the only lineage he knew has ended with me. He doesn¡¯t understand it. But I know his gratitude comes from his very core. It occurred to me today, after he¡¯d gone back upstairs, while I watched the clothes, furniture, music, and toys from my childhood on the screen in front of me¡ªjust how powerful learning to unschool well really is. How worthy all the work I put in is. How we have literally changed the world by starting with my own family. I¡¯m getting all choked up writing this. I could go on with specifics about how it¡¯s improved with my relationship with my parents and friends (because I¡¯ve changed how I interact), but really, what¡¯s amazing me in this moment is how healing this is. We talk about that often and it is so true. I think it felt profound today because I was watching a show set in the era of the heart of my own lousy childhood, with my dad upstairs working, while I was living so peacefully and beautifully with my own family on a Wednesday afternoon. I could be wrong about my dad appreciating the peaceful life we live. He comes from a generation and family belief system that worth only comes from working ourselves to the literal bone. Not because we need the money, but because it¡¯s the only honorable way to live a life. He very well could be thinking that I¡¯m raising lazy, privileged people. And you know what? It¡¯s okay with me if he does. I¡¯ve done enough work to know what he thinks of me and my family has nothing to do with me and my family. It¡¯s better for me to believe he¡¯s deeply grateful. So I do. Because it¡¯s more peaceful. For anyone reading who is just starting out, you have choices. You can yell and scream that what you are doing ¡°IS UNSCHOOLING¡±. You can yell and scream that ¡°THERE IS NO ONE RIGHT WAY TO UNSCHOOL¡±. You can yell and scream all you want. It won¡¯t bring you peace. It won¡¯t get you the cozy, beautiful life you might¡¯ve caught a glimpse of. That takes work. Reading, watching, trying, waiting. Little by little. Over time. An ever present and arching-over-everything commitment to doing the work you need to do to get here. Sure, I know I have changed the world by starting with myself and my own family. That¡¯s awesome. Know what I love more, though? This gorgeous, beautiful, spectacular, happy world I live in. I didn¡¯t have it when I was a kid¡ªthough I always wanted it with my whole self¡ªbut I have it now. Even better, my kids have it now. There¡¯s nothing in this world I¡¯d ever want more. _______________________________ If you read through this quickly, consider reading it again, slowly. Maybe aloud, even if only to yourself. Maybe tomorrow. It has jewels. I can't thank and credit the mom in public, but I will do so on the side for all of you. :-) Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Grandparents and "standard questions" 11
A reader named Jen has sent a story with a question. I'm very happy to say that although the story is standard, the question is new, and very interesting! ___________________________________ We went out to dinner with my in-laws recently, and over the course of the evening, my MIL looked at my eight-year-old and asked, "What do you like best in school?" My hackles immediately rose; I felt like this was a test, and had the uncomfortable feeling we were all about to fail. I said nothing and let my daughter answer, and as the evening went on, I was more aware that it probably *wasn't* a question with any malice or "testing" intended, but simply a grown-up trying hard to connect with a child. It seemed similar to those standard questions posed by random adults trying to make conversation with a youngster: "What grade are you in?" "What's your favorite subject in school?" My question is, is there a way to stop the defensiveness from rising in me so quickly? Does that improve with time, or is it something I need to "work on"--and if so, how? Or maybe it's normal? I'd love any thoughts. I don't like having these adrenaline-laced bursts of anger/defensiveness whenever my kids are with this grandma. :( Thanks! --jen fletcher --------------------------------------------------------------- If you quote, change "Sandra" to "Jen" if you remember. :-) Or just quote the words you're going to respond to. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Write while you can 5
I don't think it's too late to "lively up" this group. Seven years ago I wrote something about people's reactions to discussions. I was a bit... heated? Here's a response worth considering here. I will leave it anonymous, but the name is there (for those who can get to facebook): > > > > This was particularly salient to me Sandra. I have been reading this list > for quite some time and the Always Learning but I have mostly held back > from commenting on the groups as I didn't feel ready. When I read your > post I realised that these groups might not be around forever and that if > I wanted them to continue then I needed to take some personal > responsibility for contributing to them myself. I also realised that I > might be missing out on relating to the people that are here and getting > feedback on our Unschooling journey. Rather than waiting until a time in > the future when I might be able to engage in writing and sharing in > something I value, I thought that it might be the time to contribute now. > > One of my comments there is below. At this point, a few have lasted over 25 years, and some of my favorites are off to other things/places. > > All through these years, since the AOL group that Jonathan mentioned, > there have always been dozens to a hundred or more active writers at any > one time. Some last six months, or three years, or six. Some have lasted > twenty years. I'm grateful to all of them. > > > I'm also grateful to people who are willing to ask questions and roll with > the discussions without getting defensive or cranky. Every question helps > LOTS of readers. > Thanks to participants; that's what I wanted to say. https://www.facebook.com/groups/303347574750/posts/10152594330764751/
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Monkey Platters 5
Analysis of a misunderstanding (or something). I've just finished rearranging and cleaning up the main monkeyplatter page. One link went to a now-defunct blog, but my practice is to provide a link if I can, through the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine. When I found the post, I had chosen one later than the one I'd first seen. The mom had abandoned her use of monkey platters (and she didn't call them that in the first place, though pretty clearly that's the idea she was working with). I wasn't surprised, after seeing how she limited her kids in the first place. I hope the author is hidden/buried. I'm not interested in who it was, except that it was a homeschooler who had no mention of unschooling in her description or sidebar, and the blog is gone. For fun, or for practice, maybe you could read to see what problems this use could create. If you want to lift a line or phrase and shine an unschooling light on it, feel free to tear it up. There won't be feelings hurt; it's old and the blog's gone and they weren't unschoolers, but What If they WERE? (for purposes of dissection) ______________________________ Our Munchie Platter Mar 9th, 2008 An online friend recommended this a while ago and it works so well for our family. My kids used to constantly ask me ¡°what can I eat?¡± and pester me for snacks between meals. Then I saw a post about leaving healthy snacks out on a platter for kids to visit any time they wanted. I grabbed a plastic 4-compartment party tray that had been headed out as a donation, and our munchie platter was born. I try to stock it with all healthy foods, things that I¡¯d serve for meals. They¡¯re often organic and are low in sugar and fat. I also try to offer a balance of veggies, fruits, protein and carbs. Lastly, I aim for a rainbow to get a good mix of nutrients¨C green, orange, red, brown, etc. Here¡¯s some common fillers here: frozen peas raisins cut oranges organic low-sugar, whole grain cereals dried berries cheese cubes (only once a day since it¡¯s high in calories & fat) frozen corn sunflower seeds canned organic green beans edamame dried apple slices melon cubes baby carrots celery sticks fresh seasonal fruit plain popcorn Once something is eaten up, then the kids have to either eat what¡¯s left or wait till later when it¡¯s filled. An hour before dinner, only veggies are on it. I really don¡¯t care if my kids ¡°fill up¡± on frozen peas or baby carrots before dinner. I¡¯m amazed at how smoothly our days go now that the munchie platter is part of our routine. The kids are easily getting in their recommended servings of veggies and fruits now, and it¡¯s made life much easier for me. Update: Now that we have 4 kids munching, this has worked less and less well. Kids would gobble up one item and practically crush each other to get to the ¡°good stuff¡± before the others ate it all. I find it much easier and more fair to just make up little snack plates a couple of times a day for each child. Posted in cooking/home ec, nutrition | No Comments ______________ end of that quote _________________________ The page in its new-improved state is https://sandradodd.com/eating/monkeyplatter and I think it should even work on phones. :-)
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Grandparents and Unschooled Grandkids 10
*Brought anonymously at the request of the author:* My kids are 11 and 6, and since they were born, my husband and I have valued ¡°Always Saying Yes!¡± to their interests and desires. Like many here know, sometimes this means saying Yes to a safer variation of their desire or timing that fits the family team, but we usually follow their interests and find the excitement within. We currently unschool and have parented with attachment in mind from the beginning. (Both of us were parented more traditionally and went to public school.) In the last few years, I¡¯ve noticed the theme of ¡°grandparents are meant to spoil their grandkids¡± within our families and also in the larger mainstream culture in the U.S. Often quoted memes like ¡°If I¡¯d known grandkids were so much fun, I would have had them first¡± seem to point to a belief that parents are supposed to be the strict ones who say no to their kids and do all the discipline, and grandparents are supposed to the ones who say yes. Because our kids are growing up within a family culture of trust, genuine consideration for their requests, and saying yes whenever possible, I¡¯ve noticed that our parents don¡¯t necessarily have much room to do any ¡°spoiling¡± or ¡°indulging.¡± In fact, it¡¯s often the grandparents who enforce rules that they consider important, like ¡°no dessert before dinner¡± or ¡°only one scoop of ice cream/piece of candy.¡± (Their rules often are about food, interestingly enough.) It feels like the stereotypical roles (grandparents who spoil vs. strict parents) have been reversed in our family, and I¡¯ve noticed that sometimes it seems to leave our parents adrift and a bit confused about what kind of relationship they¡¯re supposed to have with our kids. I¡¯m curious about how other families have navigated this dynamic, and how they¡¯ve nurtured grandparent-grandchild relationships with their parents. How do you help them interact in ways that go beyond simply ¡°spoiling the grandkids¡±? ________________________ end of quote ____________________ Not my writing, but my name will show as the one who posted. ¡ªSandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Admissions and pressures (Re: "Concerned Parent" / stepmother) 3
-=-Her dad has recently admitted he needs to not be so defensive over her and trust me more with her. -=- WORD ALERT! "Admitted." I guess that before, the mom told him to not be defensive and to trust her, but he had denied it. After more pressure, he has "admitted" ¡ªconfessed in a pre-prepared statement. -=-I need some help because what I am doing is not helping and she is not really willing to change.-=- I don't think the family is unschooling, and I'm not sure why she asked us, but since the 1990s there have been instances of people with difficult questions going to the unschoolers, no matter how much they were critical or avoidant before. It seems the mom isn't willing to change, although I hope the calm persuasiveness of those who posted before me has her thinking, and considering her own role in the awkward, untrusting situation. "Stop doing what's not helping" is the step before "and now what?" If she were an unschooler, she would already have access to an array of "now what"s. -=-She says it's because of her mom but I sometimes can't tell if that has become an excuse.-=- Why would she say "it's because of my mom" unless someone was asking her "why are you doing this?" Another clue in the word choice. Reasons and causes are not excuses. They are realities. Even if her mom were to go to the work of recovery, it would not change the daughter's trauma from before. That isn't "becoming" an excuse. It is a reality upon which the step-mom could pour compassion. Having three other kids in the house must make it difficult to do that. -=-I have noticed when someone tells her a particular reaction is normal she will use that reaction because it has been "okayed". Any Advice will be greatly appreciated.-=- Parents often continue to do what they think other parents do, or what they "can" or "should" or "have to" do, by one traditional method or voice or another. If someone tells her that it's normal for a parent to demand respect, or to call someone out for attitude, or not to want her to have special privileges (being close with her own dad, while he might be a stepdad to one or two of the others...)... IF a parent is told a particular action is normal, they might continue to use it because it has been okayed. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
Birth order and (separately) addiction [Re: "Concerned Parent" / stepmother]
Karen, Jo and Dola caught most of the issues, so I'll try not to repeat, but I might, a bit. :-) Turns out the mom IS a teacher, and is listed as having "a 16 year old, two 14 year olds, and a 6 year old." So if the angry step-daughter was one of the 14 year olds when that teacher bio was posted, she's also being compared to a step-sibling her own age, and one older, and one younger. Sometimes I think birth order is over-rated, and then sometimes I see something like this which puts a huge spotlight on one's position in a group in flux. "Her mother is an alcoholic and drug addict. She would often disappear in the middle of night. . . .Her mother would promise to her that she would change and never would." Alcohol and drugs are stronger than most people are. It can be a bit like an alien presence that takes over one's body, and will defend itself strongly if the person is making any idle promises or deals that could prevent the alcohol or drugs from having their happy way. It is NOT easy for an addict to just "decide" not to keep using, drinking, whatever it is. Those who don't have a tendency toward addiction, or who are abstinent, or for whatever reasons aren't addicts or alcoholics can casually (and cruelly) think (and express) that they are a superior sort of human, with great "self control," or virtue, when it might be more like the luck of the genetic dice-throw. People are as different around that as they are around shoe size and nose shape and musical ability, and if you're thinking right now, "Yeah but those can be inherited," BINGO! It's not more virtuous to wear a smaller shoe size. It might be lucky (more options, less storage space). I'm not an alcoholic and my sister is. That was lucky, on my part. I got a lucky DNA blend (in that aspect; she lucked out in some others).
Started by Sandra Dodd @
Feeling lost 6
Dear all, I'm looking for help to deal with an overwhelming sense of boredom and lack of purpose. I have been dealing with terminal illnesses in the family for several years, my husband's depression and then mine. No one has been almost dying for a few months now, we are both stable, without medication, the children are fine. I don't have the sense of urgency anymore but I don't feel good either, like there's no purpose in my life. I wonder if anyone here has experienced this feeling of emptiness after years of diffiuculties? How did you found back the joy of little things in your daily life? Covid was not helpfull, it's being a long time since we travelled, went to museums or the movies. The fact thar we lost a big part of our income is not helping either. I am 44 years old, my husband is 47 years old, the children are 12 and 7 years old. Everyone at home feels good, enjoys their daily lives but my husband starts to get worried because I'm not 100% present, I feel tired and unmotivated (developed enphisema in the last 2 years what doesn't help). I also have this sense that i don't really know what happened in my life in the past couple of years and that i should be doing something but not sure what. I'm married with the man i love, we are raising our childre the way we think is rigth, i wish i did not have this feeling that something is missing. Thank you for your kind words. C¨¢tia Maciel -- C¨¢tia Maciel
Started by Catia Maciel @ · Most recent @
"Concerned Parent" / stepmother 6
I've brought a post without the name. The original poster named it "Concerned Parent." ______________________________________ I am a stepmother to a 15 year old girl. I have been in her life for about 4 years. Her mother is an alcoholic and drug addict. She would often disappear in the middle of night, leave her and her brother without food, and my stepdaughter would look for her mother in the middle of the night. She would never leave the house to look for her but she would go to a neighbor and ask to use their phone. Her mother would promise to her that she would change and never would. Her father is EVERYTHING to her and she trusts him. She has a very close relationship with her father and does not have the typical father/teenage daughter relationship. She will still sit in his lap and lay on him and kiss his face several times in a row. When I came into her life she thought I was the greatest woman she ever saw and wanted to be like me, until I called her out one day about her attitude. She doesn't like when things do not go her way (like most kids/ teenagers don't). She HATES feeling like she has disappointed her father. Ever since I called her out for being rude and disrespectful our relationship changed DRASTICALLY. Whenever I ask her to do something or not do something she will deliberately do the opposite. When her father is not home she will stare me down, is very short with me, can be rude to my 7 year old daughter and my 15 year old son, and will stay in her room and hardly EVER smile. As soon as her dad will return home she is the happiest kid EVER and is nice to me. When I have gotten to the point where I am in tears and losing sleep I will let her dad know what is going on. We will sit down with her and she immediately breaks into tears and then her dad feels so bad that nothing really happens.Sometimes she is even more mad at me after we confront her it gets worse for me. I do not know what to do. Her dad has recently admitted he needs to not be so defensive over her and trust me more with her. I need some help because what I am doing is not helping and she is not really willing to change. She says it's because of her mom but I sometimes can't tell if that has become an excuse. I have noticed when someone tells her a particular reaction is normal she will use that reaction because it has been "okayed". Any Advice will be greatly appreciated. Signed, Mother at the ends of her rope _______________________________ To the mom who wrote this: Don't identify yourself in this forum; don't claim the writing. Things here are public; it's not a private group.
Started by Sandra Dodd @ · Most recent @
It is NOT easy to understand "radical unschooling"
Someone sent me a link to the wikipedia page on unschooling. There's a paragraph about radical unschooling, and it names me, an then misrepresents what I believe, and has a footnote to a page on my site. :-) Joyce Fetteroll once wrote that if it was easy to explain, we'd just need one page. Even for definitions, I have two pages on my site. Here's some of my response to the person who sent that link. : "New Mexico homeschooling parent Sandra Dodd proposed the term "Radical Unschooling" to emphasize the complete rejection of any distinction between educational and non-educational activities"... Wrong! :-) I don't believe there ARE "non-educational activities," and I know well from being a student and a teacher and a human that "educational activities" might not result in any learning. :-) Also, as radical unschooling was honed and clarified in discussions in those old days, part of what Pam Sorooshian and Joyce Fetteroll, Deb Lewis, myself and others figured out was that the ideas about how "academics" are learned can apply also to household things, and there's a lot of learning that isn't on a school curriculum that also is best figured out through conversations and observations, and not by "being taught." And why am I only a parent and not an author? I've had articles in magazines since 1996 or so. :-) The link to that wikipedia page (which is too long for me to want to read, and I saw things I considered completely wrong just skimming down to the part about radical unschooling :-) ) is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unschooling and the footnote on what I wrote (which is not what I wrote) goes to https://sandradodd.com/unschool/radical One of the footnotes goes to this, by Pam Sorooshian, though it seems to credit Jan Hunt if the link isn't clicked. https://www.naturalchild.org/articles/guest/pam_sorooshian.html And for "outside links," two of their three are Joyfully Rejoycing (Joyce's page) and Pam Laricchia's site, so that's good. :-) Congratulations to those of you who figured it out and DID it (or figured it out while doing it :-) ). "Read a little, try a little, wait a while, watch," while being with kids we love, is way easier than reading that whole Wikipedia page. Someone could read that page twice and not learn much. Or "learn" things that aren't true or useful. Thanks for all attempts to understand unschooling better, and to help others see what you've seen, too, those of you who have written in the past. Sandra
Started by Sandra Dodd @
Current Image
Image Name
Sat 8:39am