Keyboard Shortcuts
Likes
- PacNW928
- Messages
Search
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
rhenson
Adam, I can schedule to use one of the bays with a hydraulic lift on post if
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
you want. Ray Henson 88' S4 Auto - SandMetallic/Rolls Royce -----Original Message-----
From: ADAM BIRNBAUM [mailto:adamb777@...] Sent: Saturday, June 10, 2000 11:19 AM To: PacNW928@... Subject: Re: [PacNW928] Whirring sound = torque tube Actually both Devek and 928 Int'l rebuild their A/T tubes with the extra (third) bearing. As far as my timing goes, Yeah I know. I'm going to put the shark up in the air tonight and see what I can see. -Adam ----- Original Message ----- From: <redinger@...> To: <PacNW928@...> Sent: Saturday, June 10, 2000 9:16 AM Subject: Re: [PacNW928] Whirring sound = torque tube Adam,aftermarket tube that you refer to, is it the Devek piece? If I ever have to do atorque tube replacement, I would give serious consideration to the Devek part.asked Ihow much of that was the tube, $1.9K. I jokingly asked "Is that with or wasthen asked if it would be possible for me to supply a rebuilt tube, one mya salesman walking around my car, checking it out. As I stepped out of verywife's 4Runner, I told him I'd give him a good deal on the car. He said cardifficult to sell." Iand went in to pay the $38 diagnostic fee to have the dealer tell me Idropped off the car and basically told me "We have no intention on doing wastedwould have gladly paid my $38 then and there for his honesty and not iteveryone's time. heup, whirring sound and all. The salesman got that weird expression like rolledhad just swallowed something distasteful while being constipated. I thedown my window, and piped up to the salesman, "front wheel drive is out, guess25th, and I don't think I could pass tech with the whirring sound. I doI could tell them I've got a gear drive or something. I really want to time.the repair myself, but I don't think I could complete it in two weeks aSo, if I want to drag race, I need to take it up to Seattle and pay a similar noise until he released the static load at the flexplate. I'll ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Click here for a chance to win airfare to Vegas for you and 20 friends, $15,000 and a suite at Bellagio for New Year's from Expedia.com. Or win 2 roundtrip tickets anywhere in the U.S. given away daily. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: PacNW928-unsubscribe@... |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
ADAM BIRNBAUM
Sounds like a bargain Curt!
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Have you ever thought about working for a Porsche dealership? :) -Adam ----- Original Message -----
From: Curt Nichols <curt_nichols@...> To: <PacNW928@...> Sent: Friday, June 09, 2000 6:41 PM Subject: RE: [PacNW928] Re: Whirring sound = torque tube DistanceAnyway, I'm sure if you offer some beer or something,> you could cajole some of the locals to pop over and give rates which fall monthly, plus an extra $60 in FREE calls! |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
ADAM BIRNBAUM
Thanks Jim,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I'll let you know if (when) I have questions. -Adam ----- Original Message -----
From: Jim & Tina <nebraska@...> To: <PacNW928@...> Sent: Friday, June 09, 2000 3:13 PM Subject: Re: [PacNW928] Re: Whirring sound = torque tube I wish I lived a bit closer,I'd be glad to give a hand since I'vewin.
|
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
ADAM BIRNBAUM
Tom Wrote:
Sorry to hear about your tube. Do you really think they would fail I'm not sure if it would be an issue or not (the noise). The PCA inspections are pretty cursory, but I think they would keep a car off the track if it made a strange noise. -Adam Anyway, I'm sure if you offer some beer or something, you could Thanks for the offer Tom, I'll keep everyone posted. -Adam |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
ADAM BIRNBAUM
Actually both Devek and 928 Int'l rebuild their A/T tubes with the extra
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
(third) bearing. As far as my timing goes, Yeah I know. I'm going to put the shark up in the air tonight and see what I can see. -Adam ----- Original Message -----
From: <redinger@...> To: <PacNW928@...> Sent: Saturday, June 10, 2000 9:16 AM Subject: Re: [PacNW928] Whirring sound = torque tube Adam,aftermarket tube that you refer to, is it the Devek piece? If I ever have to do atorque tube replacement, I would give serious consideration to the Devek part.asked Ihow much of that was the tube, $1.9K. I jokingly asked "Is that with or wasthen asked if it would be possible for me to supply a rebuilt tube, one mya salesman walking around my car, checking it out. As I stepped out of verywife's 4Runner, I told him I'd give him a good deal on the car. He said cardifficult to sell." Iand went in to pay the $38 diagnostic fee to have the dealer tell me Idropped off the car and basically told me "We have no intention on doing wastedwould have gladly paid my $38 then and there for his honesty and not iteveryone's time. heup, whirring sound and all. The salesman got that weird expression like rolledhad just swallowed something distasteful while being constipated. I thedown my window, and piped up to the salesman, "front wheel drive is out, guess25th, and I don't think I could pass tech with the whirring sound. I doI could tell them I've got a gear drive or something. I really want to time.the repair myself, but I don't think I could complete it in two weeks aSo, if I want to drag race, I need to take it up to Seattle and pay a similar noise until he released the static load at the flexplate. I'll |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Adam,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Boy you sure know how to pick the timing for these things! The aftermarket tube that you refer to, is it the Devek piece? If I ever have to do a torque tube replacement, I would give serious consideration to the Devek part. Hope you can get it back in working order before the drags. Terry Adam Birnbaum wrote: I got the verdict from the local Porsche Dealer, they said my whirring |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Curt Nichols
Anyway, I'm sure if you offer some beer or something,> you could cajole some of the locals to pop over and give > you a hand. Let me know if I can help. Look out Adam, Tom's just casting about for beer. I'll make you a heck of a deal--send me up a six-pack of some good stuff and I won't come down and round off every nut and bolt I lay a wrench to! :) Curt |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Curt Nichols
Adam,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
It's too bad that Tom no longer has a 2nd shark to share for the shark drags! (You'd have to check the tires first, anyway. ;-) Wow. $1,400 profit on a $500 torque tube! BTW, there were still some pleasant sights at the DE this weekend, though short a couple 928's. A few 911 turbos pouring it on coming into the front straight with *real pronounced* lift-and-squat as they upshifted <grunt>. What a garish sound they make! And a 996 or two going by whisper-quiet. Curt -----Original Message-----
From: Adam Birnbaum [SMTP:adamb777@...] Sent: Friday, June 09, 2000 1:07 PM To: rennlist928; {928}PacNW928 Subject: [PacNW928] Whirring sound = torque tube I got the verdict from the local Porsche Dealer, they said my whirring sound coming from my shark is the torque tube. [snip] |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Lloyd Johnson
¿ªÔÆÌåÓýLast time I went to the drags they weren't checking that tightly about the running condtion of your car. Just that it APPEARED to be safe and wasn't leaking fluids. Lloyd -----Original Message-----
From: midlman@... [mailto:midlman@...] Sent: Friday, June 09, 2000 1:33 PM To: PacNW928@... Subject: [PacNW928] Re: Whirring sound = torque tube Hi Adam, Sorry to hear about your tube.?? Do you really think they would fail
Anyway,? I'm sure if you offer some beer or something, you could
Later, Tom
P.S.? If someone brings a torch or hacksaw we could take care of your
--- In PacNW928@..., "Adam Birnbaum" wrote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
|
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Jim & Tina
I wish I lived a bit closer,I'd be glad to give a hand since I've
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
done it before. Let me know if I can be of any help e-mail wise with it. Anyway, I'm sure if you offer some beer or something, you could |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
Hi Adam,
Sorry to hear about your tube. Do you really think they would fail you during the tech inspection for the drag day. I've never been through one but didn't think they would care if your car made some odd noise (just tell them it's a supercharger ;-0). Im sure the PCA inspections are pretty rigorous, What did they do for yours? Anyway, I'm sure if you offer some beer or something, you could cajole some of the locals to pop over and give you a hand. Let me know if I can help. Later, Tom ready and waiting with portable tool box, 4- (2-ton) jack stands and a 3 ton jack. P.S. If someone brings a torch or hacksaw we could take care of your A/C compressor problem too ;-) --- In PacNW928@..., "Adam Birnbaum" <adamb777@w...> wrote: I got the verdict from the local Porsche Dealer, they said mywhirring sound coming from my shark is the torque tube.I asked how much of that was the tube, $1.9K. I jokingly asked "Is thatwith or without my PCA discount?" The (new) service manager wasn't tooamused. I then asked if it would be possible for me to supply a rebuilt tube,one that had an extra bearing and would actually be better than thestock replacement. He said he'd check and get back to me.there was a salesman walking around my car, checking it out. As I steppedout of my wife's 4Runner, I told him I'd give him a good deal on the car. Hesaid "Oh no, the car is beautiful, but these old All Wheel Drive modelsare very difficult to sell."my car and went in to pay the $38 diagnostic fee to have the dealer tell mewhen I dropped off the car and basically told me "We have no intention ondoing the repair that you are asking an estimate for, unless your arestupid enough to pay 4x the amount for parts, and double the time forlabor". I would have gladly paid my $38 then and there for his honesty andnot wasted everyone's time.fired it up, whirring sound and all. The salesman got that weird expressionlike he had just swallowed something distasteful while being constipated. Irolled down my window, and piped up to the salesman, "front wheel drive isout, I'm gonna fix it myself", and pulled out.on the 25th, and I don't think I could pass tech with the whirring sound.I guess I could tell them I've got a gear drive or something. I really wantto do the repair myself, but I don't think I could complete it in twoweeks time. So, if I want to drag race, I need to take it up to Seattle andpay a reasonable price for the repair. Decisions, decisions.housing this weekend, the sound may go away. Ray Wach had stated his sharkmade a similar noise until he released the static load at the flexplate.I'll keep my fingers crossed. |
Whirring sound = torque tube
Adam Birnbaum
I got the verdict from the local Porsche Dealer, they said my whirring
sound coming from my shark is the torque tube. They gave me the estimate, $2.9K which included 15 hours of labor. I asked how much of that was the tube, $1.9K. I jokingly asked "Is that with or without my PCA discount?" The (new) service manager wasn't too amused. I then asked if it would be possible for me to supply a rebuilt tube, one that had an extra bearing and would actually be better than the stock replacement. He said he'd check and get back to me. The phone message left with my secretary? "Can you pick your car up tonight?, we have limited garage space." I guess they don't install rebuilt tubes. I picked my car up afterhours, at around 7:55pm. As I pulled up, there was a salesman walking around my car, checking it out. As I stepped out of my wife's 4Runner, I told him I'd give him a good deal on the car. He said "Oh no, the car is beautiful, but these old All Wheel Drive models are very difficult to sell." I couldn't help but smile as I left "Old Shit for Brains" admiring my car and went in to pay the $38 diagnostic fee to have the dealer tell me something I already knew. It would have been nice if the service manager was upfront with me when I dropped off the car and basically told me "We have no intention on doing the repair that you are asking an estimate for, unless your are stupid enough to pay 4x the amount for parts, and double the time for labor". I would have gladly paid my $38 then and there for his honesty and not wasted everyone's time. When I got back out to my shark, the salesman was still there. I fired it up, whirring sound and all. The salesman got that weird expression like he had just swallowed something distasteful while being constipated. I rolled down my window, and piped up to the salesman, "front wheel drive is out, I'm gonna fix it myself", and pulled out. I'm going to kick around where I go from here. The shark drags are on the 25th, and I don't think I could pass tech with the whirring sound. I guess I could tell them I've got a gear drive or something. I really want to do the repair myself, but I don't think I could complete it in two weeks time. So, if I want to drag race, I need to take it up to Seattle and pay a reasonable price for the repair. Decisions, decisions. If I'm lucky, when I go to check the crank end play in the bell housing this weekend, the sound may go away. Ray Wach had stated his shark made a similar noise until he released the static load at the flexplate. I'll keep my fingers crossed. Thanks for listening, -Adam Birnbaum '88 S4 A/T |
Re: Whirring sound = torque tube
All I can say is Porsche dealers are uppity pricks, I mean 3 grand to fix a
torque tube? what dealer was it Barrier??? Akers seems to be pretty good i had my 88 up there when the are went out and had the belt tensioned. Denny said the air was electrical and sent me to another shop and charged me 100 for the adjustment...he has a pretty good rep with porsche owners in seattle. And it really pissesd me off when they stick you with the labor and then have the need for the triple mark up on the parts... Calvin 90 S4 |
Re: T-shirts
Adam Birnbaum
Hey Ray,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I've cc'd this response to the list just to update everyone. The shirts are at the printers as we speak (type?). Nicknames will be printed on them. I've been told that the arm graphic "Stuttgart Air Force" may have to be reduced slightly as it was a little too tall in my original artwork. They should be pretty cool. -Adam ---------- From: rhenson <rhenson@...> |
Re: Whirring Noise - And the winner is!
Adam Birnbaum
Thanks for the input Calvin,
I don't think the tube has degraded that far. (Yet!) Ray Wach on Rennlist said he had a similar problem, and got rid of it by releasing the stress built up inbetween the tube and the engine. (Loosen collar, re-torque). The shop said it was the torque tube, but wouldn't install an aftermarket rebuild so I'm checking other options. -Adam ---------- From: mmayn43508@...feel the vibration in the shifter or some type of vibration from the bearings |
Re: Whirring Noise - And the winner is!
ADAM BIRNBAUM
Hey Rob,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I do remember your fried torque tube. Mine is more of a whirring sound compared to the "ball bearings in a blender" sound that I remembered your shark making. So does the $900 include parts? -Adam ----- Original Message -----
From: <huntnphool@...> To: <PacNW928@...> Sent: Thursday, June 08, 2000 7:21 PM Subject: Re: [PacNW928] Whirring Noise - And the winner is! Adam,must come out, and to do this you need to support the car in the air, with thethe $900.00 or so to have it done. If you decide this is a better option,Denny Akers at Akers Foreign Auto in Seattle, does great work. I highlyrecommend him. They did mine in a day. They also replaced the front and rearbearings and serviced the trany at the same time, which I also recommend. |
Re: Whirring Noise - And the winner is!
Adam,
If you remember, my tube went out last summer. I tried to do it myself but found it very difficult without a lift. The problem is that the rear end must come out, and to do this you need to support the car in the air, with the axle free to role away. I could not find a secure way to this without worrying about the car falling off the stands. For me it was worth paying the $900.00 or so to have it done. If you decide this is a better option, Denny Akers at Akers Foreign Auto in Seattle, does great work. I highly recommend him. They did mine in a day. They also replaced the front and rear bearings and serviced the trany at the same time, which I also recommend. Rob Fossett |