Thanks to Doug for reminding me I forgot to put the watts in.
Looking at the watts, it doesn't seem like much change between
transistors, does it. Voltage gives a much finer resolution if one
wants to nitpick.?? :)
On 5/16/2025 12:44 PM, Steve Ratzlaff
wrote:
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I tested 10 each of the three transistors currently
available--2SC5706, 2SD822, 2SC2078 (from Las Vegas seller). (It
takes about 5 minutes per transistor....) I used the same NC40A
test fixture and 12.8VDC as before and the first transistor was
same as before, note the AWG setting and output level is
slightly different from yesterday. I kept the same AWG setting
but noted the output level--this is quicker to do for multiple
transistors.
Steve AA7U
2SC5706 (from kitsandparts.com)
1. -5.0 dBm in for all, 28.5 Vpp out,
2.03W
2.? 28.5 Vpp, 2.03W
3.? 28.5 Vpp, 2.03W
4.? 28.1 Vpp, 1.97W
5.? 29.9 Vpp, 2.24W
6.? 27.5 Vpp, 1.89W
7.? 27.6 Vpp, 1.90W
8.? 29.6 Vpp, 2.19W
9.? 28.9 Vpp, 2.09W
10. 28.0 Vpp, 1.96W
2SD822 (from Tayda)
1. -1.5 dBm in for all, 28.6 Vpp,
2.04W
2.? 28.6 Vpp, 2.04W
3.? 28.9 Vpp, 2.09W
4.? 28.1 Vpp, 1.97W
5.? 28.0 Vpp, 1.96W
6.? 28.8 Vpp, 2.07W
7.? 28.0 Vpp, 1.96W
8.? 28.3 Vpp, 2.00W
9.? 28.7 Vpp, 2.06W
10. 28.5 Vpp, 2.03W
2SC2078 (from eBay Las Vegas seller)
1.? -3.2 dBm in for all, 28.4 Vpp,
2.02W
2.? 28.8 Vpp, 2.07W
3.? 28.4 Vpp, 2.02W
4.? 28.9 Vpp, 2.09W
5.? 28.5 Vpp, 2.03W
6.? 28.7 Vpp, 2.06W
7.? 28.7 Vpp, 2.06W
8.? 28.2 Vpp, 1.99W
9.? 28.6 Vpp, 2.04W
10. 28.3 Vpp, 2.00W
On Thu, May 15, 2025 at
9:45?PM Steve Ratzlaff via <ratzlaffsteve=
[email protected]>
wrote:
Here are some output PA transistors I tested in the 7
MHz NC40A buffer, driver, PA circuit, with the function
generator adjusted to give 2 watts output (28.3 Vpp)
across the 50 ohm dummy load; power supply set to 12.8
VDC. My function generator can show the level in dBm but
many do not so I've included the mVpp value too. I've
listed the results in lowest drive level (better) to
highest (poorer). The BSC 2N3553 is an eBay find from
BSC--Boca Semiconductor Corp in Florida--I've tested
several eBay 2N3553s and this is the only one I've found
that compares well with the genuine old Motorola 2N3553
I have. .?
If I left out your favorite 1.5-2W PA transistor, let me
know and if I have it I'll test it too. Schematic of the
test circuit attached. I didn't install the output zener
diode since this is a bench test with 50 ohm dummy load
and won't see an antenna.
73,
Steve AA7U
1. Motorola 2N3553 -6.5 dBm
299 mVpp (old genuine Motorola transistor)
2. 2SC2314 -6.1 dBm 313 mVpp
(old genuine CB driver transistor)
3. BSC 2N3553 -5.6 dBm 332
mVpp (from eBay seller Boca Semi)
4. 2SC5706 -4.8 dBm 364 mVpp
(from )
5. 2SC2028/2 -4.6 dBm 372 mVpp
(old genuine CB driver transistor)
6. 2SC5739 -3.5 dBm 423 mVpp
(genuine, not from eBay or Amazon)
7. 2SC2078 -3.0 dBm 448 mVpp
(from eBay Las Vegas seller I've mentioned
before--Chinese transistor)
8. 2SD882 -1.2 dBm 551 mVpp
(from Taydaelectronics.com)
9. Central Semi 2N5109 -0.5
dBm 597 mVpp (genuine Central Semi transistor)
9. Central Semi 2N2219A -0.5
dBm 597 mVpp (genuine Central Semi transistor)
10. 2SC2078 -0.3 dBm 611 mVpp
(from Dan's Small Parts and Kits)
11. 2SC2078 +6.1 dBm 1.277 Vpp
(from ME 40M kit)