Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
- Nanovna-Users
- Messages
Search
Re: edy555 design notes on CALIBRATION sets
Good day,
When I began this process of working with the NanoVNA, I was not certain how the cal standards were being treated. Since the completed cal showed a perfect open, short and termination, I was pretty certain they were NOT defined as REAL SMA connector devices! The SMA connectors are NOT that perfect! At the time looking through the code, the best I could determine was they were treated as ideal. The 50 fF C for the open was a new input. In any case, what I find for RLC measurements is that the actual TEST set is a more significant problem than the calibration pieces. The stray L or C of leads to the DUT must be de-embedded. We could dedicate an entire thread on that alone. However, basically you must take into account the strays of the test set. Long leads and stray C make it more involved. But it is tempting to use that method because it is convenient. Just be prepared to adjust your readings. Again, a measurement of a known component is useful. A so called gold standard that is NOT part of the cal sequence is great for a sanity check. Alan |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Bob Albert
Larry, thanks for the encouraging information.? Where do I get the schematics?? What could be wrong with the bridge?? Where do I find it?? Pictures would help.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I don't have much to lose at this point but if I can salvage this it would be great. Bob On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 12:28:52 PM PDT, Larry Rothman <nlroth@...> wrote:
Bob, It sounds like the bridge circuit on CH0 is bad and the nano is not seeing any reflected energy to measure.Don't throw it away, just do a little troubleshooting - the schematics are available.Make sure there are no shorts going into the DSP from the reflected bridge. Regards,Larry ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 3:14:31 p.m. GMT-4, Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343@...> wrote: ? Rune, forgive me if you aren't the guy to whom I should ask this. I purchased a nanoVNA recently and it isn't working as I think it should.? Regardless of terminations I always get a dot at the right edge of the Smith chart.? I always get a flat line for SWR.? However, the frequencies are correct and I can select many menu options. I don't know if this is a hardware problem (I don't think so).? Is there a way to reset the processor or load some alternate software?? I hate to throw away this lovely little unit, but I may have to get another. I have calibrated it several times but the problem persists.? At one point I did get a reasonable display but it disappeared and haven't been able to get it back. For what it's worth, the accuracy of the frequency is amazing.? It's within less than 1 ppm.? For that alone, this unit was worth the price but that's not something I need.? I already have a rubidium standard. Bob ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:11 AM PDT, bill wright via Groups.Io <chief6226@...> wrote: ? RuneSorry for the alert? Win10 was trying to protect me from the download.I deleted? and then reloaded. This time it gave me a functional app.? Now all is well.I will test on thanks you so much for your efforts cheersBill kd5yyk ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:41 AM CDT, Rune Broberg <mihtjel@...> wrote: Hi Bill, The .exe file should work just fine on Windows 10. First startup can take a little while, maybe 10-20 seconds, but after that it should run fine. What happens when you try to start it? -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019, 17:19 bill wright via Groups.Io, <chief6226= [email protected]> wrote: ? Is there a trick to get the 0.1. version .exe to work.? I am on a win 10. |? | Virus-free. www.avast.com? | |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Bob,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
It sounds like the bridge circuit on CH0 is bad and the nano is not seeing any reflected energy to measure.Don't throw it away, just do a little troubleshooting - the schematics are available.Make sure there are no shorts going into the DSP from the reflected bridge. Regards,Larry On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 3:14:31 p.m. GMT-4, Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343@...> wrote:
Rune, forgive me if you aren't the guy to whom I should ask this. I purchased a nanoVNA recently and it isn't working as I think it should.? Regardless of terminations I always get a dot at the right edge of the Smith chart.? I always get a flat line for SWR.? However, the frequencies are correct and I can select many menu options. I don't know if this is a hardware problem (I don't think so).? Is there a way to reset the processor or load some alternate software?? I hate to throw away this lovely little unit, but I may have to get another. I have calibrated it several times but the problem persists.? At one point I did get a reasonable display but it disappeared and haven't been able to get it back. For what it's worth, the accuracy of the frequency is amazing.? It's within less than 1 ppm.? For that alone, this unit was worth the price but that's not something I need.? I already have a rubidium standard. Bob ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:11 AM PDT, bill wright via Groups.Io <chief6226@...> wrote: ? RuneSorry for the alert? Win10 was trying to protect me from the download.I deleted? and then reloaded. This time it gave me a functional app.? Now all is well.I will test on thanks you so much for your efforts cheersBill kd5yyk ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:41 AM CDT, Rune Broberg <mihtjel@...> wrote: Hi Bill, The .exe file should work just fine on Windows 10. First startup can take a little while, maybe 10-20 seconds, but after that it should run fine. What happens when you try to start it? -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019, 17:19 bill wright via Groups.Io, <chief6226= [email protected]> wrote: ? Is there a trick to get the 0.1. version .exe to work.? I am on a win 10. |? | Virus-free. www.avast.com? | |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Bob Albert
Rune, forgive me if you aren't the guy to whom I should ask this.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I purchased a nanoVNA recently and it isn't working as I think it should.? Regardless of terminations I always get a dot at the right edge of the Smith chart.? I always get a flat line for SWR.? However, the frequencies are correct and I can select many menu options. I don't know if this is a hardware problem (I don't think so).? Is there a way to reset the processor or load some alternate software?? I hate to throw away this lovely little unit, but I may have to get another. I have calibrated it several times but the problem persists.? At one point I did get a reasonable display but it disappeared and haven't been able to get it back. For what it's worth, the accuracy of the frequency is amazing.? It's within less than 1 ppm.? For that alone, this unit was worth the price but that's not something I need.? I already have a rubidium standard. Bob On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:11 AM PDT, bill wright via Groups.Io <chief6226@...> wrote:
RuneSorry for the alert? Win10 was trying to protect me from the download.I deleted? and then reloaded. This time it gave me a functional app.? Now all is well.I will test on thanks you so much for your efforts cheersBill kd5yyk ? ? On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:41 AM CDT, Rune Broberg <mihtjel@...> wrote: Hi Bill, The .exe file should work just fine on Windows 10. First startup can take a little while, maybe 10-20 seconds, but after that it should run fine. What happens when you try to start it? -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019, 17:19 bill wright via Groups.Io, <chief6226= [email protected]> wrote: ? Is there a trick to get the 0.1. version .exe to work.? I am on a win 10. |? | Virus-free. www.avast.com? | |
Re: edy555 design notes on CALIBRATION sets
Hi Mike-
This was a little unclear to me, but interesting. Are you saying thatExactly, IMO "calibration" should reflect actual measurement configuration More specifically, SHORT was by clamping alligators together and OPEN was by unclamping them. I want nanoVNA "CAL" to automagically account for alligator clamps and subsequent readings only about DUTs subsequently clamped. More "ideal" might be SHORT using a length of wire clamped between alligators approximately the length of resistor and coil. Then the data you posted was for that inductor?Yes, one that is very liable to stray pickup. The attached image shows nanoVNA display for a frequency scan, and hopefully visible is an approximating circular segment Smith plot, as reactances should be. While component RLC values at intended application wavelength[s] are obviously of interest, observing Smith plots over a wider range can reinforce credibility or reveal anomalies. Having not been otherwise informed, nanoVNA reports 50 Ohms for that 51 Ohm resistor; I can live with 2% errors... IMO, 5 stored calibrations are none too many. |
Re: edy555 design notes on CALIBRATION sets
Dr. David Kirkby from Kirkby Microwave Ltd
On Mon, 29 Jul 2019 at 16:59, alan victor <avictor73@...>
So at this point, create the best short, open and 50 ohm load... the supplied are not too bad. Perhaps the open as suggested in a prior post can Perhaps there is a transaction issue, but the source code I looked at appeared to show that the open was a 50 fF capacitor. Or maybe someone else modified the source code. -- Dr. David Kirkby, Kirkby Microwave Ltd, drkirkby@... Telephone 01621-680100./ +44 1621 680100 Registered in England & Wales, company number 08914892. Registered office: Stokes Hall Lodge, Burnham Rd, Althorne, Chelmsford, Essex, CM3 6DT, United Kingdom |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
RuneSorry for the alert? Win10 was trying to protect me from the download.I deleted? and then reloaded. This time it gave me a functional app.? Now all is well.I will test on thanks you so much for your efforts cheersBill kd5yyk
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 10:48:41 AM CDT, Rune Broberg <mihtjel@...> wrote:
Hi Bill, The .exe file should work just fine on Windows 10. First startup can take a little while, maybe 10-20 seconds, but after that it should run fine. What happens when you try to start it? -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019, 17:19 bill wright via Groups.Io, <chief6226= [email protected]> wrote: ? Is there a trick to get the 0.1. version .exe to work.? I am on a win 10. | | Virus-free. www.avast.com | |
Re: errors of "error" models
26 : Correction of Maxima Version and "Unpacked" DERDEI Code
- also @Jose Luu : /g/nanovna-users/message/3278 - Hello, Allow us, please, to inform you that, as we already promised at: 21 : The Mathematica Code and the Unpacked DERDEI Code : /g/nanovna-users/message/3290 we just uploaded the new, "unpacked" version of DERDEI at: Also allow us, please, to inform, facupov, the interested Common User that in order to avoid unnecessary complications, he has to take into account the following: (0.a/b) As it is detailed in the messages: Re: [Maxima-discuss] Maxima 5.38.1 64 bit build Windows From: <petrosez@gm...> - 2016-06-13 11:18:29 Re: [Maxima-discuss] Maxima 5.38.1 64 bit build Windows From: Gunter K?nigsmann <gunter@pe...> - 2016-06-14 06:44:35 the version 5.38.1 of [maxima] requires a bunch of hard to follow instructions for installation under wxpp32 or wxpp64. Therefore, we * e r r o n e o u s l y * suggested, what we had avoid to say, about this installation at: 2 : yza, Sep 21, 2019 : /g/nanovna-users/message/2802 and thus he should install the last * f u l l y * working 32-bit version 5.36.1 of [maxima] with [sbcl]: We are terribly sorry for the inconvenience. Please accept our apologies. (0.b/b) Note: He may need to also do the following: |Start|Settings|Control Panel|System|Advanced|Performance|Data Execution Prevention|(o) Turn on DEP for all programs and services except those I select:|Add|{X:\}{wxpp32}Program Files\ or{wxpp64}Program Files (x86)\Maxima-sbcl-5.36.1\bin\sbcl.exe| |Open| (1) He should unzip [DERDEI20191001.7z] to the default folder with name: [DERDEI20191001], in the root folder of a drive, which, if it is different than of our [K:], lets say [X:], then he has to edit [DERDEI-unpacked_20191001-600-1000.MC] and in the multi-lines beginning with /*10*/ up to /*15/ to replace every occurrence of K: by X: (2) He should skip | ignore any instructions given in the Documentation: regarding the file: [functions.txt], because all the contents of this file are now embedded into: [DERDEI-unpacked_20191001-600-1000.MC] at the aforementioned lines, and thus he should also ignore completely the file: [useless-MC-embedded-functions.txt], which was included into [DERDEI20191001.7z] just for the shake of completeness (3) He may execute sequentially, the 15 multi-line commands by Copy-Paste into [XMAxima] and Enter them one-by-one (4) He may omit the just informative multi-line commands beginning with: /*2*/, /*4*/, /*6*/, and /*8*/ (5) If he likes, then in just three 3 steps he can: (I) copy the whole content of [DERDEI-unpacked_20191001-600-1000.MC], then: (II) paste them to [maxima], and finally: (III) run it fully. (6) He may want to change the way in which the six 6 graphics windows are presented by [gnuplot] and to select between the "cascading" way, in which each window has to be closed, in order to appear the next one, or the simultaneous one, by following the instructions provided by the [Maxima 5.36.0 Manual: 12. Plotting][12.3 Functions and Variables for Plotting][System variable: gnuplot_view_args]: "In Windows versions of Gnuplot older than 4.6.3 the behavior of "~s -" and "-persist ~s" were the opposite; namely, "-persist ~s" made the plot window and the gnuplot interactive shell remain, while "~s -" closed the gnuplot shell keeping the plot window. Therefore, when older gnuplot versions are used in Windows, it might be necessary to adjust the value of gnuplot_view_args." (7) If he is indeed a [mathematica] user, then it is up to him to transfer -more-or-less "easily"- the graphics commands in the remaining just four 4 [maxima] multi-line commands beginning with: /*3*/, /*5*/, /*7*/, and /*9*/, to [mathematica], because: "Macsyma" [maxima] "was revolutionary in its day, and many later systems, such as Maple and Mathematica, were inspired by it" - at least, if not much more, more than that... Sincerely, gin&pez@arg 26 |
Re: edy555 design notes on CALIBRATION sets
This was a little unclear to me, but interesting.? Are you saying that you used the 51 ohm resistor held by the jaws of the alligator clips for calibration?? Then the data you posted was for that inductor?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Mike WY6K "... somewhere in the distance, there's a tower and a light, broadcastin' the resistance, through the rain and through the night..." On Wednesday, October 2, 2019, 12:11:09 PM CDT, Oristo <ormpoa@...> wrote:
On Mon, Jul 29, 2019 at 11:59 AM alan victor wrote: if you desire to use the nanoVNA as a component measurement tool, like anLCR meter, conduct your measurments at say 1 MHz or even 50 kHz!OSL calibration and measurement for alligator clips, using axial lead 51 Ohm resistor LOAD 23 Ohms 7 uH @ 0.1 MHz 5.5 Ohms 6.6uH @ 1 MHz 40 Ohms 400mH @ 10-100MHz ? 57 Ohms 900pH @500-900MHz Actual measurements had more separation between DUT and nanoVNA than shown in image hopefully attached; it matters particularly for air-wound coils... LCR measurement <> |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Hi Bryan,
I'm aware of the issue. I don't know if it can be turned off via the serial console - thus far, my advice to users has been to not put the device in TDR mode when using it with NanoVNA-Saver, and to use the TDR move in the application instead. If you do need to use TDR mode on the NanoVNA, disconnect it from NanoVNA-Saver first. If there is a way to distinguish and maybe even reset what mode it's in, I'd love to know! :-) -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019 at 19:23, bryburns via Groups.Io <bryburns= [email protected]> wrote: Rune, |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Rune,
Running firmware NanoVNA-H__900_ch_20190924.dfu from hugen with nanovna-saver.v0.1.0 This firmware has TDR mode built-in to the device. If the TDR Transform is enabled in the device, data sent to the PC is not what you expect. It appears to be the result of the TDR transform in some form. However, frequencies are those most recently commanded to the device. I am not sure how to turn off the transform from the PC. -- Bryan, WA5VAH |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Hi Larry,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
you're right - the application still thinks at that point that the NanoVNA is connected - despite having just received an error that it was disconnected. It should probably just disconnect when it gets the error. I'll put it on the list of little niggles ;-) Thanks for the feedback! -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019 at 19:10, Larry Rothman <nlroth@...> wrote:
Hi Rune,There is a small bug in the serial connect routine.If I disconnect |
Re: edy555 design notes on CALIBRATION sets
On Mon, Jul 29, 2019 at 11:59 AM alan victor wrote:
if you desire to use the nanoVNA as a component measurement tool, like anLCR meter, conduct your measurments at say 1 MHz or even 50 kHz!OSL calibration and measurement for alligator clips, using axial lead 51 Ohm resistor LOAD 23 Ohms 7 uH @ 0.1 MHz 5.5 Ohms 6.6uH @ 1 MHz 40 Ohms 400mH @ 10-100MHz 57 Ohms 900pH @500-900MHz Actual measurements had more separation between DUT and nanoVNA than shown in image hopefully attached; it matters particularly for air-wound coils... LCR measurement <> |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Hi Rune,There is a small bug in the serial connect routine.If I disconnect the Nano while scanning, I get the pop-up error and that's OK.If I then click on the Rescan button, the selected serial port disappears but the button underneath still shows "Disconnect".I think if there is no serial port shown, that should be reset as there is no recovery that I can see - 'Saver just hangs.
Regards,Larry |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Hi Nick,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
this looks ... interesting. The Gtk error isn't something I have any control over - it seems to be your Window Manager (at a guess?) or local Qt implementation that's using Gtk for its popups. It looks like a bug, but possibly not one I can fix... The dialog window for saving gets the following instruction in the code: filedialog.setDefaultSuffix("cal") This is supposed to set the default suffix to be added if no other suffix is provided, and it does on Windows at least. ;-) So sadly it looks a bit like Linux-specific Qt errors. (Or, of course, that I'm using it incorrectly, and it randomly happens to work on Windows. Both are likely! ;-) Thanks for getting back to me on this though, it's a very interesting problem! -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019 at 18:49, Nick <g3vnc@...> wrote:
Here's the console output when when I hit the load cal button... |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Here's the console output when when I hit the load cal button...
nick@LM19-2:~$ python3.7 ./nanovna-saver/nanovna-saver.py NanoVNASaver 0.1.0 Copyright (C) 2019 Rune B. Broberg This program comes with ABSOLUTELY NO WARRANTY This program is licensed under the GNU General Public License version 3 See for further details Settings: /home/nick/.config/NanoVNASaver/NanoVNASaver.ini Gtk-Message: 17:32:47.985: GtkDialog mapped without a transient parent. This is discouraged. I get the same Gtk-Message when I save a cal with or without the .cal extension. The cal files become visible if I give them a .cal extension. Files without the .cal extension are not visible in the object picker even when All Files is selected e.g. bnc_1 and bnc_2 are not visible to the object picker because they do not have the .cal extension. It is possible to save a cal file without the .cal extension in which case it is hidden from the object picker. Perhaps the save dialog should force a .cal extension e.g. by adding it automatically to the Name field? 73 Nick |
Re: NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Hi Bryan,
thanks for the feedback! The code used is the same for S11 and S21 charts of the same type, such as the return loss/gain charts - so the errors end up being the same ;-) Thanks for checking in any case! Early aim for next release is early next week. It depends how many features I try to push into it. ;-) -- Rune / 5Q5R On Wed, 2 Oct 2019 at 18:15, bryburns via Groups.Io <bryburns= [email protected]> wrote: Rune, |
to navigate to use esc to dismiss