¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io
Date

Re: Maldol mini-dipole and portable 10' mast

Stephen M. King
 

From: "Richard B Drake" <rich@...>
To: <FT817@...>
Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2001 5:25 PM
Subject: [FT817] RE: Maldol mini-dipole and portable 10' mast


However, one
difference in my plan is instead of using the PVC pipe as a mast
at the center of a horizontal dipole, I would slide one of the
whips into the PVC pipe for support and configure it as a center
fed "vertical" dipole.
VERY interesting idea! Please let us know how it works out ....

73,
Stephen
W3SMK


Re: ZM-2 tuner

Glyph
 

I have a ZM-2 -- my only complaint about it is that it wasn't designed for
rugged use -- such as my application on bicycle tours (a lot of vibration
and small shocks). The large and small toroids are not secured in place. I
gooped in a bunch of silicone to do the job. Hope the silicone doesn't
impair the function of the thing.

-- Bil KD6JUI

----- Original Message -----
From: Don <k7ugq@...>
To: <FT817@...>
Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2001 3:53 AM
Subject: [FT817] ZM-2 tuner


Enjoy these shots of NA1X's handy work on building this real neat and very
functional antenna tuner. After playing with them, it takes only 2 to 3
seconds to match the ft-817 to the antenna.

Bye

Don Johnson





***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM. Meet at
the food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to



Re: MP-1 vs ATX

 

--- In FT817@y..., Brickle@p... wrote:
don wrote:

...a BIG difference in making the lower mast about 3' long
instead
of the 10" stock length...
I had a chance to fool around with an MP-1 a little bit yesterday
evening, using the tripod, both the short and the 2' "mobile" mast,
the sectional (ie not telescoping) whip, and the stock counterpoise
bundle. I also eventually added a capacitance hat made of 2 pieces
of
#12 wire each 19" long at the top of the whip.

The longer mast and the hat appeared (in the few minutes I had
before
dark) to make an appreciable difference in tuning (both sharpness
and
low SWR), particularly when the hat was rotated to be parallel with
some of the counterpoise wires. However the hat made it impossible
to
tune on 10m with the longer mast. 38" of hat is probably too much.

BTW one big advantage of the MP-1 over the ATX, by me anyway, is
that
it *will* handle higher power (50w easy) if you've got it. And
lately
some extra power has become indispensable...love my 817 but it ain't
cutting it with the short antennas at the moment.

Frank
AB2KT
Frank - Get a 3/8" x 24 thread "long" nut, like used on mobile
mounts, and screw the 9" and 24" sections together - That makes
things even better. An a hat made with more (4) but shorter wires
will give the same perfomance with less interaction. I also find the
telescoping whip much easier to work with.

Don


Re: MP-1 vs ATX

 

don wrote:

...a BIG difference in making the lower mast about 3' long instead
of the 10" stock length...
I had a chance to fool around with an MP-1 a little bit yesterday
evening, using the tripod, both the short and the 2' "mobile" mast,
the sectional (ie not telescoping) whip, and the stock counterpoise
bundle. I also eventually added a capacitance hat made of 2 pieces of
#12 wire each 19" long at the top of the whip.

The longer mast and the hat appeared (in the few minutes I had before
dark) to make an appreciable difference in tuning (both sharpness and
low SWR), particularly when the hat was rotated to be parallel with
some of the counterpoise wires. However the hat made it impossible to
tune on 10m with the longer mast. 38" of hat is probably too much.

BTW one big advantage of the MP-1 over the ATX, by me anyway, is that
it *will* handle higher power (50w easy) if you've got it. And lately
some extra power has become indispensable...love my 817 but it ain't
cutting it with the short antennas at the moment.

Frank
AB2KT


PSK31 and HL50 mods (long)

Mike Agner
 

There were several messages a while back about how to create
your own cables for running the 817 in PSK31 mode. But for
those that want something different, here are the 4 or so
manufacturers that handle soundcard interfaces I know about
from the famous goodies list. There may be more of these, of
course, and if I have left someone out, please let me know:
--------------------
A. Rigblaster and Nomic
West Mountain Radio
18 Sheehan Avenue
Norwalk, CT 06854
Phone 203.853.8080
Fax 203.299.0232
URL:

B. Tigertronics Signalink Sound Card Interface
P.O. Box 5210 Grants Pass, Oregon 97527
Phone: 1-800-8BAYPAC (822-9722) FAX: (541)474-6703
URL:

C. PSK31 Isoterm
Mr J Melvin
2 Salters Court,
Gosforth,
Newcastle upon Tyne.
NE3 5BH.
ENGLAND.
Phone: 0191 2843028
Email: psk31@...
URL:

D. Windows SSTV VOX controller (useful for other modes, too)
Peter Lockwood G8SLB, 36 Davington Road, Dagenham, Essex, RM8 2LR
Email: G8SLB@...
URL:

E. The 'Rascal' and the 'Rascal Isolated' interfaces
BUX CommCo
115 Luenburg Drive
Evington, VA 24550
FAX: (804) 525-7818
URL:
--------------------------------------

Now about the HL50 mods:
These messages came in a while back and has very good
information on what to do. Note that I have left the ids
intact so someone can email these folks for more information:
---------------------------------
Date: Tue, 10 Apr 2001 07:57:20 -0400
From: "John O. Newell" <jnewell@...>
Subject: HL-50B Mod

During an HF-Pack QSO on Saturday, Norman K2YEW mentioned
that Tokyo Hy-Power would supply details on a mod to the
HL-50B amp that will allow full drive from 5w. (My LDG DWM
shows about 45w out from 5w drive using the 0-150w HF
sensor.) Bob KC3VO also mentioned a mod and offered to talk
it through on the telephone, but I've never followed up
because I hesitate to disturb the peace with the ring of the
telephone -- not sure whether this is the same mod. Anyway,
I emailed THP and with their usual blindingly fast and
friendly service, THP sent me the following information.

Replace existing components with new components (#s from
schematic supplied with amp):
R8 3.3 kOhm 0.25-0.50 Watt
R10 620 Ohm 2 Watt
R11 56 Ohm 2 Watt
R14 620 Ohm 1 Watt

Haven't tried it yet and all the usual disclaimers apply.

Date: Tue, 10 Apr 2001 12:13:07
From: "V G" <pmb1010@...>
Subject: Re: HL-50B Mod

I retrofitted my HL50B with the mentioned parts,
works perfect. 50w minimum now, and 60 on a couple
of bands (40 and 30, I think).
Be careful when you remove the board from the case.
The ribbon cable to front faceplate is very fragile.
I removed only the back cover and flipped the board over
with the ribbon cable, which was a mistake. Take off
both covers. I had to refab my ribbon cable when i
broke a couple of the delicate wires...
By the way, there are 2 schematics floating around.
The one I got with my rig was wrong. THP will gladly
fax the correct one you you for the asking. Those guys
REALLY know the meaning of "customer service"!
Vic K2YW


Date: Tue, 10 Apr 2001 12:58:57 EDT
From: K2YEW@...
Subject: Re: [HFpack] HL-50B Mod

Dear John,
FB on you purchasing the four resistors needed for the modification in order
to drive the HL-50B HF brick amplifier to its maximum output with only the 5
Watt output of the Yaesu FT-817 transceiver. After installing this mod, here
are the results, being careful to establish a perfectly flat 50 Ohm load on
the amplifier, 13.8 volts on the amplifier/FT-817, and measuring the power on
the power scale of my MFJ 969 tuner:


1/2W drive ---------------------------- 6W output [1 green light lit]
1W drive ------------------------------- 20W output [2 green lights lit]
2-1/2W drive ------------------------- 45W output [4 green lights lit]
5W drive ------------------------------ 65W output [5 green lights lit]

73s Mike


Re: Which Performs Better: ATX or MP-1?

Nick Marsh
 

julian@... wrote:

For an experiment in what you could do in the temporary indoor
situation I knocked up a rough and ready 15m dipole slung from a
light fitting, with the legs drooping and tucked down the back of
furniture.
Julian and others,

I travel a lot and have found motel rooms to be RF noisy.

Most U.S. hotels have fixed windows that don't open so a dipole draped
along the walls looked like the best deal one could get, until you turn
the radio on.

Some of the noise is TV and cable related, the rest, who knows?

Wishing for the all band, indoor glass mount, HF antenna for my 817.

73

Nick
WB4SQI


Resume delay when scanning with the FT817

David Harvey
 

I have programmed some of my local public service channels into the
FT817 so I can listen while I am tapping at the computer. However,
the resume function happens immediately and ignores whatever setting
(0,3,5,10) that I have entered.
Is there a fault in the 817, or is it some operator error?
Thanks.
es 72
de VK2DMH
DAVID


Undocumented use of Home button

Erik Schmidt
 

While fooling around with the menu's I found that the Home button will reset
menu's, e.g. 46 SSB MIC 54. If you press the Home button the default value
of 50 will be set. Maybe something for the FAQ.

Erik,
OZ1GIY
(Still having a lot of fun with the 817)


Re: MP-1 vs ATX

David Perry
 

Me too!

David

----- Original Message -----
From: <don@...>
To: <FT817@...>
Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2001 9:52 PM
Subject: [FT817] Re: MP-1 vs ATX


Some final speculation. Although the MP-1 ought theoretically to
outperform
the ATX by virtue of its bigger loading coil, you will only get the
benefit
of that if you have a very good ground system to go with it. In our
portable application with short wire ground planes or conterpoises,
it is
the ground resistance or the counterpoise, not the coil resistance
that is
determining performance. Therefore the ATX will probably work as
well as
any antenna of similar size used in that situation.

Anyone want to buy a used MP-1? :-)

--
Julian, G4ILO. (RSGB, ARRL)
Home page:
Julian - I did some computer modeling of the MP1 a while back, and
found a BIG difference in making the lower mast about 3' long instead
of the 10" stock length - like over 6 db on 7 mhz and decreasing to
about 3 db on 28 mHz (in fact, the performance should be sililar to
what you nboted on the Pro-am, as they would then be about the same
physical size). I have not found the MP1 to be as fussy about the
ground plane as the ATX, and the it certianly is more efficent, even
with the short lower section, on 10, 18 & 24 mHz. I use 4 radials 18'
long of 18 guage wire.

I've tried different counterpoise solutions, but the best seems to be
a "roll-up" counterpoise made from a Radio Shack short wave antenna -
no problem getting it to work on the MP1, but the ATX is EXTREEMLY
fussy - actually, the only way I can get the SWR anything close to
low on 14 mHz is by adjusting the length and then bring the end back
to near the rig..... putting it out in a straight line doesn't work
at all unless the whip on the ATX is made about 6" longer with a clip
lead - similar problem on 21 mHz. On 7 mHz, it is not fussy about the
groundplane and presents a reasonalble match across the whole band -
so does a dummy load!!! The MP-1 has a definite bandwidth that is
MUCH narrower, which means the coil is higher Q, and therefore should
be more efficent.

Yes - a dipole would be better - just as long as you have a place to
put it up. But also not as easy to change bands. And I shudder at the
thought of adding gear to the package in the form of an ATU. I am
very happy with the MP1 and the clamp mount or tripod - lets me get
the antenna outside in the clear, tunes easily, performs well.

I'll trade you my ATX for your MP-1 anyday

Don
W6ZO


***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM. Meet at
the food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to


Re: Looking under the hood of the '817...

Ray Goff
 

Clint,

Nice work, I look forward to the remaining sections...

72's Ray - g4fon

-----Original Message-----
From: cctbcn@... [mailto:cctbcn@...]
Sent: 15 May 2001 22:17
To: FT817@...
Subject: [FT817] Looking under the hood of the '817...


I've been doing a bit of looking under the hood of the FT-817 (having
owned one for a couple months now) and have been slowly putting
together some web pages describing what I have found. The pages may
be found at:



These pages detail things like receiver performance (image response
versus frequency, sensitivity, a few details as to why things work
the
way they do...) as well as things about the transmitter, FT-817 power
consumption, as well as how to optimize power consumption when
operating the '817 from batteries.

I have also done a bit of looking into the CAT command set and am
currently documenting a number of commands not outline that allow
much
more complete access to the inner workings of the '817 (including a
few things that could get you into *really big* trouble if you don't
take care.)

Also under construction are a few "app note" type of pages that
detail
using the '817 in signal strength measurements as well as using it
with Lithium-Ion batteries.

These pages are still under construction (some more than others) and
more are likely to be added. It is very likely that there will be
plenty of errors and typos that haven't been caught. If you see
obvious errors and/or omissions, please let me know about it (and
what
the correct information should be.)

73,

Clint



***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM. Meet at the
food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to


QST Article... Amateur Radio-The Last Line of Defense

 

The Public Service column of this month's (June) QST gives you a
sense of what's in store for my FT817 this summer, along with a
companion amp...just in case! Sold the TenTec for the joys of true
QRP with the 817.
Cheers Lynn 'Len' Hilborn VE3CSS


Re: New Product

Don
 

You say on the Daimond page... what is the url your refering to? I can't
thread this post.

Thanks

----- Original Message -----
From: <KG4CHX@...>
To: <FT817@...>
Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2001 8:46 AM
Subject: [FT817] Re: New Product


On the Daimond page you will see a multiband dipole, has fiberglass
spreaders and a balun in picture. Thia is the antenna sold by Yaesu.
I have one at QTH and it is a great performer. Low SWR across all HF
bands. Not great on 160, fais on 80 and FB on all others.
Wonder if we can buy direct from Diamond? Anyone have an e-mail
address??
Tim O'Rourke KG4CHX


***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM. Meet at
the food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to


Re: Maldol mini-dipole and portable 10' mast

 

Peter,

I find your post very interesting. I just ordered an 817 yesterday
and without even trying it yet, or seeing your post until just
now, I ordered a pair of 20 meter Maldol whips having in mind to
do almost exactly what you describe, right down to using the Radio
Shack mini box and connectors to make the center junction. If it
works out OK I'll get pairs of loading coils for the other bands.
I guess I have enough experience with whips and verticals to know
that this thing is not going to work very well without a good
counterpoise so let's dispense with that idea right off the bat.
The dipole configuration solves that problem. However, one
difference in my plan is instead of using the PVC pipe as a mast
at the center of a horizontal dipole, I would slide one of the
whips into the PVC pipe for support and configure it as a center
fed "vertical" dipole. I should be able to mount that as a
temporary antenna on my boat simply by standing it up in a fishing
rod holder. I wonder if anyone has tried anything like that? I'll
look forward to any pointers you may be able to provide and I will
certainly share my own experiences with the group.

----
73, Rich - W3ZJ

From: "Peter A. Brandenberg" <peter@b...>
Date: Fri May 11, 2001 11:30 pm
Subject: Maldol mini-dipole and portable 10' mast.


I was tired of trying to match a counterpoise to my Maldols, so I
made a
small dipole out of a set of two for each band. It works like a
charm! I
used a Radio Shack plastic box about 1.5" x 3" and put a coax
connector at
the end, and on either side a male jack for each of the Maldol
whips. Then
I bought a 10' length of 3/4" PVC and cut it into 24" pieces with
connecting
sleeves at the end of each piece. Then I can easily carry the
whole
shebang, 817, paddle, mike, battery, dipoles, and 10' mast in a
small
carrying case for easy setup.

I also have the auto-tuner that helps get the SWR to 1:1. I found
that the
20 meter Maldol is resonant at 13.8 and to get it up to 14.05 or
higher I
have to compress the whips several inches, losing radiation area.

I'd be happy to share details should anyone want them.

Also can someone tell me how I can get the 817 up to 5 watts if I
use a 12
volt battery???? Apparently if the radio doesn't see 13 volts it
runs only
2.5 watts. That is dumb!

Thanks, 73, Peter K2MMT



-----
73, Rich - W3ZJ
www.w3zj.com


Looking under the hood of the '817...

 

I've been doing a bit of looking under the hood of the FT-817 (having
owned one for a couple months now) and have been slowly putting
together some web pages describing what I have found. The pages may
be found at:



These pages detail things like receiver performance (image response
versus frequency, sensitivity, a few details as to why things work
the
way they do...) as well as things about the transmitter, FT-817 power
consumption, as well as how to optimize power consumption when
operating the '817 from batteries.

I have also done a bit of looking into the CAT command set and am
currently documenting a number of commands not outline that allow
much
more complete access to the inner workings of the '817 (including a
few things that could get you into *really big* trouble if you don't
take care.)

Also under construction are a few "app note" type of pages that
detail
using the '817 in signal strength measurements as well as using it
with Lithium-Ion batteries.

These pages are still under construction (some more than others) and
more are likely to be added. It is very likely that there will be
plenty of errors and typos that haven't been caught. If you see
obvious errors and/or omissions, please let me know about it (and
what
the correct information should be.)

73,

Clint


Re: MP-1 vs ATX

 

Some final speculation. Although the MP-1 ought theoretically to
outperform
the ATX by virtue of its bigger loading coil, you will only get the
benefit
of that if you have a very good ground system to go with it. In our
portable application with short wire ground planes or conterpoises,
it is
the ground resistance or the counterpoise, not the coil resistance
that is
determining performance. Therefore the ATX will probably work as
well as
any antenna of similar size used in that situation.

Anyone want to buy a used MP-1? :-)

--
Julian, G4ILO. (RSGB, ARRL)
Home page:
Julian - I did some computer modeling of the MP1 a while back, and
found a BIG difference in making the lower mast about 3' long instead
of the 10" stock length - like over 6 db on 7 mhz and decreasing to
about 3 db on 28 mHz (in fact, the performance should be sililar to
what you nboted on the Pro-am, as they would then be about the same
physical size). I have not found the MP1 to be as fussy about the
ground plane as the ATX, and the it certianly is more efficent, even
with the short lower section, on 10, 18 & 24 mHz. I use 4 radials 18'
long of 18 guage wire.

I've tried different counterpoise solutions, but the best seems to be
a "roll-up" counterpoise made from a Radio Shack short wave antenna -
no problem getting it to work on the MP1, but the ATX is EXTREEMLY
fussy - actually, the only way I can get the SWR anything close to
low on 14 mHz is by adjusting the length and then bring the end back
to near the rig..... putting it out in a straight line doesn't work
at all unless the whip on the ATX is made about 6" longer with a clip
lead - similar problem on 21 mHz. On 7 mHz, it is not fussy about the
groundplane and presents a reasonalble match across the whole band -
so does a dummy load!!! The MP-1 has a definite bandwidth that is
MUCH narrower, which means the coil is higher Q, and therefore should
be more efficent.

Yes - a dipole would be better - just as long as you have a place to
put it up. But also not as easy to change bands. And I shudder at the
thought of adding gear to the package in the form of an ATU. I am
very happy with the MP1 and the clamp mount or tripod - lets me get
the antenna outside in the clear, tunes easily, performs well.

I'll trade you my ATX for your MP-1 anyday

Don
W6ZO


Re: NEW FT817 ACCESSORIES + MORE AT Dayton NEWS

 

Works for me now, too. Never mind.

--- In FT817@y..., "Michael Minor" <nh6cj@h...> wrote:
I just left the site (18:15 UTC)and it worked fine...



From: "F.B. Nutter, Jr." <fbnjr@m...>
Reply-To: FT817@y...
To: FT817@y...
Subject: Re: [FT817] Re: NEW FT817 ACCESSORIES + MORE AT Dayton
NEWS
Date: Tue, 15 May 2001 13:38:10 -0400

I've been there & they have some neat items for the 817. Make sure
you're entering the URL right.
73, Fil W8FIL

ermisch@u... wrote:

www.w4rt.com or the IP address associated with w4rt.com doesn't
appear to have a web server running. Is this the correct URL?

Paul

--- In FT817@y..., w8hq@y... wrote:
If you will be attending the Dayton event, stop by Booth
114 and
check them out. Otherwise, check out their website: W4RT
ELECTRONICS www.w4rt.com

Wow,

Just what we were looking for...solves the poorly designed
battery
cover and the capacity/charging problem in one shot. I hope
they
have
a bunch of them at Dayton. The MaHa battery alone is $39.

Also look at the Austin Radio web site for an early
announcement of
Yaesu rebates during Dayton which all dealers will offer

Many will be kicking themselves for buying early...coupons
worth
$20
to $50 depending on the Yaesu product.

I have no commercial interest or gain from GigaParts, Austin
Radio
or
the w4rt guys. PS:Does anyone know if they are related to RT
systems ?? maybe some software for the FT817 ???

Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
[www.debticated.com]


***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM.
Meet
at the food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently
Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of
Service.



_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at


Re: HL-50B amp

Newell, John O
 

just arrived in the mail today the thp hl-50b amp
Mike, there are quite a few posts on the HL-50B, including the ALC connx and
tx pwr mod, in the FT817 group archive. There are also quite a few posts
(many not duplicates of posts here) in the archive for the HFPack group,
also on Yahoo...if you do a search for "HL-50B" in the subject line you will
come up with most of them.

GL es 73
John Newell
KB1FPM








































------------------------------------------------------------------------
This message is intended only for the designated recipient(s). It may
contain confidential or proprietary information and may be subject to the
attorney-client privilege or other confidentiality protections. If you are
not a designated recipient, you may not review, copy or distribute
this message. If you receive this in error, please notify the sender by
reply e-mail and delete this message. Thank you.


Re: Which Performs Better: ATX or MP-1?

Demetre Valaris - SV1UY
 

Hi guys,

I agree with Julian in most of what he says. We must not forget that
the ATX and MP-1 are convenience antennas and it all depends on which
way one uses his/her portable radio. I personally did not buy the FT-
817 to operate from home where I can have a decent aerial, such as a
dipole. I bought it to operate while I walk and when I am on holidays
and that means that I have to use a small aerial. The ATX is the
smallest multiband I have seen so far and I am quite happy with it
even if it has limitations. When I walk I cannot carry a 3 element
YAGI. Sometimes I wish I could though!!!

The MP-1 should be better than the ATX because of its bigger coil and
also because one can use a longer base section up to 1 meter or so.
The ATX has only got a 30cm wander lead which is like a base section
on the bands of 40m and above, but of course its coil is made from
think wire and the Q is rather low. I wish I had the time to stay
outside on the field and test both antennas with the same
counterpoise. Who knows, maybe some time this summer I might do it,
or maybe when I am on holiday. My father in law has a big enough
private garden for this experiment, so I might go there! Will keep
the list posted.

I do not think that experiments inside ones house are good. Any kind
of antenna inside a house will be a poor performer.

73 de Demetre SV1UY


Re: Which Performs Better: ATX or MP-1?

 

--- In FT817@y..., julian@t... wrote:
It would be nice to have more discussion
of antennas you can make here on this list.

Julian, G4ILO
Also Julian,,

Just in case you don't know the site,
You can find some interesting info at:



Rgds
David


Re: Which Performs Better: ATX or MP-1?

David Perry
 

Good points well made, but the comment "as well as any antenna that size"
says it all.

As I said, I'll keep trying.

So far the ATX has HA and SP.

David

----- Original Message -----
From: <julian@...>
To: <FT817@...>
Sent: Tuesday, May 15, 2001 7:40 PM
Subject: [FT817] Re: Which Performs Better: ATX or MP-1?


Well I am impressed with how well it works for its size. I don't
think anyone would use it from a picnic table if they could put up a
good dipole but it isn't so easy to do that in many situations (e.g.
hilltops with no trees) nor if you are operating from a hotel room or
similar. A longwire will not work very well if you don't have a
ground to tune it against, which again is hard to find out there in
the field.

For an experiment in what you could do in the temporary indoor
situation I knocked up a rough and ready 15m dipole slung from a
light fitting, with the legs drooping and tucked down the back of
furniture. Signals were broadly comparable with the ATX but in some
cases the ATX was better, presumably because of directivity of the
dipole. The dipole provided useful receive coverage down to 40m, it's
worth noting, even when plugged straight into the rig, although I
couldn't load it up on all bands, even using the ZM-2.

As I said before, I think the ATX works as well as any antenna that
size can be expected to work. Obviously, something bigger will work
better, but if you need to use something that small and easy to erect
you've got to expect to compromise. However if anyone comes up with a
better small wonder antenna I'm sure we'd all like the details so we
can make one and try it out. It would be nice to have more discussion
of antennas you can make here on this list.

Julian, G4ILO

--- In FT817@y..., "David Perry" <david.perry3@v...> wrote:

Well I have spent hours now playing with the ATX and must say I am
not
impressed at all.

I really appreciate Julian's work on the counterpoises but let's be
hoinest,
by the time you have played with enough wire to string up the moon
you still
have a fifty inch radiator! Much better surely to make a decent
dipole or
even longwire and tuner, and really get some wire in the sky.

IF the ATX worked as it is from a picknick table then it would be
great, but
it doesn't.

As a dummy load it's not even 50ohms!

I'll carry on playing but, mmm, going to a dipole I think.

Having said that I called CQ today, stating QRP and /P and the SP5
station
told me to go away, I wasn't Dx enough!!!

David G4YVM



***____FLASH_____**
FT-817 users GET TOGETHER at Dayton Hamvention Saturday at 3PM. Meet at
the food court nearest to the Yaesu booth. 439.125 simplex.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
FT817-unsubscribe@... and for a great FAQ ( Frequently Asked
Questions ) see



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to