开云体育

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 开云体育

Question on the Synoptic Gospel problem - an academic Quagmire


 

THE SYNOPTIC GOSPEL PROBLEM – AN ACADEMIC QUAGMIRE

G’day all,

Although U3A Class R09 is on hiatus over Term 2, 2022, the discussion forum and website are still open.? Please feel free to comment on or ask anything.? This email addresses the following query:

QUESTION FROM A PARTICIPANT:

We don’t know who actually wrote the synoptic gospels whether it was the disciples themselves or their scribes. Some books I have read written by bible scholars refer to a hypothetical document “Q”.? This mystery document is supposed to be the first ever written account of the synoptic gospels and these accounts have been copied,? translated and modified down through the ages. Whether the theory is that there were three documents “Q “, one for each disciple, or just one, I am not sure.?

I would appreciate your opinion on how the very first accounts of each of the synoptic gospels have been identified and your thoughts on a document or documents “Q”


Further to the preliminary answer provided a week or so ago, I have attached a 3-1/2 page PDF response (with lots of graphics) entitled "What About Q.pdf".

In addition, two academic papers are attached for those who may want to look deeper.?

  • “The Lost?Gospel Of Q—Fact Or Fantasy?” by Dr. Eta Linnemann - educated among the very heart of the beast that originated this heresy (for that's what it is), she rebelled against the theory and gives a cogent discussion in this lengthy paper.? For the record, she published a shorter paper in the Biblical Archaeology Review that despite my membership I was unable to download.

  • “The Gospel of Q: A Public Domain Translation” by Dr. Mark Mattison.? This academic paper on the pro-Q side saves you from wading through all the convoluted jargon and gives you a look in English at what the Q-source issue is all about.

I really enjoyed doing this research.? Thanks heaps for the question.? I hope that I've answered your query okay.

Blessings,

Ray?
Tutor U3A E09

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.