Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
Search
Best Crazy Horse Concert?
I hope this might be an interesting discussion for the new year.? Over the years, Neil has shared many CDs and Timeline Concerts featuring Crazy Horse.? This is a tough question, but which live recording with Crazy Horse is your favorite?? Is there one that you keep going back to??
?
Long time Rustie and Lurker,
Scott
Ordinary Person |
I started listening to Neil when I was 16 or 17 years old. And at that time Weld came out so that immediately became my favorite live recording. Especially the version of Cortez on Weld resonates with me. Last week I compared Weld to the Rustbucket album and that was a nice surprise. The sound quality and the overall feel of the recording seems to better than Weld, to my ears at last. So I guess that would be my new favorite live recording. Quite happy by the way with all the emerging timeline recordings! |
Agree on Weld, it was also a 'gateway' record for me and I love the effects he strangles out of Old Black, think it's the Whizzer that makes it sound like techtonic plates are shifting. Love To Burn and Hurricane are unbelievable as well as the Cortez / Powderfinger combo.? I think Hurricane is from Buffalo and the video of it shows the sheer physicality of Neil's playing, he looks completely exhausted at the end of it.
On Wednesday 8 January 2025 at 10:33:53 GMT, Rogier van den Braak via groups.io <rogiervandenbraak72@...> wrote:
I started listening to Neil when I was 16 or 17 years old. And at that time Weld came out so that immediately became my favorite live recording. Especially the version of Cortez on Weld resonates with me. Last week I compared Weld to the Rustbucket album and that was a nice surprise. The sound quality and the overall feel of the recording seems to better than Weld, to my ears at last. So I guess that would be my new favorite live recording. Quite happy by the way with all the emerging timeline recordings!
|
Weld is great!!!?? One note that some may remember (but others may not) is that the "audio mix" on the home video of Weld was completed by Neil with Briggs, Hanlon, Mulligan and Nowland...while the CD release of Weld was produced by Neil with Briggs and Talbot.??If my memory serves me well, I believe there was an interview where Neil indicated that he preferred the Weld video mix to the Weld CD mix.? So, for us fans who loved some songs on the CD, perhaps we should more-closely check out the mix of those songs the Weld video version! Screen shot from NYAS: Screen shot from NYAS: Some data I reformatted from the Weld Wikipedia entry (so grain of salt) - this is info regarding the Weld CD version: 01? "Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)" 每 5:42 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ? Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 02? "Crime in the City" 每 6:32 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing ? ? ? ??David Briggs 每 production, mixing 03? "Blowin' in the Wind" (Bob Dylan) ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 04? "Welfare Mothers" 每 7:04 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ? ?Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ? David Briggs 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??John Hanlon 每 mixing 05? "Love to Burn" 每 10:01 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??David Briggs 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 06? "Cinnamon Girl" 每 4:45 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ?Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ?John Nowland 每 mixing 07? "Mansion on the Hill" 每 6:14 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 08? "Fuckin' Up" 每 7:09 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ?Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ?David Briggs 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ?John Nowland 每 mixing ?09? "Cortez the Killer" 每 9:46 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??David Briggs 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??John Hanlon 每 mixing 10? "Powderfinger" 每 5:58 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 11? "Love and Only Love" 每 9:17 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 12? "Rockin' in the Free World" 每 9:22 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 13? "Like a Hurricane" 每 14:00 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 14? "Farmer John" (Don Harris, Dewey Terry) 每 5:00 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ? Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 15? "Tonight's the Night" 每 8:45 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing 16? "Roll Another Number" 每 5:19 ? ? ? ? Dave Hewitt 每 recording ? ? ? ??Neil Young 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ??Billy Talbot 每 production, mixing ? ? ? ? Phil Gitomer??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Dave Roberts??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Brian Leskowicz??每 assistant engineering ? ? ? ??Tim Mulligan 每 mixing, editing, mastering ? ? ? ??John Nowland 每 mixing
On Wednesday, January 8, 2025 at 05:48:20 AM EST, Craig Dancy via groups.io <csjd71@...> wrote:
Agree on Weld, it was also a 'gateway' record for me and I love the effects he strangles out of Old Black, think it's the Whizzer that makes it sound like techtonic plates are shifting. Love To Burn and Hurricane are unbelievable as well as the Cortez / Powderfinger combo.? I think Hurricane is from Buffalo and the video of it shows the sheer physicality of Neil's playing, he looks completely exhausted at the end of it.
On Wednesday 8 January 2025 at 10:33:53 GMT, Rogier van den Braak via groups.io <rogiervandenbraak72@...> wrote:
I started listening to Neil when I was 16 or 17 years old. And at that time Weld came out so that immediately became my favorite live recording. Especially the version of Cortez on Weld resonates with me. Last week I compared Weld to the Rustbucket album and that was a nice surprise. The sound quality and the overall feel of the recording seems to better than Weld, to my ears at last. So I guess that would be my new favorite live recording. Quite happy by the way with all the emerging timeline recordings!
|
If you want to dig deep into the differences between the various versions of Weld, I recommend visiting this link: and search for Weld.?
?
It's not easy to navigate the table, but if I've read it correct 11 tracks are from the same source.
The following are the ones that differ:
The video version of Cinnamon Girl is taken from Buffalo 2/16, the version on the album and laser disc is from Landover 2/27.
Cortez the KIller on the video also is Buffalo 2/16, album and laser disc version is from Pittsburgh 2/17.?
Hey Hey, My My (Into The Black) video and laser disc is from Pittsburgh 2/17, album version is taken from Landover 2/27.
Mansion On The Hill laser disc version is Buffalo 2/16 and video and album version is from Landover 2/27.
Powderfinger is the only one with 3 sources. Laser disc version is Buffalo 2/16, video version is Pittsburgh 2/17 and album version is Landover 2/27.
?
Bear
?
? |
羲堁极郤And throw in the Buffalo Weld show that was on The Archives site a year or two ago, as a bonus disc. ? Transformer Man.? On Jan 9, 2025, at 4:08?PM, Rogier van den Braak via groups.io <rogiervandenbraak72@...> wrote:
|
to navigate to use esc to dismiss