These are just ideas, not a real?Friday Five!
What do you contribute toward improving the world or benefiting humanity?
What in your opinion is the human?mind and?how does?it impact your?life?
What in your opinion should we change about consumer?culture and why?
What would you like to be posthumously remembered for and why?
Is a hypothetical?average human life more important than a hypothetical average dog's life? Why do you think (or not think) so?
I could probably brainstorm more, but I am tired. :)
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Fri, Mar 29, 2024 at 5:40?PM mrvnchpmn < chapman@...> wrote:
?
No jokes - just difficult to write questions.
As for the ship incident - we are never going to be sure of what happened - the one thing we are most likely to be sure of is that the official government report? will do anything but ell us what really happeed.
Marvin
?
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
?
I am sometimes staring at these questions for a really long moment, perhaps seeking the joke or the trick hidden in them!
?
In this case, my knee-jerk response was "Only when I can, too!"
?
No. The term illegal immigrant does not mean an immigrant who is exempt from legal restrictions. It refers?to a trespasser?who probably should not be encouraged to polish his skills by taking new steps in his career. Illegal immigrants should be allowed to turn themselves in to the Border Patrol, thus achieving a form of shelter from the experts.
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
?
I cannot see why not. Despite immigration being?a federal purview, local law enforcement are often supporting?federal agencies. I would even go so far as to say that any law enforcement agent has a duty to make such an arrest.
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
?
I could see some validity to this. Reciprocity exists?between some states, as with various permits and licenses. I would expect such an arrangement to be subject to oversight, of course, and not automated.?
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
?
Looks like the ship had a mechanical issue and pulled off the road in a bad spot! I understand they?did try to call for help from a tug and they did notify authorities. I am withholding?any more indignant comments until the official investigation results arrive.
?
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
?
See above. Depends?upon the circumstances. Having?said that, I would also have to admit I was assuming that such would be the case anyway.
?
?
|
?
No jokes - just difficult to write questions.
As for the ship incident - we are never going to be sure of what happened - the one thing we are most likely to be sure of is that the official government report? will do anything but ell us what really happeed.
Marvin
?
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
?
I am sometimes staring at these questions for a really long moment, perhaps seeking the joke or the trick hidden in them!
?
In this case, my knee-jerk response was "Only when I can, too!"
?
No. The term illegal immigrant does not mean an immigrant who is exempt from legal restrictions. It refers?to a trespasser?who probably should not be encouraged to polish his skills by taking new steps in his career. Illegal immigrants should be allowed to turn themselves in to the Border Patrol, thus achieving a form of shelter from the experts.
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
?
I cannot see why not. Despite immigration being?a federal purview, local law enforcement are often supporting?federal agencies. I would even go so far as to say that any law enforcement agent has a duty to make such an arrest.
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
?
I could see some validity to this. Reciprocity exists?between some states, as with various permits and licenses. I would expect such an arrangement to be subject to oversight, of course, and not automated.?
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
?
Looks like the ship had a mechanical issue and pulled off the road in a bad spot! I understand they?did try to call for help from a tug and they did notify authorities. I am withholding?any more indignant comments until the official investigation results arrive.
?
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
?
See above. Depends?upon the circumstances. Having?said that, I would also have to admit I was assuming that such would be the case anyway.
?
?
|
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
I am sometimes staring at these questions for a really long moment, perhaps seeking the joke or the trick hidden in them!
In this case, my knee-jerk response was "Only when I can, too!"
No. The term illegal immigrant does not mean an immigrant who is exempt from legal restrictions. It refers?to a trespasser?who probably should not be encouraged to polish his skills by taking new steps in his career. Illegal immigrants should be allowed to turn themselves in to the Border Patrol, thus achieving a form of shelter from the experts. 2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
I cannot see why not. Despite immigration being?a federal purview, local law enforcement are often supporting?federal agencies. I would even go so far as to say that any law enforcement agent has a duty to make such an arrest.
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
I could see some validity to this. Reciprocity exists?between some states, as with various permits and licenses. I would expect such an arrangement to be subject to oversight, of course, and not automated.?
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
Looks like the ship had a mechanical issue and pulled off the road in a bad spot! I understand they?did try to call for help from a tug and they did notify authorities. I am withholding?any more indignant comments until the official investigation results arrive.
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
See above. Depends?upon the circumstances. Having?said that, I would also have to admit I was assuming that such would be the case anyway.
|
Re: [m-scholars-and-scribes] Re: Friday Five March 29
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
No
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
Yes
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
Yes - this would bring the laws of countries like Mexico to the people who come here from there - maybe they would rise up and change their country o origin circumstances.? At the very least people not permanently legally resident should not be counted in the decimal census apportioning congressional representation.? And people who illegally entered should be forbidden from ever becoming immigrants.? And lastly there should not be birthright citizenship granted to infants born of people who are not permanent legal residents.
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
We will never know - it certainly was a Black Swan event.? Too many things are being hidden.
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
Yes - but the probably maximum penalty that can be charged is most likely the value of the ship.? Biden is absurd when he says the US government will pay the full cost of replacement.
?
?
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "M-Scholars and Scribes" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to m-scholars-and-scribes+unsubscribe@....
To view this discussion on the web visit .
|
1.? Should
illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes
without the permission of the owner?
Squatting is illegal no matter who is doing it.
2,?
Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal
immigrants for trespassing?
That is the current law. They just cannot deport anyone.
3.?
Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or
immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to
US visitors or immigrants?
No. Every nation has its own priorities.
4.? The
Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
I believe that the fault lies with the Baltimore Port Authority for
not anticipating this kind of situation.
5.?
?Should the owner of the ship or the company that
chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
No. That would ultimately result in increased prices for consumer
goods.
Aloha,
Celeste Rogers
|
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
No one should be allowed to occupy vacant homes without permission of the owner.
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
States should be allowed to arrest trespassers regardless of their immigration status.
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
No, the laws within a country should apply equally to every adult.
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
A container ship¡¯s power failed and it crashed into a bridge.
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
Liability depends on the cause of the incident, and the cause has not yet been established.
Ed
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Friday, March 29, 2024, mrvnchpmn < chapman@...> wrote:
?
?
?
?
?
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
?
|
?
?
?
?
?
1.? Should illegal immigrants be allowed to occupy vacant homes without the permission of the owner?
2,? Should individual states be allowed to arrest illegal immigrants for trespassing?
3.? Should the US laws be reciprocal toward visitors or immigrants to the degree that their home counties are to US visitors or immigrants?
4.? The Baltimore bridge collapse - what happened?
5.? ?Should the owner of the ship or the company that chartered it be held liable for the replacement cost?
?
|
1.? Define
the word disinformation
Disinformation is false information which is intended to mislead
others.
2.?
Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Well, I don't think any other nation can do anything effective in
Haiti. So we need to get our legislature to figure out what we
should do there and get a bill passed so we can do it.
3.? Who
is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Both Israel and Hamas
4.? What
20th century genocide killed the highest portion of
the single countries population?
Pol Pot's genocide in Cambodia
5.? ?Are
you considering voting for a third party presidential
candidate this year?
No.
Aloha,
Celeste Rogers
|
. 1.? Define the word disinformation Anything and everything that comes out of Justin Trudeau's mouth. That is, false information which is deliberately intended to mislead¡ªintentionally misstating the facts. 2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti? No 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
There is no famine crisis in Gaza. The claim of famine is more lies from Hamas, along with their lies about how many have been killed and how many of those are women and children. All of it "supported" by their booming Pallywood industry, where dolls or healthy people play the part of injured and dead civilians, with a liberal dash of fake blood splashed across the bandages that hide their healthy bodies. The part of "starving children" has mainly been played by one little boy with cerebral palsy, who is unable to eat normally and is very thin, with other signs, of course, of disability. I have seen him displayed in several different settings, usually being cried over by various healthily plump women.? Before October 7, approximately 70 trucks loaded with aid were entering Gaza every day. Now, there are well over 200 trucks loaded with aid entering every day. Israel is not in any way restricting the aid that can enter, and in fact is inspecting it far more quickly than it can be distributed; there are trucks lined up INSIDE Gaza, already admitted but not distributed. Plus, Israel has excess capacity to process even more aid, if anyone wants to send more. There are problems inside Gaza with distribution, thus there are a few pockets of hunger - NOT famine - ?in the north. Distribution problems include, of course, the trucks being seized by Hamas and the aid taken for their own use, or sold to the population at vastly inflated prices. Also, Hamas has been opening fire on the crowds of Gazans gathered to receive the aid. As well, vast crowds of unruly Gazans have been trampelling each other to death as the trucks arrive, or being run down by the trucks. Note that they have also injured and killed some of the drivers and damaged some of the trucks. This is not an orderly and peaceful population. 4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population? Armenia 1915. ?Note that there was another Armenian genocide in 2023, this time carried out by Azerbaijan. It sucks to live near an Islamic country or territory. 5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year? I'm not considering voting for any presidential candidate this year. I suspect the US system would object to a Canadian voting. On second thought, if I voted Democrat they'd probably let me do it multiple times. Why do they call it a "3rd party candidate"? They appear to be running as independents, not as part of a 3rd party. If I was voting in the USA I would probably vote for Mr. Trump. I also like RFK Jr., except for his extreme belief in the climate change hoax.? Pat ? ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
------ Original Message ------ From: chapman@... To: [email protected]; [email protected]; m-scholars-and-scribes@... Sent: Friday, March 22nd 2024, 06:35 AM Subject: Re: [M-Powered] Friday Five March 22 ? 1.? Define the word disinformation
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
?
|
. Rwanda
600,000 versus population of 6.3 million ??9.5% April 7 - July 14
Ukraine
3.3 million versus population of 36 million ? 9.2% July 1932 - September 1933
Cambodia
3 million versus population of 6.3? million ? ?47.6% 1976 - 1978
Poland
6 million versus population 30 million ? ? ? ? ? 20% ? Armenia Records vary. 1.5 million out of a population of 1.9 million ? ? ?78.9% Or, 664,000 (min) vs a population of 1.5 million ? ? 44.3% Up to 1.2 million out of a population of 1.5 million ? ?80% 1915 Looks like Armenia wins the prize, though if one looked at the Jewish population of Europe in the 1930s to 1940s, the percentage slaughtered might be even higher.
Pat ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
------ Original Message ------ From: chapman@... To: [email protected]; [email protected]; m-scholars-and-scribes@... Sent: Friday, March 22nd 2024, 06:19 PM Subject: Re: [M-Powered] genocide statistics ?
?
Rwanda
600,000 versus population of 6.3 million ? 9.5% April 7 - July 14
Ukraine
3.3 million versus population of 36 million ? 9.2% July 1932 - September 1933
Cambodia
3 million versus population of 6.3? million ? ?47.6% 1976 - 1978
Poland
6 million versus population 30 million ? ? ? ? ? 20%
?
|
?
?
Rwanda
600,000 versus population of 6.3 million
April 7 - July 14
Ukraine
3.3 million versus population of 36 million
July 1932 - September 1933
Cambodia
3 million versus population of 6.3? million
1976 - 1978
Poland
6 million versus population 30 million
?
|
?
The only person who will be able to stop th e horrors will be the last person standing.
?
Oh. Different?interpretations, ten, Ed.? I rarely use that particular perspective?of individual origin as I see every person (and his actions) as the sum of the contributing factors leading to that person in this moment. This does not mean?
I fail to recognize the contribution of the person's actions, but those actions would not exist without the infinite path of history that led to them.
?
Netanyahu would not have acted exactly?as he did without the Hamas attack. Hamas would not have attacked without the contributions of both Palestinian and Israeli?history. Or without the holes in Israel's?defenses, or the sources that supplied the weapons and equipment. Those sources exist because of the impact of financial wealth on individual circumstances, etc, etc. In the end, in this moment, the only choice we each have is how we each act. We can assign blame, but we cannot reverse the actions that led us to that and so we have to ask what good are we doing?
?
In the end, every turning point can be linked to a previous one.? Netanyahu > Hamas > Israeli?state > Palestinian state > Britain's choices in the Middle East > Islam > Judaism > Human minds > evolution > a mammal leaving the trees for life aground > a meteor devastating the dominant dinosaur population > the sun creating the Earth > gravity contributing the the path of that meteor > ...and so on. Each thing depends upon the last.
?
I would ask, "Who can stop the horrors?"
?
D
?
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 1:47?PM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote:
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
When Marvin wrote who is to blame for the famine, I take it as meaning what one person could have stopped or avoided it.
As with Putin and the 100,000 deaths in Ukraine, the famine is due to Netanyahu's action. ?
?
?
Not sure where the part about Putin having?nothing to do with it came from, Ed? My opinions?in the original response were that everyone and everything had a part in the long run up from the Big Bang to the Gaza war. Ukraine is, of course, just another version of the same phenomenon.?
?
As for (not) feeding, I do not feel guilt is a required emotion. Or an effective one, for the most part. Yes, though, if I am not feeding or helping to feed (or heal or house or whatever), then I am contributing to the pain felt by those who are impacted. This seems obvious to me.
?
Note that I am speaking for myself, not as a representative of the U.S., even though I did lace my post with some nationally relevant?thoughts. I do not think that I can speak for the masses even though I do feel the need to feed would be best served by widespread represetationinN!
?
D
?
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 11:57?AM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote:
So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
?
?
1.? Define the word disinformation
?
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
?
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and?
general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing.
3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
?
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
?
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
?
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
|
?
Was he supposed to just sit back and let Israelis die in their own homes - my thought was that Hamas started this and could end it at any point - but just keep it up to get notoriety - as well as the have more publicity about all the starving children who look a to more nourished than more of the third world.
?
When Marvin wrote who is to blame for the famine, I take it as meaning what one person could have stopped or avoided it.
As with Putin and the 100,000 deaths in Ukraine, the famine is due to Netanyahu's action. ?
?
?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Not sure where the part about Putin having?nothing to do with it came from, Ed? My opinions?in the original response were that everyone and everything had a part in the long run up from the Big Bang to the Gaza war. Ukraine is, of course, just another version of the same phenomenon.?
?
As for (not) feeding, I do not feel guilt is a required emotion. Or an effective one, for the most part. Yes, though, if I am not feeding or helping to feed (or heal or house or whatever), then I am contributing to the pain felt by those who are impacted. This seems obvious to me.
?
Note that I am speaking for myself, not as a representative of the U.S., even though I did lace my post with some nationally relevant?thoughts. I do not think that I can speak for the masses even though I do feel the need to feed would be best served by widespread represetationinN!
?
D
?
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 11:57?AM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote:
So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
?
?
1.? Define the word disinformation
?
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
?
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and?
general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing.
3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
?
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
?
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
?
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
|
Oh. Different?interpretations, ten, Ed.? I rarely use that particular perspective?of individual origin as I see every person (and his actions) as the sum of the contributing factors leading to that person in this moment. This does not mean? I fail to recognize the contribution of the person's actions, but those actions would not exist without the infinite path of history that led to them.
Netanyahu would not have acted exactly?as he did without the Hamas attack. Hamas would not have attacked without the contributions of both Palestinian and Israeli?history. Or without the holes in Israel's?defenses, or the sources that supplied the weapons and equipment. Those sources exist because of the impact of financial wealth on individual circumstances, etc, etc. In the end, in this moment, the only choice we each have is how we each act. We can assign blame, but we cannot reverse the actions that led us to that and so we have to ask what good are we doing?
In the end, every turning point can be linked to a previous one.?
Netanyahu > Hamas > Israeli?state > Palestinian state > Britain's choices in the Middle East > Islam > Judaism > Human minds > evolution > a mammal leaving the trees for life aground > a meteor devastating the dominant dinosaur population > the sun creating the Earth > gravity contributing the the path of that meteor > ...and so on. Each thing depends upon the last.
I would ask, "Who can stop the horrors?"
D
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 1:47?PM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote: When Marvin wrote who is to blame for the famine, I take it as meaning what one person could have stopped or avoided it. As with Putin and the 100,000 deaths in Ukraine, the famine is due to Netanyahu's action. ?
Not sure where the part about Putin having?nothing to do with it came from, Ed? My opinions?in the original response were that everyone and everything had a part in the long run up from the Big Bang to the Gaza war. Ukraine is, of course, just another version of the same phenomenon.?
As for (not) feeding, I do not feel guilt is a required emotion. Or an effective one, for the most part. Yes, though, if I am not feeding or helping to feed (or heal or house or whatever), then I am contributing to the pain felt by those who are impacted. This seems obvious to me.
Note that I am speaking for myself, not as a representative of the U.S., even though I did lace my post with some nationally relevant?thoughts. I do not think that I can speak for the masses even though I do feel the need to feed would be best served by widespread represetationinN!
D
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 11:57?AM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote: So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
1.? Define the word disinformation
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and? general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing. 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
|
Re: [m-scholars-and-scribes] Re: Friday Five March 22
?
?
?
?
?
1.? Define the word disinformation
The simple answer - anything I disagree with.? The complex answer - anything twisted to achieve an objective.
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Didn't work in 1915 - why would it work now.? More importantly it would take away the impetus for the citizens of Haiti to start solving their own problems.
3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
I was thinking Rwanda when I wrote this.
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
Very definitely considering it
?
?
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "M-Scholars and Scribes" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to m-scholars-and-scribes+unsubscribe@....
To view this discussion on the web visit .
|
When Marvin wrote who is to blame for the famine, I take it as meaning what one person could have stopped or avoided it. As with Putin and the 100,000 deaths in Ukraine, the famine is due to Netanyahu's action. ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Not sure where the part about Putin having?nothing to do with it came from, Ed? My opinions?in the original response were that everyone and everything had a part in the long run up from the Big Bang to the Gaza war. Ukraine is, of course, just another version of the same phenomenon.?
As for (not) feeding, I do not feel guilt is a required emotion. Or an effective one, for the most part. Yes, though, if I am not feeding or helping to feed (or heal or house or whatever), then I am contributing to the pain felt by those who are impacted. This seems obvious to me.
Note that I am speaking for myself, not as a representative of the U.S., even though I did lace my post with some nationally relevant?thoughts. I do not think that I can speak for the masses even though I do feel the need to feed would be best served by widespread represetationinN!
D
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 11:57?AM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote: So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
1.? Define the word disinformation
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and? general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing. 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
|
Not sure where the part about Putin having?nothing to do with it came from, Ed? My opinions?in the original response were that everyone and everything had a part in the long run up from the Big Bang to the Gaza war. Ukraine is, of course, just another version of the same phenomenon.?
As for (not) feeding, I do not feel guilt is a required emotion. Or an effective one, for the most part. Yes, though, if I am not feeding or helping to feed (or heal or house or whatever), then I am contributing to the pain felt by those who are impacted. This seems obvious to me.
Note that I am speaking for myself, not as a representative of the U.S., even though I did lace my post with some nationally relevant?thoughts. I do not think that I can speak for the masses even though I do feel the need to feed would be best served by widespread represetationinN!
D
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 11:57?AM Ed Lomas < relomas2@...> wrote: So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
1.? Define the word disinformation
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and? general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing. 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
|
So would you say the same about Ukraine? Putin had nothing to do with it; the Ukranians should share the burden for provoking the Russians, and we should have some collective guilt for not sending checks to feed the Ukranians?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
1.? Define the word disinformation
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and? general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing. 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
|
1.? Define the word disinformation
Lying with a goal to gain advantage from the lie. Oh, what a tangled?web we weave...
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
Not out of the goodness of our hearts? To jump into the internal affairs of a sovereign?nation without invitation seems like an arrogant and probably dangerous precedent.
If we are invited in, like Kenya has been, then I could see it as more feasible, but the goal should be to establish a safe environment for noncombatants. It feels a lot like eliminating?ISIS, the Viet Cong, the South American cartels or Hamas, though: potentially a long campaign against guerilla forces on their home turf. The single advantage?in this scenario is that the people seem to be callously victimized and voting with their feet, which means the gangs may have lost the most important guerilla advantage of indigenous population support.?
My intuitive feel of the global mood right now is that every national move has become a potential step deeper into a mire intended to take down Western powers. Maybe we deserve it after all the profiteering, corporate abuse and? general arrogance we have exhibited. I am not convinced we are evil, though, despite the special interest transgressions of the consumer?culture frenzy. The U.S. was built on some pretty defensible?ideals and I think they continue to have moral value. People around the world are hurting?(including inside the U.S.) and I think helping to alleviate some of that pain is a solid step toward a better world.?
Should we build a relationship with Haiti's legal government, provide civil police material help or counseling, or economic aid? Sure, if we are invited and if Haiti's authorities and populace are is willing to take the lead and shoulder the lion's share of the work involved. Crying children look the same no matter where they are photographed. But we would be helping, not rescuing. 3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
Hamas, Israel, and every nation, group or individual who has taken a hand in the situation whether this year or 50 years ago. Also the Jewish God, Alah, all the angels and priests throughout history, worshiping populations and the media who report on them. Weather patterns?since the Earth was formed, the celestial bodies that impacted the formation of the Earth and any aliens who visited this planet throughout history...or prehistory.
All things (a humorous?concept, that one) are the consequences of everything that contributed to them and all contributes to each. The Butterfly effect. Blame Buddha for pointing it out.
I ate today and I sent no food to Gaza. Blame me for being responsible. When we each truly grasp that nobody is responsible and that we are all responsible, we may take a collective giant step forward.
The Palestinian State, the Jewish State, Islam, Christianity, nationalism and righteous indignation are all meaningless conceptual thought stories compared to the simple act of handing a sandwich to a hungry child.
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
The Armenian genocide seems to win at 90 percent according to Google. Congratulations to the Ottoman Empire, I believe. Russia?seems to figure in several of the other totals according to Wikipedia, though. Perhaps the wars in Europe and the Middle East will expand to include battlefield nukes and we can get a new record?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
It has crossed?my mind. Nobody showing an interest?so far has captured mine, though.
|
?
?
?
1.? Define the word disinformation
2.? Should the US unilaterally intervene in Haiti?
3.? Who is to blame for the famine crisis in Gaza?
4.? What 20th century genocide killed the highest portion of the single countries population?
5.? ?Are you considering voting for a third party presidential candidate this year?
?
|