Keyboard Shortcuts
Likes
- Gemini_users
- Messages
Search
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Sorry that should have read INDI and not Indian? On Tue, Dec 28, 2021 at 2:04 PM Michael Herman <mherman346@...> wrote:
--
Brian? Brian Valente portfolio |
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Thank you guys for your insights and success stories. I'll get into the jam in 2022 (raspberry jam anyways) Happy?Holidays! Michael On Tue, Dec 28, 2021, 2:58 PM Brian Valente <bvalente@...> wrote:
|
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
>>>?Are there any concerns running the Gemini 1 on the ASI air pro platform? None from the Gemini standpoint (at least that I¡¯m aware of), but you will probably run across quirky behavior on the AAP. They based it on the Indi drivers, which are community developed and supported, and I¡¯m not sure what state those are in. I recently picked up an AAP so I anticipate getting more familiar with it.? Brian On Tue, Dec 28, 2021 at 12:10 PM Nick <nbill1797@...> wrote:
--
Brian? Brian Valente portfolio |
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
>>>?Isn't the ASI Air basically a (more expensive) raspberry pi that comes preconfigured? In a very general sense, yes. But ZWO took the Indian foundation and built apps on top of it, so it¡¯s customized to the point that you wouldn¡¯t recognize it compared to say ekos.? AAP definitely has the self-contained feel. The apps are functional and work well together (provided you only use ASI cameras, focuses, etc. though it does work with other mounts including Gemini).? However, if you want to do something else, you are stuck. For example, their version of PHD was pulled from the open source repository some time ago, so the latest features are unavailable and some basic capabilities are limited (e.g., no backlash compensation).? For people who enjoy fiddling or tuning things, the rPi approach is probably a better (and less expensive) approach On Tue, Dec 28, 2021 at 12:32 PM Tino Heuberger via <tinoheuberger=[email protected]> wrote:
--
Brian? Brian Valente portfolio |
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
I am using a Raspberry Pi 4 with 8GB of RAM, which is more than plenty. The Pi can handle pretty much everything in terms of astrophotography. Mine is setup to create a hotspot automatically on boot to connect to. All the software for astrophotography is then run remotly on the raspberry pi, meaning I can let it image without the need of a laptop or secondary pc. Basically it uses INDI as an interface to the telescope hardware, EKOS for Sequencing and KSTARS as a substitute to Stellarium. Further it has PHD2 for guiding and a local astrometry.net install for platesolving. I wrote a script that setups my own astro pi setup (running on arch linux arm). It can be found here: (in the profile folder "AstroPi") Note that the script is made for arch linux, while the raspberry pi runs raspbian by default (which is basically debian). So my script won't work without adjusting distro specific calls to raspbian. Best Tino Heuberger Sent with Secure Email.
©\©\©\©\©\©\©\ Original Message ©\©\©\©\©\©\©\ On Tuesday, December 28th, 2021 at 10:42 PM, Michael Herman <mherman346@...> wrote:
publickey - [email protected] - 0x0D581256.asc
publickey - [email protected] - 0x0D581256.asc
signature.asc
signature.asc
|
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Tino, I'm interested bin the Raspberry Pi approach too....for experimentation. Can you recommend a "pick list" for such a project?? What Raspberry Pi to get etc. Time for me to play Santa to ... myself. Best, Michael On Tue, Dec 28, 2021, 1:32 PM Tino Heuberger via <tinoheuberger=[email protected]> wrote:
|
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Isn't the ASI Air basically a (more expensive) raspberry pi that comes preconfigured? If so it should be running linux with INDI, EKOS and KSTARS. You will have to install the INDi Driver (INDI is the equivalent of ASCOM on linux) for your mount then. They can usually be found on the github repo here (with instructions to install them): Sent with Secure Email.
©\©\©\©\©\©\©\ Original Message ©\©\©\©\©\©\©\ On Tuesday, December 28th, 2021 at 9:21 PM, Michael Herman <mherman346@...> wrote:
publickey - [email protected] - 0x0D581256.asc
publickey - [email protected] - 0x0D581256.asc
signature.asc
signature.asc
|
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Nick, Not having an ASI Air, I cannot say. You'll have to experiment, or contact ZWO for their ASIAir instructions. The Gemini-1 uses only a standard serial port at 9600 baud to pass instructions back and forth.? ?The Gemini sysrem takes its own instruction set.? That instruction set was based on the earlier Meade instruction set.? Paul K is the real expert in this area. ASCOM has these instructions in it's Gemini.net driver interface.? If some other group member knows how these parts (ASI air and Gemini-1) all fit together, please let us know the right way for Nick to proceed. Happy holidays and a safe New?Year, Michael On Tue, Dec 28, 2021, 1:10 PM Nick <nbill1797@...> wrote:
|
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Nick
Michael and Howard,
Thanks? ? ? |
Re: ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Hi Nick, I'll guess: Start over with a Cold Boot.? That erases your model data that I'm guessing is messing your system up.?? Then run your system as you did the first successful night.? ? After your first 3 stars aligned West (or East) or meridian, align to a few more in the other side of the meridian.?? Then....do not add any more alignment stars.? Do not allow your plate silver to "add alignment points." Be sure the setting in Gemini.net for "Synch performs additional align" is left unchecked.?? Your system should run correctly.? I hope so! Let us know if that?helps...or hopefully solves your?problems.?? Best of luck and happy new year, Michael On Mon, Dec 27, 2021, 9:55 PM Nick <nbill1797@...> wrote: Alright gents... It seems my G11 (circa 2007) is a little sensitive when working with the ASI Air Pro (AAP). I've thumped my head enough on the proverbial wall many - many times. Thinking it's time to ask the pros. |
ASI Air Pro use on Gemini 1
Nick
Alright gents... It seems my G11 (circa 2007) is a little sensitive when working with the ASI Air Pro (AAP). I've thumped my head enough on the proverbial wall many - many times. Thinking it's time to ask the pros.
Here's the setup: Gemini 1 Lvl4 v1.05, recently changed the Eprom per Michael Herman's advice. Mounted on heavy duty tripod. The rig isn't taken down. Hand controller is not connected.? ASI Air Pro (not plus), version 1.8(8.83). ASI 120mini guide cam, ASI 294MC main. External motors (servo I think). Symptom: Go-To works fine on first object, then completely misses following objects. Example:?during last use- let's call them nights one and two, I had no issues. PA was fast and easy. Plate solving was nice and smooth. Error free Go-To with target on center. Even slewed to and photographed Comet Leonard before it descended. Enjoyed three targets afterwards...Ahh life is GOOD :) Then, on night three the uglies showed up. Followed the same process of turning on the system and had issues from the jump. PA was fussy, plate solving seemed to lock up, then this- Go-To the first object was ok but not great. Go-To second object was WAAYYY off (pointing down). The misdirected OTA happened consistently. Half a dozen times before I had to shut down.? I ran through the setup a few times with basically the same result. I even tried "sneaking up" on the object (Jupiter in western sky, then eventually down to Leonard). No luck. BUT...I did note that movements Eastward (starting from NCP) seemed to be the culprit. It nailed M45(once) but didn't want to see, Capella, M42 or Jupiter. All of these targets yielded a downfacing OTA. The only thing that seemed to work was to point my scope west after polar alignment. In my case Vega, then Jupiter, then Formalhaut. All seemed to be much closer, however I couldn't confirm since the clouds rolled in. Lens location seemed much more acceptable though. The AAP displays my mount as?"Losmandy Gemini"?on the drop-down menu. No problems syncing and controlling mount via Gemini 1 serial port using?ATEN UC232A. It's actually REALLY nice...when it works.? Possible causes: settings, meridian flip, firmware?? Q: Did I just get lucky the first couple of nights when she ran flawless? Any advice on this one? Is AAP compatible with my system?? Thanks, Nick |
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Hi Andy,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
That's what I think Howard should try. Without seeing the ASCOM logs, I can't guess as to what each software is doing when trying to nudge. If it really is using pulse guiding, then guider calibration must be done first, and yes, precision pulse-guiding should be turned off for Gemini-1 (but not for Gemini-2). Regards, ? ? ?-Paul On Sat, Dec 25, 2021 at 07:22 PM, collimated1 wrote: Paul |
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Paul
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
?Do you think it¡¯s possible that MaxIm is using the guide command signal for the move command? ?If so, maybe this is tied to Howard¡¯s issue if he has Precision Pulse Guide checked. ?I recently installed a new computer at my observatory and installed the Gemini ASCOM driver. ?I¡¯m assuming the driver installs with Precision Pulse Guide checked on? Andy? On Saturday, December 25, 2021, 5:45 PM, Paul Kanevsky <yh@...> wrote:
|
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
On Sat, Dec 25, 2021 at 05:02 PM, collimated1 wrote:
Howard,That's good advice for Gemini 1 / Level 4. This was fixed in Gemini-2 L5, so that precision pulse-guiding became the default and only available option. For Gemini-1, turn it off if it's turned on. Regards, ? ? -Paul |
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Howard,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
?I just had an issue similar to yours. ?I also use MaxIm. ?During an RA guide correction, my G11 would run off in RA indefinitely until I intervened. ?I found that I had Precision Pulse Guide checked in the setup in Gemini ASCOM. ?I unchecked it and my problem went away. ?If you¡¯re running a Gemini1 unit, you can¡¯t use Precision Pulse Guiding. ? Andy? On Saturday, December 25, 2021, 12:13 PM, Michael Herman <mherman346@...> wrote:
|
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Hi Howard, First of all, updating the Gemini-1 to the last available version 1.05 is easy to do.? Send me your address, privately (see Respond to Sender at the bottom of these emails for a link) and I can send you a new EPROM.? You will use a metal hook tool to gently pry up the existing EPROM by it's ends, remove it fully, then use tweezers to gently nudge the pins of the replacement EPROM into the same mounting holes.? Here is a picture showing the correct orientation...also printed on the circuit board.? Second thing... your puzzling overshoot corrections when you "nudge" the mount.?? Two ideas come to mind: There is a "TVC" parameter that you can adjust it's value.? If that is not zero, try changing that to zero and see what happens.? I thought that parameter only affects the DEC axis, but I never use it (always zero in my case) so I can't be sure.? Anyways, look into that setting. On the Gemini-2, when you slew RA, it will drive to the destination then reverse the motor briefly...to eliminate backlash. At least in one direction.? I've seen it on my G11T RA belt drive, that makes this reversal observable.? I've no way to look for that behavior on the DEC drive of the G-2, or on any of the G-1 controllers.? So TVC may be a variable in your puzzle. Another idea is that the skew rate setting before the Nudge is having an effrct.? To autoguide, you must have the Gemini set to "G" guide mode.? But the Gemini will slew from remote commands in C center mode or S slew mode.? These more coarse modes will give a large quantum jump in position.? So try and see if setting your Gemini into G guide mode gives you "nudge" the smaller gradation you are seeking.? My guess at the moment is that you are doing a "nudge" in either C or S modes and these will certainly jump your pointing position a large distance.? Only G guide mode will work for my precision centering.?? Best of luck and merry Xmas, Michael On Sat, Dec 25, 2021, 10:22 AM Howard via <hmooers=[email protected]> wrote: I reported an issue with MaxIm DL 6 not nudging properly using the Gemini Telescope ASCOM driver. I would choose "nudge" 10 arcsec and the scope would move way to far. The issue is NOT with MaxIm. After logging serial traffic in ASCOM, Maxim is issuing the correct command, but the mount is way over correcting. The same happens in The Sky Pro using the ASCOM driver. I also connected The Sky using its native Gemini driver. However, I am accessing the observatory remotely and can't check on the accuracy of the coordinates (I do not have access to the hand controller). |
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Hi Howard, On Sat, Dec 25, 2021 at 12:22 PM, Howard wrote: I reported an issue with MaxIm DL 6 not nudging properly using the Gemini Telescope ASCOM driver. I would choose "nudge" 10 arcsec and the scope would move way to far. The issue is NOT with MaxIm. After logging serial traffic in ASCOM, Maxim is issuing the correct command, but the mount is way over correcting. The same happens in The Sky Pro using the ASCOM driver. I also connected The Sky using its native Gemini driver. However, I am accessing the observatory remotely and can't check on the accuracy of the coordinates (I do not have access to the hand controller). |
Re: Gemini 1 ASCOM and Maxim DL 6 - Nudge scope position
Howard
I reported an issue with MaxIm DL 6 not nudging properly using the Gemini Telescope ASCOM driver. I would choose "nudge" 10 arcsec and the scope would move way to far. The issue is NOT with MaxIm. After logging serial traffic in ASCOM, Maxim is issuing the correct command, but the mount is way over correcting. The same happens in The Sky Pro using the ASCOM driver. I also connected The Sky using its native Gemini driver. However, I am accessing the observatory remotely and can't check on the accuracy of the coordinates (I do not have access to the hand controller).
the issue is either with the ASCOM interface or the mount itself. I am using Gemini 1 v. 1.04. I have not updated the firmware to the latest version, 1.05. Any suggestions or ideas?? |
Re: Connecting ZWO ASI autoguider to Gemini-1, using PHD2
#photo
Many thanks, Johan, for offering your experience. I hadn't appreciated the cable fouling issue, but can readily see the benefits of reducing the number of cables.
Unfortunately, I'm still waiting for a clear-enough night to try everything out. PHD2 connects to both the camera and mount without any dramas, so all is "go" at the moment apart from this hiatus. Paul Lloyd. |