On Apr 18, 2020, at 9:05 PM, Bob S <rstonebraker212@...> wrote:

?

I believe the attached photo is from the clubhouse on 24^th Street in NY. The lady next to Bill is Ruth Hock. I think the person next to Bill on the other side is Dick Stanley (He Had to be Shown—3^rd edition). He may have been “Fred” in the Big Book (p. 39-43). Question: Was lady next to Dick Stanley, ?Marty Mann? What about the others? ??

?

Thank you.

?

Bob S

--
Bob S

<Early AA members.JPG>