Hi,
For filters the steepness of the skirts is important apart from the 3dB bandwidth.
-6DB and -80 dB are a real measure for the skirts!
However ,many filters ( or measuring conditions ) are not attaining the -80dB , so -60dB will have to do.
This is OK as long as you realise or/and that this is CLEARLY mentioned/stated.
I have seen many tables with comparisons of filters and their steepness.
Steepness was then 80/3 or 60/3 dB value.
Older engineers told me that this was better than using the ratio of the frequency of the -3 and -60 dB points because the difference between the types of filters( number of poles/crystal,L-C;etc/etc.) could be better evaluated.
I know of discussions because of mixing between -60 and -80 dB values( don't compare two sorts of beasts)
Jan ON4MMW
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message-----
From:
[email protected] <
[email protected]> On Behalf Of hwalker
Sent: 04 October 2019 17:45
To:
[email protected]Subject: Re: [nanovna-users] NanoVNA-Saver 0.1.0
Mike,
Google on filter bandwidth and the majority of the results will come up as the -3 dB point. Not saying the -6 dB and -60 db points are not useful info, just that the -3dB point is the common reference.
Herb
