¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Locked Re: Signaling feedback to Panels


 

¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Scott,

What Ken is referring to is that JMRI can not receive signal data from another source (than itself) if that data is using turnout information. (i.e. SE8c mode, Output mode, LDT mode, etc.) There have been numerous attempts to make that work over the years, but it simply can not be done without adding time stamps to the turnout commands. The reason is that you can not tell what aspect is desired simply by looking at the current state of the turnouts. You need to know the LAST sent command for each head and only consider it.

However if the signals are being controlled with NMRA aspect commands, then it should be able to work OK. However to make things work with aspects requires a different underlying mast type. This has been implemented for LCC/OpenLCB which normally operates as aspects, but may not be available for LocoNet which normally works as turnouts. I do notice that there are new appearing selection options in the current test releases. It is possible that someone has recently been working on this again. Try 4.17.5 or 4.17.6 to see if that changes anything.

Dick :)

On 11/20/2019 8:20 AM, Scott Walton wrote:

The signals are using masts. JMRI obviously understands the signal message format as I can click on the signal, choose "set aspect" and send any of aspects and the signal displays the results. The message appears to be identical to what the boards send. It sounds like one of those things that hasn't been implemented. It shouldn't be all that different from turnouts, sensors and reporters.?

Scott Walton

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.