开云体育

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 开云体育

Solder paste recommendations


 

I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave


stefan_trethan
 

Hi Dave,

I use??from ChipQuick for both stencil printing and pneumatic dispenser.
You can easily get it at all the usual suspects (Digikey, Mouser, RS, Farnell,....) and it doesn't require refrigeration.
We still put it in the refrigerator to extend the shelf life, but unlike other brands of paste it has never gone bad on me, even the dispensing needle is usually still good after a few weeks of storage.

The main advantage is that it doesn't require refrigerated shipping (expensive) and keeps very well, solder performance wise it is similar to other products.
Also there seems to be some turnover at my distributors so I don't get ancient stock, which has happened before with other brands.

They also sell a jar, but unless you solder a lot it's probably best to turn over the syringes more often, one needs so little.

There is also a low melting point variant with a Bismuth alloy, I found a whole box of that stuff in the chemical waste one day.
It's rather too low melting for regular use, especially if any lead gets mixed into it, but can be useful to remove tricky components.

ST



On Tue, Nov 5, 2019 at 6:39 PM Dave <theschemer@...> wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy
some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some
in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder
better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave





stefan_trethan
 

I see there is now a new thermally stable type:


I have no experience with it, but since the regular stuff keeps so well this might be even better for the occasional user.

ST


On Tue, Nov 5, 2019 at 7:47 PM Stefan Trethan <stefan_trethan@...> wrote:
Hi Dave,

I use??from ChipQuick for both stencil printing and pneumatic dispenser.
You can easily get it at all the usual suspects (Digikey, Mouser, RS, Farnell,....) and it doesn't require refrigeration.
We still put it in the refrigerator to extend the shelf life, but unlike other brands of paste it has never gone bad on me, even the dispensing needle is usually still good after a few weeks of storage.

The main advantage is that it doesn't require refrigerated shipping (expensive) and keeps very well, solder performance wise it is similar to other products.
Also there seems to be some turnover at my distributors so I don't get ancient stock, which has happened before with other brands.

They also sell a jar, but unless you solder a lot it's probably best to turn over the syringes more often, one needs so little.

There is also a low melting point variant with a Bismuth alloy, I found a whole box of that stuff in the chemical waste one day.
It's rather too low melting for regular use, especially if any lead gets mixed into it, but can be useful to remove tricky components.

ST



On Tue, Nov 5, 2019 at 6:39 PM Dave <theschemer@...> wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy
some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some
in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder
better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave





 

Thanks Stefan,
?? I will hunt some down for my smd crash course. The internet is not sending (forwarding) my posts or replies again so I logged in to see if there was any replies. I guess like usual, they will show up within the next 12-24 hours.
Dave


 

I use Kester 186, that's in a magic-marker style flux pen.? While I do have some solder paste, I find it of limited use unless I'm doing air reflow or oven reflow (and I don't have an oven).? For best results in applying paste, you need a syringe or a stencil.

Tin lead should still be available.? You may want to get some chip-quik, it's a bismuth low melting point solder you put on a chip and then heat it up.? It alloys with the existing solder and reduces the melting point.? You can use it for low temperature soldering, but it doesn't make nice shiny joints.

There may be a problem with "no clean" in that it does leave residues.? There's also a point where some solder flux is more "aggressive" than other types.? You may want to clean anyway.

91% alcohol does reasonably well with some fluxes, but you really want whatever's in the MG chemicals flux remover.

Harvey

On 11/5/2019 12:39 PM, Dave wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave





 

Thanks Harvey,
? I bought a syringe of as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave


 

Hi there.

We have been purchasing 63/37 solder paste from Chip Quik - both direct and via Digikey. It's available in both syringe and jar form.

Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a year. It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after breaking the seal.

We normally purchase the Water Soluble flux version - we then just wash the boards under running hot water and blow dry with compressed air. This works especially well for the small prototype board runs that we do.

dwayne

At 10:39 AM 11/5/2019, Dave wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave
--
Dwayne Reid <dwayner@...>
Trinity Electronics Systems Ltd Edmonton, AB, CANADA
780-489-3199 voice 780-487-6397 fax 888-489-3199 Toll Free
www.trinity-electronics.com
Custom Electronics Design and Manufacturing


Jim Higgins
 

Lead-free solder is mostly tin, with trace metallic additives to reduce the likelihood that the solder will grow "whiskers."

If interested in details on "tin whiskers," the following is a good overview. You can't retouch a joint to remove whiskers in a satellite.
(metallurgy)



I only mention the following because I can't see much use for soldering paste except for close spaced leads or if you use a reflow oven.

I've done very little soldering of IC packages with many closely spaced leads on four sides. Used to do MIL Spec soldering in the late 60s, but we had nothing like that back then. I used tin-lead solder then and now... darn near hair thin when soldering closely spaced IC packages. Get the super thin stuff and if too thin just double or triple it... thin so there's no chance of getting too much solder and having it short something somewhere out of sight... like under the IC.

My approach - on the rare occasions these days - is to place the multi pin package and tack the thing down with pins aligned with the pads via a few leads on each corner. Then with plenty of flux, solder all leads on one side without worrying whether they're shorted - just don't apply so much solder that it flows where it can't be seen. The less the better, but be sure all pins are soldered to the pads even if shorted. Repeat for all sides. Now apply more flux and lay solder wick along one side and run the soldering tip along it to suck up all excess solder. Same for the other three sides. Inspect closely and apply solder and/or wick if needed... always with plenty of flux.

With this approach the leads all must be at the same level so when the chip is resting on the board before soldering, all leads are in contact with the pads... or at least so close that solder wick won't pull out the solder between lead and pad. Works like a charm. How fast you move the soldering iron tip along the solder wick plays a role in the quality of the job and the need for rework. Start off faster and go slower if pins remain shorted.

Jim H



Received from Dave at 11/5/2019 21:49 UTC:

Thanks Harvey,
I bought a syringe of <> as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave


 

"> Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a
year. It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after
breaking the seal."
Guys, there's something I always wanted to know about that shelf
life....what the heck causes the stuff to go bad?

Charlie


On Tue, 05 Nov 2019 14:51:58 -0700 "Dwayne Reid" <dwayner@...>
writes:
Hi there.

We have been purchasing 63/37 solder paste from Chip Quik - both
direct and via Digikey. It's available in both syringe and jar
form.

Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a
year. It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after

breaking the seal.

We normally purchase the Water Soluble flux version - we then just
wash the boards under running hot water and blow dry with compressed

air. This works especially well for the small prototype board runs
that we do.

dwayne


At 10:39 AM 11/5/2019, Dave wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to
buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would
like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is
no-clean
solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still
available.

Thanks,

Dave

--
Dwayne Reid <dwayner@...>
Trinity Electronics Systems Ltd Edmonton, AB, CANADA
780-489-3199 voice 780-487-6397 fax 888-489-3199 Toll Free
www.trinity-electronics.com
Custom Electronics Design and Manufacturing





 

The medium carrying the solids changes viscosity as it ages and evaporates and oxidises and/or reduces); the solder balls settle as gravity exerts its ever-present force; the flux reacts with the vehicle and solder reducing the fluxing potency and the vehicle viscosity and solder wettability. There are probably other effects, but those are the big ones that I've read about.

Donald.
--
*Plain Text* email -- it's an accessibility issue
() no proprietary attachments; no html mail
/\ <>

On 2019-11-05 6:30 p.m., Charlie Hansen wrote:
"> Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a
year. It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after
breaking the seal."
Guys, there's something I always wanted to know about that shelf
life....what the heck causes the stuff to go bad?
Charlie
On Tue, 05 Nov 2019 14:51:58 -0700 "Dwayne Reid" <dwayner@...>
writes:
Hi there.

We have been purchasing 63/37 solder paste from Chip Quik - both
direct and via Digikey. It's available in both syringe and jar
form.

Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a
year. It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after

breaking the seal.

We normally purchase the Water Soluble flux version - we then just
wash the boards under running hot water and blow dry with compressed

air. This works especially well for the small prototype board runs
that we do.

dwayne


At 10:39 AM 11/5/2019, Dave wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to
buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would
like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is
no-clean
solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still
available.

Thanks,

Dave


 

开云体育

Lead free is, I think, tin, bismuth, and silver (might have remembered this properly).? However, it does not play well with low temperature soldering and is (AFAIK) inferior in all respects to what one would want in solder.? I have never heard of a eutectic mix, so the low melting temperature doesn't happen with lead free.? This puts more stress on parts, let alone makes soldering more difficult.? Yep, tried lead free, didn't' work as well.

Now the chip-quik has a much lower melting point (IIRC, pure bismuth has a rather low mp, but again, could be wrong).? The chip-quik is designed to alloy and melt at a lower temperature, making removal of large ICs easier.

They do say that you can use it for soldering directly, but that's a good question about how and what.

Harvey


On 11/5/2019 4:49 PM, Dave wrote:

Thanks Harvey,
? I bought a syringe of as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave


 

Somewhat easier method, but it diverges after you tack down the opposite pins.? If you don't do that, then the solder hardening pulls the chip out of alignment, so do diagonals first then go for the rest.

Once you have all the pins aligned properly with the corners soldered, then add more flux.? You want flux on the top of the pins to the chip.

I use about a 50 mil/ 1/16 diameter metcal tip.

I've found that putting a little solder on the tip (a solder reservoir, but not a hoof tip) and running the tip from the end of the pad up to the pin allows solder to flow from the tip down onto the pad, and covers the "foot" of the chip pin.? If you should happen to hit two pins at the same time, solder may flow to both without shorting the pins.

If you do short the pins, then adding flux and reheating both *can* separate them (not always).? Otherwise the solder wick works wonders.

Note that this works best on boards with a solder mask.

I use 0.015 solder, eutectic, with a flux core.

Harvey

On 11/5/2019 5:59 PM, Jim Higgins wrote:

Lead-free solder is mostly tin, with trace metallic additives to reduce the likelihood that the solder will grow "whiskers."

If interested in details on "tin whiskers," the following is a good overview. You can't retouch a joint to remove whiskers in a satellite.
(metallurgy)



I only mention the following because I can't see much use for soldering paste except for close spaced leads or if you use a reflow oven.

I've done very little soldering of IC packages with many closely spaced leads on four sides. Used to do MIL Spec soldering in the late 60s, but we had nothing like that back then. I used tin-lead solder then and now... darn near hair thin when soldering closely spaced IC packages. Get the super thin stuff and if too thin just double or triple it... thin so there's no chance of getting too much solder and having it short something somewhere out of sight... like under the IC.

My approach - on the rare occasions these days - is to place the multi pin package and tack the thing down with pins aligned with the pads via a few leads on each corner. Then with plenty of flux, solder all leads on one side without worrying whether they're shorted - just don't apply so much solder that it flows where it can't be seen. The less the better, but be sure all pins are soldered to the pads even if shorted. Repeat for all sides. Now apply more flux and lay solder wick along one side and run the soldering tip along it to suck up all excess solder. Same for the other three sides. Inspect closely and apply solder and/or wick if needed... always with plenty of flux.

With this approach the leads all must be at the same level so when the chip is resting on the board before soldering, all leads are in contact with the pads... or at least so close that solder wick won't pull out the solder between lead and pad. Works like a charm. How fast you move the soldering iron tip along the solder wick plays a role in the quality of the job and the need for rework. Start off faster and go slower if pins remain shorted.

Jim H



Received from Dave at 11/5/2019 21:49 UTC:

Thanks Harvey,
I bought a syringe of <> as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave




 

Thanks for the info Dwayne. Water soluble flux sounds like the way to go.

Dave

On 11/5/2019 3:51 PM, Dwayne Reid wrote:
Hi there.

We have been purchasing 63/37 solder paste from Chip Quik? - both direct and via Digikey.? It's available in both syringe and jar form.

Be aware that the rated shelf life is anywhere from 6 months to a year.? It lasts longer if you keep it refrigerated, especially after breaking the seal.

We normally purchase the Water Soluble flux version - we then just wash the boards under running hot water and blow dry with compressed air.? This works especially well for the small prototype board runs that we do.

dwayne


At 10:39 AM 11/5/2019, Dave wrote:
I have plenty of regular solder, and plenty of flux, now I need to buy some solder paste for smd stuff. Any recommendations? I would like some in a jar and also a syringe just to have both. Is no-clean solder better? Also, I just want tin/lead solder if it is still available.

Thanks,

Dave


 

Hi Jim,

? Thanks for the info. I have heard of tin whiskers although never had any dealings with them. I was thinking about building a reflow oven although my needs are small as a hobbyist, I like projects it seems. I have watched many videos recently that show the tricks you describe on soldering packages I would have never though possible. That has peaked my interest knowing it may not be as impossible as it seems.

Dave

On 11/5/2019 4:59 PM, Jim Higgins wrote:

Lead-free solder is mostly tin, with trace metallic additives to reduce the likelihood that the solder will grow "whiskers."

If interested in details on "tin whiskers," the following is a good overview. You can't retouch a joint to remove whiskers in a satellite.
(metallurgy)



I only mention the following because I can't see much use for soldering paste except for close spaced leads or if you use a reflow oven.

I've done very little soldering of IC packages with many closely spaced leads on four sides. Used to do MIL Spec soldering in the late 60s, but we had nothing like that back then. I used tin-lead solder then and now... darn near hair thin when soldering closely spaced IC packages. Get the super thin stuff and if too thin just double or triple it... thin so there's no chance of getting too much solder and having it short something somewhere out of sight... like under the IC.

My approach - on the rare occasions these days - is to place the multi pin package and tack the thing down with pins aligned with the pads via a few leads on each corner. Then with plenty of flux, solder all leads on one side without worrying whether they're shorted - just don't apply so much solder that it flows where it can't be seen. The less the better, but be sure all pins are soldered to the pads even if shorted. Repeat for all sides. Now apply more flux and lay solder wick along one side and run the soldering tip along it to suck up all excess solder. Same for the other three sides. Inspect closely and apply solder and/or wick if needed... always with plenty of flux.

With this approach the leads all must be at the same level so when the chip is resting on the board before soldering, all leads are in contact with the pads... or at least so close that solder wick won't pull out the solder between lead and pad. Works like a charm. How fast you move the soldering iron tip along the solder wick plays a role in the quality of the job and the need for rework. Start off faster and go slower if pins remain shorted.

Jim H


 

Harvey,

? All good info. I have watched videos that show some things I always wondered how they did that without a machine doing it for them. Very interesting. I recently watched a guy using a tip that had a pocket in it to hold extra solder (maybe a hoof tip). He was soldering a bunch of DIPS as he tested different solders. Flux played a key role in this demo. The smallest diameter solder I have now is 0.020 but if I need it, I will get some 0.015.

Thanks,

Dave

On 11/5/2019 6:58 PM, Harvey White wrote:
Somewhat easier method, but it diverges after you tack down the opposite pins.? If you don't do that, then the solder hardening pulls the chip out of alignment, so do diagonals first then go for the rest.

Once you have all the pins aligned properly with the corners soldered, then add more flux.? You want flux on the top of the pins to the chip.

I use about a 50 mil/ 1/16 diameter metcal tip.

I've found that putting a little solder on the tip (a solder reservoir, but not a hoof tip) and running the tip from the end of the pad up to the pin allows solder to flow from the tip down onto the pad, and covers the "foot" of the chip pin.? If you should happen to hit two pins at the same time, solder may flow to both without shorting the pins.

If you do short the pins, then adding flux and reheating both *can* separate them (not always).? Otherwise the solder wick works wonders.

Note that this works best on boards with a solder mask.

I use 0.015 solder, eutectic, with a flux core.

Harvey


On 11/5/2019 5:59 PM, Jim Higgins wrote:

Lead-free solder is mostly tin, with trace metallic additives to reduce the likelihood that the solder will grow "whiskers."

If interested in details on "tin whiskers," the following is a good overview. You can't retouch a joint to remove whiskers in a satellite.
(metallurgy)



I only mention the following because I can't see much use for soldering paste except for close spaced leads or if you use a reflow oven.

I've done very little soldering of IC packages with many closely spaced leads on four sides. Used to do MIL Spec soldering in the late 60s, but we had nothing like that back then. I used tin-lead solder then and now... darn near hair thin when soldering closely spaced IC packages. Get the super thin stuff and if too thin just double or triple it... thin so there's no chance of getting too much solder and having it short something somewhere out of sight... like under the IC.

My approach - on the rare occasions these days - is to place the multi pin package and tack the thing down with pins aligned with the pads via a few leads on each corner. Then with plenty of flux, solder all leads on one side without worrying whether they're shorted - just don't apply so much solder that it flows where it can't be seen. The less the better, but be sure all pins are soldered to the pads even if shorted. Repeat for all sides. Now apply more flux and lay solder wick along one side and run the soldering tip along it to suck up all excess solder. Same for the other three sides. Inspect closely and apply solder and/or wick if needed... always with plenty of flux.

With this approach the leads all must be at the same level so when the chip is resting on the board before soldering, all leads are in contact with the pads... or at least so close that solder wick won't pull out the solder between lead and pad. Works like a charm. How fast you move the soldering iron tip along the solder wick plays a role in the quality of the job and the need for rework. Start off faster and go slower if pins remain shorted.

Jim H



 

Harvey,

? I was hoping to avoid "lead free" solders altogether but I am sure there is a good reason for them. I will continue to avoid them as long as I can. But, that brings up a new question. Now that I am starting to gather the goods to try SMD pcbs, I have run into a small issue. I have a bunch of thru hole PRC fuses and when I tried to hunt down a SMD alternative from LittleFuse, all they have is the "lead free" variety. Can a lead free component be soldered to a copper clad pcb with tin/lead solder? Or would I have to use lead free solder on that one component? Or better yet, mixing thru hole and SMD components on the same board is not a problem I guess?

Thanks,

Dave

On 11/5/2019 6:45 PM, Harvey White wrote:

Lead free is, I think, tin, bismuth, and silver (might have remembered this properly).? However, it does not play well with low temperature soldering and is (AFAIK) inferior in all respects to what one would want in solder.? I have never heard of a eutectic mix, so the low melting temperature doesn't happen with lead free.? This puts more stress on parts, let alone makes soldering more difficult.? Yep, tried lead free, didn't' work as well.

Now the chip-quik has a much lower melting point (IIRC, pure bismuth has a rather low mp, but again, could be wrong).? The chip-quik is designed to alloy and melt at a lower temperature, making removal of large ICs easier.

They do say that you can use it for soldering directly, but that's a good question about how and what.

Harvey


On 11/5/2019 4:49 PM, Dave wrote:
Thanks Harvey,
? I bought a syringe of as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave


 

On 11/6/2019 10:02 AM, Dave wrote:
Harvey,

? I was hoping to avoid "lead free" solders altogether but I am sure there is a good reason for them.
The reason for lead free solders is that a lot of the electronics equipment gets dumped in a landfill.? The lead leaches out and gets into the ground.? In the EU, environmentally conscious people decided to mandate that lead be removed from electronics equipment, thus causing the switch to lead free solder with the included difficulties.


I will continue to avoid them as long as I can. But, that brings up a new question. Now that I am starting to gather the goods to try SMD pcbs, I have run into a small issue. I have a bunch of thru hole PRC fuses and when I tried to hunt down a SMD alternative from LittleFuse, all they have is the "lead free" variety. Can a lead free component be soldered to a copper clad pcb with tin/lead solder?
Easily.? Just ignore the lead-free solder and use standard solder.? I have a number of parts that are ROHS (Reduction of Hazardous Substances), and they seem to solder just as well.? OF course, the PC boards I get from China use standard tin/lead solder.



Or would I have to use lead free solder on that one component?
I've not had a problem.


Or better yet, mixing thru hole and SMD components on the same board is not a problem I guess?
Design wise, no, not a bit of a problem.? They're just parts.? On my latest designs, almost everything is SMT with the exception of the so called "dupont" connectors, standard through hole pin connectors you connect either IDC or single row (tektronix style) wire connectors.

One reasonable thing to do is to make jumper cables with the standard Chinese socket to socket connectors (they're a bit long, but if they fit....).? You just buy a connector kit and replace the plastic shrouds with a single piece, inline or not.? Does very well for test connectors.


Harvey



Thanks,

Dave

On 11/5/2019 6:45 PM, Harvey White wrote:

Lead free is, I think, tin, bismuth, and silver (might have remembered this properly).? However, it does not play well with low temperature soldering and is (AFAIK) inferior in all respects to what one would want in solder.? I have never heard of a eutectic mix, so the low melting temperature doesn't happen with lead free.? This puts more stress on parts, let alone makes soldering more difficult.? Yep, tried lead free, didn't' work as well.

Now the chip-quik has a much lower melting point (IIRC, pure bismuth has a rather low mp, but again, could be wrong).? The chip-quik is designed to alloy and melt at a lower temperature, making removal of large ICs easier.

They do say that you can use it for soldering directly, but that's a good question about how and what.

Harvey


On 11/5/2019 4:49 PM, Dave wrote:
Thanks Harvey,
? I bought a syringe of as per Stefan's post above. I have read about a foreign brand named Mechanic that most people give it high marks.

I also watched some video's earlier today about flux cleaners and in one of them they said MG's the winner.

Isn't bizmuth the stuff that is in lead free solder, or is it some new type? I guess it is a new type because from what I read, lead free has a higher melting point that no lead solder. I have no clue as I never tried it.
Dave



Jim Higgins
 

Received from Dave at 11/6/2019 15:02 UTC:

Harvey,

I was hoping to avoid "lead free" solders altogether but I am sure there is a good reason for them.

The reason is environmental... lead being harmful.


Can a lead free component be soldered to a copper clad pcb with tin/lead solder?

Absolutely yes. In reality it takes almost 3X as long to thoroughly wet a joint when soldering with ROHS solder than with the old tin-lead solder. Using tin-lead actually improves your chances of getting a good joint.


Or better yet, mixing thru hole and SMD components on the same board is not a problem I guess?

Not a problem for hand soldering. But tin-lead and ROHS solder melt at different temperatures and take different times to assure a thoroughly wet joint, so using a reflow oven for soldering with different types of solder isn't adviseable.

Jim H


 

Harvey,
? I figured the environment was the main reason but I wasn't sure if it was the only reason. I know the majority of the people don't seem to like it though. Well, that is all good news then. I can just use my thru hole parts and skip buying the lead free, or if I do buy the SMD versions, I can just solder them in with regular solder. Win-Win.
Thanks,
Dave


 

Hi Jim,
? Ok on the environment. Figured that but didn't know if there was more to it than that.
I know that lead free needs higher temps and components also need to be able to take the higher temps, but I didn't know about the joint quality. But it always seemed like lead flows better.
Good point on the reflow oven issue with 2 types of solder. I will stick to tin/lead like my original plan. :)
Thanks,
Dave

p.s. I have been getting delays with the posts coming to my home email inbox again so I am logging into the group to see these. Just in case I am slow to respond...that's why.