Re: Need information on a Felder combo jointer and planner.
Looks like you asked this before and I answered it but in case you missed the reply or didn't like it, here is the reply again.
Hi, Either the AD531 or the Hammer A331 for a lot less money. I really like the value you get with the Hammer. For 16" the equivalent would be the Hammer A3-41. Felder does not up the HP claim on their motors because they run on 60hz in the USA. They are placarded as 4hp at 50 and 60hz. Make sure you look at the machines in action.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "WilliamM" <williamoss1948@...> wrote: I am interested in a combo unit planner/jointer.
AS I own a Minimax slidingtable saw, I am familiar with the Minimax line of combos, but not the Felder's. I am considering the MiniMax 12 Inch combo which has a 59 inch long bed, a 3 blade Tersa head 4.8 HP motor 220 volt, 20 amp single phase motor which sells for about $4,200. The 16 inch model has a 71 inch bed and same specs as the other but sells for $5200.
What does Felder have that is comparable?
William Moss
|
Need information on a Felder combo jointer and planner.
I am interested in a combo unit planner/jointer.
AS I own a Minimax slidingtable saw, I am familiar with the Minimax line of combos, but not the Felder's. I am considering the MiniMax 12 Inch combo which has a 59 inch long bed, a 3 blade Tersa head 4.8 HP motor 220 volt, 20 amp single phase motor which sells for about $4,200. The 16 inch model has a 71 inch bed and same specs as the other but sells for $5200.
What does Felder have that is comparable?
William Moss
|
Re: How to order the dado blade set for c331
I see you posted a message on the HSM forum about drilling blades. Forrest make a nice dado set that is reasonable. I thing some FOG members use this set and like it. I do not know if they ship to Turkey.
Jerry P
|
Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
Jason, That's way to low heck. mac,,, Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: "likesawdust" <jholtzy@...> Sender: felder-woodworking@... Date: Mon, 07 May 2012 13:41:47 To: <felder-woodworking@...> Reply-To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: [felder-woodworking] Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
Hi Bill Nice post about the Nordfab stuff. It is a joy to install, isn't it? I'd like to put it in the new shop when I have to move again. Except I already have all the spiral stuff that will be a pain to take apart.
I do think however, that spending $192, plus a bunch of time to make a drum level indication system is definitely not keeping it as simple as possible. We have a clear hose connecting the cyclone to the drum. Doesn't get much simpler than that. You start to see chips in that hose, stop planing and change the drum. Simple. Even if it gets overfull, I can swap a drum barely getting any on the floor.
Jason
|
Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
Hi Bill Nice post about the Nordfab stuff. It is a joy to install, isn't it? I'd like to put it in the new shop when I have to move again. Except I already have all the spiral stuff that will be a pain to take apart.
I do think however, that spending $192, plus a bunch of time to make a drum level indication system is definitely not keeping it as simple as possible. We have a clear hose connecting the cyclone to the drum. Doesn't get much simpler than that. You start to see chips in that hose, stop planing and change the drum. Simple. Even if it gets overfull, I can swap a drum barely getting any on the floor.
Jason
|
I've pretty much switched over to the clear hose from McMaster Carr. Although the remaining piece of hose, a short 160mm section that fits between the intake of the RL160 and the pipe has been holding up pretty well for a few years. The first one or two pieces disintegrated after a couple of years. Supposedly the culprit is some fire prevention additive required by CE regs.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: felder-woodworking@... [mailto:felder-woodworking@...] On Behalf Of Brian Lamb Sent: Sunday, May 06, 2012 6:34 PM To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: Re: [felder-woodworking] Dust Collection Hose LOL! I'm the victim of a wire coil and no hose in the bottom of my machine again too.... Going to go buy some 4" hose locally and replace it this time. Brian Lamb blamb11@... Weimaraner Rescue of Arizona www.vswc.weimaraner.com click on "rescue dogs" On May 6, 2012, at 1:01 PM, Dino wrote: Since we are talking about dust collection - BTW, great post Bill - I'll add my two cents. I have been using the ClearVu cyclone system with spiral ducting and am very pleased with it. IMO, the only thing that SUCKS more is the premium Felder collection hose. Amazing how it all of a sudden just disintegrates and there is nothing left but the wire. This same thing happened to me some years ago and Felder stated that inferior material had been used and even replaced it; assuring me that the problem had been corrected. Apparently not the case!!!
------------------------------------ To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@... Visit the group web site: Visit the FOG photo library at FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
Bill, Very informative. If you don't mind I'll put that info in PDF format and put it in the files section.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: felder-woodworking@... [mailto:felder-woodworking@...] On Behalf Of mcdavis Sent: Sunday, May 06, 2012 2:56 PM To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: [felder-woodworking] Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection good post Bill, thanks! --- In felder-woodworking@..., "Bill Billick" <billick@...> wrote: To start with, here's some thoughts about my recent Nordfab installation -- in no particular order...
1. Yes, Nordfab does cost "at least twice as much" as other ductwork options. But it's easy to install; easy to make adjustments to reposition pieces (or to rethink how you originally planned to layout a run); easy to take apart to clear a clog; and, if you ever move your shop to another address, most of the pieces of your system would be readily reusable. Plus if you ever retire your woodworking shop (not that any of us will ever do that), most of your Nordfab ductwork will still retain much of its value for resale. For all of these reasons, I choose Nordfab and if I had to do it again -- well, I would do it again.
2. Nordfab's catalog only shows 30 degree wye branches, but 45 degree wyes are also readily available without any special order charges. They aren't mentioned in their catalogs -- you just gotta ask for them. If you have a relatively small workshop (like I have), using 45 degree wyes may help a lot in laying out your dust collection system.
3. Nordfab's standard length pipes are about 60" in length. They also offer what they call nipple pipes which are about 12" long. To create a pipe less than 60" long, you cut off a section of the 60" pipe, and then slide it into the 12" nipple pipe and secure it with a quick-clamp. All of this is pretty common knowledge to anyone who has previously bought Nordfab ductwork. But what I didn't initially know was that you can also special order nipples that are "less than" 12" long -- for example, when you only need a 7" long piece of quick-connect
pipe for a particular location. Actually you can special order lots of different connectors from Nordfab, and if they're similar to any of Nordfab standard offerings then there may not be any special charges. I found that to be surprising.
4. Whenever I had to shorten a pipe, I used a bench-mounted 14" metal-cutting cut-off saw to slice through the Nordfab pipes (although I didn't cut anything wider than 6" pipes). These are the cheap cut-off saws that can be found at Home Depot and Lowes. Very easy to do -- I put a 4" wide strip of cardboard around the entire pipe, marked it with a magic marker where it needed to be cut, and then just 2 quick cuts for each pipe. Lots of sparks that scared my wife, but it worked like a dream and cut through the pipes like butter. Definitely wear goggles and a hat -- and if you have a ceiling- mounted air cleaner, that helpful too! After each cut I smoothed out the cut edges with a small grinding wheel mounted on the end of a hand power drill.
5. I've discovered that it's not unusual for Nordfab to ship old inventory first. But in all fairness to Nordfab, most companies probably have a similar policy. For example, my first 7" quick-clamp arrived with a fairly short handle that was close to impossible to close. When I called for advice about how I could leverage the "too short handle" to close the quick-clamp, Nordfab quickly shipped me a later model 7" quick-clamp (at no charge) with a longer handle that was much easier to close. So when you place your Nordfab order be sure to specify that you only want the "latest available inventory" for each piece ordered. Hey, it may not actually happen but it sure doesn't hurt to ask.
6. FYI -- In the last few months, Nordfab has introduced a new quick-clamp for their system that provides a full 360 degree seal around the entire pipe connection. Their old quick-connect clamp (which, of course, includes ALL of the ones that I bought) didn't quite do a full seal (probably only about 95% to 98% although they still sealed quite tight with very little leakage). So if you place a 2009 order, be sure that you specify that you want only the newer clamps otherwise Nordfab might try to ship you some of their older style clamps to clear out old inventory.
7. Most of Nordfab's independent dealers charge Nordfab's full list price, and some may even add on extra charges for processing paperwork, etc. Felder recommended contacting Doug Lippy with Industrial Corp. in Maryland, and Doug is one of those Nordfab dealers that charges full list price. Maybe at one time Doug gave Foggers a discount, but he apparently doesn't do it anymore. In this tight economy you would think he would. So instead I went with:
Kevin Bolland Bolland Machine 2718 Darlington Rd. Beaver Falls, PA 15010 Phone: 724-846-1290 Fax: 724-846-5253 kevin@...
Kevin had been previously recommended by several Foggers (that's how I found him). He offers a 10% discount to FOG members (if you ask for it), and I've found him to be both helpful & easy to work with. When I explained to him what I was trying to do, he patiently listened & then offered suggestions & solutions that saved me both money & future grief. And, in fact, several of my tips in this post originated from Kevin. In addition to the 10% discount, there also weren't any additional hidden charges for consultations, handling the paperwork, shipping markups, etc. Kevin's a good guy to do business with.
8. All orders are packed and shipped directly from Nordfab's facility in North Carolina. So it really doesn't matter where a dealer is located: you'll still pay the same shipping charges to your shop regardless of which dealer you use. All of the truck and UPS shipments that I received from Nordfab (without exception) were well packed and arrived without damage. FYI -- I took advantage of a FREE SHIPPING offer that Nordfab had this past December. That saved me a lot of money. I don't know if that was a one-time free shipping offer -- or whether Nordfab will be doing it again if the U.S. economy continues to tank. Does anyone know if Nordfab ever offered this before?
9. Even though all of Nordfab's pipes and pieces will readily clamp together without any tools needed, always wear leather-faced gloves when doing your installation -- there are lots of tiny, unseen sharp metal edges everywhere that will definitely cut up your hands (even if you're being quite careful). I'm talking from experience here. I found a nice pair of leather-faced gray mechanics gloves at Lowes for about $15.00 that fit like a second skin and worked great to eliminate further cut hands. 10. There are lots of different ways to hang Nordfab ductwork from your ceiling. I choose to use #2 Gripple hangers ( see www.gripple.com ) which are rated to hang about 100 lbs. per Gripple. For those unfamiliar with Gripples, they use a thin wire rope to hang the ductwork from your ceiling, and they're designed to be easily re-adjusted/re-tensioned. That makes them quick & easy to install and, if needed, to later easily re-adjust. The Gripples that I bought came already attached to a small "L" bracket, and I just screwed them into my basement ceiling joists. It was a very clean, nice-looking installation. Gripples are available in several different varieties and sizes, depending upon: how much weight they need to support, how
you'll attach them, and how long a support wire you'll need. I used 5-foot long # HF-SEYE90G-NO2-5FT @ $5.35 each and I bought them in late December '08 from:
Alan Manufacturing Inc. 3927 East Lincoln Way Wooster, OH 44691 (800) 435-2526 Fax (877) 333-2526
Alan Manufacturing has Gripple info available at: www.alanmfg.com/Catalog/Alan 2009 Catalog.pdf Their Web site doesn't take orders, so you'll need to call them at their 800 number to place your
order. Be aware though that Alan Manufacturing isn't really set up for Web mail orders and it may take them a few weeks to ship your order, but otherwise they are reliable, honest, and they charge reasonable prices. Their Gripples are normally sold in packages of 10 -- so I ordered 2 packs. Alan Manufacturing was the only U.S. source who I found that sells and stocks most of the various varieties of Gripples available -- although you might be also able to find them elsewhere as well. When I searched the Web, Gripples seemed to be more readily available in Europe than in the U.S. 11. I modified the Nordfab gates per a previous FOG posting (sorry that I can't give credit to where its due since I forgot who posted it) -- "Disassemble a standard metal blast gate into its' 3 components. On one side of the cast housing, drill 3 holes, 17/64 diameter through (one side of) the housing. Locate these holes near the area where the thumb-screw threads are. Reassemble the blast gate. Drop 1/4" rare earth magnets from Lee Valley Tools into the holes. These magnets will stick to the gate portion of the assembly and provide the same
function as the thumbscrew". That worked great -- many thanks for the tip! While the gates were disassembled I smoothed out some of the rough edges on the sliding part to make it slide a little better. I also substituted (on each gate) a steel round-nose spring-plunger set-screw with a 1/4"-20 thread ( www.McMaster.com #3126A142 ) for the gate's thumbscrew adjuster.
12. I installed all of my gates to be as close to my main line as feasible -- as recommended by Bill Pentz. From what I understand, that helps to prevent large quantities of debris from slamming into your cyclone and then make its way into your filter(s) instead of your collection drum. And it may also help your system to run better too. My Oneida cyclone is only a 2 HP 230 volts single phase unit -- so anything that I could do to help it function a little better became important to me.
13. I attached a short extension handle to each gate to make them easier to reach & use. These handles were fabricated from a 1/4" x 1" wide aluminum bar. I just cut the 5 foot long bars to the appropriate length needed, and then bolted it to the end of the gate. My longest extension handle was only about 12 inches long. If you need longer extension handles you might want to go with a thinner aluminum bar (i.e., 1/8" or 3/16" thick). To finish off the end of each extension handle, I slipped on a nice-looking red plastic handle grip that I bought from www.McMaster.com #9692K24. McMaster-Carr has these handle grips available in several designer colors (I.e., red, black, or white). Initially the handle grips were pretty hard to slip over the end of the aluminum bar, but adding a few drops of blue Loctite #242 thread locker into the end of the grip (as a temporary lubricant) helped a lot. The extra weight of these aluminum extension handles was offset by both the magnets and spring-plunger set-screws previously described. The extension handles added a very nice finishing touch to the gates.
14. Following another FOG recommendation, I bought an aluminum 5" duct coupler (www.McMaster.com # 5518K14) and attached it with HVAC metal ductwork tape to a Felder 120mm plastic quick-connector. After assembly, it now fits both a 5" hose and the Felder 120mm port perfectly -- a very sweet combination that looks & works great.
15. I'm now building a dust level monitor for my Oneida 35 gallon dust collector drum. Per Art Pentz's recommendation from a while back, I purchased a Series DBLM "Mini-Bin" Dry Bulk Level Monitor that I'll be mounting on the dust collector drum. The monitor uses a small 120 volt motor that rotates a small blade with paddles at 1 rpm. When the drum is close to full, the paddle blade is stopped, a micro-switch then turns off the power to the motor, and a second micro-switch turns on another device to alert you that the bin is full. In my application, I'll be using that second micro-switch to set off an LED strobe light mounted on the lid of the dust collector drum. I purchased the motorized bulk level monitor (part # DBLM3040) for $125 directly from www.dwyer-inst.com. The LED flashing strobe light (part # LEDFL-RV350-ACA) cost $67 and was purchased from www.safetylightsandsignals.com While the LED strobe light provides plenty of attention-getting light for its purpose, it only consumes about 1/10th of one amp at 120 volts so it shouldn't burn out the micro-switch which is only rated for 3 amps. Yes, I could've instead wired in a relay to control a higher amperage alerting device but I wanted to keep it all as simple as possible and, for safety concerns, I also didn't want to create any potential sparks near my dust collector. That said, the whole circuit is pretty basic and intuitive to wire (the bulk level monitor comes packaged with a color-coded wiring diagram). I'm also going to hook it up so that it only receives power when the Oneida cyclone is actually running. Hopefully at least a few of you folks will find some of the above info helpful.
Best,
Bill
------------------------------------ To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@... Visit the group web site: Visit the FOG photo library at FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Re: hello from a new member
Hi, Either the AD531 or the Hammer A331 for a lot less money. I really like the value you get with the Hammer. For 16" the equivalent would be the Hammer A3-41. Felder does not up the HP claim on their motors because they run on 60hz in the USA. They are placarded as 4hp at 50 and 60hz. Make sure you look at the machines in action.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: felder-woodworking@... [mailto:felder-woodworking@...] On Behalf Of WilliamM Sent: Sunday, May 06, 2012 12:48 PM To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: [felder-woodworking] hello from a new member
I am interested in a combo unit planner/jointer. I currently have a Minimax sliding table saw. 18 inch General band saw, General 1 inch mortiser, general drill press, 38 Woodmaster inch wide belt sander, 8 inch jointer and a delta planner, all of which are on mobile bases, except the saw which i move around using a Dayton pallet jack. The pallet jack is the only one made that goes at 90 degrees instead of just in arcs. Very handy in a garage shop. My dust collection is Oneida.
I am familiar with the MInimax line of combos, but not the Felder's. I am looking the MiniMax 12 Inch combo which has a 59 inch long bed, a 3 blade Tersa head 4.8 HP motor 220 volt, 20 amp single phase motor which sells for about $4,200. The 16 inch model has a 71 inch bed and same specs as the other but sells for $5200.
What does Felder have that is comparable?
William Moss
------------------------------------
To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@...
Visit the group web site:
Visit the FOG photo library at
FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Re: Telescopic Extension, Short Crosscut Fence, Install Help?
Hi Tony, If there is a little knob and washer that will fit in a threaded hole on the bottom of the crosscut fence. It's used to hold the extension in place.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: felder-woodworking@... [mailto:felder-woodworking@...] On Behalf Of nospamelf Sent: Monday, May 07, 2012 12:40 AM To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: [felder-woodworking] Telescopic Extension, Short Crosscut Fence, Install Help?
Just got it...and there is absolutely no install manual.
Anyone have any guidance on how to install the little pieces that came with it? :)
Tony
------------------------------------
To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@...
Visit the group web site:
Visit the FOG photo library at
FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Telescopic Extension, Short Crosscut Fence, Install Help?
Just got it...and there is absolutely no install manual.
Anyone have any guidance on how to install the little pieces that came with it? :)
Tony
|
LOL! I'm the victim of a wire coil and no hose in the bottom of my machine again too.... Going to go buy some 4" hose locally and replace it this time. Brian Lamb blamb11@... Weimaraner Rescue of Arizona www.vswc.weimaraner.com click on "rescue dogs" On May 6, 2012, at 1:01 PM, Dino wrote: Since we are talking about dust collection - BTW, great post Bill - I'll add my two cents. I have been using the ClearVu cyclone system with spiral ducting and am very pleased with it. IMO, the only thing that SUCKS more is the premium Felder collection hose. Amazing how it all of a sudden just disintegrates and there is nothing left but the wire. This same thing happened to me some years ago and Felder stated that inferior material had been used and even replaced it; assuring me that the problem had been corrected. Apparently not the case!!!
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|
Dino, Felder offers two types of flexible DC hose. One of them is single layer, ultra flexible and disintegrates in 18-36 months even if nothing is being sucked through it - just as you say. This is the version they put inside the machines to couple the pickup to the DC connector on the outside of the chassis. Felder also sells a clear double-walled, heavy duty flexible hose that's more expensive, but is absolutely terrific - it's the only thing I use in my shop and I've been through several brands. Felder refers to this double-walled DC hose as H/SE and you can order it online from the Felder site, but I suggest you add a note to your oder that you want the heavy duty stuff when you place the order just to be sure. David Best On May 6, 2012, at 1:01 PM, Dino wrote: Since we are talking about dust collection - BTW, great post Bill - I'll add my two cents. I have been using the ClearVu cyclone system with spiral ducting and am very pleased with it. IMO, the only thing that SUCKS more is the premium Felder collection hose. Amazing how it all of a sudden just disintegrates and there is nothing left but the wire. This same thing happened to me some years ago and Felder stated that inferior material had been used and even replaced it; assuring me that the problem had been corrected. Apparently not the case!!!
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|
Since we are talking about dust collection - BTW, great post Bill - I'll add my two cents. I have been using the ClearVu cyclone system with spiral ducting and am very pleased with it. IMO, the only thing that SUCKS more is the premium Felder collection hose. Amazing how it all of a sudden just disintegrates and there is nothing left but the wire. This same thing happened to me some years ago and Felder stated that inferior material had been used and even replaced it; assuring me that the problem had been corrected. Apparently not the case!!!
|
Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
Hi Bill, Nice post doing your dust system this way if you can afford it is the way to go. The only thing I am not keen on is I think your blast gates should be easy to reach @ 5' from floor it makes absolutely no sense to put close to the main and hard to reach. If you have dirt dropping down your verticals you have an improperly designed system. Also Kirk and Blum is allot less pricey and make just about as nice a product. I am still using stuff I bought from them 36 years ago, old style van stoned connectors. mac,,, Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: "mcdavis" <mcdavis@...> Sender: felder-woodworking@... Date: Sun, 06 May 2012 18:55:52 To: <felder-woodworking@...> Reply-To: felder-woodworking@... Subject: [felder-woodworking] Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection good post Bill, thanks! --- In felder-woodworking@..., "Bill Billick" <billick@...> wrote: To start with, here's some thoughts about my recent Nordfab installation -- in no particular order...
1. Yes, Nordfab does cost "at least twice as much" as other ductwork options. But it's easy to install; easy to make adjustments to reposition pieces (or to rethink how you originally planned to layout a run); easy to take apart to clear a clog; and, if you ever move your shop to another address, most of the pieces of your system would be readily reusable. Plus if you ever retire your woodworking shop (not that any of us will ever do that), most of your Nordfab ductwork will still retain much of its value for resale. For all of these reasons, I choose Nordfab and if I had to do it again -- well, I would do it again.
2. Nordfab's catalog only shows 30 degree wye branches, but 45 degree wyes are also readily available without any special order charges. They aren't mentioned in their catalogs -- you just gotta ask for them. If you have a relatively small workshop (like I have), using 45 degree wyes may help a lot in laying out your dust collection system.
3. Nordfab's standard length pipes are about 60" in length. They also offer what they call nipple pipes which are about 12" long. To create a pipe less than 60" long, you cut off a section of the 60" pipe, and then slide it into the 12" nipple pipe and secure it with a quick-clamp. All of this is pretty common knowledge to anyone who has previously bought Nordfab ductwork. But what I didn't initially know was that you can also special order nipples that are "less than" 12" long -- for example, when you only need a 7" long piece of quick-connect pipe for a particular location. Actually you can special order lots of different connectors from Nordfab, and if they're similar to any of Nordfab standard offerings then there may not be any special charges. I found that to be surprising.
4. Whenever I had to shorten a pipe, I used a bench-mounted 14" metal-cutting cut-off saw to slice through the Nordfab pipes (although I didn't cut anything wider than 6" pipes). These are the cheap cut-off saws that can be found at Home Depot and Lowes. Very easy to do -- I put a 4" wide strip of cardboard around the entire pipe, marked it with a magic marker where it needed to be cut, and then just 2 quick cuts for each pipe. Lots of sparks that scared my wife, but it worked like a dream and cut through the pipes like butter. Definitely wear goggles and a hat -- and if you have a ceiling- mounted air cleaner, that helpful too! After each cut I smoothed out the cut edges with a small grinding wheel mounted on the end of a hand power drill.
5. I've discovered that it's not unusual for Nordfab to ship old inventory first. But in all fairness to Nordfab, most companies probably have a similar policy. For example, my first 7" quick-clamp arrived with a fairly short handle that was close to impossible to close. When I called for advice about how I could leverage the "too short handle" to close the quick-clamp, Nordfab quickly shipped me a later model 7" quick-clamp (at no charge) with a longer handle that was much easier to close. So when you place your Nordfab order be sure to specify that you only want the "latest available inventory" for each piece ordered. Hey, it may not actually happen but it sure doesn't hurt to ask.
6. FYI -- In the last few months, Nordfab has introduced a new quick-clamp for their system that provides a full 360 degree seal around the entire pipe connection. Their old quick-connect clamp (which, of course, includes ALL of the ones that I bought) didn't quite do a full seal (probably only about 95% to 98% although they still sealed quite tight with very little leakage). So if you place a 2009 order, be sure that you specify that you want only the newer clamps otherwise Nordfab might try to ship you some of their older style clamps to clear out old inventory.
7. Most of Nordfab's independent dealers charge Nordfab's full list price, and some may even add on extra charges for processing paperwork, etc. Felder recommended contacting Doug Lippy with Industrial Corp. in Maryland, and Doug is one of those Nordfab dealers that charges full list price. Maybe at one time Doug gave Foggers a discount, but he apparently doesn't do it anymore. In this tight economy you would think he would. So instead I went with:
Kevin Bolland Bolland Machine 2718 Darlington Rd. Beaver Falls, PA 15010 Phone: 724-846-1290 Fax: 724-846-5253 kevin@...
Kevin had been previously recommended by several Foggers (that's how I found him). He offers a 10% discount to FOG members (if you ask for it), and I've found him to be both helpful & easy to work with. When I explained to him what I was trying to do, he patiently listened & then offered suggestions & solutions that saved me both money & future grief. And, in fact, several of my tips in this post originated from Kevin. In addition to the 10% discount, there also weren't any additional hidden charges for consultations, handling the paperwork, shipping markups, etc. Kevin's a good guy to do business with.
8. All orders are packed and shipped directly from Nordfab's facility in North Carolina. So it really doesn't matter where a dealer is located: you'll still pay the same shipping charges to your shop regardless of which dealer you use. All of the truck and UPS shipments that I received from Nordfab (without exception) were well packed and arrived without damage. FYI -- I took advantage of a FREE SHIPPING offer that Nordfab had this past December. That saved me a lot of money. I don't know if that was a one-time free shipping offer -- or whether Nordfab will be doing it again if the U.S. economy continues to tank. Does anyone know if Nordfab ever offered this before?
9. Even though all of Nordfab's pipes and pieces will readily clamp together without any tools needed, always wear leather-faced gloves when doing your installation -- there are lots of tiny, unseen sharp metal edges everywhere that will definitely cut up your hands (even if you're being quite careful). I'm talking from experience here. I found a nice pair of leather-faced gray mechanics gloves at Lowes for about $15.00 that fit like a second skin and worked great to eliminate further cut hands.
10. There are lots of different ways to hang Nordfab ductwork from your ceiling. I choose to use #2 Gripple hangers ( see www.gripple.com ) which are rated to hang about 100 lbs. per Gripple. For those unfamiliar with Gripples, they use a thin wire rope to hang the ductwork from your ceiling, and they're designed to be easily re-adjusted/re-tensioned. That makes them quick & easy to install and, if needed, to later easily re-adjust. The Gripples that I bought came already attached to a small "L" bracket, and I just screwed them into my basement ceiling joists. It was a very clean, nice-looking installation. Gripples are available in several different varieties and sizes, depending upon: how much weight they need to support, how you'll attach them, and how long a support wire you'll need.
I used 5-foot long # HF-SEYE90G-NO2-5FT @ $5.35 each and I bought them in late December '08 from:
Alan Manufacturing Inc. 3927 East Lincoln Way Wooster, OH 44691 (800) 435-2526 Fax (877) 333-2526
Alan Manufacturing has Gripple info available at: www.alanmfg.com/Catalog/Alan 2009 Catalog.pdf Their Web site doesn't take orders, so you'll need to call them at their 800 number to place your order. Be aware though that Alan Manufacturing isn't really set up for Web mail orders and it may take them a few weeks to ship your order, but otherwise they are reliable, honest, and they charge reasonable prices. Their Gripples are normally sold in packages of 10 -- so I ordered 2 packs. Alan Manufacturing was the only U.S. source who I found that sells and stocks most of the various varieties of Gripples available -- although you might be also able to find them elsewhere as well. When I searched the Web, Gripples seemed to be more readily available in Europe than in the U.S.
11. I modified the Nordfab gates per a previous FOG posting (sorry that I can't give credit to where its due since I forgot who posted it) -- "Disassemble a standard metal blast gate into its' 3 components. On one side of the cast housing, drill 3 holes, 17/64 diameter through (one side of) the housing. Locate these holes near the area where the thumb-screw threads are. Reassemble the blast gate. Drop 1/4" rare earth magnets from Lee Valley Tools into the holes. These magnets will stick to the gate portion of the assembly and provide the same function as the thumbscrew". That worked great -- many thanks for the tip! While the gates were disassembled I smoothed out some of the rough edges on the sliding part to make it slide a little better. I also substituted (on each gate) a steel round-nose spring-plunger set-screw with a 1/4"-20 thread ( www.McMaster.com #3126A142 ) for the gate's thumbscrew adjuster.
12. I installed all of my gates to be as close to my main line as feasible -- as recommended by Bill Pentz. From what I understand, that helps to prevent large quantities of debris from slamming into your cyclone and then make its way into your filter(s) instead of your collection drum. And it may also help your system to run better too. My Oneida cyclone is only a 2 HP 230 volts single phase unit -- so anything that I could do to help it function a little better became important to me.
13. I attached a short extension handle to each gate to make them easier to reach & use. These handles were fabricated from a 1/4" x 1" wide aluminum bar. I just cut the 5 foot long bars to the appropriate length needed, and then bolted it to the end of the gate. My longest extension handle was only about 12 inches long. If you need longer extension handles you might want to go with a thinner aluminum bar (i.e., 1/8" or 3/16" thick). To finish off the end of each extension handle, I slipped on a nice-looking red plastic handle grip that I bought from www.McMaster.com #9692K24. McMaster-Carr has these handle grips available in several designer colors (I.e., red, black, or white). Initially the handle grips were pretty hard to slip over the end of the aluminum bar, but adding a few drops of blue Loctite #242 thread locker into the end of the grip (as a temporary lubricant) helped a lot. The extra weight of these aluminum extension handles was offset by both the magnets and spring-plunger set-screws previously described. The extension handles added a very nice finishing touch to the gates.
14. Following another FOG recommendation, I bought an aluminum 5" duct coupler (www.McMaster.com # 5518K14) and attached it with HVAC metal ductwork tape to a Felder 120mm plastic quick-connector. After assembly, it now fits both a 5" hose and the Felder 120mm port perfectly -- a very sweet combination that looks & works great.
15. I'm now building a dust level monitor for my Oneida 35 gallon dust collector drum. Per Art Pentz's recommendation from a while back, I purchased a Series DBLM "Mini-Bin" Dry Bulk Level Monitor that I'll be mounting on the dust collector drum. The monitor uses a small 120 volt motor that rotates a small blade with paddles at 1 rpm. When the drum is close to full, the paddle blade is stopped, a micro-switch then turns off the power to the motor, and a second micro-switch turns on another device to alert you that the bin is full. In my application, I'll be using that second micro-switch to set off an LED strobe light mounted on the lid of the dust collector drum. I purchased the motorized bulk level monitor (part # DBLM3040) for $125 directly from www.dwyer-inst.com. The LED flashing strobe light (part # LEDFL-RV350-ACA) cost $67 and was purchased from www.safetylightsandsignals.com While the LED strobe light provides plenty of attention-getting light for its purpose, it only consumes about 1/10th of one amp at 120 volts so it shouldn't burn out the micro-switch which is only rated for 3 amps. Yes, I could've instead wired in a relay to control a higher amperage alerting device but I wanted to keep it all as simple as possible and, for safety concerns, I also didn't want to create any potential sparks near my dust collector. That said, the whole circuit is pretty basic and intuitive to wire (the bulk level monitor comes packaged with a color-coded wiring diagram). I'm also going to hook it up so that it only receives power when the Oneida cyclone is actually running.
Hopefully at least a few of you folks will find some of the above info helpful.
Best,
Bill
|
Re: 15 Things I've (Sort of) Learned About Dust Collection
good post Bill, thanks!
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "Bill Billick" <billick@...> wrote: To start with, here's some thoughts about my recent Nordfab installation -- in no particular order...
1. Yes, Nordfab does cost "at least twice as much" as other ductwork options. But it's easy to install; easy to make adjustments to reposition pieces (or to rethink how you originally planned to layout a run); easy to take apart to clear a clog; and, if you ever move your shop to another address, most of the pieces of your system would be readily reusable. Plus if you ever retire your woodworking shop (not that any of us will ever do that), most of your Nordfab ductwork will still retain much of its value for resale. For all of these reasons, I choose Nordfab and if I had to do it again -- well, I would do it again.
2. Nordfab's catalog only shows 30 degree wye branches, but 45 degree wyes are also readily available without any special order charges. They aren't mentioned in their catalogs -- you just gotta ask for them. If you have a relatively small workshop (like I have), using 45 degree wyes may help a lot in laying out your dust collection system.
3. Nordfab's standard length pipes are about 60" in length. They also offer what they call nipple pipes which are about 12" long. To create a pipe less than 60" long, you cut off a section of the 60" pipe, and then slide it into the 12" nipple pipe and secure it with a quick-clamp. All of this is pretty common knowledge to anyone who has previously bought Nordfab ductwork. But what I didn't initially know was that you can also special order nipples that are "less than" 12" long -- for example, when you only need a 7" long piece of quick-connect pipe for a particular location. Actually you can special order lots of different connectors from Nordfab, and if they're similar to any of Nordfab standard offerings then there may not be any special charges. I found that to be surprising.
4. Whenever I had to shorten a pipe, I used a bench-mounted 14" metal-cutting cut-off saw to slice through the Nordfab pipes (although I didn't cut anything wider than 6" pipes). These are the cheap cut-off saws that can be found at Home Depot and Lowes. Very easy to do -- I put a 4" wide strip of cardboard around the entire pipe, marked it with a magic marker where it needed to be cut, and then just 2 quick cuts for each pipe. Lots of sparks that scared my wife, but it worked like a dream and cut through the pipes like butter. Definitely wear goggles and a hat -- and if you have a ceiling- mounted air cleaner, that helpful too! After each cut I smoothed out the cut edges with a small grinding wheel mounted on the end of a hand power drill.
5. I've discovered that it's not unusual for Nordfab to ship old inventory first. But in all fairness to Nordfab, most companies probably have a similar policy. For example, my first 7" quick-clamp arrived with a fairly short handle that was close to impossible to close. When I called for advice about how I could leverage the "too short handle" to close the quick-clamp, Nordfab quickly shipped me a later model 7" quick-clamp (at no charge) with a longer handle that was much easier to close. So when you place your Nordfab order be sure to specify that you only want the "latest available inventory" for each piece ordered. Hey, it may not actually happen but it sure doesn't hurt to ask.
6. FYI -- In the last few months, Nordfab has introduced a new quick-clamp for their system that provides a full 360 degree seal around the entire pipe connection. Their old quick-connect clamp (which, of course, includes ALL of the ones that I bought) didn't quite do a full seal (probably only about 95% to 98% although they still sealed quite tight with very little leakage). So if you place a 2009 order, be sure that you specify that you want only the newer clamps otherwise Nordfab might try to ship you some of their older style clamps to clear out old inventory.
7. Most of Nordfab's independent dealers charge Nordfab's full list price, and some may even add on extra charges for processing paperwork, etc. Felder recommended contacting Doug Lippy with Industrial Corp. in Maryland, and Doug is one of those Nordfab dealers that charges full list price. Maybe at one time Doug gave Foggers a discount, but he apparently doesn't do it anymore. In this tight economy you would think he would. So instead I went with:
Kevin Bolland Bolland Machine 2718 Darlington Rd. Beaver Falls, PA 15010 Phone: 724-846-1290 Fax: 724-846-5253 kevin@...
Kevin had been previously recommended by several Foggers (that's how I found him). He offers a 10% discount to FOG members (if you ask for it), and I've found him to be both helpful & easy to work with. When I explained to him what I was trying to do, he patiently listened & then offered suggestions & solutions that saved me both money & future grief. And, in fact, several of my tips in this post originated from Kevin. In addition to the 10% discount, there also weren't any additional hidden charges for consultations, handling the paperwork, shipping markups, etc. Kevin's a good guy to do business with.
8. All orders are packed and shipped directly from Nordfab's facility in North Carolina. So it really doesn't matter where a dealer is located: you'll still pay the same shipping charges to your shop regardless of which dealer you use. All of the truck and UPS shipments that I received from Nordfab (without exception) were well packed and arrived without damage. FYI -- I took advantage of a FREE SHIPPING offer that Nordfab had this past December. That saved me a lot of money. I don't know if that was a one-time free shipping offer -- or whether Nordfab will be doing it again if the U.S. economy continues to tank. Does anyone know if Nordfab ever offered this before?
9. Even though all of Nordfab's pipes and pieces will readily clamp together without any tools needed, always wear leather-faced gloves when doing your installation -- there are lots of tiny, unseen sharp metal edges everywhere that will definitely cut up your hands (even if you're being quite careful). I'm talking from experience here. I found a nice pair of leather-faced gray mechanics gloves at Lowes for about $15.00 that fit like a second skin and worked great to eliminate further cut hands.
10. There are lots of different ways to hang Nordfab ductwork from your ceiling. I choose to use #2 Gripple hangers ( see www.gripple.com ) which are rated to hang about 100 lbs. per Gripple. For those unfamiliar with Gripples, they use a thin wire rope to hang the ductwork from your ceiling, and they're designed to be easily re-adjusted/re-tensioned. That makes them quick & easy to install and, if needed, to later easily re-adjust. The Gripples that I bought came already attached to a small "L" bracket, and I just screwed them into my basement ceiling joists. It was a very clean, nice-looking installation. Gripples are available in several different varieties and sizes, depending upon: how much weight they need to support, how you'll attach them, and how long a support wire you'll need.
I used 5-foot long # HF-SEYE90G-NO2-5FT @ $5.35 each and I bought them in late December '08 from:
Alan Manufacturing Inc. 3927 East Lincoln Way Wooster, OH 44691 (800) 435-2526 Fax (877) 333-2526
Alan Manufacturing has Gripple info available at: www.alanmfg.com/Catalog/Alan 2009 Catalog.pdf Their Web site doesn't take orders, so you'll need to call them at their 800 number to place your order. Be aware though that Alan Manufacturing isn't really set up for Web mail orders and it may take them a few weeks to ship your order, but otherwise they are reliable, honest, and they charge reasonable prices. Their Gripples are normally sold in packages of 10 -- so I ordered 2 packs. Alan Manufacturing was the only U.S. source who I found that sells and stocks most of the various varieties of Gripples available -- although you might be also able to find them elsewhere as well. When I searched the Web, Gripples seemed to be more readily available in Europe than in the U.S.
11. I modified the Nordfab gates per a previous FOG posting (sorry that I can't give credit to where its due since I forgot who posted it) -- "Disassemble a standard metal blast gate into its' 3 components. On one side of the cast housing, drill 3 holes, 17/64 diameter through (one side of) the housing. Locate these holes near the area where the thumb-screw threads are. Reassemble the blast gate. Drop 1/4" rare earth magnets from Lee Valley Tools into the holes. These magnets will stick to the gate portion of the assembly and provide the same function as the thumbscrew". That worked great -- many thanks for the tip! While the gates were disassembled I smoothed out some of the rough edges on the sliding part to make it slide a little better. I also substituted (on each gate) a steel round-nose spring-plunger set-screw with a 1/4"-20 thread ( www.McMaster.com #3126A142 ) for the gate's thumbscrew adjuster.
12. I installed all of my gates to be as close to my main line as feasible -- as recommended by Bill Pentz. From what I understand, that helps to prevent large quantities of debris from slamming into your cyclone and then make its way into your filter(s) instead of your collection drum. And it may also help your system to run better too. My Oneida cyclone is only a 2 HP 230 volts single phase unit -- so anything that I could do to help it function a little better became important to me.
13. I attached a short extension handle to each gate to make them easier to reach & use. These handles were fabricated from a 1/4" x 1" wide aluminum bar. I just cut the 5 foot long bars to the appropriate length needed, and then bolted it to the end of the gate. My longest extension handle was only about 12 inches long. If you need longer extension handles you might want to go with a thinner aluminum bar (i.e., 1/8" or 3/16" thick). To finish off the end of each extension handle, I slipped on a nice-looking red plastic handle grip that I bought from www.McMaster.com #9692K24. McMaster-Carr has these handle grips available in several designer colors (I.e., red, black, or white). Initially the handle grips were pretty hard to slip over the end of the aluminum bar, but adding a few drops of blue Loctite #242 thread locker into the end of the grip (as a temporary lubricant) helped a lot. The extra weight of these aluminum extension handles was offset by both the magnets and spring-plunger set-screws previously described. The extension handles added a very nice finishing touch to the gates.
14. Following another FOG recommendation, I bought an aluminum 5" duct coupler (www.McMaster.com # 5518K14) and attached it with HVAC metal ductwork tape to a Felder 120mm plastic quick-connector. After assembly, it now fits both a 5" hose and the Felder 120mm port perfectly -- a very sweet combination that looks & works great.
15. I'm now building a dust level monitor for my Oneida 35 gallon dust collector drum. Per Art Pentz's recommendation from a while back, I purchased a Series DBLM "Mini-Bin" Dry Bulk Level Monitor that I'll be mounting on the dust collector drum. The monitor uses a small 120 volt motor that rotates a small blade with paddles at 1 rpm. When the drum is close to full, the paddle blade is stopped, a micro-switch then turns off the power to the motor, and a second micro-switch turns on another device to alert you that the bin is full. In my application, I'll be using that second micro-switch to set off an LED strobe light mounted on the lid of the dust collector drum. I purchased the motorized bulk level monitor (part # DBLM3040) for $125 directly from www.dwyer-inst.com. The LED flashing strobe light (part # LEDFL-RV350-ACA) cost $67 and was purchased from www.safetylightsandsignals.com While the LED strobe light provides plenty of attention-getting light for its purpose, it only consumes about 1/10th of one amp at 120 volts so it shouldn't burn out the micro-switch which is only rated for 3 amps. Yes, I could've instead wired in a relay to control a higher amperage alerting device but I wanted to keep it all as simple as possible and, for safety concerns, I also didn't want to create any potential sparks near my dust collector. That said, the whole circuit is pretty basic and intuitive to wire (the bulk level monitor comes packaged with a color-coded wiring diagram). I'm also going to hook it up so that it only receives power when the Oneida cyclone is actually running.
Hopefully at least a few of you folks will find some of the above info helpful.
Best,
Bill
|
I am interested in a combo unit planner/jointer. I currently have a Minimax sliding table saw. 18 inch General band saw, General 1 inch mortiser, general drill press, 38 Woodmaster inch wide belt sander, 8 inch jointer and a delta planner, all of which are on mobile bases, except the saw which i move around using a Dayton pallet jack. The pallet jack is the only one made that goes at 90 degrees instead of just in arcs. Very handy in a garage shop. My dust collection is Oneida.
I am familiar with the MInimax line of combos, but not the Felder's. I am looking the MiniMax 12 Inch combo which has a 59 inch long bed, a 3 blade Tersa head 4.8 HP motor 220 volt, 20 amp single phase motor which sells for about $4,200. The 16 inch model has a 71 inch bed and same specs as the other but sells for $5200.
What does Felder have that is comparable?
William Moss
|
Re: New K3 saw not quite starting
Should start right up. The On buttons on Hammer equipment are supposed to be held in the depressed state until the blade speeds up to full. I've never noticed this as an issue on my saw, but the JP cutter block is sufficiently heavy that it needs this each time. I'd contact tech and see what they say.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On 5/5/2012 4:00 PM, simon_km wrote: Hello Group
I'm using my new K3 saw for the first time, and when powering up, there is a gentle quite loud hum while the button is depressed, but the motor doesn't seem to be springing into action, with no turning of the blade. Belt is intact. I suspect there is something I'm not attending to! Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated!
Best wishes,
Simon
------------------------------------
To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@...
Visit the group web site:
Visit the FOG photo library at
FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Re: Hammer B3 Slider Problem
David, keep counting. I find this information fascinating and hard to acquire. how various companies accomplish the same goal and opinions as to their success make for good learning. Thanks, Dave
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
To: felder-woodworking@... From: dbest@... Date: Sat, 5 May 2012 15:52:36 -0700 Subject: Re: [felder-woodworking] Hammer B3 Slider Problem
Ian, my comments to Jerry were in no way intended to be critical toward you and your alignment process. I know you had alignment issues stemming from the trunion when the blade was tilted. However, for the average user who doesn't have such problems, starting to mess around with the pivot mechanism to align the slider trajectory is asking for more trouble than it's worth.
My K975 saw (which is the same basic platform as the Kappa 30 and Kappa 40) has a trunion pivot system derived from the Hammer line - dual pivot hinges hanging from the underside of the cast iron table, and I've gone at it "for kicks" just to see "how it's put together" and about 10 hours later was kicking myself for falling captive to the curiosity. My K975 does have "jacking screws" to adjust the slider trajectory (toe-out), but it's completely independent of the trunion mechanism.
I've experienced NO issues or problems with this "pivoting" trunion system, although I must admit that I had my reservations when I first saw it. In practice it's been just fine. It is curious to me that the newer double trunion on the 700-series is a conventional system of dual-tracked semicircular ways instead of the much simpler pivot mechanism on the Kappa 40 and Hammer lines. The newer 700-series shaper has the same semicircular pair of ways for a trunion, which is probably more robust to the nature of the forces endured by a shaper operation. I'm guessing (totally guessing) Felder did the shaper trunion design first and migrated it to the saw when re-engineering the trunions for the 700 series. I don't know if Felder makes the claim that the newer 700-series trunion keeps the zero-crossing line constant as the trunion is tilted.
I know Altendorf and Martin make such claims, and I've verified this as truth - at least on the Martin T74. The Martin T60 uses a microcomputer to calculate the current zero-crossing line as the trunion is tilted and offsets the crosscut stops and rip fence position readouts accordingly. The Altendorf dual-way trunion mechanism fully compensates mechanically for zero-crossing line displacement as it tilts. But since I've never been a fan of the roller-skate mechanism that provides for a sliding table on the Altendorf line, I've never given that machine much due, although I will say that their trunion system - when pulled out of the chassis and put under glass at the shows - looks positively bomb proof.
I'll be interested to see what the Kappa 400 system has, and surprised if they migrated away from the pivot system for the trunion. Obviously the parallelogram outrigger table on the new 400 is a derivative of the same feature that's been available on the Martin sliding saws for over a decade (at probably five times the cost). Did Felder have the courage to implement for the 400-serise a conventional dual-way trunion too? Now I'm wondering if I've devolved into counting angels on the head of a pin - again.
David Best
On May 5, 2012, at 10:17 AM, ondablade wrote:
It wouldn't surprise me David if it's the case that Felder would prefer that the blade tilt hinge mounting on the K3 is not disturbed by owners.
That said my saw was showing about a .010in difference in toe out when the blade was tilted from 90 deg to 45 deg as received. It really wasn't an option to leave it that way, and the only obviously available adjustment seemed to be to shim the in feed end trunnion down a hair. (the presence of what looks like a shim in this location in the parts manual suggests that this is how Felder do it)
The saw spindle assembly is hinged from the table, so it presumably was that way from the factory. The table and the slider were significantly misaligned too, but not in ways that would have disturbed the above. i.e. toe out measured with a dial gauge off the slider was within the spec quoted in the set up guide when the blade was at 90 deg, but as above well off at 45 deg.
One factor on the K3 (being a more budget model than some) is that the blade tilt uses a fairly basic hinge mechanism rather than a trunnion set per se. This places the blade tilting axis some small distance (maybe 6mm?) below the surface of the table.
I'm no expert, but a little thought suggests that a full trunnion set up would make it possible that the tilt axis could run precisely on the line where the plane of the table surface, and the 'non-offcut' face of the saw blade intersect.
Which if accurately enough placed would open the way to the possibility that the 'zero' of the cross cut scale would not be disturbed, and the toe out would remain more or less at the vertical setting as the blade tilted.
Given such a set up it'd make a lot of sense to avoid disturbing these alignments, and to stay with the slider to set toe out. More upmarket saws of course have a jacking screw that make this alignment easier too.
That's not the situation on the K3 though, and i'm not sure that it's such a big deal on it...
ian
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "David P. Best" <dbest@...> wrote:
For slider toe-out, I'd like to discourage you from moving the pivot blocks for the saw trunion, and encourage you to adjust the lower rail of the sliding table instead. If you mess with with the trunion, you're likely to have misalignment issues when you tilt the saw blade.
David Best
On May 4, 2012, at 5:55 AM, Jerry wrote:
I removed the slider table from the bottom mount. I wanted to check out everything and no problems were found. The rails and bearing were very clean. The bearing carriage was not centered. It is now centered and comes about 1" from the each end durring a full stroke. I was adjusting the bearing rails at the front where the lateral play was high. Now that the bearing are correctly positioned I thighten up the rails where the bearing carriage is when getting the large movement. That took care of the lateral play problem. It is had to believe that a 230mm long bearing carriage will handle a 1250mm slider but it does.
I now will move on to the slider toe out after I do all the checks you suggested. I think I will try Ian's method and adjust the front saw mounting bracket.
Thanks for getting me on the right track. I will wait for your next batch of BBAS-2416-RED squares to fine tune my crosscut fence...
Jerry P
------------------------------------
To Post a message, send it to: felder-woodworking@...
Visit the group web site:
Visit the FOG photo library at
FOG Amazon link: - Support the FOG with purchases at Amazon. ! Groups Links
|
Re: Hammer B3 Slider Problem
No prob David, and thanks for all the input on how it's done on some of the other saws.
I think we're on the same hymn sheet. I've no issue whatsoever with the K3 design, and agree that disturbing the tilt mechanism opens up possibilities for misalignment that may not at first be obvious to the unwary.
That said it seems to have proved a very straightforward fix for me.
I think too as you said that if the design was a trunnion type that targeted the very precise alignment of the tilt axis discussed that the chances of running into subtle problems as a result of disturbing it would be even greater....
ian
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "David P. Best" <dbest@...> wrote: Ian, my comments to Jerry were in no way intended to be critical toward you and your alignment process. I know you had alignment issues stemming from the trunion when the blade was tilted. However, for the average user who doesn't have such problems, starting to mess around with the pivot mechanism to align the slider trajectory is asking for more trouble than it's worth.
My K975 saw (which is the same basic platform as the Kappa 30 and Kappa 40) has a trunion pivot system derived from the Hammer line - dual pivot hinges hanging from the underside of the cast iron table, and I've gone at it "for kicks" just to see "how it's put together" and about 10 hours later was kicking myself for falling captive to the curiosity. My K975 does have "jacking screws" to adjust the slider trajectory (toe-out), but it's completely independent of the trunion mechanism.
I've experienced NO issues or problems with this "pivoting" trunion system, although I must admit that I had my reservations when I first saw it. In practice it's been just fine. It is curious to me that the newer double trunion on the 700-series is a conventional system of dual-tracked semicircular ways instead of the much simpler pivot mechanism on the Kappa 40 and Hammer lines. The newer 700-series shaper has the same semicircular pair of ways for a trunion, which is probably more robust to the nature of the forces endured by a shaper operation. I'm guessing (totally guessing) Felder did the shaper trunion design first and migrated it to the saw when re-engineering the trunions for the 700 series. I don't know if Felder makes the claim that the newer 700-series trunion keeps the zero-crossing line constant as the trunion is tilted.
I know Altendorf and Martin make such claims, and I've verified this as truth - at least on the Martin T74. The Martin T60 uses a microcomputer to calculate the current zero-crossing line as the trunion is tilted and offsets the crosscut stops and rip fence position readouts accordingly. The Altendorf dual-way trunion mechanism fully compensates mechanically for zero-crossing line displacement as it tilts. But since I've never been a fan of the roller-skate mechanism that provides for a sliding table on the Altendorf line, I've never given that machine much due, although I will say that their trunion system - when pulled out of the chassis and put under glass at the shows - looks positively bomb proof.
I'll be interested to see what the Kappa 400 system has, and surprised if they migrated away from the pivot system for the trunion. Obviously the parallelogram outrigger table on the new 400 is a derivative of the same feature that's been available on the Martin sliding saws for over a decade (at probably five times the cost). Did Felder have the courage to implement for the 400-serise a conventional dual-way trunion too? Now I'm wondering if I've devolved into counting angels on the head of a pin - again.
David Best
On May 5, 2012, at 10:17 AM, ondablade wrote:
It wouldn't surprise me David if it's the case that Felder would prefer that the blade tilt hinge mounting on the K3 is not disturbed by owners.
That said my saw was showing about a .010in difference in toe out when the blade was tilted from 90 deg to 45 deg as received. It really wasn't an option to leave it that way, and the only obviously available adjustment seemed to be to shim the in feed end trunnion down a hair. (the presence of what looks like a shim in this location in the parts manual suggests that this is how Felder do it)
The saw spindle assembly is hinged from the table, so it presumably was that way from the factory. The table and the slider were significantly misaligned too, but not in ways that would have disturbed the above. i.e. toe out measured with a dial gauge off the slider was within the spec quoted in the set up guide when the blade was at 90 deg, but as above well off at 45 deg.
One factor on the K3 (being a more budget model than some) is that the blade tilt uses a fairly basic hinge mechanism rather than a trunnion set per se. This places the blade tilting axis some small distance (maybe 6mm?) below the surface of the table.
I'm no expert, but a little thought suggests that a full trunnion set up would make it possible that the tilt axis could run precisely on the line where the plane of the table surface, and the 'non-offcut' face of the saw blade intersect.
Which if accurately enough placed would open the way to the possibility that the 'zero' of the cross cut scale would not be disturbed, and the toe out would remain more or less at the vertical setting as the blade tilted.
Given such a set up it'd make a lot of sense to avoid disturbing these alignments, and to stay with the slider to set toe out. More upmarket saws of course have a jacking screw that make this alignment easier too.
That's not the situation on the K3 though, and i'm not sure that it's such a big deal on it...
ian
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "David P. Best" <dbest@> wrote:
For slider toe-out, I'd like to discourage you from moving the pivot blocks for the saw trunion, and encourage you to adjust the lower rail of the sliding table instead. If you mess with with the trunion, you're likely to have misalignment issues when you tilt the saw blade.
David Best
On May 4, 2012, at 5:55 AM, Jerry wrote:
I removed the slider table from the bottom mount. I wanted to check out everything and no problems were found. The rails and bearing were very clean. The bearing carriage was not centered. It is now centered and comes about 1" from the each end durring a full stroke. I was adjusting the bearing rails at the front where the lateral play was high. Now that the bearing are correctly positioned I thighten up the rails where the bearing carriage is when getting the large movement. That took care of the lateral play problem. It is had to believe that a 230mm long bearing carriage will handle a 1250mm slider but it does.
I now will move on to the slider toe out after I do all the checks you suggested. I think I will try Ian's method and adjust the front saw mounting bracket.
Thanks for getting me on the right track. I will wait for your next batch of BBAS-2416-RED squares to fine tune my crosscut fence...
Jerry P
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|
Re: Hammer B3 Slider Problem
Ian, my comments to Jerry were in no way intended to be critical toward you and your alignment process. I know you had alignment issues stemming from the trunion when the blade was tilted. However, for the average user who doesn't have such problems, starting to mess around with the pivot mechanism to align the slider trajectory is asking for more trouble than it's worth. My K975 saw (which is the same basic platform as the Kappa 30 and Kappa 40) has a trunion pivot system derived from the Hammer line - dual pivot hinges hanging from the underside of the cast iron table, and I've gone at it "for kicks" just to see "how it's put together" and about 10 hours later was kicking myself for falling captive to the curiosity. My K975 does have "jacking screws" to adjust the slider trajectory (toe-out), but it's completely independent of the trunion mechanism. I've experienced NO issues or problems with this "pivoting" trunion system, although I must admit that I had my reservations when I first saw it. In practice it's been just fine. It is curious to me that the newer double trunion on the 700-series is a conventional system of dual-tracked semicircular ways instead of the much simpler pivot mechanism on the Kappa 40 and Hammer lines. The newer 700-series shaper has the same semicircular pair of ways for a trunion, which is probably more robust to the nature of the forces endured by a shaper operation. I'm guessing (totally guessing) Felder did the shaper trunion design first and migrated it to the saw when re-engineering the trunions for the 700 series. I don't know if Felder makes the claim that the newer 700-series trunion keeps the zero-crossing line constant as the trunion is tilted. I know Altendorf and Martin make such claims, and I've verified this as truth - at least on the Martin T74. The Martin T60 uses a microcomputer to calculate the current zero-crossing line as the trunion is tilted and offsets the crosscut stops and rip fence position readouts accordingly. The Altendorf dual-way trunion mechanism fully compensates mechanically for zero-crossing line displacement as it tilts. But since I've never been a fan of the roller-skate mechanism that provides for a sliding table on the Altendorf line, I've never given that machine much due, although I will say that their trunion system - when pulled out of the chassis and put under glass at the shows - looks positively bomb proof. I'll be interested to see what the Kappa 400 system has, and surprised if they migrated away from the pivot system for the trunion. Obviously the parallelogram outrigger table on the new 400 is a derivative of the same feature that's been available on the Martin sliding saws for over a decade (at probably five times the cost). Did Felder have the courage to implement for the 400-serise a conventional dual-way trunion too? Now I'm wondering if I've devolved into counting angels on the head of a pin - again. David Best On May 5, 2012, at 10:17 AM, ondablade wrote: It wouldn't surprise me David if it's the case that Felder would prefer that the blade tilt hinge mounting on the K3 is not disturbed by owners.
That said my saw was showing about a .010in difference in toe out when the blade was tilted from 90 deg to 45 deg as received. It really wasn't an option to leave it that way, and the only obviously available adjustment seemed to be to shim the in feed end trunnion down a hair. (the presence of what looks like a shim in this location in the parts manual suggests that this is how Felder do it)
The saw spindle assembly is hinged from the table, so it presumably was that way from the factory. The table and the slider were significantly misaligned too, but not in ways that would have disturbed the above. i.e. toe out measured with a dial gauge off the slider was within the spec quoted in the set up guide when the blade was at 90 deg, but as above well off at 45 deg.
One factor on the K3 (being a more budget model than some) is that the blade tilt uses a fairly basic hinge mechanism rather than a trunnion set per se. This places the blade tilting axis some small distance (maybe 6mm?) below the surface of the table.
I'm no expert, but a little thought suggests that a full trunnion set up would make it possible that the tilt axis could run precisely on the line where the plane of the table surface, and the 'non-offcut' face of the saw blade intersect.
Which if accurately enough placed would open the way to the possibility that the 'zero' of the cross cut scale would not be disturbed, and the toe out would remain more or less at the vertical setting as the blade tilted.
Given such a set up it'd make a lot of sense to avoid disturbing these alignments, and to stay with the slider to set toe out. More upmarket saws of course have a jacking screw that make this alignment easier too.
That's not the situation on the K3 though, and i'm not sure that it's such a big deal on it...
ian
--- In felder-woodworking@..., "David P. Best" <dbest@...> wrote:
For slider toe-out, I'd like to discourage you from moving the pivot blocks for the saw trunion, and encourage you to adjust the lower rail of the sliding table instead. If you mess with with the trunion, you're likely to have misalignment issues when you tilt the saw blade.
David Best
On May 4, 2012, at 5:55 AM, Jerry wrote:
I removed the slider table from the bottom mount. I wanted to check out everything and no problems were found. The rails and bearing were very clean. The bearing carriage was not centered. It is now centered and comes about 1" from the each end durring a full stroke. I was adjusting the bearing rails at the front where the lateral play was high. Now that the bearing are correctly positioned I thighten up the rails where the bearing carriage is when getting the large movement. That took care of the lateral play problem. It is had to believe that a 230mm long bearing carriage will handle a 1250mm slider but it does.
I now will move on to the slider toe out after I do all the checks you suggested. I think I will try Ian's method and adjust the front saw mounting bracket.
Thanks for getting me on the right track. I will wait for your next batch of BBAS-2416-RED squares to fine tune my crosscut fence...
Jerry P
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
|