Re: Battery Charger Question
My charger (a cheapo) quits if it thinks the air around it is too warm. I put a fan next to it, restart it, and all seems to be fine.<br>Kirsti.
|
Re: Battery Charger Question
My guess is that there was a bad connection (high resistance) on one of the leads that caused the charger to think it was done. Did you move any of the connections when you restarted charger...which might have made a better ground ? If not it might be a faulty charger. Good luck.
|
Under what circumstances does an automatic battery charger stop charging in the middle of its cycle? I had 170AH to replace in the bank this morning and when I went down to check I found that the charger had stopped after adding 70AH. It started right up again when I restarted it.<br><br>Any ideas?<br>Larry
|
Re: Sailing with Electric auxiliary
I've sailed so far without being able to rely on an engine, first the old Gray-marine gasoline, and now this old monster. I def. rely on my sails, but am not good (nor brave!) enough to try to enter my slip in the marina under sail. Can't afford to pay for the damages.<br>About cruising under 2-3 Kn. That's pretty common - I thought! And all I would ask for. But those shuold be with some good torque...<br>About writing the manual as we go...mine would mostly consist of ?-marks!<br>Good luck to you with your projects.<br>Kirsti.
|
Sailing with Electric auxiliary
Kirsti there are more steamers than sailors on these pages and the Freshwaterseas site says it all there. North America is very inclined (electrically) to that idyllic pursuit of tranquil lakes and trolling. No doubt you are as excited as i am that there are a few bigger units around capable of replacing internal combustion.<br>You can find my boat in my profile - a lot different to yours but similar power needs.<br>I am waiting for a final solution which includes re-charging as i sail because i have the sailpower/boatspeed. Until then i am fitting a pancake (disc) motor in my outboard as a retro as it's all i can afford and i'll use the bits later in a new system (probably first battery change)and sell off the surplus.<br>Getting out of the port is all i need and there's usually off-shore morning wind so 10-30 minutes power is adequate. If there was no wind at all then it would be 3 knots of speed and conserve the range. As the boat was always under-powered i will still put up with 2 kn boatspeed into a 35kn headwind when i cannot sit outside all nite.<br>I think 90% of us are like you and we are writing the manual ouselves as we speak....
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
Sorry about that my isp shut down just as I posted that message.So w'ell try again. <br><a href= target=new></a> hope that worked.
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
Hi Gary.<br>Couldn't find the mentioned link- please try to post it again.<br>kirsti
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
Hi Gary,<br><br>Just joined, but have been following this thread. Where's the link?
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
Kirsti you may find this link of interest as it contains pricing on a couple of systems and a few interesting links.As a bonus they are cheaper than the diesel.<br><br>g'luck
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
THANKS!<br>Kind of what I was hoping for: The possibility to buy the "pieces" (whatever they might be) as my economy would allow me. To me that looked like another HUGE benefit of going electric...the chunk of batteries one day, the motor another eehh...month, then the controller e.t.c. instead of forking out $7-10.000,- for a diesel, and:VOILA!<br>I've installed a diesel myself once, and still don't know how I had the guts to do it, but it went fine, was easy, and was only about a week of sleepless nights. I had by my side two 3" thick manuals, full of coffee-stains, but finally the thing turned over and RAN. Stupid me, I sold the boat!<br>So, here I am, having to do something similar to this "new" boat...but very different! Because I won't have those 3-inchers by my side to leaf tru when all the questions pop up.<br>I have realized, that I'll have to rely on somebody with electrical engineering experience. Darn!<br>I feel a littel bit like an easy mark.<br><br>Your advice is good, and looking back on 16 years of cruising, several years of those with old Gray-marine gasoline, halfway retired gasoline engine (that was the one that got retired in favor of a new Yanmar) I don't need much. It's a sailboat, and I'm in no hurry. I'll heave to if I can't make port in daylight. It's nice out there under the stars anyway! But I DO need some little thing-a-majobby to push me into my slip. And it WOULD be nice to know that I could flip a switch and pull away from that reef not charted!<br>Modest demands, I'd say.<br>What do you think?
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
"I do have problems understanding why an electric motor for a boat<br> should cost MORE than a diesel replacement!"<br><br>Not a bad question, Kirsti. It doesnt have to. Mine cost about 45% of the cost of a similarly sized diesel.<br><br>Its easy to define your "needs" so that only very expensive, limited production components can meet them. Youve self-defined a very expensive system. If you can define your "needs" to suit an already existing, mass-produced technology you can save lots. <br>Are some of the products and systems discussed on this list "better"? I dont know for sure, but I certainly suspect so. But I also believe the law of diminishing returns kicks in pretty rapidly: 10% "better" may cost 100% more, 30% "better" may cost 1000% more and that last little increment of "best" maybe only the government can afford. If you really NEED the little bit better, then you will simply have to pay the hefty premium. But often people confuse "desirable" with "necessary". <br><br>I just bought a 38lb thrust (I think that works out to about hp electricright?) electric outboard at Costco for $134.95. How can they do that? Answer: thousands of fishermen use these things and they are mass-produced.<br><br>36V golf cart components are quite cheap up into the 6-10 hp. range. So are the batteries and accessories that go with them. How come? Same reasonlots of people wanting to use the same product.<br><br>So my advice is to look hard at the existing, off-the-shelf technology and look hard at what you realistically demand from the system. A great many of us, I think, could function quite happily with systems that are a fraction of the cost of some of the more esoteric technologies and those systems are more easily serviced, more easily repaired and more easily replaced when the time comes.<br>Larry
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
OOOOps! I didn't mean to start a fight! I appreciate ALL input and help, in this new and exciting world (new to me, at least!) I do have problems understanding why an electric motor for a boat should cost MORE than a diesel replacement!<br>I would have thought there were all kind of financial help and suppeot available to developers of any device improving the environment? <br>You guys: Why not get together and post good links in this club to manufact. of motors, a page of evaluations, what ever would help in the research for the rest of us. Off course EWHEEL will will try to promote his product, but an open and positive discussion about available options would be more productive. All manuf. I have heard from are making "the best" on the market, and that leaves me more confused than ever! Right now my only way of choosing is counting my pennies and see what I can afford. Haven't even been able to decide if it should be inboard, or if I should make a well for an electric outboard! Or maybe I should just get a pair of OARS!<br>If anybody in this club have the knowledge, time and interest, I'd love to see a good evaluation of products, including the biggest secret: The price! That eval. could be the biggest promotion of electric drives for boats, something all of us are interested in.<br>It's a jungle out there, and I'm getting lost and discuraged!
|
Re: Lynch Super motor dialogue
At the risk of offending both ewhel and donaldbaer please remember that this dialectic or collision of ideas reveals advantages of both motors. Both ewhel and donaldbaer are correct. The insufficient words used to describe complex devices cannot convey adequately the advantages that both ewel and donaldbaer are really referring to. Some of us, your audience, need to see diagrams (can either of you provide these?) <br><br>I surmise that donaldbaer's totally enclosed motor is not completely sealed/pressurized but that it is vastly superior to regular motors that flow vast quantities of air over the armature or windings for cooling, and that it could be sealed up. I am particularly interested in doing this with submerged motors in my "electric log" boats, or by adding fins that contact the outer surface of the boat hull for cooling. At the same time, ewel's motor seems to be rather efficient and to require less cooling, as well as less moving parts for at least some function(s).<br><br>The market that we are watching develop is (will be) very complex and fractured. It is easy to believe that both motors are absolutely perfect in different areas of that market.
|
Re: Lynch Super motor...?
Donalbaer....get a grip on yerself man....Lynch motors do have to breath...and how much are the thrust bearings,thrust plate, belts, fans, pullys, and controls for that AC motor. And beyond that...has anyone called Hunter in Alachua, FL to ask how well AC motor systems did on Hunter's Child....and how much regeneration they collected. And learn how to spell man or at least cut back on the coffee yer gettin' too wound up. I did all my homework...that's why our motor is the "only" motor designed specifically for pushing props and the marine environment.
|
Re: has anyone used 100# thrust trolling
hi everyone . I was just wondering if anyone has any experience with the 100 pound plus trolling motors/outboards with larger displacement hulls.<br>my boat is an 80 year old 32 foot motor sailer that is very easily driven, currently it is over powered by an 18 hp diesel(1/2 throttle equals 8 knots).I would be keeping the diesel.regarding the thread on designs, the boat next to mine at the marina is 60 years newer in design 1 foot longer and requires its full 110 hp to reach 8 knots! things other than efficiently using available hp now take priority.not to mention the fact that most of the newer designs lack character.IMHO thanks Gary
|
Re: Lynch Super motor...?
You should do some research before you keep sticking you foot in you mouth. Your so busy plugginh your own product you don't bother to look around to see what other people are talking about. You stated that "has to breath that salt air to keep cool...and so does the AC motor."<br>The Stainless steel motor I refered to in my post is a TEFC that stand for totaly Enclosed fan colled. In case you not familiar with the terminology that means that AIR does not go into the motor on over the outside and sinze it all stainless steal gues what the salt air wont bother it. OH and buy the way a 5 HP 1750 RPM motor sells for less tha $700. ALso if an AC motor is oer driven it will regenerate.
|
Re: Lynch Super motor...?
Kirsti....sorry for the delay in response but I have been on the road....we are getting Coast Guard and Lloyds certifications and going public at the same time. I need your address or phone number to give you data as I have been reminded several times that I can't use this as a forum for advertising the Solomon motors. Email: ewhel@... and our phone number is 301-274-4479. We will send you a package. And when it's all said and done...you won't find a drop-in replacement with thrust bearings, controls, emeter and for less than our Solomon 35 motor. Oh and did I mention that no one in the world is providing more regenerative sailing energy than us.P.S. that Lynch motor has to breath that salt air to keep cool...and so does the AC motor.
|
If you are considering using AC motors you might want to look at the "Sterliseal" all stainless motors from Sterling Electric. They are made for wash down environments and are relativly inexpensive. Visit their web site at www.sterlingelectric.com. I am sure they have reps and distributors in your area. These will require a 230 VAC 3 pase power. If you have 230 3 Phase available you can the use any good ac Variable frequency controler which would control the speed and also provide reversing. At 230 Volts you would draw about 16 amps per motor. These controler cost about $1500 each. The advantage to this setup is you have a NO maintence motor. <br>As a side note, a company in San Diago (ISE research) is building a hybred electric garbage truck with a 300 HP AC motor for propulsion. They power the AC controler with a 100 KW Generator driven from a Natural Gas engine running at a constant speed. They also have batteries hooked into the controler so when they need more power the controler can draw it from the batteries. This type of Hybred design is becoming very popular in the EV field for extended range EV's. Several cars will be hitting the market this year with similar propulsion systems.<br><br>I hope this helps. <br><br>Don Baer
|
Re: Lynch Super motor...?
Thanks, Chris. <br>I went to the 4QD site and got overwhelmed!<br>Lots of information there.<br>I'll keep meandering on.....<br>Kirsti
|
Re: Lynch Super motor...?
Kirsti -<br>I considered purchasing a lynch motor a couple of years ago for a smaller solar electric boat, but the price was a bit too high for the high school project which was limited to 24 volts. Their specifications are very good, noting 87 - 93% max efficiency at voltages between 12 and 48. Their web site and literature has great charts and much info on electric boat conversions. <br><br>I'm on my third electric boat project and all three have been inboards with cog belt drive and series-wound dc motors. The first used a surplus Thermo King refrigeration motor with an industrial (not marine!) Leeson PWM motor controller. The last two have used Advanced DC motors with Curtis PWM speed controllers and Albright system and reversing contactors (relays). The Advanced motors were chosen for budget reasons. The Curtis controllers are rugged units, sealed in a watertight aluminum heatsink case. They're used in a lot of electric vehicle conversions. System on/off is usually controlled via a 12v coil contactor and a 12v coil reversing contactor. Albright is a typical manufacturer, and they make "marinized" models. These relays are not cheap - expect to pay $75-150 for the main contactor and $150 - 225 for the reversing unit, depending on system amperage. You have to use them because the Curtis controller isn't designed as a full h-bridge (reversing) controller.<br><br>With all this said, the ~$1200 Lynch motor claims much higher peak efficiency than an Advanced DC motor in the 36-48 volt range (92% vs 85%)and the Lynch's efficiency curve is very flat through most of it's RPM range. The Lynch motor weighs about 28# vs the 50-60# of most series wound motors w/ similar specs. I'd explore using a $QD brand speed controller - They are British w/ US reps, and their top model controllers have solid-state revers built into their design. They also have a number of standard safety features like acceleration/deceleration ramping linked to reverse. If you throw the motor into reverse at full speed, you won't fry the controller. Instead the motor will decel rapidly, reverse kicks in, then accel starts. 4QD has worked with Lynch in Europe on boat and go-kart projects. They also have this nifty weather resistant control box with an umbilical you can carry in your hand for on-off, speed pot, reverse, etc.<br><br>Good luck on your project...<br><br>Chris Krumm<br>krumly@...
|