Just reviewing comments beginning to end. MK's EM series are intriguing. Hopefully you can give us an update as to how they perform a year later?? The EP series (designed for main propulsion of pontoon boats, although I don't understand how that differs from other "day in day out" use) is also interesting, but the MKota catalog doesn't detail the inherent differences. And finally, does anyone have experience with prop selection in the off-the-shelf electric outboards??
|
Re: I Like this design...
The leisure style boats are cool. I personnally like their style and was contemplating getting one, but the cost for one is more than I personally would pay for one, except for their bass boats. But overall, I feel this is type of boat that would benefit from the use of the electric motor that you are wanting to use on it.<br>The boat has a very stable platform and the seating is very comfotable, perfect fishing, leisure style boat. The only thing I see that would ber a problem would be the transom mount as thier is none on this boat, although someone could manufature something or another to mount on the boat.Good luck let us know what you find or do.
|
Does the motorplate mention the ampere draw? Multipy this by 36 to get kW (and hence horsepower). <br><br>15 mph in a john boat. That means it will have to plane. The problem with electrics and planing boats is getting enough power while keeping weight down. Planing boats go from plowing through the water to planing over the top, they never glide (which of course is economical). <br><br>I'm not going to say a 15 mph chase boat using a 12' john boat is out of the question, but I'd make sure I could return all those batteries if it doesn't work out!
|
Hi,<br>I am new to this list, but am part of another list that is somewhat related, the EV discussion list. I have just finished converting a honda civic to electric power, and am thinking of doing a boat next. I am in a rowing club that rows on the petaluma river in CA and is in need of a boat. The boat would be used by our instructor (and by me to muck around in :) to instruct us as we row. I already have a small boat that I would like to use, although I am not sure it will work as it probably doesn't glide through the water as well as might be necessary. The boat is an 11.5 foot long gamefisher. It is a flat front aluminum boat with a 5 horse max rating. This boat would need to be able to go at least 15 mph for about 45 minutes. Is this a reasonable expectation? I would like to just convert a gas outboard, but I could go with a more efficient drive system if needed. I also have a "mystery motor" that I would like to use. I don't know what it is, but it is rated for 36 volts, 4500 rpm, is about 5 inches in diameter and about 10 inches long with some pretty heavy duty brushes. <br>Any feedback would be greatly appriciated.<br>Thanks,<br>Thomas
|
I think I found what I am looking for in a small electric fishing boat. You can see it at:<br><br><a href= target=new></a><br><br>I am not interested in the rails, motor, or chairs and consoles, but I like the design of the hull. I am trying to see if I cna purchase just a hull and maybe the top deck. If not, I will probably just make a mold similar to this design...<br><br>What do you guys think....?
|
For an interesting article about early semidisplacement hull design, much of which can be apppied to electric boats, check out this article from the "Rudder" magazine. <a href= target=new></a>
|
Re: Good looking semi-displacement hull
When considering a hull for electric, keep in mind that early power boat designers faced the same problems that EB designers face now--low power and high weight. The Handy Billy is based on a William Hand design from 1912 and would indeed make a nice electric boat--other designs to look at are the boats from William and John Atkin, the plans for which were published in MotorBoating Magazine during the 1930-50s, maybe even earlier. Just because a design is old, don't dismiss it for being outdated and irrelevent--I'll take the practical experience and common sense of those early designers over a computer program anyday.
|
Good looking semi-displacement hull
The current WoodenBoat magazine cover story is about the 21' Handy Billy. It is a semi-displacement hull, a very efficient form. Semi displacements have a higher operating speed range than displacements and are still energy efficient. They don't have the 'power hump' associated with planing boats. Semi's will slowly come up to skimming, and if enough power, planing. This one looks like a good hull shape for someone interested in a medium size, moderately fast electric. Although it would move along nicely with 2Hp, the Lynch motor would really make it scoot around. The hull is shown planked, but the form would be easy to make in stich 'n glue plywood. Take a look!
|
Re: Small Fantail Hull available
Yes Jim builds efficient and beautiful boats and hangs out like JulieAndrews on her HighonaHill meadow, he's in Colorado: JThayer, Rt1 Box 75, Collbran, CO 81624
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
Marvin, I took a look at patent 6,138,602. Interesting shape, the forward half reminds me of a Boston Whaler or cathedral hull. The after portion is very interesting it is a negative deadrise! An upside down vee hull. This boat is a planing boat, probably not what he's looking for.
|
Small Fantail Hull available
Jim Thayer Who is alergic to email makes 2 diferent Glass fiber Hulls, The 16' Victoria Hull pictured in steam trim here <a href= target=new></a> is as I recall is about $1200 the much larger 19' Mountain Gal Hull is about $3600. If people are interested I will dig up his snail mail address.<br><br>Matt
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
Hey mmotsenbocker,<br><br>What you propose sounds interesting. I do have some knowledge of desiging efficient hulls, but no where near the level of the person that you describe. I am not quite sure how well ship design would scale down to a little 17' fishing boat.<br><br>I just want a stable fishing boat that will run about 10mph for say 30-50 miles... <br><br>Making a mold is not all that hard or expensive, but it is extreamly time consuming and messy ( lots of sanding and polishing ) Simple shapes with gentel curves tend to make the most efficient designs.
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
Hey webcrawler:<br>If you have the wherewithall to mold any shape you need, there are some very good designs out there (see U.S. Patent NO. 6,138,602 for example). If you are thinking about putting an outboard in the middle, why not let an accomplished former navy boat designer who has pushed the envelope already design a fast, more efficient boat for free? Eugene Clements has the knowledge and is willing to (or was, the last time I talked to him) help you. Eugene was looking for someone like you and had contacted people in the solar splash competitions who also need his help. Let me know if you would like to pursue this. Marvin
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
That is what I have found....<br><br>I can get a stable ( inefficient boat ) or a Efficient boat that is not very stable.<br><br>I am seriously thinking about making a mold for my boat. ( My dad is a 38 year retired composists specialist from Lockheed )<br><br>What do you guys think about dimentions. I was thinking about 17' with about a 90" beam. Each side of the catamaran design would be approx 2' to 3' wide to provide stability.<br><br>Best way to think about the design would be two 17' Canoes with a platform between the two and the outboard in the center. I would of course adjust the shape of the hulls as nesessary. I would not make the hulls symetrical to reduce the bow wave collision in the center of the boat which would cause significant drag. I guess it would look more like a tunnel hull with a rectuangler tunnel down the middle.<br><br>I have never seen a large bass boat made this way before, but it should be fairly stable and offer much better efficiency...I do see a lot of small 8'-10' two man crafts made this way....They are basically two pontoons with two chairs connecting them together. Not exactly what I am going for...<br><br>Any thoughts or comments will be most welcome...
|
Please ignore the last posting
After posting # 907, I read all of the previous postings and found most of my answers. I'll cogitate on the good information already available rather than troubling people to repeat it, but I may come back to you if I'm still stumped!
|
Motor sizing and other neophyte ??
I'm thinking about converting an old 14' cedar lapstrake keeled dory to electric. It already has an inboard gas engine (11hp) swinging a 12' prop (I don't know the pitch). That's more power than it needs, I think. I wrote to EVAA, and they estimated I needed a 2HP motor to push this at 5 knots, assuming it weighs about 1000 lb fully loaded. I then spoke with Budsin boats, who make a fiberglass boat similar to mine and power it with a 1/2 to 3/4 hp motor. Before I buy a motor, any thoughts about whether I can get by with a motor smaller than 2HP?<br><br>Second question is whether people doing this type of conversion typically use one of the new solid state controllers, or an old Curtis controller. I don't really need infinite speed variation -- 2 or 3 speeds would be fine. On the other hand, I'm concerned that the old-type controllers could get hot -- not a good idea in a cedar boat!<br><br>Any advice would be appreciated.
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
You don't have terrific choices. The best hull is a displacement boat designed for power, but these aren't made much anymore.<br><br>Jon Boats and other powerboats are a poor choice because they are planing boats. (Chopping off the stern adds about 30% drag to a boat.) <br><br>Sailboats make poor cruising boats because sailboats are designed to have poor initial stability, and high ultimate stability. You will find them 'tippy' when the beam is level.
|
Re: Looking for a Small boat
Webcrawler,<br> There are alumin flat bottom boats I can't remember if it was made by sea ark or by nova, or if it was some other company. They were designed if I remember for jet boat motors. <br> There are numerous options available. I used to have a sailboat that i converted into a fishing boat using an electic trolling motor. It was pretty nifty as it almost planned on the water, and it was fairly light weight. Two people could pick it up easily and load it into the back of my pickup truck.<br> Go to a local boat show and you'll see countless designs that will probably fit your budget, in the type of boat you want. Good Luck in your quest for your boat.
|
I am still trying to figure out what I want to try my new electric motor on. Do any of you guys have any ideas of a small boat to try it on???<br><br>I really do not want a John boat, I was thinking about a small glass boat that I could do some modifications to the transom to improve low speed efficiency. I guess I could modify a john boat, but the metal work would probably be extensive.<br><br>I saw a pic of an old Tunnel Hull HydroSport that looked interesting. Have any of you guys ever seen one?<br><br>I still think a catamaran type of boat about 16'-17' would be ideal. Do you guys think an old sail boat could be converted into a bass fishing platform???<br><br>Any other ideas????
|
Re: 34' heavy cutter, conversion in prog
Welcome Dave. I think you will have much to contribute to the club. There are a number of members who are involved in conversions of larger boats. No doubt you will hear from them.<br>Paul
|