MotorGuide makes a 2 speed 22lb thrust for about $80 that would propel your canoe at a top speed of 3.5-4MPH. I have devised a detachable rudder/electric motor arrangement for canoes that's both attractive and functional elimating the need for an ackward side mount. Contact me if interested or if I can be of further help. Terry
|
Does anyone have knowledge of Where, When, How, etc. of electric boat races here in the US? This is something I'd like to get into, but am having trouble finding out information on schedules, class requirements, etc. Terry
|
Re: Is there any hope for sailboats over
I hae recently found information on a new type of motor, the "electric wheel". It is sold by Solomon technologies, David Tether, 301-274-4479.<br>It is designed so that it will regenerate the batteries by letting the prop turn while sailing. It sounds like it could be just the ticket for the cruising sailboat. This unit with a solar panel should not need any outside charging. If your electricity usage is high, you may need to add a wind generator as well. But, it sound like you could go without any type of fossel fuel powered generator to keep your batteries up. Has anyone else heard about this?
|
Terry: In the recent past, there was some high-speed racing in the Northwest U.S. with boats reaching speeds in excess of 70 mph. I dont think they're doing it anymore. Each year, Solar Splash, an activity for college students, has races at Minneapolis. They do short sprints and some timed distance racing. The boats are specially built by the students and competition is limited to them. The Electric Boat Association of the Americas has tried some racing, but since the boats were usually very different, there was no way to conduct a fair competition. Usually, you could calculate who the winner would be before they left the dock. The practical solution, then, would be to come up with a one-design boat which individuals could build to strict specifications. Then racing would have more to do with seamanship and skill than with battery size and number, prop size, hull design, etc. etc.<br>I'm sure the group would like to hear your comments on this.
|
Re: Is there any hope for sailboats over
Bill: I have talked with Dave Tether about the electric wheel, and I am impressed by what he says. The Electric Boat Journal ran an article about it last year based on information provided by Tether. It's certainly worth a close look.
|
kenmatthews - Maybe what the electric boat industry needs more than racing events is some sort of periodic expo where like-minded individuals could exchange ideas and show off their own inventions. Speed is not what electric boating is all about anyway. Or am I so naive about the subject and this is already going on?
|
Re: Is there any hope for sailboats over
Ken:<br><br>Is it possible to get the old issues of the Electric Boat Journal? BTW I have sent you an application to join the EBAA, you should be getting it soon.<br><br>Bill
|
Has anyone done any experimenting on battery recharging using a system other than solar or a gas engine hooked up to an alternator? When a kid in the 50's I had a small generator that attached to the frame of my bike and turned by rubbing against my front tire producing electricity to power my headlight. It seems to me, something like that could be rigged up to recharge a battery much like that of an alternator on an auto???????? Terry
|
I am far from an expert, but the only motor that I have found that would regenerate, that is recharge the batteries as the prop turns due to sail power moving the boat, is the Electric Wheel by Solomon Technologies. The only caveat is that it will only regen at a speed of 4MPH or greater. But this is readily attainable in pretty much any sailboat with a decent wind.
|
Thank you, Bill, I'll look into it. I assume this is the same Electric Wheel that's been mentioned several times here recently. Haven't had time to read everything. Don't happen to have an address or website to go along with this information, do you? Terry
|
Phone# for Solomon Technologies is 301-274-4479. Speak with Dave Tether
|
1) I'm expecting some material,prices etc. for the electric wheel, hopefully soon. I have spoken with someone, who actually took a trip with the owner on his sailboat, outfitted with the motor. He got so impressed, that he decided to invest in the comp!<br>The sailboat used for the trial run was 30-32' old (and=heavy), and the reports was rather impressive. Lots of details missing : how much battery storage, price, etc. <br>I'll be back when I know some more details.<br>2) recharging of batteries, I know of several options, apart from the old umbilical cord:shorepower: Solar, Wind, and at least one windgenerator manuf. AMPAIR, also makes a dynamo outfitted with a propeller that is either towed behind the sailing boat, or transom mounted. Can be found somewhere under renewable energy on the web. I don't know how effective this is, but have heard stories about how sharks go for them...<br>I remember well, how much drag on the bicycle these small dynamolights put on, and how little light came out of them. Technology should have improved a bit since our childhood!<br>3) I've seen pictures of a boat w. el-motor, but in that particular case the motor was connected to the shaft via a belt. To me this seems a little flimsy, and I don't like the sidewards pull on the shaft. Even if triple-pulley is used (if one belt breaks, maybe the other two will hold...)it still leaves the problem w. the sidewards pull. The biggest advantage I see with this system is, that you can get the motor above spray and bilgewater-sludge...
|
Electric propulsion for 18-20' boat
Greetings! I have some questions that I'm hoping some of you might be able to answer.<br>My intent is to use one or two submersible electric motors, e.g., Minn Kota RT 70, 24V, to propel a smaller boat that will have ample room for two people and two large dogs. There are ready-built displacement hull launches available, but they are "pricey" and the layout is not ideal for our situation. I'm considering an aluminum fishing boat with a planing hull (e.g., a Lund) as these have the entirely open layout that I desire with high freeboard and lots of room for the sea dogs.<br>I understand the loss of efficiency compared to a displacement hull compounded by the fact that electric motors are a bit under powered. Does this make the idea unworkable? Does weight play a factor? The aluminum runabout would not weigh nearly as much as the fiberglass launch.<br>I need to consider initial cost vs. usability. I can carry extra batteries for cruises of six to eight hours if necessary. Another possibility is the "expedition" type canoe of long ago. The hull would work better, but I also need stability as there is coastal cruising (New England, primarily CT and RI) involved.<br>Speed is not critical -- the boat will obviously not plane with electric propulsion. Am I loony or this idea worth looking into? I would appreciate any comments, from anyone who has done anything even remotely similar or anyone who has any suggestions. Thanks!<br><br>Doug<br>taliesin@...
|
I guess this message is primarily aimed toward those members who are builders or experimenters, but anyone interested can enter into the conversation or possible events. <br>I've been encouraged by a staff member of the IEB to research the feasibility of having events whereby builders and other interested parties could show-off their latest innovations in electrical boat propulsion. Not racing, since speed is not really what electric boating is all about, but some sort of competition to make the events interesting and fun. Ideas,comments?????
|
Doug,<br><br>I'd look into sailboat hulls,particularly catboats,as they are extremely wide for their length and are true displacement hulls. In the size you're after, I'd suggest a Marshall Saunderling. Try www.catboats.org..... a classified listing.<br><br>Maybe you'd better not mention your plans! Some sailors are "anti powerboat"!!!!!!!!!<br><br>Good luck..........Frank
|
Re: Electric Regattas in the NE
Do you have any idea about how much electric boat info will be a the St. Michaels get-together? <br><br>Do you think there will be an inwater display?<br><br>My electric boat I discribed in message#20 is about ready for display. It is running nicely now. I am running at 4 knots (1/2 power) for about 8-10 hours and 5.5 knots (full power) for 3-4 hours. It handles great and rides very well. <br><br>Hope to see you in St. Michaels.
|
Re: Electric Regattas in the NE
It looks as though there will be at least six electric boats on display -- in and out of the water -- at St. Michaels.<br>A workshop on electric boats will be held on Oct. 2 at 10 a.m. Many of the most knowledgeable EBAA members will be there, four of them on the panel leading the discussion.<br>There will be plenty of time for everybody to talk about his or her own particular interest during the three days of the event.<br>I hope you can come and bring your boat.<br>You can pre-register with the Chesapeake Bay Maritime Museum (c/o John Ford) at 410-754-2916.<br><br>Hope this helps.<br><br>Ken Matthews
|
I am impressed!<br>The prices of electric motors are something else....<br>If I'm going to get one (and I'd love to....) I'd expect it to at least be competitive with a new diesel.<br>Not so!<br>Anybody have any suggestions on sites/companies?<br>To me a price over $8,000.- for just motor and controller is rediculous.<br>Then comes batteries, charging,installation, etc.etc.<br>hope to get some hints.......
|
Try EV america , talk to Bob. EVAmerica@....<br><br>Yoe didn't say whom you got that price from, but i would guess that it was Elco. They don't seem to think that ther is any other compition out there. EV America is primarily an electric car group but they also do boats. Have you gotten a price from Solomon technolgies? If their price seem high remember that this is brand new technologies, and with the recharge capablities extras such as generators are not needed at all or a much smaller one can be used. This will save quite a bit of money. Also, fuel is a constant expense. And finally, I don't know why you what to go electic, but for me it is a quality, reliblity, and packaging issue, not a price one. Hey, all you lurkers out there what do you all think?<br><br>Bill
|
I would add KTA Services to the list of places to check: (909) 949-7914.<br><br>I recently purchased all the propulsion system components, except batteries and charger, for my 23' fantail from them. The cost was just over $2200 and that included LOTS more than just the motor and the controller--right down to the cabling and crimping tools, and the connectors.<br><br>I did find that the more power your application requires, the more specialized (and the more expensive) everything becomes. A 38' boat is BIG.<br><br>One other general point--you have to keep in mind that once those batteries are installed you not only have a major portion of your propulsion system but a major portion of your operating costs as well. You can recharge the batteries at a fraction of the cost of pumping $1.50/gal diesel into those tanks after each outing.
|