Aaron,?

I'm not sure of your interest in this haplogroup, but we now know that I-A5716 is not downstream of I-Z58.

Instead it is directly downstream of I-DF29.

If you manage a kit that is either confirmed A5716+ or A5734+ or matches kits who have a haplogroup like this, please join our haplogroup project at

?

Vince Vizachero

I am the founder of that group at FTDNA, but have not been involved for years. Thanks for your note. That progression is from the site I cited.

?

Aaron

I meant that I am the founder of the haplogroup I1 project at FTDNA. I will join your subgroup. I cannot remember precisely where these matches came from. I think it was the Johnson/Johnston/Johnstone project at FTDNA.

It’d be nice to have a Hill upgrade to Big Y at some point, but there’s no doubt which part of the I-A5716 tree they belong to.

I have done my entire genome. Will see if I can get the data.