Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
Search
Fan noise in 2445B
raymonddompfrank
Hi,
The following has been sort of haunting me for a while: When I switch on my 2445B, the fan starts running at a low speed and is barely audible. After a while, it increases its speed to what I consider its maximum. It is quite audible by then. At the same time, I detect no air flow. Using a piece of tissue as an airflow detector I can't "prove" there's any air flow, apart from the fan's location at the back. Inside the 'scope, nothing is impeding the air flow. This seems independent of ambient temperature, which varies between 18C and 25C. The fact that I can't detect an airflow as such does't give me much concern, since often it's just a little "moving air" that's enough but i'd like to know if this is normal behaviour. Can anyone of you confirm that it is normal for these 'scopes' (24x5y's) fans to be running at or close to maximum speed under normal operating conditions? FYI, I'd like to add that I'm sure it's not noisy bearings or anything like that. AAMOF, my TDS420 is even noisier, having a much larger fan as well. My 465B isn't anywhere near as noisy, let alone my 7904 (which has no fan). I'd appreciate to hear about anybody else's experiences. Raymond |
Hi Raymond,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I own a 2465A and 2467. At least with those models, there is only one fan speed as there is no thermostatic control. I do not think the fans are very noisy and the amount of air flow is not tremendous. I suggest that you remove the rear plastic cover and measure the voltage from the feedthrough capacitor located in the upper left corner (when viewing the rear) to ground. Note that the fan receives DC power via that capacitor. You should find this voltage is constant. If you agree that the voltage is constant, yet the fan speed varies, then the fan needs help (perhaps cleaning) or replacement. Good luck, Patrick Wong AK6C --- In TekScopes@..., "raymonddompfrank" <r.domp.frank@...> wrote:
|
raymonddompfrank
Hello Bob and Patrick,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Of course, what I really should have asked is if I should be worried about the internal temperature because the fan seems to run at full speed all the time and still there's no obvious airflow (detectable outside), although there's no obstruction. I have measured the voltage at the red feedthrough capacitor as around 12VDC. From your comments, I tend to conclude that there's no need to worry. While calibrating the 'scope a few weeks ago, I had an external fan blowing air over the hybrids in very low volume at a very low speed, hardly more than a draft. It was enough to keep all hybrids almost as cool as the environment, whereas e.g. U600 heats up to at least 50C (untouchable) in still air. So, together with your comments, I've answered my own question I guess. Thanks again for your input! Raymond --- In TekScopes@..., "Patrick Wong" <patwong3@...> wrote:
|
Hi Raymond,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
The fan in my scopes is a Nidec, TA300DC model which operates at 12VDC. As you are measuring 12V to the fan, the fan should be running at normal speed and I would say there is no need for concern. Referring to the low voltage PS circuit diagram #9 in my repair manual, the fan circuit is in the upper right corner. I see +15V unregulated voltage feeding a LM317T three-terminal regulator. The voltage adjustment circuit includes RT1110 which is a 5K ohm negative temp coefficient resistor. Hence, the fan voltage should increase as RT1110 heats up. Thanks to Bob for pointing out the presence of that. Patrick Wong AK6C --- In TekScopes@..., "raymonddompfrank" <r.domp.frank@...> wrote:
|
Hi Raymond,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
To provide you with another reference: I measured the fan voltage on my 2465A from a cold start: 7.5V initially. I ran the scope for 20-30 minutes, measuring low voltage power supply ripple. At the end of that process the fan voltage was 9V and the fan remained fairly quiet. My TDS 3032 fan makes more noise (if that means anything to you.) I don't know if your scope is behaving normally or if mine is. I've run the scope for hours with the cabinet on, and no overheating is apparent so it seems that the fan is adequate. I haven't measured the fan voltage on my 2467 but subjectively I would say that both fans are running at around the same speed and producing similar noise. Perhaps the thermistor in your unit is changing its resistance at a faster rate given a certain temperature change. In any event, if your fan is running at full speed I suppose that can't hurt. Patrick Wong AK6C --- In TekScopes@..., "raymonddompfrank" <r.domp.frank@...> wrote:
|
raymonddompfrank
Hi Patrick,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Thanks for this valuable extra information. Do you know where the thermistor is located (in your 2465A)? Raymond --- In TekScopes@..., "Patrick Wong" <patwong3@...> wrote:
|
Hi Raymond,
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
RT1110 is located below T1060 on the A3 Inverter Board which is part of the low voltage power supply. This is probably the same for your unit and all other 24xx analog scopes since they all share a similar LV power supply. Patrick Wong AK6C --- In TekScopes@..., "raymonddompfrank" <r.domp.frank@...> wrote:
|
raymonddompfrank
Thanks, Patrick, for looking this up for me. From what I remember when I last opened my 'scope, I think my fan is the same as yours. I intend to check if the thermistor actually does get warm enough to explain the fan's behaviour. If not, the explanation that you gave earlier is probably correct and I shouldn't worry.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Raymond --- In TekScopes@..., "Patrick Wong" <patwong3@...> wrote:
|
to navigate to use esc to dismiss