At the end of OotP.

Did the Death Eaters caught in the MoM go through a trial? I don't
remember reading about any trial and I want to make sure of it.

- Bob

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...> wrote:

At the end of OotP.

Did the Death Eaters caught in the MoM go through a trial? I don't
remember reading about any trial and I want to make sure of it.

- Bob

It wasn't mentioned. If they did, this information either never came
to Harry or wasn't important enough to him for the autor to mention
it. In HBP I think Lucius was still in jail, but there was no mention
of a trial there either. Given the Shunpike situation, I'd suspect
the Ministry has reverted to imprisonment without trial again.

Dorothy

--- In snorkack@..., "Dorothy McComb" <dmccomb1958@y...>
wrote:

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...>

wrote:

At the end of OotP.

Did the Death Eaters caught in the MoM go through a trial? I

don't

remember reading about any trial and I want to make sure of it.

- Bob

It wasn't mentioned. If they did, this information either never

came

to Harry or wasn't important enough to him for the autor to mention
it. In HBP I think Lucius was still in jail, but there was no

mention

of a trial there either. Given the Shunpike situation, I'd suspect
the Ministry has reverted to imprisonment without trial again.

Dorothy

Thanks. I thought that was the case. :)

- Bob

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...> wrote:

Thanks. I thought that was the case. :)

- Bob

Of course with the DEs offing Amelia Bones that could have postponed
any trials that were going to take place...

--- In snorkack@..., "mjc" <cashman_26250@y...> wrote:

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...>

wrote:

Thanks. I thought that was the case. :)

- Bob

Of course with the DEs offing Amelia Bones that could have postponed
any trials that were going to take place...

Nope. As far as this fic is concerned, book six doesn't exist.

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...> wrote:

As far as this fic is concerned, book six doesn't exist. <

Would that it were the case in reality... at least, from a ficwriter's
PoV. HBP has _so_ limited the scope of possible plots if canon is to be
adhered to. Shame.

Phil, who has at least 3 WIPs (some published, some not) that HBP has
forced into AUs, and is slightly annoyed by it.

--- Phil <tarkas1956@...> wrote:

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357"
<submitaccount@y...> wrote:

As far as this fic is concerned, book six doesn't

exist. <

HBP has _so_ limited the scope of possible
plots if canon is to be
adhered to. Shame.

Phil, who has at least 3 WIPs (some published, some
not) that HBP has
forced into AUs, and is slightly annoyed by it.

I agree. I mean, the only valid plots that could be
easily continued are those focused on the romance and
less on the actual action. And Harry goes horcrux
shopping > kills horcruxes > gets together with Ginny

kills voldemort is a boring plotline already.

Crs, who is so annoyed that he has started his own
alternative to canon, starting with first year.


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around

Nothing is mentioned in the book, as far as I remember.

--- In snorkack@..., "Phil" <tarkas1956@n...> wrote:

--- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...>

wrote:

As far as this fic is concerned, book six doesn't exist. <

Would that it were the case in reality... at least, from a

ficwriter's

PoV. HBP has _so_ limited the scope of possible plots if canon is to

be

adhered to. Shame.

Phil, who has at least 3 WIPs (some published, some not) that HBP has
forced into AUs, and is slightly annoyed by it.

That is exactly why I won't write a post HBP fic. It's far too
limiting.

Why be annoyed about your story being AU? We knew Sunset would be AU
from the moment the first word was put into a word processor file. Its
sequel will be even more AU. Our first two stories are totally AU now
thanks to HBP. And personally I think our stories are better than HBP
but thats beside the point. :)

- Bob

开云体育

I have no problem with AU. In fact, by definiton, fanfiction is AU.
The story I am writing, "Stranger in a strange land" set out from the
begining to be AU, as I doubt JKR would ever write in Sirius's return,
the explorer corps, and the conquest of earth by an invading fleet,
with Harry Potter at the helm and Weasely the tactician plotting it.

--- In snorkack@..., "Keith McComb" <kinsfire@g...> wrote:

I've always looked at any story I write as being AU the moment the

first word of the story makes it to the page, be it electronic or
paper. I am not going to write the story that another writes, and I'm
certainly not going to write at JKR's level. (Personal opinion is
that I'd be writing DOWN to her level after HBP, but that's just a
very dissatisfied reader talking.)

Keith

Wilner's Observation:

All conversations with a potato should be conducted in private.

----- Original Message -----
From: bobmi357
To: snorkack@...
Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2005 5:30 PM
Subject: [snorkack] Re: Quick Question for the canon fanatics out

there.

--- In snorkack@..., "Phil" <tarkas1956@n...> wrote:
> --- In snorkack@..., "bobmi357" <submitaccount@y...>
wrote:
> > As far as this fic is concerned, book six doesn't exist. <
>
> Would that it were the case in reality... at least, from a
ficwriter's
> PoV. HBP has _so_ limited the scope of possible plots if canon

is to

be
> adhered to. Shame.
>
> Phil, who has at least 3 WIPs (some published, some not) that

HBP has

> forced into AUs, and is slightly annoyed by it.

That is exactly why I won't write a post HBP fic. It's far too
limiting.

Why be annoyed about your story being AU? We knew Sunset would be AU
from the moment the first word was put into a word processor file.

Its

sequel will be even more AU. Our first two stories are totally AU now
thanks to HBP. And personally I think our stories are better than HBP
but thats beside the point. :)

- Bob

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS

a.. Visit your group "snorkack" on the web.

b.. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
snorkack-unsubscribe@...

c.. Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of

Service.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--- In snorkack@..., "magyareagle" <magyareagle@y...>
wrote:

I have no problem with AU. In fact, by definiton, fanfiction is AU.
The story I am writing, "Stranger in a strange land" set out from the
begining to be AU, as I doubt JKR would ever write in Sirius's

return,

the explorer corps, and the conquest of earth by an invading fleet,
with Harry Potter at the helm and Weasely the tactician plotting it.

If this story is not already posted somewhere, you must tell us
*IMMEDIATELY* when it is!

Dorothy

It already was posted in fanfiction.net Currently the first two
chapters are up and Chapter 3 should be up within a week or two. I
have the entire story plotted out already. The link is


Thanks for the interest!

Balint Szoke

--- In snorkack@..., "Dorothy McComb" <dmccomb1958@y...>
wrote:

--- In snorkack@..., "magyareagle" <magyareagle@y...>
wrote:

I have no problem with AU. In fact, by definiton, fanfiction is AU.
The story I am writing, "Stranger in a strange land" set out from the
begining to be AU, as I doubt JKR would ever write in Sirius's

return,

the explorer corps, and the conquest of earth by an invading fleet,
with Harry Potter at the helm and Weasely the tactician plotting it.

If this story is not already posted somewhere, you must tell us
*IMMEDIATELY* when it is!

Dorothy

--- In snorkack@..., "magyareagle" <magyareagle@y...> wrote:

It already was posted in fanfiction.net Currently the first two
chapters are up and Chapter 3 should be up within a week or two. I
have the entire story plotted out already. The link is


Thanks for the interest!

Balint Szoke

Ooh, goody! *scampers off to read*

Dorothy (who is always looking for stories with concepts that haven't
been done to death already)