Keyboard Shortcuts
Likes
- S-Scale
- Messages
Search
Re: A Rose by Any Other Name . . .
National Allergy Strategy Group
North American Stamping Group The NASG is a simple, neoprene and Velcro first-aid device that looks like the bottom half of a wetsuit, cut into segments. It is used to treat shock, resuscitate, stabilize and prevent further bleeding in women with obstetric hemorrhage. |
|
I missed that email
开云体育I have mostly pulled back from engaging the “other scales” about S. They are almost definitely not going to change. I currently have 214 locos 860 freight cars and 160 passenger cars. I missed the email that there is “nothing made in S Scale”. ? People find me once every year+ that are about to cross over I just seal the deal. Those are the people I spend the time with. ? Thank You, ? See my layout progress at:
? |
|
Re: NWSL J&L Tank
Bill,? It was standard practice to "white wash" equipment in order to knock the shine off and enhance the display of the details. With steam engines it was more of a matt spray. With freight equipment it was more of a grey color. When the B&O rolled out their wagon top series of cars for display they were painted in a grey color with black lettering. The display included included their caboose, cement hopper & box car. After the cars were removed from their display they were all painted into in-service colors with the proper in-service lettering.? Mike (Ohio) |
|
NWSL J&L Tank
开云体育Did anyone ever consider the J&L Tank builders photo that truly everyone has used forever was reversed for black and white? ? Thank You, ? See my layout progress at:
? |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
开云体育From:?Mike Swederska For "the greatest thing" I would fall back on the Goldilocks principle that O is too big, HO is too small, but S is just right.? In defense of this, Ed Packard of C-D gave a clinic at the 1987 NASG convention at which he said he settled on 3/16” scale in the late 1930s because models “felt right” when held in a boy's hand. In the vendor room he had a table of leftover wooden parts for sale.? Today his??continues in business, selling plans for model airplanes. There is no mention of its model railroad impact. --? Bill Roberts, Receiver San Antonio &?Aransas Pass Railway?Co. * * * Timetable Notes?(selected) * * * a Slight delay due to?unavoidable?conditions ? Stops to discharge?passengers of funeral?parties g Mail box on station?platform j Does not stop in?months lacking letter?"r" m Stops on flag daily?except Monday p Bees?in station t Pauses crossing?Colorado River during?bluebonnet season w If Skidmore agent has cleaned the men’s restroom, Train 41 engineer stops to shave. Add 11 minutes. y Conductor doesn't?like to leave without?at least one passenger |
|
Re: NWSL J&L Tank, Another Question
jjmannmmr
Circus City I have 15 of these J&L tank cars and need white decals instead of the black or green Champ decals |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
开云体育I think Michael hit the nail on the head. This is exactly why I returned to S Scale, ease of building models and putting a few scenes on a layout in my rather small space. It makes since to seek out other modelers that will more easily see the advantages of S scale as a builders scale. Rather then to some how entice another three thousand modelers into the scale who want modern stuff and will therefor attract manufactures to build it. I do think P48 is on the cutting edge of building models, however it takes a lot of space to build a scene. If you want to have a realistic scene in a reasonable space for your built models to be displayed, S Scale is a great choice. The builders have been the history of S and they are also the future. Ian McKinley On 6/21/2024 11:17 AM, Michael Eldridge
wrote:
On Thu, Jun 20, 2024 at 05:43 PM, Ed Loizeaux wrote: |
|
WTB: SHS Caboose Trucks
开云体育
I recently bought a caboose where someone had replaced the original trucks with SHS roller bearings, so I'd prefer to use proper SHS caboose trucks.? I thought I had a spare pair, but all I seem to have is AM caboose trucks.? SHS trucks can be AF flanges, as
I do still?
have scale wheelset replacements.
If someone has a spare pair, I'll buy them or perhaps swap if I have something someone else wants.
Jace Kahn
|
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
Jamie,? I saw your presentation on YouTube yesterday. I learned about some S passenger car stuff I didn't know existed, even if most of it was too modern for me. Previously, I used to watch while usually doing some other modeling stuff, but I have another commitment?on Wednesday evening, so I have to watch anything I want to see later. Dave Heine
|
|
Painted undecorated S-Helper cars for sale
|
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
On Thu, Jun 20, 2024 at 05:43 PM, Ed Loizeaux wrote:
And so, without fanfare, here is what the HO guys in the San Francisco area have told me:? "There is not enough S product available to build the accurate authentic complete layout which I envision."?I wasn't going to jump in until I saw this. My contention all along has been that most HO railroaders' goals are different from most S scale railroaders' goals. Model railroading has always been a big tent with lots of sub-rooms. I enjoy building models, and am less interested in building a layout except as a place to put my finished models. Jack Burgess wanted to build the Yosemite Valley railroad in August 1939, so S scale would be a poor choice. At the same time, there are plenty of HO modelers who enter scratch-built models in the NMRA contests - models that took a year or more to build.? I believe we make two mistakes when we advocate switching from HO to S scale. We tend to lump all HO modelers into one box, and we try to appeal to them all in the same way. So, to address Mike's original question, I would emphasize that S scale modeling is in many ways a different hobby, or at least a different feel, than modeling in more popular scales. I would assiduously avoid telling people that they can do the same things in S that they can do in HO or N scale. The people most likely to "convert" are the people that are already doing what works well in S Scale. Because of my emphasis in the hobby, the fertile areas for me to find people that are willing to build models would be RPM meets and NMRA model contests, so I try to put models in those whenever I can. The LD-OP sig is not the place for me, but maybe another S Scaler that emphasizes operations should show there.? -Michael Eldridge |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
No, I was responding specifically to the statement about just purchasing prebuilt, pre-decorated stuff.? There just isn't much actual modeling involved in opening a blisterpack and pouring a finished product out onto the flextrack.? As always, Tom Dempsey
|
|
Re: A Rose by Any Other Name . . .
Bill, If you've ever Googled "NASG", then you know about the North American Specialty?Glass right down the road from me in Trumbauersville. There's also Non-pneumatic Anti-Shock Garment, whatever that is. Jamie Bothwell A Little North of Trumbaurersville On Fri, Jun 21, 2024 at 11:48?AM Bill Wade via <bill=[email protected]> wrote:
|
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
"Gauge" was once used almost universally where "scale" would have been the correct term.? You can go to the beginning of Model Railroader magazine and observe this.? This gradually changed.? The exception is toy trains where "gauge" is still used as "S Gauge" or "O Gauge" (and sometimes "G" gauge).? High Rail (Hi Rail or Hirail) are under "O Gauge" but involve scale size equipment, scale structure, usually good scenery, with the distinction that the rail is too "high".? (And for O gauge, it will be 3-rail.) I created these info panels for a Boy Scout merit badge class we occasionally have at the local railroad museum. .?? Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer
On Friday, June 21, 2024 at 08:38:27 AM PDT, Lindsey Neas via groups.io <getitbronco@...> wrote:
Mike, ? ? ?I can't resist responding to your restatement of the question.? "There's far more available in scale S than most model railroaders realize.? That said, when it comes to building a layout, operating and building kits and scratchbuilding, S occupies that sweet spot between O and HO.? It allows for far more layout than in O and almost as much as in HO.? Mechanical and operating problems are more easily dealt w/ than in the smaller scales.? And, if you like to build, whether it's scratchbuilding in brass or styrene, kitbashing or building kits, it's the perfect size."?? ? ? ? In other words, I'd stick w/ the script.? Titman, Wade, Schumacher, Bortz et al had it right 50-plus years ago.? Lindsey Neas Route of the Eagles? |
|
A Rose by Any Other Name . . .
开云体育Who are we and what do we call ourselves? ?? It's a question older than time that probably started with "me not neanderthal; me troglodyte!"One poster mentioned that 'gauger' is an outdated term for our group of 3/16 modelers.? Yea, I concur since "gauge" references distance between rails.? Scalers would be a better term, but Flyer folks might be offended. Modelers is fairly generic, and even putting a flyer loco on the track is working with a model, so it is inclusive. So what do we need to do to get the NASG renamed to NASM? with the word "Modelers" replacing "Gaugers"? Rats, the plot thickens . . .? NASM is the National Academy of Sports Medicine and nasm.org is already used by them.? So we go with NASMTM - National Association of S Model Train Modelers. But wait, some are just collecting stuff in boxes.? ? NASMTMAC it is! ? National Association of S Model Train Modelers And Collectors.?? With tongue still firmly secured in my cheek, I think you get the point and will agree with another old adage, slightly modified . . . you can please some of the people all the time, all of the people some of the time, and none of the S folks at any time!!? Y'all take care now, ya hear!? ;-) Bill -- == Author of Military Crime Fiction == Coming Later this Year - Fair Winds of Doubt == Scale Model Railroad Products == == Manufacturer - Retailer - Importer == Bill Wade B.T.S. 1782 Trinity Rd Belington, WV 26250-7621 Phone: 304-823-3729 Fair Winds Always! |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
Mike, ? ? ?I can't resist responding to your restatement of the question.? "There's far more available in scale S than most model railroaders realize.? That said, when it comes to building a layout, operating and building kits and scratchbuilding, S occupies that sweet spot between O and HO.? It allows for far more layout than in O and almost as much as in HO.? Mechanical and operating problems are more easily dealt w/ than in the smaller scales.? And, if you like to build, whether it's scratchbuilding in brass or styrene, kitbashing or building kits, it's the perfect size."?? ? ? ? In other words, I'd stick w/ the script.? Titman, Wade, Schumacher, Bortz et al had it right 50-plus years ago.? Lindsey Neas Route of the Eagles? |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
On Fri, Jun 21, 2024 at 07:40 AM, Mike Swederska wrote:
Well, the problem is one mans greatest is another mans "say what???"? One could say camaraderie, size, challenge, etc. but those are pretty nebulous answers.? The same things occur in the other scales. I would probably still say the AM FP7 because that's what got me to jump scales from HO back in '85, but that statement wouldn't resonate with HO and N folks today who are becoming accustomed to prototype-specific mass produced models be they historic or contemporary. Rich G(ajnak) |
|
Re: hypothetical question with a real answer
For me it is the variety brought to S by all of us aficionados, whether that is scale, high-rail or Flyer, not the particular "scarcity" of the RTR manufacturing.
?
When I finally had the opportunity and means, S was the only choice for me, even though I could have had more track and rolling in HO.? I grew up with Flyer, my Dad still has his Flyer layout running.? I am going to model... scenery, rolling stock, whatever... and have chosen a high-rail route.
?
It can be vexing at times, but the challenge and the doing is a reward unto itself.
?
Bill
Philadelphia
IMinS
?
?
|
|
Re: NWSL J&L Tank, Another Question
开云体育
I should let the longer-time members sort this out, but I think you are confusing the later NASG tank cars project with Overland with the 1972 NWSL import.
Jace Kahn
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> on behalf of Michael Lytle <bnomike280@...>
Sent: Friday, June 21, 2024 11:05 AM To: [email protected] <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [S-Scale] NWSL J&L Tank, Another Question ?
Rusty,?
Likewise I'm also looking for the white decals but I only have two cars.?
Didn't the NASG only import 100 brass models of this car??
Mike (Ohio)
|