Re: new G-11 user with questions
Hi Gregory, Thanks for replying. The previous owner of the mount is of the opinion that the polar finder will get me close enough to use the DSCs with only a 1-star alignment. Do you agree?
I'm almost certainly going to buy this mount. It is being offered to me at about 1/2 the price for a new mount, DSCs and other accessories and as far as I can determine, it is in pretty much new condition. Are there other accessories I should consider getting? I'm certain I'm going to want the side-by-side saddle plate. Are the RA/Dec replacement clutch knobs useful? The replacement knobs for the screws that attach the mount to the tripod look useful. Is a similar replacement knob available for the screw that locks down the latitude adjustment? I hate fumbling with allen wrenches in the dark.
There is no grease on the polar scope or where it mounts. I have the polar scope, a small, white plastic washer that fits against a flange on the widest part of the polar scope (not sure which side of the flange it goes on, closest to the objective or the eyepiece?) and the retaining ring that screws onto the RA housing to secure the polar scope. If I tighten the retaining ring completely, the polar scope won't move (in fact, attempting to move it only unscrews the retaining ring). Should there be a second washer or something to allow the polar scope to float against the retaining ring and the RA housing?
Is a dust cover of some kind available to protect the polar scope if it is left in place all the time and to close the end of the RA housing when the polar scope is not in place?
Here's what the manual says about setting the scope to +90 degrees when doing a 2-star alignment with a GEM:
Losmandy DSC Manual, Section 5.3, Page 6 "When you are prompted for 1 or 2-star alignment, select 2-star. You will be prompted to set the scope to +90 degrees. This means relative to the scope, not the sky. For instance, if the scope is on a fork mount, it should be positioned parallel to the form arms. For a German Eq, the scope should be parallel the polar shaft.
For fork mounts, this positioning is not very critical (within a degree or so is fine). If the mount is a German Eq, you must set this position with some accuracy. See appendix (A) which describes a method for determining the +90 degree position for German equatorial."
Appendix A describes a method for determining the +90 degree point by sighting on Polaris and rotating the scope from one side of the mount to the other -- centering Polaris using the alt-az controls on one side and shims on the other (not something I particularly want to do every time I set the scope up).
There is something else I noticed last night. The manual, in the section on calibrating the mechanical declination setting circle, a set screw to lock down the dec circle is mentioned. The manual also says the screw should be between 0 and 10 degrees declination. I can't find that screw anywhere. Is it so small that it is hard to see or is my mount an older model that is missing something?
Thanks, ================================================ Ray Porter Applications Analyst Programmer Administrative Information Services, UNC-CH Phone: 966-5878 email: ray_porter@... dragon@... Home Page:
"Meddle not in the affairs of dragons, for thou art crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
|
Re: new G-11 user with questions
Ray,
You should be able to turn the polar finder without releasing the locking ring. The polar finder may be stuck from old grease??
You can't use the DSC's in alt-az mode on a GEM. You CAN use them without polar aligning.
You do need to do two star alignments initially. Generally the first alignment may be off by quite a bit, but the second if done well with bring everything into alignment. After two stars, I am still off a bit, so I use "guide" to M13 which is easily picked up in my finderscope as a third and final alignment target. If you leave the DSC's powered up all of the time via AC then you obviously would not need to worry about aligning. Just occasionally update by aligning on any target.
The polar alignment scope will give you a very close polar alignment though, enough to test CCD's for focus, study clusters or nebula, watch for comet or neo movements, etc.. Take your time. Every effort here only pays off in the long runs.
I am not sure of the +90 question. There is an initial balancing of the GEM and initializing to 0 DEC (for my DSC's) which is a process I have to do each time I set up. After a few times, it requires a little effort. The LX200 series does make this process a lot easier, granted.
Your polar finder illuminator sounds like an older model, mine is from JMI and has small actuator button with the built in battery compartment. About an inch square for the whole thing. You may be able to change to newer switch if they are sold independant of the polar finder. Give JMI a call.
Hope this helps.
Take care, Gregory david Stempel FIREFRAME
|
George,
Define your purposes first. Are just into the visual targeting or do you plan anything like imaging, photometry or astrometry?
GEM's make excellent platforms for the above but is unecessary for casual or general purpose viewing. Forks require additional wedges or other accessories to accomplish most of the above.
GEM's typically are more stable than forks. Can be a lot easier to polar align and give you views of virtally any area of the sky. Forks can hit their mountings and make it difficult to view your zenith.
Accuracy of pointing is generally the same with either. This is more dependant on encoder resolution and accuracy of alignments.
Get a GEM. I would not advise though, putting a 9.25 on a GM-8, unless you do not plan on adding too many accessories. Wieght limit for the GM8 is 30 lbs or so.
Take care, Gregory david Stempel FIREFRAME
|
I can comment on #4, as I have a C9.25 that I use on both a GM8 and a GM100 (predecessor to the G11). IMO, the GM8 is enough mount for visual use but not for photography or imaging through the scope. There was a discussion recently (within the past three weeks) about GEM vs. fork. You might want to check the archives. Paul Sterngold --- George Smith <gsmith4789@...> wrote: I am going to purchase an SCT but am undecided on a GEM or a fork mount. Under consideration are: C8 Deluxe, LX 200, U2K and C 9.25 on a GM 8. Any information you could offer on the following would be appreciated: 1) Advantages / disadvantages of a SCT-GM8 combination compared to a fork mounted SCT. 2) Portability of GM 8 compared to forks. 3) Experience of anyone using a C 9.25 with a GM 8. 4) Is a GM 8 enough mount for the C 9.25 or is a G 11 more appropriate.
This will be a significant investment for me so any information you can provide would be appreciated.
George Smith
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - Free email you can access from anywhere!
|
I am going to purchase an SCT but am undecided on a GEM or a fork mount. Under consideration are: C8 Deluxe, LX 200, U2K and C 9.25 on a GM 8. Any information you could offer on the following would be appreciated: 1) Advantages / disadvantages of a SCT-GM8 combination compared to a fork mounted SCT. 2) Portability of GM 8 compared to forks. 3) Experience of anyone using a C 9.25 with a GM 8. 4) Is a GM 8 enough mount for the C 9.25 or is a G 11 more appropriate.
This will be a significant investment for me so any information you can provide would be appreciated.
George Smith
|
Re: GM-8 Hand Controller Question ?
Thanks Rockett and Paul for the feedback. I was afraid there was a problem and you guys confirmed it. The cables are all plugged in correctly (that was the first thing I checked). I called Pocono West where I had purchased it and talked to Glenn. He then had me call Scott Losmandy. Mr. Losmandy confirmed that something was wrong. I will check the wiring in the back of the hand controller when I get home today and if I can't solve the problem, I will have to send the control box and the hand controller back to Losmandy.. Mr. Losmandy said he'd never heard of that problem before though. Sort of a bummer since its just one day old :(
Tony
|
hermperez@... wrote: Rockett, I'm sorry but I cant explain my argument better, lead acid batteries have a finite number of times that they can be discharged to zero, All batteries do, not just lead acid. The cycling does not waist a discharge since the batteries are no good to me on that first charge/discharge cycle because they will die on me 1/2 way through the night. also they don't suffer from a "memory effect". I really don't know why you are noticing an improvement but if it works for you... I didn't say anything about them having "memory effect" and my description of the problem doesn't fit the definition of the memory effect. That is caused by charging nicads over and over without fully discharging them. I am familiar with this phenomena because I also fly RC planes. My problem is charging my marine batteries fully after sitting for weeks and them having just 1/2 of the capacity when discharged. After the next charge however they have full capacity. Cycling them before the first night solves this problem. take care, Rockett Crawford ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|
Rockett, I'm sorry but I cant explain my argument better, lead acid batteries have a finite number of times that they can be discharged to zero, also they don't suffer from a "memory effect". I really don't know why you are noticing an improvement but if it works for you... Herm Rockett Crawford <Rockett@...> wrote:
hermperez@... wrote:
this does no good to lead acid batteries, all you are doing is shortening its life. No, you are definitely wrong about the batteries I am using. It does do a lot of good. I discovered this by accident. I noticed that every time I went out for more than one night, the second night the batteries had almost twice the capacity as they did the night before.
Finally I wised up and started cycling the batteries before a star party rather than just charging them up.
Astropics
|
Re: GM-8 Hand Controller Question ?
Paul Sterngold wrote: --- Rockett Crawford <Rockett@...> wrote:
No, this is not normal. You have a defective hand controller. Or it may be that you have the motors plugged into the wrong jacks on the drive control box. (I've done this before- the scope keeps moving the DEC axis! <g>) Be sure that you have the upper motor connected to DEC and the lower one connected to RA. But I would think the axis would merely be swapped in that case. If that is not the problem, then indeed you have a defective drive system. It is probably the hand controller but could possibly be the drive control box.
Good point, there is a chance it could possibly be the drive control also. Rockett Crawford ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|
Re: GM-8 Hand Controller Question ?
--- Rockett Crawford <Rockett@...> wrote: No, this is not normal. You have a defective hand controller. Or it may be that you have the motors plugged into the wrong jacks on the drive control box. (I've done this before- the scope keeps moving the DEC axis! <g>) Be sure that you have the upper motor connected to DEC and the lower one connected to RA. If that is not the problem, then indeed you have a defective drive system. It is probably the hand controller but could possibly be the drive control box. Paul Sterngold __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - Free email you can access from anywhere!
|
Re: GM-8 Hand Controller Question ?
No, this is not normal. You have a defective hand controller. Rockett Crawford Tony Bonanno wrote: Hi Everyone,
Just received my new GM-8 yesterday and my initial impressions are very positive. I had never seen one before and purchased it on its reputation. I think I've made a good choice. I'm sure I'll have some questions for the group as I become more familiar with it and already have one question regarding the hand controller.
Looking at the hand controller with the RA and DEC reverse switches at the top, there is a diamond shape arrangement of four buttons. My assumption was that the buttons opposite each other would control the motion of the same axis. However, on this particular controller, the TOP and LEFT buttons seem to work on one axis while the RIGHT and BOTTOM buttons control the other axis. I've found it very frustrating as it is not intuitive at all. Is this the normal operation for the GM-8 hand controller or is my specific example "wired wrong" ??
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|
GM-8 Hand Controller Question ?
Hi Everyone,
Just received my new GM-8 yesterday and my initial impressions are very positive. I had never seen one before and purchased it on its reputation. I think I've made a good choice. I'm sure I'll have some questions for the group as I become more familiar with it and already have one question regarding the hand controller.
Looking at the hand controller with the RA and DEC reverse switches at the top, there is a diamond shape arrangement of four buttons. My assumption was that the buttons opposite each other would control the motion of the same axis. However, on this particular controller, the TOP and LEFT buttons seem to work on one axis while the RIGHT and BOTTOM buttons control the other axis. I've found it very frustrating as it is not intuitive at all. Is this the normal operation for the GM-8 hand controller or is my specific example "wired wrong" ??
Thanks for the help,
Tony
|
hermperez@... wrote: this does no good to lead acid batteries, all you are doing is shortening its life. No, you are definitely wrong about the batteries I am using. It does do a lot of good. I discovered this by accident. I noticed that every time I went out for more than one night, the second night the batteries had almost twice the capacity as they did the night before. Finally I wised up and started cycling the batteries before a star party rather than just charging them up. Its definitely good for nicads but does not apply to lead acid batteries. All you have to do is to promptly recharge the battery with a good automatic charger, or float it at 13.8v...keep the electrolyte topped off etc.. I do charge it with a good automatic charger designed specifically for marine batteries. I also charge them immediately when I get home to leave them in a charged state. all you possibly could want to know about rechargeable batteries, all types, check it out here:
This is a good page, but it appears to only apply to small R/C packs that go into models. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|
Paul Sterngold wrote: The G11 should consume less than 1 amp per hour, but for safety's sake, estimate that rate. The DSC's consumption should be negligible but again, play it safe and estimate 0.5 amps per hour The DSCs have a display heater which takes about 1/2 amp, but only when the temperature drops below freezing. The digital drive pulls about 1/2 an amp. Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|
new G-11 user with questions
Hi everyone, I am in the process of purchasing a used G-11 with Losmandy digital setting circles and polar alignment scope from a fellow club member. After years of using fork mounts, I'm still getting used to using German mounts and I have a few questions that don't seem to be really covered in the manuals, mostly about the DSCs. Fortunately, the current owner is allowing me to borrow the mount before actually purchasing it so I can "kick the tires" and get any questions answered up front.
1) The manual states that the polar bore scope should rotate freely when inserted in the RA housing. However, after tightening the retaining ring, the finder won't budge. Is it normal to have to loosen the retaining ring slightly to rotate the polar finder?
2) Will the DSCs in alt-az mode with the G-11?
3) Will the polar scope give me a sufficiently close alignment that the DSCs will work with a 1-star alignment?
4) Appendix A in the DSC manual describes a process for determining the +90 degree position for the telescope/mount that is necessary for a 2-star alignment with a GEM. Shimming the mount may be all fine and dandy if you have a permanent installation, but it sounds impractical if you have to setup and take down the scope and mount for every viewing session. How accurate does this process have to be? Will centering Polaris and setting the mechanical declination circle get me close enough?
5) The illuminator and battery pack for the polar bore scope seems a little cumbersome. Is there an illuminator available with a self-contained battery?
I'm sure I'll have other questions as I start using the mount.
Thanks, ================================================ Ray Porter Applications Analyst Programmer Administrative Information Services, UNC-CH Phone: 966-5878 email: ray_porter@... dragon@... Home Page:
"Meddle not in the affairs of dragons, for thou art crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
|
--- In Losmandy_users@..., hermperez@w... wrote: this does no good to lead acid batteries, all you are doing is shortening its life. Its definitely good for nicads but does not apply to lead acid batteries. All you have to do is to promptly recharge the battery with a good
automatic charger, or float it at 13.8v...keep the electrolyte topped off etc.. all you possibly could want to know about rechargeable batteries,
all types, check it out here:
Herm
Rockett Crawford <Rockett@a...> wrote: Thanks to all of you who responed. The battery is a lead-acid battery sold by Pep Boys for boosting your car battery when needed. The amp-hr rating is not listed. It was alway fully charged as indicated by the pilot light (green) when the button was pressed. Over charging may be the cause because I tend to leave the wall unit charger plugged in all the time. In any case when used three days in a row, it is recharded overnight and the third night failed after about 4 hrs. I assume that the battery is a dud and leaving for Sam's to buy another. Once again thanks.
This is called "cycling" by NiCad users. I don't know if the concept applies to these batteries or not, but it definitely makes a big difference. Astropics
|
this does no good to lead acid batteries, all you are doing is shortening its life. Its definitely good for nicads but does not apply to lead acid batteries. All you have to do is to promptly recharge the battery with a good automatic charger, or float it at 13.8v...keep the electrolyte topped off etc.. all you possibly could want to know about rechargeable batteries, all types, check it out here: Herm Rockett Crawford <Rockett@...> wrote: This is called "cycling" by NiCad users. I don't know if the concept applies to these batteries or not, but it definitely makes a big difference. Astropics
|
I doubt it, most likely your battery pack is not in good shape. What kind of batteries and how big is the pack made off? I sometimes use a 5ah lead-acid gellcell and its good for two nights. Herm havriliak@... wrote: The battery pack that I use claims that a radio or TV can be operated for 20 hrs. On several occassions, by freshly charged battery went dead driving the G-11 with DSC. I couldn't understand this at first, and later concluded that a fine layer of bubbles formed over the battery plates made it appear dead. So when it happened again, I simpley shook the battery as hard as I could but to no avail. Any comments, or does the G-11 draw about 5 times the current of a radio or TV Astropics
|
The G11 should consume less than 1 amp per hour, but for safety's sake, estimate that rate. The DSC's consumption should be negligible but again, play it safe and estimate 0.5 amps per hour. If you estimate 1.5 amps per hour total consumption, you'll be very safe. It's probably about half that in reality.
Was your battery fully charged before you used it? What is the amp-hour rating?
Deep cycle batteries such as this should be recharged immediately after use, no matter how low you've run them. Running them all the way down and/or letting them sit in a partially or fully discharged condition shortens their life.
They have no memory and can be discharged to any point before recharging.
I use a hefty Marine battery rated at 105 AH along with a smaller "Gates Cyclon" 24 AH battery. The pair can run my scope, CCD camera, autoguider and laptop for four nights without recharging, as I learned this past June on Mt Lassen in California. Fortunately, I didn't have to use my dew straps, as they are some of the biggest consumers of electrical power.
Paul Sterngold
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - Free email you can access from anywhere!
|
I use a 34 amp hour marine battery (a small battery, about the size used in rider mowers) for my G-11 /w DSCs and it lasts all night long even in the winter. I use marine batteries because unlike car batteries, they are designed to be discharged almost completely without harming them. I also use two other 34 amp batteries to run my laptop and CCD camera but I'm fixing to upgrade to two 68 amp hour batteries because the smaller batteries are just borderline enough. I have noticed something about marine batteries (don't know which kind you have), that if you charge them up after a few weeks of sitting, they don't have as much capacity. The longer they have sat, the lower their capacity is. However after I cursed at them for running completely down in say 1/2 the time they should have and charge them up fully again. Then they have full capacity and last much longer. So what I now will do if I haven't been out for a month or so is charge them up, run them down, and then charge them up again before I go out. This is called "cycling" by NiCad users. I don't know if the concept applies to these batteries or not, but it definitely makes a big difference. Rockett Crawford havriliak@... wrote: The battery pack that I use claims that a radio or TV can be operated for 20 hrs. On several occassions, by freshly charged battery went dead driving the G-11 with DSC. I couldn't understand this at first, and later concluded that a fine layer of bubbles formed over the battery plates made it appear dead. So when it happened again, I simpley shook the battery as hard as I could but to no avail. Any comments, or does the G-11 draw about 5 times the current of a radio or TV
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Capella's Observatory (CCD Imaging)
|