Thank you Mark,
Yes, on this particular guiding session, I do recall Dec was
almost perfectly balanced, rather than a little camera heavy. I
was having a bit of trouble getting the balance correct and
finally said "good enough".? I use NINA TPA, and try to get <
0.8", which PHD2 then tells me is 2.0" !? This guiding session, it
started at 2.0" and was 0.2" for the bulk of the guiding.
I will add this to my things to try. Also considering ordering a
21# CW to move up the shaft, to reduce moment arm.
Now the skies are cloudy for a few nights as usual.
Dale
On 3/3/25 11:49 AM, Mark Christensen
via groups.io wrote:
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Your DEC may be too perfectly balanced, and your polar
alignment may be too good.
?
Seems contradictory but if there is any backlash in your DEC
then every time you correct (say) a negative DEC error you may
overcompensate.
Then you have a positive error, which it then also
overcompensates. The cycle continues then, which it looks like
what is happening.
?
One thing to try is to reduce the DEC aggressiveness (aka
feedback). That may, just may, fix it. I say that because your
graph makes it appear your
DEC corrections are overshooting on a periodic basis. PEC is
a non-issue with DEC as DEC guiding commands will rarely, if
ever, cause a worm cycle.
?
Another thing to try is to turn off Auto DEC and force it to
correct in only one direction - namely that needed to correct
any (tiny, but not too tiny) DEC drift.
That way it will never reverse so, with a tiny amount of DEC
imbalance (in the right direction) the DEC gear will always be
engaged.
?
Same idea as RA being heavy east and guiding aggressiveness
in the range of 0.5X. Doing that guarantees it will never
reverse so any backlash is a non-issue.
?
You will need, of course, to figure out which (if any)
direction you have DEC drift. But a bit of experimentation will
tell you which works for any particular target.
?
A tiny amount of DEC drift, together with setting the DEC
algorithm so it only goes in one direction, may solve your
problem.
?
Usually, on most mounts that I've seen, the RA has the larger
residual guiding error, not the DEC. Your RA residuals look
splendid.
?
And, of course, some of this advice is hard to do with remote
operations.
?
Best regards,
?
Mark C.