¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Re: HP8753B VNA question regarding if I purchase one


 

On Sun, 20 Oct 2024 at 12:23, Chuck Harris via <cfharris=[email protected]> wrote:
I see, so I should pander and lie to him.? I will try to
remember that.

Investing $50 in a nanoVNA, to see if he even knows what
a VNA should do, or has any use for one, is foolish...
Far better to spend $3K to 10K only to find out he has no
interest, or need for a? VNA.?

Check. Got it.

-Chuck Harris

Your argument could be used any time someone asks about buying an oscilloscope, multimeter, or just about any other piece of test equipment. You can buy a cheap Chinese version and see if you want one.

The NanoVNA are supplied with a useless calibration kit, which does give people the illusion they are making decent measurements, when really they are not.

Your estimate of $3k-$10k is well off too.

The original poster should note that 4 N-N cables are needed to connect a test set to the VNA. You can make those up? yourself - they do NOT need to be phase matched, despite the original HP documentation saying they do. As long as the cables are stable, that's all that matters. The cable does not have to be anything special, as long as the screen is not so poor it leaks lots of RF.

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.