¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Re: Ideas for "bulletproofing" the uBitx


 

Mad,

Thousands of stock uBit's are operating with no trouble at all.
If the IRF510's die at all, It is almost certainly because of overheating.
Perhaps when running some digital mode, inside an enclosure, with zero airflow..

Many of the reports of blown IRF510's can be attributed to people fiddling with the gate bias pots
without first spending 10 minutes to figure out what they are doing.?
The "clockwise is minimum" pot rotation plays a big factor.
Going to RD16HHF1's will only make this mistake much more expensive.

The uBitx is designed to be a minimalist SSB rig for all of HF at minimum cost, and succeeds wildly.
If it is to be used continuously at full power in digital modes, the minimalist heatsinks should be improved.

I can imagine that a shorted antenna jack (thus infinite SWR) could play a role.
But only because the IRF510's might heat up after some period of time.

Many in the forum run the IRF510's at around 20 volts for increased power.
With an adequate heatsink, this works reliably.
If you insist on telling them they should switch over to "real" RF devices such as the RD16HHF1,
you should also warn them?not to run at much beyond 12 volts.

The qrp-labs 10W PA blows away the many claims over the years in this forum
that the IRF510's are not suitable as RF transistors.?
It simply works, flat and clean, from 3.5 to 30mhz.
And is bulletproof when operated at 12v, even when presented with a worst case SWR.
The uBitx IRF510's can be just as reliable if given a suitable heatsink.

Jerry, KE7ER




On Fri, Jan 1, 2021 at 01:31 AM, MadRadioModder wrote:

Don¡¯t understand the point.? Why would you want to operate excellent RF transistors designed specifically for the 12-14V mobile world at a higher voltage?? They make all of their power in that range.

?

You are correct¡­ that most people won¡¯t get much out of replacing IRF devices with the RDs¡­? until they blow out a set or two of them.? Then it will start to matter, because the RD devices survive much better under bad circumstances like infinite SWR.? Again, real RF transistors designed for load mismatch tolerance ?(read the app note, load tolerance spec).? Bullet-proof.

?

You are also correct that most people won¡¯t spend the time to replace the IRF devices for the RD devices even after they kill a few sets.? They will just keep killing IRF510¡¯s.

?

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.