¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Re: Modular uBitx - "Ex: Harmonics"


 

¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Thanks Gordon / Alison,

In the mists of time, along time ago now......

there was a suggestion of what about using 'this or that', off the shelf relay board,

I agreed with another contributor that it didn't look particularly "suited to RF" applications. General observation, not a full on analysis.

(Just what ever is ultimately chosen should be a best as possible a "cure all" (to which there is no such thing, we can only strive to become close)

(Some regions are governed by the -50dB rule, we cannot ask you NA / US solutioneer's? be guided by that.

It would be nice however not to have to reinvent the wheel to come up with another solution that satisfies "our legislation"?))


Now it's resorted to quoting Lecher Lines / Skin resistance and? waving smiths charts at dawn.? :-P


Can we agree the theory of short, direct traces is good

"Noodle soup" bad.

Well bonded top / bottom groundplanes are good

Input traces parallel to output traces, bad

Attention paid to layout, Good?

and 1001 things that that all can be read in a book, possibly EMFD all contribute to good practice.

(Sometimes even that is not enough,

and sprinkling 103's liberally everywhere at least shows willing, or weakness....? :-) )


It was what I was trying to portray?

looking back, at what I wrote.

The LPF's work. The physical relay device chosen works, the problem was how it was all put together


Alan


On 20/08/2018 15:02, ajparent1/KB1GMX wrote:

Alan,

With short lines the impedance is rarely critical unless they are parallel
or over a questionable ground.? The other is narrow lines are low in surface area
and even at HF that meas RF loss to skin resistance though small.

One thing I tried after ripping the relays off. I stripped all the interconnecting
paths top and bottom and left bare pads.? I reinstalled the relays from the
ground side (bottom)? then wired them up using a different scheme.? Since
there were only three relays? I did only three filters to prove wiring not componenets.
The filters used were 80/40/20 and it tested far better.? The wiring scheme
attached.

The layout is the entire issue.? Look under the relays and its long noodle soup.
?
Allison

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.