开云体育

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 开云体育

Really small space help needed


 

This is for HO.
I have a small L shaped space that is only 4 feet long on each leg. The width of each leg is 12 inches however one leg could go out to 18 inches.
Obviously this is a switching plan, small locos and short cars so allowable track radius could go down to the 15-16 inch range if unavoidable.
I haven't been able to think of anything usable but then track planning is not my strong suit. Anyone have any suggestions?

Cliff Smith


 

Cliff, may I do some doodling and come up with a suggested plan?

With best regards,


Paul Boehlert


On Fri, Apr 5, 2019 at 11:41 AM Cliff Smith <ccsmith.3rd@...> wrote:
This is for HO.
I have a small L shaped space that is only 4 feet long on each leg. The width of each leg is 12 inches however one leg could go out to 18 inches.
Obviously this is a switching plan, small locos and short cars so allowable track radius could go down to the 15-16 inch range if unavoidable.
I haven't been able to think of anything usable but then track planning is not my strong suit. Anyone have any suggestions?

Cliff Smith


 

That's actually gigantic when compared to the typical micro-layout. Here are hundreds of inspirations that can be expanded to fit your space:

?

Aurelio Locsin

P.S. I'm thinking a Trackmobile layout would be ideal.?


Scooter Oak
 

开云体育

Look at Lance Mindheim’s blog (or read his books). This is exactly the kind of thing he excels at. In general, you need to decide which industry or scene is the most interesting for you, and model that thing.?

--Scooter ::

On Apr 5, 2019, at 8:51 AM, Paul Boehlert <pboehlert30@...> wrote:

Cliff, may I do some doodling and come up with a suggested plan?

With best regards,


Paul Boehlert

On Fri, Apr 5, 2019 at 11:41 AM Cliff Smith <ccsmith.3rd@...> wrote:
This is for HO.
I have a small L shaped space that is only 4 feet long on each leg. The width of each leg is 12 inches however one leg could go out to 18 inches.
Obviously this is a switching plan, small locos and short cars so allowable track radius could go down to the 15-16 inch range if unavoidable.
I haven't been able to think of anything usable but then track planning is not my strong suit. Anyone have any suggestions?

Cliff Smith


 

As someone said, two four-foot legs 12 to 18 inches wide is a lot of space. Do you have space at both ends to have a small removable module that would enable you to have a turning circle? That would enable you to have a round-trip type of layout.

Philip Sharp

On Sat, Apr 6, 2019 at 4:40 AM Cliff Smith <ccsmith.3rd@...> wrote:
This is for HO.
I have a small L shaped space that is only 4 feet long on each leg. The width of each leg is 12 inches however one leg could go out to 18 inches.
Obviously this is a switching plan, small locos and short cars so allowable track radius could go down to the 15-16 inch range if unavoidable.
I haven't been able to think of anything usable but then track planning is not my strong suit. Anyone have any suggestions?

Cliff Smith


 

You might want to take a look at the Small/ Microlayouts FB page as there are some good ideas there



and also the HO Scale Shelf Layouts on FB



Bruce Wilson
Barrie, ON


 

I have a like/detest relationship with Facebook, but will have to check these both out as well.?

Thanks Bruce.?

Paul Pearson
Denver, Colorado


 

Given the 4' lengths and the L-shape, an hour or so looking over the Carl Arendt scrapbook might give you some great inspiration. You could combine a couple layouts and have something pretty unique and very functional. Depending on your width, you might even be able to install something like the Gumstump and Snowshoe on the L-shaped layout. Check out June 2005 Special Edition on the link below for the 1' x 6' version.?

http://www.carendt.com/category/small-layout-scrapbook/

Sincerely,

Joe

?

?

?

On 04/05/2019 02:24 PM, Paul Pearson wrote:

I have a like/detest relationship with Facebook, but will have to check these both out as well.?

Thanks Bruce.?

Paul Pearson
Denver, Colorado


Ron Hunt
 

It all depends on what you want out of a layout -

Here are a few that could be modified to fit your dimensions. You speak of length but not of what would be below or above them ... could it be possible to mount a little wider layout in the same length but hinged so that it would be dropped when not in use for space then lifted up and flat for use or the opposite, folded up when not in use and lowered down and flat for use?

Just for grins and giggles ... what about a vertical layout ... I have seen underground mines done in narrower spaces. Try UTube for idea's, look for model rail road mines. N gauge track - HO scale powered wheelset could be used to construct an "electric" mule to pull mine cars. Elevator(s) to take the cars to the top and return empties.

The possibilities are endless. :-)

The Carendt.com website will have a bunch of suggestions ...

Ron


On Fri, Apr 5, 2019 at 11:41 AM Cliff Smith <ccsmith.3rd@...> wrote:
This is for HO.
I have a small L shaped space that is only 4 feet long on each leg. The width of each leg is 12 inches however one leg could go out to 18 inches.
Obviously this is a switching plan, small locos and short cars so allowable track radius could go down to the 15-16 inch range if unavoidable.
I haven't been able to think of anything usable but then track planning is not my strong suit. Anyone have any suggestions?

Cliff Smith


 

On 4/5/19 1:12 PM, TILLMAN, JOE via Groups.Io wrote:
Depending on your width, you might even be able to install something like the Gumstump and Snowshoe on the L-shaped layout. Check out June 2005 Special Edition on the link below for the 1' x 6' version.

GS&S is always good, and a lot better if a runaround can be included.?? There's also a long narrow track plan or two in 101 Track Plans, and there was a coastal layout in MR a few years back that could probably be made to work.?? Sorry for the vagueness on layout names - I suffer from CRS :-).


 

Please be my guest.

Thank you.
Cliff Smith


 

Unfortunately no room at the ends.

Cliff Smith


 

You may be right about the Gumstump and Snowshoe. A variation of that just might be made to fit if I keep the curve radii tight since there are no turnouts in the middle where the bends would be located.
I'll see what I can come up with. Thank you to everyone and if anyone has a better idea don't hesitate to to chime in.

Cliff Smith


 

"Port Ogden and Northern track plan" is no. 8 in 101 track plans.? Google the six words in my quotes and add the word "images" and you will find it.? Too long for the subject at hand at 16 ft x one foot.? It was my second layout when I was 15 and laid entirely with Atlas steel track.? Fortunately I had a Varney dockside that ran pretty well.? It's a neat plan for switching industrial sidings.? Steep grades at around 4% and practically limited to #4 turnouts and short rolling stock.? The grades didn't bother the heavy dockside 0-4-0 on steel track.? That thing with added weight could pull a "house".

There is a line drawing of the layout which accompanies the plan.? The drawing is deceptive in that it shows an impossible slanted bank at the near end separating the upper and lower levels.? At one foot wide that separation has to be a vertical retaining wall.? The separation of the upper and lower tracks at the far end is a bit of a fantasy.? But allowing for that it is practical to build in HO.? That's how I did it and it worked.? If you add 3 or four inches to the width the whole thing gets easier to do and the scenery can be logical rather than fantasy.

101 track plans has other "L" shaped plans at nos. 51, 55 and 68.? All still too big; but worth a look.? The whole book is an inspiration and worth having in your library if you can find an affordable copy.

Ed Weldon


 

On 4/6/19 5:37 PM, Cliff Smith wrote:
You may be right about the Gumstump and Snowshoe. A variation of that just might be made to fit if I keep the curve radii tight since there are no turnouts in the middle where the bends would be located.
Another thing you might try, in addition to a runaround, is a small yard on the 18" wide portion.?? Two tracks plus the main could make an Inglenook for more operating fun.

As you can probably tell, a variation of the GS&S is on my to-do list after I finish my interchange layout :-).


 

If you are looking for prototype railroads that will fit nicely into your L space, take a look at some rail barge fed terminal railroads.
?
?
You might want to consider T-trak modules for your benchwork. They are available in the sizes that are near what you have mentioned.?
?
?
David
?


 

Hi Cliff
A layout of about your size though straight was Leonard Blumenschine's Beaver Bay Transfer Co. that appeared in MRR in November 1976. He actually built it in his office in a Madison Ave. advertising company during his lunch breaks.

For operating sessions it was mounted on a couple of shel brackets that normally supported a shelf over his desk. It was in two sections bolted together with bolts and wing nuts and the buildings were added. I think the truss girder bridge dropped in place and the upper section "Beaver Bay" was 1.5 inches above the TL&FJ branch transfer yard? and separated by retaining walls(TL&FJ was the Tupper Lake and Faust Junction - Blumenshine's home layout)
.
The layout was only 10 inches wide and I think you could bend it onto an L at the split without needing outrageously sharpt curves.
I've redrawn it for a length of 8ft using Peco 83 line #4 Y turnouts and #5 left and right turnouts. ISTR that Leonard Blumenschine used Atlas #4 turnouts but I'll try to dig out the original article.I could envisage reversing it so Beaver bay is lower level (and at the front) and representing a quayside with cars brought down from a main line yard above (There was such a set up in Newcastle England with a very steep connecting grade from the main line down to the River Tyne operated by a couple of electric locos)?

Leonard Blumenschine wrote several articles in MRR and actually managed to operate some kind of layout in his cabin on the USS Boxer, on which he served as a Lt. (JG) during the Korean War. ?


 

Gumstump and Snowshoe layouts. One was featured in the March 2017 Gazette completed with scenery (a favorite of mine). The other was used by City Classics model railroad manufacturer as their display railroad at shows and was built to allow continuous running via a loop.?


 

I seem to recall a plan in Model Trains International for this size of area.? Switchem Corner designed by Jack Trollope.

Clive Burdikin


 

A look at the associated SLD file groups might be worth the time.

/g/sldfiles

/g/sldfiles2

/g/SLDFiles3

Bruce Wilson
Barrie, Ontario, Canada
Life Member NMRA
Member Scale 7 Group Gauge 0 Guild 7mmNGA
Member Bird Studies Canada Ontario Bird Banding Association
Nature Barrie Simcoe County Banding Group

On 4/8/2019 11:00, Clive Burdikin via Groups.Io wrote:
I seem to recall a plan in Model Trains International for this size of area.? Switchem Corner designed by Jack Trollope.

Clive Burdikin