Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
S parameters get used in matrix calculations on arbitrarily complex networks, they have to be mathematically correct. The "Return Loss" in dB, on the other hand, strikes me as a handy way to casually
By
Jerry Gaffke
·
#16486
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
The book is available (legally) on the web as a pdf: http://www.w3pga.org/Antenna%20Books/Reflections%20III.pdf Maxwell had an amazing career, and knew this stuff cold. Lots of good insights in that
By
Jerry Gaffke
·
#16485
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Clarifying it seems unlikely to appreciably mitigate Wiki confusion...
By
Oristo
·
#16484
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Thanks.
By
Dave Daniel
·
#16483
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
https://store.cq-amateur-radio.com/shop/reflections-iii/
By
Oristo
·
#16482
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Which Maxwell? What book? DaveD
By
Dave Daniel
·
#16481
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
This reminds me of this old discussion about how to represent the reflection coefficient. The stuff included below is from post /g/nanovna-users/topic/34589622#5275 All but the final
By
Jerry Gaffke
·
#16480
·
|
Re: Simple stand for holding VNA
I cheated and used 1/4" (5.6mm) plywood as its easy to cut and finish plus wooden legs. Allison ----------------- No direct email, it goes to bit bucket due address harvesting in groups.IO
By
aparent1/kb1gmx <kb1gmx@...>
·
#16479
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Thank you for the article Roger. So many people doing it incorrectly is no excuse to remain ignorant. We can start here and now, since it is pertinent to this purpose of this group. Danny K5CG
By
Danny K5CG
·
#16478
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
It is incorrect but so many people do it even in engineering literature. The editor of IEEE transactions got concerned about it and wrote this article... Roger
By
Roger Need
·
#16477
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
And generally they're both plotted with "smaller reflection coefficient magnitude lower than higher" - So the plot goes from, say, -40 to 0 (or 40 to 0)
By
Jim Lux
·
#16476
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
You will see Return Loss presented both ways, depending on the author. Retaining the negative sign is less often seen and perhaps *wrong*, but either way the intent is obvious. Jerry, KE7ER
By
Jerry Gaffke
·
#16475
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Larry, I assume the user guide you wanted me to look at is this one: /g/nanovna-users/files/NanoVNA-User-Guide-English-reformat-Jan-15-20.pdf I tried using an earlier version of that
By
Jerry Gaffke
·
#16474
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
The presentation is very good. However, slide 12 is not correct in the suggestion that Return Loss is always a negative number. That is simply not the case. The reflection magnitude in db is always a
By
Danny K5CG
·
#16473
·
|
Re: Firmware choices, wiki is awfully confusing
Well, I think you made a great choice! I started out with a fairly early NanoVNA in October, 2019 and liked it, but had a hard time reading it outdoors, and sometimes indoors. I got a -F this June and
By
DougVL
·
#16472
·
|
Re: Simple stand for holding VNA
As you say, most cutting boards are PE, but it is also a significant ESD hazard - Unless you buy a piece of dissipative plastic (McMaster Carr) most plastics are a hazard. You could coat it with a
By
Jim Lux
·
#16471
·
|
Re: Simple stand for holding VNA
Before you scrap your wonderful stand there Dallas check to see if it is an ESD hazard. Most of the food prep boards I have used for construction (yes, they are an excellent and cheap source of
By
Spike
·
#16470
·
|
Re: Bad V2 clones incoming
Hi Hugen, how is status of V2 with 4 inches! may I ask 617DB-1023 or YB006T-1023 is used in yours? Do your product support same firmware+software from S-A-A-2, mean direct updates? bcos I am
By
oakkar7
·
#16469
·
|
Updated Wiki Page: User Guides
#wiki-notice
The wiki page User Guides ( /g/nanovna-users/wiki/12475/114877 ) has been updated by Oristo. *Reason:* move videos to External Links page Compare Revisions (
By
[email protected] Notification <nanovna-users@...>
·
#16468
·
|
Re: Simple stand for holding VNA
Dallas 3:48am #16466 Good point on ESD. Thin metal, plywood, paneling, or Masonite might be a better material choice. I will make up a new one. Thanks, Dallas, N5fee
By
Dallas
·
#16467
·
|