Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
I think it makes a worthwhile improvement.
But...
If the signal levels re too high, the amplifier will produce IMD, so it's a trade between the best Signal to Noise Performance and unwanted spurious
By
Martin - Southwest UK
·
#20179
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi Martin,
Thanks for the useful tips.
As the thick tube may rip off the narrow PCB trace, I will replace the tiny plate with a 1m long wire. Is 1m sufficient to result in a noticeable
By
biastee@...
·
#20178
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
The choice of inductor will depend upon the plate capacitance, input capacitance and inductor self resonance. Without a series resistor, it will have a sharp peak, which is not desirable.
I don't
By
Martin - Southwest UK
·
#20177
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi Dan,
Indeed, Q1 is marked ¡° MR? ¡± - the suffix indicating the reverse formed version of BF998. On the other hand, the PCB footprint is intended for the normal formed version.
Hi
By
biastee@...
·
#20176
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi Chin-Leong Lim,
The reason for the peak in gain at HF is the incorrect choice of input inductor.
It should have a series resistor, and an inductance value to produce a suitably damped LPF
By
Martin - Southwest UK
·
#20175
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Yes, very poor quality control.? They likely substituted a component with reversed pinout (e.g. BF998R....note the "R") for the original one (e.g. BF998) thinking it was the same.? Both components
By
Dan Clementi
·
#20174
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi Simon,
I bought a PA0NHC clone for ~USD2 from a China vendor (photo below). The price includes the biastee.
Both mini-whip and biastee are fully surface mount and the build quality is very good.
By
biastee@...
·
#20173
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Read the two links I posted earlier.
https://www.pa3fwm.nl/technotes/tn07.html
https://www.pa3fwm.nl/technotes/tn09d.html
It does need an "earth" "ground" or some other return path, and it's better
By
Martin - Southwest UK
·
#20172
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
When I tried out my Miniwhips they were mounted on a bamboo cane tied to a garden stake mounted at the corner of my shed. The earth wire ran straight down the pole to a copper pipe driven into the
By
Ian Brooks
·
#20171
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
My understanding is that yes it will work but the noise floor would be very high.
By
Mike Usher
·
#20170
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
It doesn¡¯t necessarily need an Earth To
work good.
By
J Ferro
·
#20169
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
I have used the Bonito range of miniwhips for something very similar. Basically I have 2 loops mounted orthoganally in an L shape with the mini whips mounted where the 2 lines of the L meet. Then
By
Mike Usher
·
#20168
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
It's not too difficult to build one of these yourself, but the output transistor used in the original PA0RDT design is obsolete and any on e-bay or AliExpress at reasonable prices are likely to be
By
Ian Brooks
·
#20167
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
You need to take precautions with a Mini-Whip installation, to get the best from it.
https://www.pa3fwm.nl/technotes/tn07.html
https://www.pa3fwm.nl/technotes/tn09d.html
Regards,
Martin
By
Martin - Southwest UK
·
#20166
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Build
Your own.
By
J Ferro
·
#20165
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Thank you!
Simon
<nigel_clayton@...> wrote:
By
rfsam
·
#20164
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Here is a link (not sure if still valid)
roelof@...
By
Oyster Town (G0IFS)
·
#20163
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi,
I've read a lot about those but where I can purchase them?
Thanks,
Simon
<nigel_clayton@...> wrote:
By
rfsam
·
#20162
·
|
Re: Mini-Whip recommendation?
I use PA0RDT mini whips in two locations together with other receive only loops that can be phased one against the other. I suggest using original PA0RDT not Chinese copies!
By
Oyster Town (G0IFS)
·
#20161
·
|
Mini-Whip recommendation?
Hi everyone,
Thank you,
Simon
KM6MUL
By
rfsam
·
#20160
·
|