开云体育

Locked Throwing turnouts from NCE throttle #nce


 

I have panel pro working well with my NCE system via a serial cable to the five amp Pro Cab system.
what I would like to happen is if a turnout gets thrown using an accessory command on the NCE throttle that panel pro would show the change on the computer screen. All is of course fine if I throw turnouts using panel pro.
apologies if this is obvious
Andy


 

开云体育

Andy,

On 5 May 2023, at 7:53 pm, andy.keane@... wrote:

I have panel pro working well with my NCE system via a serial cable to the five amp Pro Cab system.
what I would like to happen is if a turnout gets thrown using an accessory command on the NCE throttle that panel pro would show the change on the computer screen. All is of course fine if I throw turnouts using panel pro.
apologies if this is obvious

From:
<>


MONITORING
Default for LocoNet Turnouts (and probably XpressNet soon), and available for NCE. When selected, the network is monitored for messages about the status of the Turnout. This mode is only available for certain systems, i.e. some systems can't do the monitoring properly, and don't have this choice

Dave in Australia?in.


 

Andy,
make
If you have the Power Pro system box (not PowerCab, SB5, Twin) you can see those
turnout operations. Add the turnout in JMRI and make sure the feedback mode is
set for MONITORING.

-Ken Cameron, Member JMRI Dev Team
www.jmri.org
www.fingerlakeslivesteamers.org
www.cnymod.com
www.syracusemodelrr.org


 

Thanks, I will give that a try. I had thought maybe it was obvious but I am a bit of a beginner!
Would the same think work with semaphore signals?
regards
Andy


 

Andy,

Please clarify your question about working with signals. Normal case the
computer provides the logic to implement the signals so it knows what's
happening.

-Ken Cameron, Member JMRI Dev Team
www.jmri.org
www.fingerlakeslivesteamers.org
www.cnymod.com
www.syracusemodelrr.org


 

Ken
thats sorted my point motor feedback - many thanks.
I next want to operate my signals from JMRI and / or my NCE throttle (via accessory commands).
I have not yet started this but assume if points can generate feedback maybe semaphores could to?
regards
Andy


 

Also has anyone ever looked at creating lower quadrant semaphores for JMRI


 

Andy,

On 9 May 2023, at 4:03 am, andy.keane@... wrote:

thats sorted my point motor feedback - many thanks.
I next want to operate my signals from JMRI and / or my NCE throttle (via accessory commands).
I have not yet started this but assume if points can generate feedback maybe semaphores could to?
If your semaphore decoders are driven by Turnout (SELECT ACCY) commands, the MONITORING facility in the Power Pro command station will work.

If your semaphore decoders are driven by Signal Aspect. (SHIFT CLEAR) commands, the MONITORING facility in the Power Pro command station will not work.

Dave in Australia


 

Andy,

Now you are getting into a fuzzy area. It will all depend on the signal
hardware. Some masts assign different turnout numbers to select different
aspects on a mast. Some use special signal accessory commands. There are a
couple of more options but you get the idea, you have to match whatever that
hardware wants. Some hardware doesn't do masts, it does heads, JMRI would make
them into a mast and then talk to each of the heads to make things happen.

But which ever way is used, JMRI does not try to reconstruct the value for a
mast from some combination of lower level items. Meaning if the physical mast
hardware uses turnout commands to each head, a mast in JMRI won't follow those
commands. Trying to think it up the tree so to speak misses some details so it
doesn't work. But more importantly by not trying to follow those lower commands
prevents JMRI from getting into a loop of change.

-Ken Cameron, Member JMRI Dev Team
www.jmri.org
www.fingerlakeslivesteamers.org
www.cnymod.com
www.syracusemodelrr.org


 

Ken, are you aware of anyone operating traditional BR signalling from the pre-war era using multiple heads on a single mast to indicate different routes? So I have points (switches) with a mast in front of them where there are two semaphore arms (heads) one for each direction.
thanks
Andy


 

Maybe I should start a fresh topic for this?