Keyboard Shortcuts
Likes
Search
Homemade Half Moon Footswitch
I'm having a weird problem. I bought a Booker LBB to use my guitar with my Leslie 122. It works quite nicely. It requires a footswitch to change speeds. So I built one. The standard for the CU-1 Half Moon switches is that you ground either the tip or the ring to select fast/slow. Oddly, to my mind, what you're grounding is 12V. Now, sometimes, but only on occasion, those 12 volts will get passed into the casing of the footswitch and the cable connectors and give you a slight shock. How does the CU-1 handle this? Is the whole mechanism electrically isolated? Or am I missing some essential information about how this is meant to work? Why, for instance, doesn't it always shock me if it's passing 12V to ground no matter which speed is selected? I'm very confused. Thanks for any help you can give.
|
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Mar 23, 2020, at 16:25, andrew.bryce.howard@... wrote:
|
I just got off the phone with James and Tom at Booker Labs. They heard about my post through the grapevine and have offered to look the switch over while they’re modding my LBB.? Thanks for offering to help, regardless!?
|
开云体育Well, to start with, 12 volts isn't enough to give you a shock. You could for example grab one terminal of a car battery with each hand and not feel a thing, even with wet hands. Secondly, you're not switching a high current 12 volt source to ground, you're connecting 12 volts through a resistor to ground. When the switch is open, this 12 volts is used to switch the internal logic of the LBB to one state, when the switch closes the 12 volt input to the logic becomes 0 volts and the logic changes state and operates the internal switching? to change the Leslie speed. If you're sometimes getting a small shock from the switch this
suggests that some AC mains current is getting to the chassis
ground of the Leslie or the LBB. This shouldn't be able to happen
if everything is properly grounded to a three pin power outlet. If
there was anything more than the slightest leakage, the safety
breaker on current house wiring systems would trip and cut the
power off. If you're using a two pin power oulet, it's not
uncommon for mains transformers in vintage equipment (such as a
122 Leslie) to have enough leakage (strictly speaking the charging
current of inter winding capacitance rather than an actual
connection) to cause sufficient AC voltage to appear on the
chassis of the Leslie, and thus the chassis of any connected
equipment, to cause a "tingling" sensation when the chassis is
touched.? If the two pin mains plug isn't polarised, you may well
find that you get a tingle with the plug in one way round but not
the other. On 24/03/2020 17:37,
andrew.bryce.howard@... wrote:
--
|
开云体育After my last post, I googled the LBB and looked at it on their
website. As you say it does have a two pole mains connector. As
the Leslie is powered through the LBB, it effectively also has a
two pole connector. I would say that the small shock you are
getting is almost certainly coming from the Leslie, due to the
charging current of the interwinding capacitance, rather than any
breakdown of insulation. The best work around, without going to
the trouble of providing a mains ground to the Leslie chassis, is
to find which way round the mains input plugs are fitted when you
don't get a shock, both the inlet to the LBB, and the wall plug.
Then mark the plugs so that you always fit them this way around.
Maybe Booker Labs will be happy to fit a three prong, grounded
mains inlet for you when they do the other mods. The only possible
downside of grounding old equipment with this problem is that
enough current may flow to ground to trip modern safety breakers.
You may remember the recent discussion about replacing the mains
wiring on a B-3. Some people said they always update to three
prong grounded mains connectors when rewiring, others said no
because of problems with safety circuit breakers tripping. There's
no easy answer to this, one of the joys of using vintage
electrical equipment! I well remember 40+ years ago when clubs
started fitting saftey circuit breakers to their stage power
supply to protect artistes, even brand new Hammonds and Leslies in
perfect working order could sometimes cause these circuit breakers
to trip out. On 25/03/2020 18:08,
andrew.bryce.howard@... wrote:
It's certainly not much of a shock. A little more so than licking a 9V battery. --
|
Wow. I wouldn't have guessed that adding a grounding pin could be problematic. I'll ask the Booker guys what they think. That's probably why it's two-prong in the first place. Thanks for the advice. If it comes to it, I'll try flipping the plug when I get it back and see if it still happens. It's not consistent already, so might be hard to say.
Andrew |