开云体育

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

Re: Meteor echos of the day

 

There was another set of weird echos earlier.


Meteor echos of the day

 

开云体育

Here are several interesting echoes. Starting with the echo bottom left. This was seen by NW Hampshire with horizontal polarisation and by Armagh but not by NW Hampshire with vertical polarisation or by Norman Lockyer.

The echo upper right seen by NW Hampshire with vertical polarisation and only faintly by Armagh was unseen by Norman Lockyer and NW Hampshire with horizontal polarisation. The distinct straight line start of this echo and it's slight slope from lower left to upper right suggest that the meteor passed through an area with wind shear as the negative Doppler shift at the start suggests and extending reflection path while the positive Doppler shift suggests a reducing reflection path. This cannot be explained by the motion of a meteor. Or can it ?? In the future we hope to be able to answer this question using the raw data from the receivers that has much higher resolution in time that it is not practical to show on the live displays. Brian





Meteor echo of the day

 

开云体育

Although fairly quiet an average of two or more echoes per minute have been seen most mornings lately. In today's screenshot the NW Hampshire H Pol receiver sees two echoes only one of which is seen by the co-located V Pol receiver. The very feint echo observed by the Norman Lockyer receiver is most likely the same one seen on both the NW Hampshire receivers while Armagh saw neither. The upper echo seen by the Norman Lockyer receiver appears to have been unseen by any of the other receivers. So once again the observations show that the echoes are directional and linearly polarised despite the incident illumination being Right Hand Circular Polarised. Improvements we are working on will enable accurate correlation of echoes received at the different locations but this will be achieved by post processing as it isn't practical to do so on the live displays. There is guidance on using the system at and more notes are available at ? Brian


Meteor echo of the day

 

开云体育

Here are two meteor echoes seen by NW Hampshire along with the full bandwidth horizontal lines which are lightning strikes from a local Thunderstorm unseen by the other receivers.

Note that the lightning interference is stronger on the? vertically polarised system.




Meteor echoes of the day

 

开云体育

An early start enabled me to capture some interesting echoes this morning while working on other things. You can capture your own observations at

This interesting echo is more or less omni directional and un-polarised. Note the differences in Doppler shifts with Norman Lockyer centred with positive Doppler, NW Hampshire centred with Zero Doppler and Armagh with only slight positive Doppler.??

The spread of Doppler is most likely due to wind shear in the region through which the meteor passed.

This echo is clearly directional and polarised as it was not seen by Armagh or by NW Hampshire with vertical polarisation.? It is possible that the direction in which the receive antennas point accounts for why some receivers see an echo and others don't but this is unlikely as all the antennas cover most of the region illuminated by the beacon and the cut off is gradual.

Brian




Meteor echo of the day.

 

开云体育

Today's screenshot shows what are most likely the same echo viewed from three different locations. The vertical scales are not precisely aligned due to processing delays, a problem which can be overcome when the raw receiver data with precision timing is available so that echoes viewed from different stations can be correlated precisely. This is not be possible on the live display.? The echo received at Norman Lockyer is feint and has a positive Doppler shift of more than 20Hz while the same echo viewed from Armagh and NW Hampshire has close to zero Doppler shift. The vertical polarised receiver is seeing a slightly stronger echo than the horizontally polarised receiver in this example.

Brian


Re: Echoes of the day

 

Circular Polarisation is used to ensure that if the reflecting target has any polarising properties as a wire or cylinder with a diameter small compared to the illuminating wavelength would, that some energy is reflected. If linear polarisation were used and was cross polarised with the reflector little energy would be reflected.
There is also a difference in the electric field strength between a circular polarisation (CP) and linear incident radiation of a factor of two.? For the same transmitted power a meteoroid trail perfectly normal to and aligned with a linear field would scatter twice as much power as in a CP field. If one used vertical polarisation there are very few horizontal meteoroid trails to be cross polarised.? The choice of CP would be a case of "swings and roundabouts" and it take some thinking about ...?

BRAMS for example also use RHCP.?Do you know what polarisation Graves uses ??
It is published that GRAVES used vertically polarised receiving antennas and, although the transmission polarisation is unknown I can see no benefit in it being anything other than vertical.
If the reflecting object were? for example? a sphere, large in diameter compared to the illuminating wavelength, it would reflect the incident signal with RHCP as? LHCP.
Radars at higher frequency this change is used to reject rain which is spherical and accept aircraft for example.
It would be interesting to put this to the test using two co located receivers one with RHCP and one with LHCP.? Sadly with my other commitments I can't volunteer to do that but perhaps someone else would like to investigate ?
I operate three receiving systems with various antenna configurations.? This provides full sky coverage.

I? am not familiar with the acronym GPV ?
GPV = Ground Plane Vertical.? As a transmitter antenna it would provide something similar to the dipole doughnut shape radiation pattern.? Again one needs to think about the distribution of possible meteoroid trails and the benefits of direct signal reduction to evaluate its potential.? If it were me I would give it a try - but maybe something for you to experiment with in the future.??


Re: Echoes of the day

 

开云体育

Circular Polarisation is used to ensure that if the reflecting target has any polarising properties as a wire or cylinder with a diameter small compared to the illuminating wavelength would, that some energy is reflected. If linear polarisation were used and was cross polarised with the reflector little energy would be reflected.

BRAMS for example also use RHCP.?Do you know what polarisation Graves uses ??

If the reflecting object were? for example? a sphere, large in diameter compared to the illuminating wavelength, it would reflect the incident signal with RHCP as? LHCP.

It would be interesting to put this to the test using two co located receivers one with RHCP and one with LHCP.? Sadly with my other commitments I can't volunteer to do that but perhaps someone else would like to investigate ?

I? am not familiar with the acronym GPV ?

Brian

?24/03/2024 20:21, Mike German via groups.io wrote:

Why is th tx antenna CP?
Have you considered a GPV? ?It may help reducing direct wave if horizontal polarised Rex antennas are used.?


Re: Echoes of the day

 

Why is th tx antenna CP?
Have you considered a GPV? ?It may help reducing direct wave if horizontal polarised Rex antennas are used.?


Re: Echoes of the day

 

yes it's difficult thinking about what the polarisation is the meteoroid ?and then how this is seen at the receiver. ?One needs to consider azimuth and elevation angles

Are these the azimuthal pattern over ground?
Can you calculate what does the elevation pattern looks like.?


Re: Echoes of the day

 

开云体育

Hello Mike

The X and Y plots look similar but I would not claim that we are able to make any precise measurements of polarisation, just a strong indication. Another problem is that it is very difficult to maintain good circularity far off the Bore Sight for the transmit antenna.

It would be good to have observations with both polarisations from two or more locations.

Brian


On 24/03/2024 13:39, Mike German via groups.io wrote:

Do the NW Hampshire H and V polarisation antennas have the same radiation patterns?


Re: Echoes of the day

 

开云体育

Hello Mike

A good question !? The Moxon rectangle calculator has the facility to calculate the main lobes but I've forgotten how to work it ! I need to re visit it. see

Brian

On 24/03/2024 13:39, Mike German via groups.io wrote:

Do the NW Hampshire H and V polarisation antennas have the same radiation patterns?


Re: Echoes of the day

 

Do the NW Hampshire H and V polarisation antennas have the same radiation patterns?


Echoes of the day

 

开云体育

?This screenshot shows? the outputs from 4 of the receivers in our network as waterfall displays which can be viewed live at

This example shows an echo seen only by the Norman Lockyer receiver?? and another seen by the Armagh receiver and the NW Hampshire receiver with the Vertically polarised antenna but not by the receiver at the same location with a horizontally polarised antenna. Today's screenshot? illustrates? the? directional and polarised nature of meteor echoes despite being illuminated with circular polarisation.The Malvern receiver is OFF and the Much Wenlock receiver is a development system which currently sees few echoes.

The vertical, time scale of the waterfall is about 30 seconds. Much more detail will be available when we are able to stream the live feeds from the receivers.?

Brian


illustrates the


Re: observing with GB3MBA

 

开云体育

There is an interest article here??on AI and meteor type recognition by Wilhelm Sicking who has written several articles on the methodology.?


Mike German
High Peak
Hayfield?


Hackaday video on GB3MBA Meteor Beacon

 

I just discovered that 'Hackaday' has featured a 'Tech Minds' video on receiving the meteor beacon at Buxton.



Tony


Re: observing with GB3MBA

 

开云体育

Hello Roo

That sounds like a great idea. I've attached? the last four screenshots that I have grabbed. They are fairly representative, with some "typical" echoes, some aircraft and direct signals that need to be recognised and ignored and one of the strange echoes that need more explaining. ? Note that not all receivers see the same echos due to their directional nature and and the H and V systems give different results due to the linear polarisation of the echoes. ? We are working on some improvements to the live display at so there will be some changes in the pipeline. The main ones will be to increase in displayed bandwidth, currently +/-30Hz will increase to +/- 100Hz. Also, currently the dynamic range from dark to bright is about 10dB and linear. We may change that.

If those screen grabs are OK for your purposes you can garb you own from the live stream. Best time is in the first half of the day unless there's a shower.

I also attach a 5th screenshot of one of the more unusual echoes showing a tail with lots of wind shear ?

Ultimately we are working towards making the raw data available that will have greater bandwidth and precision timing with resolution to about 1mS so that results from different receivers can be correlated.

Good Luck

All the best

Brian


On 20/03/2024 11:39, Rupert Powell wrote:

Brian

Some time ago I proposed we should take a look at some AI based meteor identification. As you are now able to start collecting images containing meteor strikes, which can be verified, it would be possible to create a set of data for an AI system to learn from.

Having now settled in to my new home (2-years today since I moved in) I am starting to get some free time to allow for this sort of thing. Therefore I am going to resurrect my work in this area and look to stating some trials with learning style pattern recognition in an attempt to automate the detection and collection of meteor events.

If yo already have a set of images from your monitoring maybe you could make them available to me so I can start building the model to teach the AI device?

Best wishes

Roo
--
Rupert Powell

rupert@...


T: +44 (0)7969 87 40 82


On Sun, 17 Mar 2024 at 11:16, Brian <brian@...> wrote:

Now with the GB3MBA meteor beacon back ON how about making some observations ?

Few people have time to look at a screen for long and I certainly don't.? The way I make observations is by using a second screen on my PC while continuing with other work. I put on the second screen and if, while doing other things, I see something interesting I grab a screenshot of the live stream from all the receivers using “Snipit” , ( + Win +Shift +S ) and save the second screen. Best times are in the mornings UK Time or if there is a recognised shower of course expect to see about two echoes per minute.?

Things to note include the spread of Doppler shift of the head and tail echoes, duration of the tail echo, and which receivers in the network see the echoes. Head echoes are highly directional and linearly polarised. Note the difference between the horizontal and vertical polarised systems at NW Hampshire.

For very little investment of time and effort I'm sure you'll see all sorts of interesting echoes and your feedback will enable us to improve the system. Attached are some notes and examples. We are improving the system and your feedback will help us to achieve the best results.

Regards

?Brian

Attachments:


Re: observing with GB3MBA

 

Brian

Some time ago I proposed we should take a look at some AI based meteor identification. As you are now able to start collecting images containing meteor strikes, which can be verified, it would be possible to create a set of data for an AI system to learn from.

Having now settled in to my new home (2-years today since I moved in) I am starting to get some free time to allow for this sort of thing. Therefore I am going to resurrect my work in this area and look to stating some trials with learning style pattern recognition in an attempt to automate the detection and collection of meteor events.

If yo already have a set of images from your monitoring maybe you could make them available to me so I can start building the model to teach the AI device?

Best wishes

Roo
--
Rupert Powell

rupert@...


T: +44 (0)7969 87 40 82


On Sun, 17 Mar 2024 at 11:16, Brian <brian@...> wrote:

Now with the GB3MBA meteor beacon back ON how about making some observations ?

Few people have time to look at a screen for long and I certainly don't.? The way I make observations is by using a second screen on my PC while continuing with other work. I put on the second screen and if, while doing other things, I see something interesting I grab a screenshot of the live stream from all the receivers using “Snipit” , ( + Win +Shift +S ) and save the second screen. Best times are in the mornings UK Time or if there is a recognised shower of course expect to see about two echoes per minute.?

Things to note include the spread of Doppler shift of the head and tail echoes, duration of the tail echo, and which receivers in the network see the echoes. Head echoes are highly directional and linearly polarised. Note the difference between the horizontal and vertical polarised systems at NW Hampshire.

For very little investment of time and effort I'm sure you'll see all sorts of interesting echoes and your feedback will enable us to improve the system. Attached are some notes and examples. We are improving the system and your feedback will help us to achieve the best results.

Regards

?Brian

Attachments:


observing with GB3MBA

 

开云体育

Now with the GB3MBA meteor beacon back ON how about making some observations ?

Few people have time to look at a screen for long and I certainly don't.? The way I make observations is by using a second screen on my PC while continuing with other work. I put on the second screen and if, while doing other things, I see something interesting I grab a screenshot of the live stream from all the receivers using “Snipit” , ( + Win +Shift +S ) and save the second screen. Best times are in the mornings UK Time or if there is a recognised shower of course expect to see about two echoes per minute.?

Things to note include the spread of Doppler shift of the head and tail echoes, duration of the tail echo, and which receivers in the network see the echoes. Head echoes are highly directional and linearly polarised. Note the difference between the horizontal and vertical polarised systems at NW Hampshire.

For very little investment of time and effort I'm sure you'll see all sorts of interesting echoes and your feedback will enable us to improve the system. Attached are some notes and examples. We are improving the system and your feedback will help us to achieve the best results.

Regards

?Brian


Re: VLF Transmitters in Australia

 

开云体育

Hello,

??? ??? There is a VLF station guide at but it is still dated in 2000, so probably not very reliable now. It does list a signal at 22.8kHz from Holt, N.W Cape, but the vast majority of entries are in the northern hemisphere. You may be able to find signals using spectrumlab software. It uses the sound card on a PC, with a loop aerial plugged into the microphone socket. By rotating the aerial, you may be able to identify some active frequencies.

Not much help, I'm afraid,
Best wishes,
John.

On 17/03/2024 05:39, Nick Tate wrote:

Hello everyone.

?

I am based in Australia, and I am aware of the Exmouth VLF Transmitter.

?

Is anyone aware of any other VLF transmitters in or near Australia.

?

Thanks

?

Nick

?

?

Dr Nick Tate

Haroldton

80 Mowbray Terrace

EAST BRISBANE,

Queensland 4169

Australia

?

+61 412 674010