My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive) Q502 gets very hot and its gate-source voltage goes to below -2V With supply voltage at 9Volt the gate-source voltage of Q502 is -1.4V I can use the QMX at 9V which is as intended, but something is not right I have checked for shorts and I cant find any. In transmit the buck converter works as intended and Q502 stays cool Any suggestions someone? 73 de SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
On Mon, Jul 24, 2023 at 10:58 PM, <Ugglekatten@...> wrote:
My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive)
Hi Gunnar.? You say that the QMX works fine with good receive and output power when operating with 9V.? Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? ? -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
Peter,
Gunnar should be able to receive at 12v without drawing excessive current. Had he wired for 12v operation, that would be mandatory. I believe he is correct in his assessment that something is amiss.
JZ KJ4A?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 6:37 AM G3SPL < leepd60@...> wrote: On Mon, Jul 24, 2023 at 10:58 PM, <Ugglekatten@...> wrote:
My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive)
Hi Gunnar.? You say that the QMX works fine with good receive and output power when operating with 9V.? Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? ? -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
On 25/07/2023 10:37, G3SPL wrote: Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? Peter, That is a good question. But it does seem strange. Assuming that transmit is not attempted I'd expect the current to go down as voltage is increased due to the switched regulators on board. 73 Alan G4ZFQ
|
Gunnar,
It is as if the feedback loop that controls the bias buck converter is not working.
Check at both sides of R505 to make sure the ADC is getting a converter output sense signal. Check at the gate of Q501 to make sure a controlling PWM signal is present.
JZ KJ4A?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:05 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Peter,
Gunnar should be able to receive at 12v without drawing excessive current. Had he wired for 12v operation, that would be mandatory. I believe he is correct in his assessment that something is amiss.
JZ KJ4A?
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 6:37 AM G3SPL < leepd60@...> wrote: On Mon, Jul 24, 2023 at 10:58 PM, <Ugglekatten@...> wrote:
My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive)
Hi Gunnar.? You say that the QMX works fine with good receive and output power when operating with 9V.? Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? ? -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023 at 12:06 PM, John Z wrote:
Peter,
?
Gunnar should be able to receive at 12v without drawing excessive current. Had he wired for 12v operation, that would be mandatory. I believe he is correct in his assessment that something is amiss.
?
JZ KJ4A?
?
?Good point, John! -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
Gunnar, one more thing... With power off check the resistance from Q502 gate to drain and gate to source. If a short to gate has developed both Q502 and Q501 will exhibit elevated temperatures.
JZ
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:35 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Gunnar,
It is as if the feedback loop that controls the bias buck converter is not working.
Check at both sides of R505 to make sure the ADC is getting a converter output sense signal. Check at the gate of Q501 to make sure a controlling PWM signal is present.
JZ KJ4A?
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:05 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Peter,
Gunnar should be able to receive at 12v without drawing excessive current. Had he wired for 12v operation, that would be mandatory. I believe he is correct in his assessment that something is amiss.
JZ KJ4A?
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 6:37 AM G3SPL < leepd60@...> wrote: On Mon, Jul 24, 2023 at 10:58 PM, <Ugglekatten@...> wrote:
My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive)
Hi Gunnar.? You say that the QMX works fine with good receive and output power when operating with 9V.? Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? ? -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
For completeness, check Q501 for shorts as well.? JZ
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:56 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Gunnar, one more thing... With power off check the resistance from Q502 gate to drain and gate to source. If a short to gate has developed both Q502 and Q501 will exhibit elevated temperatures.
JZ
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:35 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Gunnar,
It is as if the feedback loop that controls the bias buck converter is not working.
Check at both sides of R505 to make sure the ADC is getting a converter output sense signal. Check at the gate of Q501 to make sure a controlling PWM signal is present.
JZ KJ4A?
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 7:05 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Peter,
Gunnar should be able to receive at 12v without drawing excessive current. Had he wired for 12v operation, that would be mandatory. I believe he is correct in his assessment that something is amiss.
JZ KJ4A?
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 6:37 AM G3SPL < leepd60@...> wrote: On Mon, Jul 24, 2023 at 10:58 PM, <Ugglekatten@...> wrote:
My newly built QMX has a strange behaviour... When supply voltage is 9V current consumption on receive is 110mA on tranmit 1.27A Output power is fine on all bands. I can hear signals on all bands But when i raise supply voltage to 10.5V the current consumtion goes to 220mA, at 11V it goes to 300mAn (always in receive)
Hi Gunnar.? You say that the QMX works fine with good receive and output power when operating with 9V.? Why are you trying to run a higher voltage supply? ? -- Peter Lee G3SPL
|
Thank you all for your answers, I will try to answer all your questions in the order received:
Peter G3SPL, well I noted that the minimum power consumption occurred at 9.2V. If everything was OK it would get lower at higher voltage, but not. This is an indication that something is not right
John Z and Alan, you came to the same conclusion as I did
All measurements are taken with a supply voltage of 9.0V
John Z: both sides of R505 show 0.749V DC, no AC signal superimposed PWM signal on the gate of Q501 is only present during transmit, amplitude 3.3V, goes to 0V between pulses The strange thing is that in receive it does not rest at 0, it rests at 1V. Looks like the PWM output is changed to an input at receive
Q502: resistance gate to source 700kOhm, gate to drain 740 kOhm Q501: resistance gate to source 10/7.3? kOhm, gate to drain 12/28 kOhm The first value with the plus tip ov the DVM connected to the gate, the second with the minus tip
My own conclusion: the signal on the gate of Q501 should be at 0V in receive... maybe i should try with a 10kOhm pulldown resistor in parallell with R502??
br SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
Gunnar,
Your observation of 1 volt at the PWM input is strongly suggestive of a gate to drain short in Q501. The resulting current flow into the microcontroller pin could overwhelm its ability to hold a down level.
Check that Q501 for unusual gate to drain resistance. With power off you should see numbers in the vicinity of 100K ohms. Much less would indicate a gate oxide failure in Q501.
JZ
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Thank you all for your answers, I will try to answer all your questions in the order received:
Peter G3SPL, well I noted that the minimum power consumption occurred at 9.2V. If everything was OK it would get lower at higher voltage, but not. This is an indication that something is not right
John Z and Alan, you came to the same conclusion as I did
All measurements are taken with a supply voltage of 9.0V
John Z: both sides of R505 show 0.749V DC, no AC signal superimposed PWM signal on the gate of Q501 is only present during transmit, amplitude 3.3V, goes to 0V between pulses The strange thing is that in receive it does not rest at 0, it rests at 1V. Looks like the PWM output is changed to an input at receive
Q502: resistance gate to source 700kOhm, gate to drain 740 kOhm Q501: resistance gate to source 10/7.3? kOhm, gate to drain 12/28 kOhm The first value with the plus tip ov the DVM connected to the gate, the second with the minus tip
My own conclusion: the signal on the gate of Q501 should be at 0V in receive... maybe i should try with a 10kOhm pulldown resistor in parallell with R502??
br SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
Oh, I see you have already done that! Your numbers do suggest a failed transistor.
JZ
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Tue, Jul 25, 2023, 10:26 AM John Zbrozek < jdzbrozek@...> wrote: Gunnar,
Your observation of 1 volt at the PWM input is strongly suggestive of a gate to drain short in Q501. The resulting current flow into the microcontroller pin could overwhelm its ability to hold a down level.
Check that Q501 for unusual gate to drain resistance. With power off you should see numbers in the vicinity of 100K ohms. Much less would indicate a gate oxide failure in Q501.
JZ
Thank you all for your answers, I will try to answer all your questions in the order received:
Peter G3SPL, well I noted that the minimum power consumption occurred at 9.2V. If everything was OK it would get lower at higher voltage, but not. This is an indication that something is not right
John Z and Alan, you came to the same conclusion as I did
All measurements are taken with a supply voltage of 9.0V
John Z: both sides of R505 show 0.749V DC, no AC signal superimposed PWM signal on the gate of Q501 is only present during transmit, amplitude 3.3V, goes to 0V between pulses The strange thing is that in receive it does not rest at 0, it rests at 1V. Looks like the PWM output is changed to an input at receive
Q502: resistance gate to source 700kOhm, gate to drain 740 kOhm Q501: resistance gate to source 10/7.3? kOhm, gate to drain 12/28 kOhm The first value with the plus tip ov the DVM connected to the gate, the second with the minus tip
My own conclusion: the signal on the gate of Q501 should be at 0V in receive... maybe i should try with a 10kOhm pulldown resistor in parallell with R502??
br SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
John, since the microcontroller can get the PWM voltage down to 0 during transmit, it looks more as if the microcontroller changes the port to an input port for some reason. I attach an image from the oscilloscope showing the beginning of a transmission
|
Gunnar, Either that means your firmware has been corrupted or this is extant and epidemic.
Re-flash your firmware if you believe the first to be true. I can't imagine the second to be true.
My vote remains with Q501 being damaged. I have seen this behavior before on another fellow's QDX. Replacing the transistor restored proper function of the bias generator.
A MOSFET with gate oxide damage may still function to some degree, depending on the level of damage and the strength of the driving circuit. That may be why things seem to be OK in transmit.
Also, the dynamic drive capability of a microcontroller output is not necessarily the same as its static current sinking ability.
Look again at the big difference in measurements you made at Q502 v. Q501. I think changing Q501 is in order.
JZ KJ4A?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
John, since the microcontroller can get the PWM voltage down to 0 during transmit, it looks more as if the microcontroller changes the port to an input port for some reason. I attach an image from the oscilloscope showing the beginning of a transmission
|
John, I accept your analysis, thank you! What finally convinced me was that if I put a pull-down resistor of 2.2kOhm in parallell to R502 the drain voltage of Q501 change is only about 10mV up. It is steady at 7.38V when the source voltage of Q502 is 8.97V. It should be the same, so the conclusion is that Q501 is leaking! I will replace it. Thank you very much for your help
73 de SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
Excellent, Gunnar! I am very? eager to hear that your device is fully restored!?
Good luck and 73 for now!
JZ KJ4A?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
John, I accept your analysis, thank you! What finally convinced me was that if I put a pull-down resistor of 2.2kOhm in parallell to R502 the drain voltage of Q501 change is only about 10mV up. It is steady at 7.38V when the source voltage of Q502 is 8.97V. It should be the same, so the conclusion is that Q501 is leaking! I will replace it. Thank you very much for your help
73 de SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
Yezz !! I replaced Q501, it was not the easiest task, but I got it done. Now everything is fine !! Input current at 9V is 125mA, at 12V it is 100mA with backlight on
Put another feather in your hat John ! (I dont know is this swedish saying is translatable to english, but I think you grasp the meaning...)
73 de SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
Message received, Gunnar! I am delighted that you are up and running again. Enjoy your fabulous new radio!
73 JZ KJ4A?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Yezz !! I replaced Q501, it was not the easiest task, but I got it done. Now everything is fine !! Input current at 9V is 125mA, at 12V it is 100mA with backlight on
Put another feather in your hat John ! (I dont know is this swedish saying is translatable to english, but I think you grasp the meaning...)
73 de SM5EIE / Gunnar
|
It looks like I got the same problem with my QMX(12V version): While using 9V, tx ?current of abt 1.2A with low power output (1-2W).
|