Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
Search
Jazz Guitar and the Internet -- A Good Thing
John Amato
Inveterate Jazz Guitarists,
It's been about a few months since I searched the web for jazz guitar sites that offered a forum type venue where you can discuss and share ideas in common and juxtaposed in order to expand one's vision and capabilities on our beloved instrument, jazz guitar. I go back to 1968 when I started playing, and I have to say, in all honesty, that the amount of material available to us back then, as compared to today, is quite a leap (boggles the mind) over truck loads of information never before available. In just a few short months I must have downloaded charts, instructional materials, fake books (thanks to Juan), mp3s, songs, lyrics, chord charts, sub. charts, jazz harmony manuals, scalar studies, modal studies, rhythm studies -- I could go on and on. And all this, plus loads more, is all available by the click of the mouse. It's quite remarkable in view of the amount of information that is availabble for young players today. Years ago, in order to acquire maybe 1/10 of what you can download in an hour, you'd have to travel to your largest city in your state's music publishing store and, if lucky, they may have what you're looking for -- if not, you'd have toorder it and wait a few weeks. Back then there were not even that many mail order houses. You had to call the publishing co. to find there nearest retailer. But today there is so much material available right on the Internet -- it is just amazing. Having said that, I will venture to go one step further: progress is awesome. We will be seeing great jazz guittarists in a few short years -- partially due to this new media of the internet feeding data at such a speed. Back when I was in college searching out study material, movation was a prime factor (same as today) in the amount of time it took to improve on the instrument. Material, of course, was limited to what you could acquire either from your teacher (if you had one), or from retailers who had to order "jazz guitar" studies -- and you had to wait, and wait till they came in. In t he meanwhile, you would (I would) study what materials you had (and make due), and transcribe songs and solos from records (33rpm), albums. And your "chops" improved over time, basically doing the same as the gigs were lining up ... and you repeated the process (studying your materials over and over agian more than once or twice) as growth was always on the horizon because pracctice and acquiring new studies materials was a constant. Now, I foresee students acquiring skills faster than in my days because of the Internet. And, I really believe, we will see great players in the years ahead. Case in Point: When I studied with Barry Galbraith back in '74, those 42 chord melodies that today have been made public domain, would have cost any one of his students $35 a lesson (each lesson he gave you a new chord melody); tha'ts over $1300; plus, you had to travel to NYC to the Brill building where he was located, or to New Hampshire. With all the information available on the web today, I wonder whether youung players actually appreciate what is really ouut there in the sense of how hard it was to acquire just 1/10 of this materials 20 or 30 years ago. I can see how the art of jazz guitar is in a very healthy state due to the public awareness and availablility of data. But, there is no getting away from "woodshedding." The fact remains that information overload may cause a tendency to see all the available material with no focus or attention to direction, goals and objectives, purposes and intentions. All the material mounted up in plies jst waiting to get practiced is not a focused direction. It's like being in a gigantic candy store with so much candy we are bound to get a belly ache. I say all this in awe of the material on the web, and in a very positive note; however, i have to say to the young players to treat each bit of data with careful analysis as to how it perians to you goals and objectives, and to treat that data with sufficient time, study, and parctice. I would be hesitant to download every single piiece of data I see on jazz guitar because much of it is repetitive, and information overload could very easily cause one to study to become a "jack of all trades,master of none..." My message is this: stick with one thing untill it is mastered and move on ... I say this because years ago, that "one thing" is all we had, and in order tomove on we had to wait for materials that were long time coming -- today they are here, right to your computer HD... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________ Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 |
--- In jazz_guitar@..., John Amato <jamato316@y...>
wrote: With all the information available on the web today, IIt's been pointed out many times that this can be a bad thing too. So much stuff is out there that many people don't learn this stuff by ear anymore (as someone mentioned in another thread). It can sort of lead the the guitar magazine syndrome (where kids can learn licks right away and create meaningless music)... This sort of relates to the ear vs. theory thread. I know it's not either/or, of course, but the fact is that the more theory you start with up front, the less you will learn. (and by the way, the classical composers in the old days didn't just come out and start banging away at the piano creating timeless masterpieces all by ear and natural talent. They had teachers teaching them rules, theory etc...) It's like learning math. You can study math, memorize the rules and then read through all the proofs, but you won't ever become a good mathematician if you don't sit down and try to work out some of the proofs yourself... Anyway, interesting points. I agree somewhat, and I myself am very thankful of the information out there... Ken |
--- In jazz_guitar@..., "kuboken1" <kuboken1@y...> wrote:
This sort of relates to the ear vs. theory thread. I know it's notOoops, meant to say the less you will learn by ear, or organically. Which is fine if at the end it all syncs up. But as I mentioned in my other post (and Alisdair also points out), I think it often doesn't sync up even though many think it will at some point... The one great thing about the internet as far as I'm concerned is the disintermediation of information. I've learned more about other guitarists, up and comers etc... from yjgg and rmmgj than any jazz publication, radio or music store. I've heard more clips of many more different people than would have been available 20 years ago... Back then, if it wasn't in a record store, on the radio, or on TV, I never would have had a chance to hear all these other people... Not to mention Amazon, CDbaby and all those long-tailed internet retailers that can stock a seemingly infinite inventory of CDs (due to the lower physical contraints...) Ken |
John Amato
--- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:
It's been pointed out many times that this can be a...good point John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________ Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 |
John Amato
--- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:
The one great thing about the internet as far as I'm I've heard more clips of many more different people... I second that (e)motion ... .....and I labsolutely love the term, "disintermediation of information" ... is that a Dick Chaney quote...lol John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 ______________________________________________________ Yahoo! for Good Donate to the Hurricane Katrina relief effort. |
I agree, that's a great term I want to steal and use, with or
without attribution to Ken! Disintermediation of information means that the internet did for info what Martin Luther did for prayer. Maintain Marshall --- In jazz_guitar@..., John Amato <jamato316@y...> wrote: --- kuboken1 <kuboken1@y...> wrote:The one great thing about the internet as far as I'm |
This may have been already said (my Jazz Guitar folder
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
is quite full of unread messages): the Internet is a wide and shallow pool of information. Experience is still the great teacher. Mr. Obvious. --- John Amato <jamato316@...> wrote: --- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:The one great thing about the internet as far asI'mconcerned is the |
Quote: "The fact remains that information
overload may cause a tendency to see all the available material with no focus or attention to direction, goals and objectives, purposes and intentions. All the material mounted up in plies jst waiting to get practiced is not a focused direction. It's like being in a gigantic candy store with so much candy we are bound to get a belly ache." Unfortunately, this is happening to me. I would sincerely like to chuck all my mounds of accumulated material and just practice argeggios and chord inversions over and over in all keys. I know that's what I need to do to truly progress, but instead I get bored and frustrated, go through the fakebooks, play a few heads, get stuck, go online, read up on stuff, look at guitars, click on an online store, buy another repetitive instructional item, learn the first few bars of something new, stumble at the first hard bit, decide it's time to look at more guitars. Stupid thing is -- not a single step in the process is unconconcious, I know I'm doing it and also why. I managed to quit smoking. How does one quit flakey practice habits? Cheers, Andy |
--- In jazz_guitar@..., "stottunit"
I managed to quit smoking. How does one quit flakey practicehabits? Easy. Just stop doing them. Learn some tunes and play them. Learn one really good solo (either trasncribed or off of a transcription) and keep playing it. You don't have to throw anything out. Just learn to play tunes and go back to all that material a little at a time on an as needed basis when you want to. The big mistake that I made and many people make is that in jazz there is this 'hurdle' in terms of knowledge and skill you need to achieve before you can play jazz... This is why people end up practicing scales, arps and inversions for years and still can't play anything that sounds remotely like jazz... Just switch around the priorities so that you spend most of your time on learning tunes (or learning one tune really well) and other people's solos. Ken |
--- In jazz_guitar@..., "kuboken1" <kuboken1@y...> wrote:
Oops, I meant the mistake is that in jazz we *think* there is a hurdle in terms of... There might be a little bit, but not as much as you think at first (at least to get to the first level). Just try to learn it the way you learned rock... Ken |
theunknownguitarplayer
I agree that the internet has changed the landscape for guitar
players since days of old. I can't say for sure whether it's good or bad, but it sure is different! In the old days, your universe as a guitar player trying to find his way consisted of the handful of players you might know in your hometown, your teacher (if you had one), the records you owned, and whatever live jazz you were lucky enough to see. There weren't a lot of guitar books, and they often were rooted in older "orchestral" styles (Mickey Baker, wrong as it was, helped a lot of us get started, and the first "orange" Joe Pass Book was a gift from the Gods). You spent an awful lot of time holed up in your room practicing, and would come up for air occasionally to test your progress. Perhaps it's wrong to generalize this way, but my recollection was that the overall mindset of a 60's / 70's guitar player was much more secretive than the very open sharing that goes on today. Today, a player, even in a small town (or country) is much less isolated, as he can tap into a network of players that is huge and available around the clock. To me, the most fascinating (and different) thing about the web, compared to those old days is not just hearing other people play...it's being able to understand how they think. You just didn't have the opportunity to get inside people's heads the way you do today. It's not only listening to and interacting with heavy players that can help. Through the web, you can also learn an enormous amount by observing people who are perhaps not moving in the right direction. Often, it's easier to see the mistake or unhealthy pattern is someone else than it is in yourself. Once you recognize the problem, you can take the necessary steps to correct it, or better still, avoid it altogether. I agree that there are negatives as well as positives. You can easily get distracted, and based on what you read, you could probably convince yourself on a weekly (maybe daily) basis that you need to change styles, buy a new guitar / amp, play like (insert name here), move to (insert place here), buy every CD by (...), study with (...) etc. It's the Flavor of the Month Club gone wild. And as opposed to the Mickey Baker / Joe Pass days, you've got so many people ready to show you "the way" that you can get gridlocked trying to listen to just a small fraction of them. What we all come to learn eventually is that regardless of how much free crap you download and collect off the web, video lessons you take, seminars you attend or musics schools or private lessons you do, all that really is gonna count is what you can truly internalize, as that will be what you can execute "in the moment". The one thing that remains constant, then as now, is that the process of internalization takes place over time, and requires a lot of practice, thought and repitition. A LOT of practice (for many of us, a lifetime). For the player who recognizes where the web ends and practice starts, I'd guess that this is a great time to be studying the guitar. |
John Amato
--- stottunit <andrew_mcconnell_stott@...>
wrote: Unfortunately, this is happening to me. I wouldAndy, Go back to step #1 -- take out your original material, if it was scales and arpeggios -- and put the other material away -- with good teaching there are assigned levels of skill proficiency attached to each level (let's call it "Grade"). learning is facilitated in a braid-like manner: you learn new material only when you have mastered familiar material (which was once unnfamiliar), and as you progress you add new layers of proficiency (like in "braids"). "Braided" because there is never anything new that does not rely, or depend, or gets "braided" to old material. (In fact, this is how we learned decimals, which was "braided" to the prior learning of fractions, which was "braided" to the prior learning of whole numbers, etc., etc.... It is how we learn And, go back to step #1 -- it sounds to me like all the other material you have may be all geared to different grades, or levels, of proficiency ... ....that is why it is so important to hook up with a good teacher... do you have the opportunity to find and study with a good teacher ... ...what area are you from ... plenty of players here can direct you to a good teacher anywhere in the US.... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________ Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 |
John Amato
--- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:
--- In jazz_guitar@..., "kuboken1"Ken, The reality of learning jazz guitar is a subset of learning jazz, ...a subset because the instrument has certain limitations and blindspots that other instruments may not have ... ...having said that, not as an excuse, but as a reality .. learning jazz on the guitar is the highest form of the instrument (and to me the hardest form of guitar) because of onemain thing: IMPROVISATION ... Hear me out ... what we do requires extra specialization ... it requires a high degree of intellectualization (not be misconstrued with "intellegence," as well as feeling, emotion, and all gooey stuff we call "FEEL" ... The closest form of instrumental virtuosity on the guitar, I would say, is Classical Guitar (a subset of that would be Flamenco) ... but, in classical guitar the study of dynamics would be the closest they would come to "improvisation..." But there is absolutley no comparison to what they do and what a jazz guitarist has to learn in order to play "Jazz Guitar". I studied some Classical -- I love lassical guitar, but it's not me ... I have a great respect for classical guitarists ... their's is a hard road ... but it's not "Improv"..... The Flamenco players do employ improvisation, but not the degree as in Jazz.... ...why is jazz guitar so sweet...because it is so hard...because it is such an art that requires dedication and one thing that makes jazz guitarists maybe a step beyond (not above) all the other genres of guitar playing is this: DISCIPLINE & DEDICATION ... ....w/out Discipline anything worthwhile in life will never come to any achieveable height ... ...many young players have to learn discipline -- either before, during, or while they are studying ... there is not such thing as "discipline" after an achieveable goal because the goal will never be reached .... The greatest thing about discipline is this: it gives you a hunger and thirst for the thing you are being discipline in..." ...yep, it's like a circle, the more you pratice and get betterm the more you want to play, and the more you play, the better you get ... and more discipline...etc...etc... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around |
John Amato
--- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:
--- In jazz_guitar@..., "kuboken1"Ken, The reality of learning jazz guitar is a subset of learning jazz, ...a subset because the instrument has certain limitations and blindspots that other instruments may not have ... ...having said that, not as an excuse, but as a reality .. learning jazz on the guitar is the highest form of the instrument (and to me the hardest form of guitar) because of onemain thing: IMPROVISATION ... Hear me out ... what we do requires extra specialization ... it requires a high degree of intellectualization (not be misconstrued with "intellegence," as well as feeling, emotion, and all gooey stuff we call "FEEL" ... The closest form of instrumental virtuosity on the guitar, I would say, is Classical Guitar (a subset of that would be Flamenco) ... but, in classical guitar the study of dynamics would be the closest they would come to "improvisation..." But there is absolutley no comparison to what they do and what a jazz guitarist has to learn in order to play "Jazz Guitar". I studied some Classical -- I love lassical guitar, but it's not me ... I have a great respect for classical guitarists ... their's is a hard road ... but it's not "Improv"..... The Flamenco players do employ improvisation, but not the degree as in Jazz.... ...why is jazz guitar so sweet...because it is so hard...because it is such an art that requires dedication and one thing that makes jazz guitarists maybe a step beyond (not above) all the other genres of guitar playing is this: DISCIPLINE & DEDICATION ... ....w/out Discipline anything worthwhile in life will never come to any achieveable height ... ...many young players have to learn discipline -- either before, during, or while they are studying ... there is not such thing as "discipline" after an achieveable goal because the goal will never be reached .... The greatest thing about discipline is this: it gives you a hunger and thirst for the thing you are being discipline in..." ...yep, it's like a circle, the more you pratice and get betterm the more you want to play, and the more you play, the better you get ... and more discipline...etc...etc... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________ Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 |
In a message dated 9/26/2005 12:42:41 PM Eastern Daylight Time,
andrew_mcconnell_stott@... writes: Quote: "The fact remains that information overload may cause a tendency to see all the available material with no focus or attention to direction, goals and objectives, purposes and intentions. All the material mounted up in plies jst waiting to get practiced is not a focused direction. It's like being in a gigantic candy store with so much candy we are bound to get a belly ache." Unfortunately, this is happening to me. I would sincerely like to chuck all my mounds of accumulated material and just practice argeggios and chord inversions over and over in all keys. I know that's what I need to do to truly progress, but instead I get bored and frustrated, go through the fakebooks, play a few heads, get stuck, go online, read up on stuff, look at guitars, click on an online store, buy another repetitive instructional item, learn the first few bars of something new, stumble at the first hard bit, decide it's time to look at more guitars. Stupid thing is -- not a single step in the process is unconconcious, I know I'm doing it and also why. I managed to quit smoking. How does one quit flakey practice habits? Cheers, Andy I think getting a good teacher is the solution. He/she can be your guide through the morass that's out there. And while he may not see EVERYthing theory-wise or ear-wise, at least you're getting one path through it all. And you have another human being there beside you, not just a website or a book :) Of course, it costs money! But it's a damned good investment, IMHO. Rick Cape Cod |
--- In jazz_guitar@..., John Amato <jamato316@y...>
Hear me out ... what we do requires extraYeah, I understand all that. Sorry for the misunderstanding. My point was that oftentimes, beginners/novices will spend TOO MUCH time on all that theory, scales, modes, arpeggios, inversions at the expense of learning some tunes, transcribing solos and just trying to create music! You can go very far with very little. I bet that if someone learned to play even just a few of the bird solos in the omnibook (can be at half-speed. No need to play it fast. All that stuff sounds really good slow too...) and really internalized it, they will quickly be able to play some decent sounding solos. That was my point... Ken |
Rick_Poll
I've discussed this with several musician friends. It is, apparently,
quite common for people to be scattered in their practice habits. I think it's because there's so much good stuff out there. Every day you hear something new you want to try. And can't resist. My suggestion is to try to figure out the aspect of your playing that sucks the worst. Then, figure out some way to work on it and do it daily. Two examples from my own experience: I recognized that I was better in some keys than others, so I started playing all my old favorites in my "bad" keys using BIAB. I recognized that my ear completely sucks, so I got an ear training program and started working with it daily. Rick - In jazz_guitar@..., "stottunit" <andrew_mcconnell_stott@h...> wrote: stuck, go online, read up on stuff, look at guitars, click on an onlinefew bars of something new, stumble at the first hard bit, decide it'stime to look at more guitars. Stupid thing is -- not a single step in the |
John Amato
--- kuboken1 <kuboken1@...> wrote:
You can go very far with very little.Ken, Tthat is absolutely the ticket -- exactly what I am talking about -- when I started getting into jazz, it was self-motivation, there was very little sources around .. I think I learned the Micky Baker Jazz Chord book #1 & 2 about 3 times -- because we were so limited with materials ... (and I taught from the same books...) ...I remember I flipped out when I found a book by Chuck Wayne in the 70s on arpeggios in the back bins of a music publishing company. It had a moveable transparency template that you would place on top of chord types ... ...so, I transcribed Benson, Dexter Gordon, Sonny Rollins, James Moody, and Charile Christian before they came out with his transcribed solos ... I went out and bought Benny Goodman records checking the back side of the albums to see if Charlie Christian was on the recordings ... I remember spending hours upon hours on Django's "Nuages' ... ...tha's how we cut ouur teeth back then ... today it is operation overload ... and a lot of the kids are getting frustrated because of little direction and no foucus ... they really should have teachers to guide them... ...another truth is this: this art of jazz guitar comes slow ... you can't rush it ... it is so much about life experiences ... the tone I get now was not the tone I got in 1976 or 1984 or 1993 ... tone is a maturing thing ... and I feel my tone changing every day ... ...this art of jazz guitar is about maturing .... can't be rushed ... life can't be rush ... it comes with experience ... when I listen to jazz guitarists the first thing that graps you is his/her lines .. but immeidately that falls away and you are left with "Tone" ... ffor my money I gravitate to the guys with super luscious tone ...and IMO the guys below have most gorgeous tone ... 1. Johnny Smith 2. George Van Eps 3. Wes Montgomery 4. Jimmy Raney 5. Pat Martino ... I know I'm leaving a lot out ... but this is a short list ... ...like I said, when I hear a guitarist, the first thing that hits me are his lines, then ideas, then finally his tone -- and that is where I settle into because that is really what keeps me lsitening -- evenwhen I listen to Joe Pass' "Catch Me" album, when he does "Joy Spring" at lightening speed ... alot of players can play that fast ... but nnot that clean and with that tone ... Tal Farlow has a tone that if he were a bell he'd be in a cathedral, Barney Kessel: killer tone, Herb Ellis too, Jimmy Bruno also has a lightening speed with super tone .. there are no young players with that kind of nimble virtuosity and that tone .. why? becuaser tone comes with years ... time spent with fretborad under fingers -- lots of days and nighst of friction making music ... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________ Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 |
John Amato
--- theunknownguitarplayer
<unknownguitarplayer@...> wrote: The one thing that remains constant, then as now, is..excellent points .. and so true .. when the party is over and everyone has gone home, I put on a Johnny Smith record (opps) CD ... John Amato Music blows the dust off your soul... Isa.55:11 __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around |
to navigate to use esc to dismiss