开云体育

Date

Re: HP200CD oscillator

 

OK, I replaced the Black Cat capacitors C8 & C9, both could hold 0.5uf but had an ESR of around 12 Ohms ? seems high?. Anyway, after replacing them I have a working 200CD after adjusting the amplitude as it appeared to be clipping.

However, several of the voltages are still off and R30 is still scorching hot.

I removed the little PCB that holds C8/C9 (what a task that was) and the associated circuitry after noticing this is where the voltages are definitely different one side to the next suggesting something may be an issue. L2/L3 voltages were substantially different. I pulled L2/L3 and L2 is an open circuit, I can see the tiny wire has broken at one end. So, question is what modern component could I use to replace both L2/L3 ? Again, my lack of understanding is showing but can I use an axial choke ? I am actually wondering if I could repair the wire somehow also.

Regards

Richard


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

On 11/6/21 9:54 PM, peter bunge wrote:
I would like to learn graphics on the RaspberryPi but?I cannot find the right area. It seems to be all games written in Python. It has always seemed?Mickey Mouse to me.
Part of the problem you're hitting is that you're probably looking for information about "graphics programming on a Raspberry Pi", which is not what you should be looking for. (unless you're talking about doing bare-metal framebuffer access, which you probably aren't)

Instead, look into graphics programming on Unix and/or Linux systems on the X Window System. The fact that the hardware platform is a Raspberry Pi makes no difference; the APIs are all the same.

There are lots and lots (and lots) of graphics libraries. Too many. You can code against bare Xlib or Xt, but that's pretty complex. Qt and GTK are two of the most popular, they've both been around for a long time, and have language bindings for essentially all languages. There are good "hello world" tutorials for them that are easily found. I would probably recommend GTK.

Games (and weed) seem to be the only things society is interested in today, so you'll have to shovel your way through all of that garbage to get to anything useful, but there is good grownup material out there.

Everyone has free software but the free MS Visual C++ turned out to be $50/month. I wasted 2 weeks on?that when I got?a?message saying my trial period was over.
I don't remember anything that?said?trial when I downloaded?it. I thought it?was a stripped?down version.
I don't mind a few hundred $ like CCS C that?I use often for programming PICs.
All of the world's best compilers, the ones that are used to build very nearly all of the software that the world runs on, with very few exceptions, are free. CCS is one of those exceptions, but it has a single target architecture family. (most compilers are retargetable) When I say "are free", I don't mean "they have a limited free versions", but are *actually free*, for real. This has been the case for a long time.

-Dave

--
Dave McGuire, AK4HZ
New Kensington, PA


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

开云体育

Replies interleaved

On 11/6/2021 9:54 PM, peter bunge wrote:
Thanks Harvey; I am not ruling anything out. I would like the skills that NewScopes has.

High speed board design, FPGA programming, possibly some microprocessor programming in C or C++.


I will take a look at those displays you mentioned. I can do graphics on a 128x64 LCD using a Digole adapter driven?by a PIC. That is easy.

The F469I-Disco board is an ST micro "discovery" board.? Processor, SDRAM, FLASH RAM, SDcard interface, I2C, USB, built in programmer, SPI, 800 x480 DSI MIPI (an interface) LCD display.


I would like a "C" compiler for my PC. with a useful Graphics library. I just?installed one and wrote a program. Next I will try drawing a box.
Microsoft's Visual C has a "community" version which is free (IIRC).
I would like to learn graphics on the RaspberryPi but?I cannot find the right area. It seems to be all games written in Python. It has always seemed?Mickey Mouse to me.

The hardware isn't, some of the users might be.? Python is nice, but I don't use it.? I do use C and C++, and have used Pascal.


I also need to learn to use the VESA library and find out what software can use it. Is it free? I'm using Prologix and EZGPIB now. It works.

You may just use the graphics additions to your compiler.


Everyone has free software but the free MS Visual C++ turned out to be $50/month. I wasted 2 weeks on?that when I got?a?message saying my trial period was over.?

Community version....


I don't remember anything that?said?trial when I downloaded?it. I thought it?was a stripped?down version.
I don't mind a few hundred $ like CCS C that?I use often for programming PICs.
I am reluctant to learn Python (or Pascal for EZGPIB, or R to?plot, or all the other suggestions that I am told are so easy).

Well, let's see.

STMicro has a free C/C++ compiler based on eclipse which has a chip configuration tool built in for their ARM processor.? If the display on the board you get has a graphics display, you can use it.? Chip setup and low level drivers are provided (drivers in 2 flavors HAL (higher level) and LL (lower level).? Their demo packages use BSP drivers which are a bit more of a complete package and combine some of the chip inits directly.

I've been doing microprocessor graphics for a bit, and am sitting next to a Disco board running an LCARS display with buttons, screen selection, Icons and an RTC.? There are easier ways to do some of that, though.

I'd go for free to start with, and see what you can do.?

You may want to try the ProgramIO platform (IIRC), it also does C, and may do it for the PC.? I think that there's a solution out there that may do graphics in C++, though.? I just don't really program on the PC in C++ for the PC.

You can likely (if you want) use either a Disco board, or maybe a Nucleo 64 board and use an arduino compatible LCD display, which takes care of the graphics angle, although it may only be 320 x 240.

ST also has FreeRTOS as an add-on and it is integrated into their development system.

If you decide to do C++, (which you can) you need to know the limitations of C++ in their system, do contact me off list.

Harvey




Peter


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 9:04 PM Harvey White <madyn@...> wrote:

You don't need to read the entire 1700 page book.? It's useful for finding out exactly what a section does, or if you wish to program in assembly (depending on which 1700 pages).? More important would be the board manual.

Once you start messing with graphics, things can be complicated, but that very much depends on how you do it.? There are drivers available that work on the board, though.?

The one F469I-disco board needs only scaled inputs.? An arduino style breadboard plugged in can likely give you that and you can access the 4 ADC converter inputs and protect the chip with op amp buffers.? The display is 800 x 480 with a 4 inch screen, similar to a cell phone.

There are ways to configure the chip fairly easily.? All you need to do is write C code.?

If you can design and make PC boards, then a Nucleo-144 board with a homemade board can drive an LCD display.? You'll have to roll your own software for that, though, since most of the display hardware would not be supported.?

For smaller projects, there's a Nucleo-32 board which has the same form factor as an arduino Nano.? The Nucleo 64 boards (more powerful processor) have an arduino plugin capability.

Harvey



On 11/6/2021 4:33 PM, peter bunge wrote:
I looked at the 1700 page data sheet for the Arm Cortex 32 bit CPU and the much smaller development board data sheet (30 pages?).
It looks complicated!
I have a RaspberryPi 3 inserted in a SmartiPi Touch Case with wireless ISB keyboard. I think it would be easier to use and it has a higher resolution screen. $350 Cdn if I remember correctly.
It may be easier to replace in 5 years time when the ST becomes obsolete.


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 2:36 PM peter bunge via <bunge.pjp=gmail.com@groups.io> wrote:
I am impressed with the video and would love to add an LCD to my HP4192A Impedance Analyzer that has no CRT and expects an XYY analog pen plotter.
Anyone interested please contact me privately and maybe we can do something.
I also have a Tek 576 Curve Tracer but the CRT is good and I have a spare. I can see the advantages of updating it. Keep me in the loop,?I may be able?to contribute.
I updated my HP8753B with the Newscope LCD and am delighted with it. My HP8757C has a colour LCD and is excellent but a bit dim in bright lighting, as is my HP54542C DSO.
Getting a digital screen capture would be great as well. My 3 HP mentioned have ways to get a screen capture (John Miles 7470A emulator, Prologix USB/GPIB, and a USB floppy reader).
What language is the software written in? I am struggling with a decision to learn Python but have pretty well decided to stick to C which I use for programming PICs. Python would be a huge distraction and time burner for me.
Peter

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 12:49 PM green <hrgerson@...> wrote:

hi,

In the event of instrument CRT death, one might want to do a replacement having an LCD display:

The question is:
-- are there any existing modules ( or schematics, or projects )? that might be used for an HP older instrument having an XY (XYZ or Vector) type CRT that would allow replacement of the CTR with an LCD ( & also provide a laptop connection for data manipulation & saving ) ?

This question is for a Vector type XY or XYZ CRT?? found in some older scopes, ... & ? for example the Tek 576 Curve Tracer ( CT ) :

??? {??? Raster type CRT to VGA type modules can be had inexpensively on eBay for ~ $29,etc.? .... and is not the topic in this thread }

There has been some recent discussion about this for the Tek 576 CT on that Groups .io .... without a resolution as of yet,
but the same solution *might* be of use to older HP instruments as well ?

/g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
and
/g/TekScopes/topic/69490299#164207


Anyway, looking for a solution to this XY ( XYZ, Vector )? type CRT to LCD problem.
{ Not wanting to replace the CRT with another CRT ! }

There is an example of someone doing a retrofit add-on LCD module for an HP 141T 18GHz SA:



The individual did not make any further YouTube video upgrades to that project; but it is a start !
The discussed ST LCD module is not too expensive ( $55 to $130 ).


The video Arcade Game folks do have an expensive module that can do this for their Vector type CRT's,
... discussed in the Tek Curve Tracer CRT discussion : /g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
However, this Tempest module ( ~$525 !! ) & the NewScope modules are way too expensive !
-- So, would not be buying those at all !

So, looking for a less expensive module or schematics of such to attempt a DIY for the XY (XYZ or Vector) CRT to LCD replacement.

>> Anyone having specific detailed technical knowledge for an XY (XYZ, Vector) to LCD module, or schematics? to the above issue ?
? would be appreciated.

thank you,
rick


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

Thanks Harvey; I am not ruling anything out. I would like the skills that NewScopes has.
I will take a look at those displays you mentioned. I can do graphics on a 128x64 LCD using a Digole adapter driven?by a PIC. That is easy.

I would like a "C" compiler for my PC. with a useful Graphics library. I just?installed one and wrote a program. Next I will try drawing a box.
I would like to learn graphics on the RaspberryPi but?I cannot find the right area. It seems to be all games written in Python. It has always seemed?Mickey Mouse to me.
I also need to learn to use the VESA library and find out what software can use it. Is it free? I'm using Prologix and EZGPIB now. It works.

Everyone has free software but the free MS Visual C++ turned out to be $50/month. I wasted 2 weeks on?that when I got?a?message saying my trial period was over.?
I don't remember anything that?said?trial when I downloaded?it. I thought it?was a stripped?down version.
I don't mind a few hundred $ like CCS C that?I use often for programming PICs.
I am reluctant to learn Python (or Pascal for EZGPIB, or R to?plot, or all the other suggestions that I am told are so easy).
Peter


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 9:04 PM Harvey White <madyn@...> wrote:

You don't need to read the entire 1700 page book.? It's useful for finding out exactly what a section does, or if you wish to program in assembly (depending on which 1700 pages).? More important would be the board manual.

Once you start messing with graphics, things can be complicated, but that very much depends on how you do it.? There are drivers available that work on the board, though.?

The one F469I-disco board needs only scaled inputs.? An arduino style breadboard plugged in can likely give you that and you can access the 4 ADC converter inputs and protect the chip with op amp buffers.? The display is 800 x 480 with a 4 inch screen, similar to a cell phone.

There are ways to configure the chip fairly easily.? All you need to do is write C code.?

If you can design and make PC boards, then a Nucleo-144 board with a homemade board can drive an LCD display.? You'll have to roll your own software for that, though, since most of the display hardware would not be supported.?

For smaller projects, there's a Nucleo-32 board which has the same form factor as an arduino Nano.? The Nucleo 64 boards (more powerful processor) have an arduino plugin capability.

Harvey



On 11/6/2021 4:33 PM, peter bunge wrote:
I looked at the 1700 page data sheet for the Arm Cortex 32 bit CPU and the much smaller development board data sheet (30 pages?).
It looks complicated!
I have a RaspberryPi 3 inserted in a SmartiPi Touch Case with wireless ISB keyboard. I think it would be easier to use and it has a higher resolution screen. $350 Cdn if I remember correctly.
It may be easier to replace in 5 years time when the ST becomes obsolete.


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 2:36 PM peter bunge via <bunge.pjp=gmail.com@groups.io> wrote:
I am impressed with the video and would love to add an LCD to my HP4192A Impedance Analyzer that has no CRT and expects an XYY analog pen plotter.
Anyone interested please contact me privately and maybe we can do something.
I also have a Tek 576 Curve Tracer but the CRT is good and I have a spare. I can see the advantages of updating it. Keep me in the loop,?I may be able?to contribute.
I updated my HP8753B with the Newscope LCD and am delighted with it. My HP8757C has a colour LCD and is excellent but a bit dim in bright lighting, as is my HP54542C DSO.
Getting a digital screen capture would be great as well. My 3 HP mentioned have ways to get a screen capture (John Miles 7470A emulator, Prologix USB/GPIB, and a USB floppy reader).
What language is the software written in? I am struggling with a decision to learn Python but have pretty well decided to stick to C which I use for programming PICs. Python would be a huge distraction and time burner for me.
Peter

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 12:49 PM green <hrgerson@...> wrote:

hi,

In the event of instrument CRT death, one might want to do a replacement having an LCD display:

The question is:
-- are there any existing modules ( or schematics, or projects )? that might be used for an HP older instrument having an XY (XYZ or Vector) type CRT that would allow replacement of the CTR with an LCD ( & also provide a laptop connection for data manipulation & saving ) ?

This question is for a Vector type XY or XYZ CRT?? found in some older scopes, ... & ? for example the Tek 576 Curve Tracer ( CT ) :

??? {??? Raster type CRT to VGA type modules can be had inexpensively on eBay for ~ $29,etc.? .... and is not the topic in this thread }

There has been some recent discussion about this for the Tek 576 CT on that Groups .io .... without a resolution as of yet,
but the same solution *might* be of use to older HP instruments as well ?

/g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
and
/g/TekScopes/topic/69490299#164207


Anyway, looking for a solution to this XY ( XYZ, Vector )? type CRT to LCD problem.
{ Not wanting to replace the CRT with another CRT ! }

There is an example of someone doing a retrofit add-on LCD module for an HP 141T 18GHz SA:



The individual did not make any further YouTube video upgrades to that project; but it is a start !
The discussed ST LCD module is not too expensive ( $55 to $130 ).


The video Arcade Game folks do have an expensive module that can do this for their Vector type CRT's,
... discussed in the Tek Curve Tracer CRT discussion : /g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
However, this Tempest module ( ~$525 !! ) & the NewScope modules are way too expensive !
-- So, would not be buying those at all !

So, looking for a less expensive module or schematics of such to attempt a DIY for the XY (XYZ or Vector) CRT to LCD replacement.

>> Anyone having specific detailed technical knowledge for an XY (XYZ, Vector) to LCD module, or schematics? to the above issue ?
? would be appreciated.

thank you,
rick


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

开云体育

You don't need to read the entire 1700 page book.? It's useful for finding out exactly what a section does, or if you wish to program in assembly (depending on which 1700 pages).? More important would be the board manual.

Once you start messing with graphics, things can be complicated, but that very much depends on how you do it.? There are drivers available that work on the board, though.?

The one F469I-disco board needs only scaled inputs.? An arduino style breadboard plugged in can likely give you that and you can access the 4 ADC converter inputs and protect the chip with op amp buffers.? The display is 800 x 480 with a 4 inch screen, similar to a cell phone.

There are ways to configure the chip fairly easily.? All you need to do is write C code.?

If you can design and make PC boards, then a Nucleo-144 board with a homemade board can drive an LCD display.? You'll have to roll your own software for that, though, since most of the display hardware would not be supported.?

For smaller projects, there's a Nucleo-32 board which has the same form factor as an arduino Nano.? The Nucleo 64 boards (more powerful processor) have an arduino plugin capability.

Harvey



On 11/6/2021 4:33 PM, peter bunge wrote:

I looked at the 1700 page data sheet for the Arm Cortex 32 bit CPU and the much smaller development board data sheet (30 pages?).
It looks complicated!
I have a RaspberryPi 3 inserted in a SmartiPi Touch Case with wireless ISB keyboard. I think it would be easier to use and it has a higher resolution screen. $350 Cdn if I remember correctly.
It may be easier to replace in 5 years time when the ST becomes obsolete.


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 2:36 PM peter bunge via <bunge.pjp=gmail.com@groups.io> wrote:
I am impressed with the video and would love to add an LCD to my HP4192A Impedance Analyzer that has no CRT and expects an XYY analog pen plotter.
Anyone interested please contact me privately and maybe we can do something.
I also have a Tek 576 Curve Tracer but the CRT is good and I have a spare. I can see the advantages of updating it. Keep me in the loop,?I may be able?to contribute.
I updated my HP8753B with the Newscope LCD and am delighted with it. My HP8757C has a colour LCD and is excellent but a bit dim in bright lighting, as is my HP54542C DSO.
Getting a digital screen capture would be great as well. My 3 HP mentioned have ways to get a screen capture (John Miles 7470A emulator, Prologix USB/GPIB, and a USB floppy reader).
What language is the software written in? I am struggling with a decision to learn Python but have pretty well decided to stick to C which I use for programming PICs. Python would be a huge distraction and time burner for me.
Peter

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 12:49 PM green <hrgerson@...> wrote:

hi,

In the event of instrument CRT death, one might want to do a replacement having an LCD display:

The question is:
-- are there any existing modules ( or schematics, or projects )? that might be used for an HP older instrument having an XY (XYZ or Vector) type CRT that would allow replacement of the CTR with an LCD ( & also provide a laptop connection for data manipulation & saving ) ?

This question is for a Vector type XY or XYZ CRT?? found in some older scopes, ... & ? for example the Tek 576 Curve Tracer ( CT ) :

??? {??? Raster type CRT to VGA type modules can be had inexpensively on eBay for ~ $29,etc.? .... and is not the topic in this thread }

There has been some recent discussion about this for the Tek 576 CT on that Groups .io .... without a resolution as of yet,
but the same solution *might* be of use to older HP instruments as well ?

/g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
and
/g/TekScopes/topic/69490299#164207


Anyway, looking for a solution to this XY ( XYZ, Vector )? type CRT to LCD problem.
{ Not wanting to replace the CRT with another CRT ! }

There is an example of someone doing a retrofit add-on LCD module for an HP 141T 18GHz SA:



The individual did not make any further YouTube video upgrades to that project; but it is a start !
The discussed ST LCD module is not too expensive ( $55 to $130 ).


The video Arcade Game folks do have an expensive module that can do this for their Vector type CRT's,
... discussed in the Tek Curve Tracer CRT discussion : /g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
However, this Tempest module ( ~$525 !! ) & the NewScope modules are way too expensive !
-- So, would not be buying those at all !

So, looking for a less expensive module or schematics of such to attempt a DIY for the XY (XYZ or Vector) CRT to LCD replacement.

>> Anyone having specific detailed technical knowledge for an XY (XYZ, Vector) to LCD module, or schematics? to the above issue ?
? would be appreciated.

thank you,
rick


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

On 11/6/21 4:33 PM, peter bunge wrote:
I looked at the 1700 page data sheet for the Arm Cortex 32 bit CPU and the much smaller development board data sheet (30 pages?).
It looks complicated!
They are complicated, but they're very forgiving, and they don't have the toxic ecosystem of the PIC family. Once you get into small ARM microcontrollers (and now, RISC-V) you will never look back.

I say this because I didn't. I develop with these processors every day; I absolutely love it. No proprietary tools, no Microsoft toys, no dicking around, just getting work done in the most efficient ways possible.

I have a RaspberryPi 3 inserted in a SmartiPi Touch Case with wireless ISB keyboard. I think it would be easier to use and it has a higher resolution screen. $350 Cdn if I remember correctly.
It may be easier to replace in 5 years time when the ST becomes obsolete.
20210509_194618.jpg
Are you under the impression that that model of Pi and those accessories won't become obsolete by then? ;) Just look at how many generations of that stuff there have been over the years.

But either way, booting up (and more importantly, making arrangements to cleanly shut down, every time!) an entire instance of Linux, many millions of lines of code, to digitize and rasterize a display is...well, as a design engineer, let's just say it offends my sensibilities. ;)

-Dave

--
Dave McGuire, AK4HZ
New Kensington, PA


Re: Buying a used VNA

 

Shown is my old HP8754A and my software for it compared with my software for the PNA.?


HP 8665A Latest ROMS

 

The HP8665A?Installation Note 08665-90067 lists 4.2.1 as the last version. I see there is a 4.2.2 in the files section but labeled for the 8665B.
Can this be used on the A version? If not can someone help me out with images for the last version issued for the A?

thanks,
? Michael


Re: New member intro

 

开云体育



On 11/6/21 2:50 AM, Chris Wilkson via groups.io wrote:
Hello Group!

I'm trying to get a handle on my test gear and decided to start looking at my HP hoard.
I need to decide what to keep/fix/purge/replace and finally joining here seemed like a good first step.

I have at least the following items, maybe more hiding unseen in the various piles:

HP:
- several linear power supplies,
- K04-0980A Powerstat
- a gain phase meter (3575A?)
- 33120A function generator
- 3456A voltmeter
- a pair of 1662AS logic analyzers (with at least one keyboard and one mouse...more I think)
- 8505A vector network analyzer with 8501 storage normalizer and 8503A S-parameter kit

Agilent:
- 1147A scope current probe (for the 3034T 'scope below)
- 34410A multimeter
- and maybe a scope in storage?? I need to check on that.

Keysight:
MSOX-3034T oscilloscope

Tektronix:
- approximately 0.42 container ships full of big iron piled ceiling high in the living room

Random other MFG's:
- a pair of IBM Model M keyboards, one for work and one for home (they count as boat anchors too!)
- generally too much stuff !!!
Might be interested in the model M keyboards--are they full size (with numberpad to the right of direction arrow keys, or no numberpad?
(Both were available, and I have one of each.) What are you asking for one or two? (I'm on Long Island, for shipping.)
--doug
?

The immediate goal is to get all of this off the floor and off the benches so I can at least check functionality of everything.
Longer term I want to eliminate redundant gear and fill some holes in the lab and then start playing with stuff again!

Cheers,
-Chris




Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

I looked at the 1700 page data sheet for the Arm Cortex 32 bit CPU and the much smaller development board data sheet (30 pages?).
It looks complicated!
I have a RaspberryPi 3 inserted in a SmartiPi Touch Case with wireless ISB keyboard. I think it would be easier to use and it has a higher resolution screen. $350 Cdn if I remember correctly.
It may be easier to replace in 5 years time when the ST becomes obsolete.
20210509_194618.jpg


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 2:36 PM peter bunge via <bunge.pjp=gmail.com@groups.io> wrote:
I am impressed with the video and would love to add an LCD to my HP4192A Impedance Analyzer that has no CRT and expects an XYY analog pen plotter.
Anyone interested please contact me privately and maybe we can do something.
I also have a Tek 576 Curve Tracer but the CRT is good and I have a spare. I can see the advantages of updating it. Keep me in the loop,?I may be able?to contribute.
I updated my HP8753B with the Newscope LCD and am delighted with it. My HP8757C has a colour LCD and is excellent but a bit dim in bright lighting, as is my HP54542C DSO.
Getting a digital screen capture would be great as well. My 3 HP mentioned have ways to get a screen capture (John Miles 7470A emulator, Prologix USB/GPIB, and a USB floppy reader).
What language is the software written in? I am struggling with a decision to learn Python but have pretty well decided to stick to C which I use for programming PICs. Python would be a huge distraction and time burner for me.
Peter

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 12:49 PM green <hrgerson@...> wrote:

hi,

In the event of instrument CRT death, one might want to do a replacement having an LCD display:

The question is:
-- are there any existing modules ( or schematics, or projects )? that might be used for an HP older instrument having an XY (XYZ or Vector) type CRT that would allow replacement of the CTR with an LCD ( & also provide a laptop connection for data manipulation & saving ) ?

This question is for a Vector type XY or XYZ CRT?? found in some older scopes, ... & ? for example the Tek 576 Curve Tracer ( CT ) :

??? {??? Raster type CRT to VGA type modules can be had inexpensively on eBay for ~ $29,etc.? .... and is not the topic in this thread }

There has been some recent discussion about this for the Tek 576 CT on that Groups .io .... without a resolution as of yet,
but the same solution *might* be of use to older HP instruments as well ?

/g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
and
/g/TekScopes/topic/69490299#164207


Anyway, looking for a solution to this XY ( XYZ, Vector )? type CRT to LCD problem.
{ Not wanting to replace the CRT with another CRT ! }

There is an example of someone doing a retrofit add-on LCD module for an HP 141T 18GHz SA:



The individual did not make any further YouTube video upgrades to that project; but it is a start !
The discussed ST LCD module is not too expensive ( $55 to $130 ).


The video Arcade Game folks do have an expensive module that can do this for their Vector type CRT's,
... discussed in the Tek Curve Tracer CRT discussion : /g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
However, this Tempest module ( ~$525 !! ) & the NewScope modules are way too expensive !
-- So, would not be buying those at all !

So, looking for a less expensive module or schematics of such to attempt a DIY for the XY (XYZ or Vector) CRT to LCD replacement.

>> Anyone having specific detailed technical knowledge for an XY (XYZ, Vector) to LCD module, or schematics? to the above issue ?
? would be appreciated.

thank you,
rick


Re: HP200CD oscillator

 

Largely, PCB transformer oil is sufficiently inert that
it won't hurt you. All that happened to technicians that
had their arms up to their arm-pits daily in PCB oil while
servicing HV supplies, is they got what is called Chloracne.

I'm not saying you should go out of your way to get in
contact with PCB's, but once most everyone did. They were
in lipstick, of all places! Also typewriter ribbons, carbon
paper, NCR paper...

It is highly unlikely that someone not dealing with PCB, in
the trades, will ever get enough exposure to matter.

That is my opinion, take it for what you may.

-Chuck Harris


On Sat, 6 Nov 2021 13:23:20 -0500 "Dave Casey" <polara413@...>
wrote:
Be careful when handling the oil in those old bathtub caps. The older
ones are full of PCBs.

Dave Casey

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 1:15 PM Bob Albert via groups.io <bob91343=
yahoo.com@groups.io> wrote:

Regarding reliability of oil filled capacitors, a while back a
friend had the main filter capacitor of an HP410B fail. It
exploded. It was an oil filled bathtub capacitor, maybe 4
microfarads. As luck would have it (and has had it multiple times)
I had an identical part in my stash and except for cleaning up the
mess, it was a simple repair. The new part had a 1947 date code
and was older than the failed one.

Bob

On Saturday, November 6, 2021, 10:41:26 AM PDT, Richard Knoppow <
dickburk@...> wrote:


I absolutely agree with this. However, all paper caps tend to
become degraded with time. The Sprague caps seem to have had a
peculiar problem and short time failures but all old paper caps
should be suspect.
Old oil filled transmitting caps seem to have a longer life
than the wax filled kind. My understanding is that one function
of the oil is to eliminate air which can cause oxidation of the
paper. This may also have been the reason for using a plastic
impregnant. I thought I saw advertising from Sprague saying that
the Black Beauty caps were plastic impregated but was not later
able to find it. The paper looks like it has a coating of something.
I would certainly be interesting to know the manufacturing
process used for these. It may be buried in the literature
somewhere. In any case really old paper caps of any make or type
should probably be replaced.

On 11/6/2021 6:57 AM, Chuck Harris wrote:
Hi Richard,

I have never seen anything that would lead me to believe
an end cap was glued onto the body of the capacitor, but
maybe that is what they did? Or, maybe the capacitor was
built in halves, and the mold line is really a glue line?

Capacitors of all types ultimately boil down to a pair of
plates, with a dielectric fill between them.

If the dielectric sheet does not fill the space fully, it
greatly reduces the effect of the dielectric on the capacitance.
The oil's greatest contribution is in making an intimate
contact with both plates, and eliminating any air between
the plates. This both improves the capacitor's stability,
and its dielectric strength.

All of my speculation is secondary to the message both of
us should be (are) giving:

Replace oil filled BB capacitors on sight!

I know that ASCII art doesn't work well on these lists, but
if you consider this line below a single axial slice of the
capacitor, it shows the important observable characteristics
of BB capacitors:


==========O(|||..||...)==========

The "O" is a solder blob that seals the oil filler tube.
The "==" is the capacitor's leads.
The "(" and ")" are the domed ends of the capacitor's body.
The "|||" are the color bands on the body...
And, the "..." is just the black body.

-Chuck Harris


On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 22:08:12 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
<dickburk@...> wrote:
I may be wrong about the voltage value, I am going by memory
of the advertising.
I have wondered the same thing about the oil filling. Its
possible the casings were cast and the winding inserted in it. I
don't think the windings were deliberately misshapen but that
might be. I wonder what effect squeezing them would have on the
value. If the spacing remained constant the shape would have
little effect. My own experience in manufacturing is with
precision resistors, I have little idea how capacitors were made.
BTW, the Micamold paper caps seem to have a terrible
reputation. Every one I've encountered was very leaky but they
look find inside. Same with the Solar flat paper caps.
Both of these companies vanished shortly after WW-2, I have
never been able to find out what happened. Solar had space
reserved in an early "Radio's Master" catalog but no entry and
the next issue just was not there.
I've never seen any Micamold caps in -hp- stuff but lots of
Sprague, they must have had something going for them.

On 11/5/2021 9:11 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
Hi Richard,

Bumble bee was a descriptive name based on the colorful
bands used to indicate the capacitor's value and voltage
rating. It was certainly not a brand name.

Tektronix used numerous 400V oil filled versions of this
capacitor. I replaced several dozen in my 513D, so I am
certain that your statement about the 650V version being
the only oil version is incorrect. The 400V rating is one
of the yellow bands that makes it look like a bumble bee.

Every one that I replaced had the oil filler tube.

I have observed that the capacitor "slug" is smaller than
the cavity that it fits into. It had to be, or they would
not have been able to fill the capacitor with oil from the
tube on the end. How did they make that cavity?

It is my impression that if the slug was misshapen, it most
probably was built that way. Perhaps to keep it from rattling
about in the larger cavity that it fit into.

Excepting where the solder sealed filler tube was damaged during
the capacitor's installation, oil filled BB's lasted a very long
time... easily more than 10 years. The ordinary beeswax dipped
paper capacitors became leaky after a year or two.

-Chuck Harris


On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 15:50:59 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
<dickburk@...> wrote:
I want to respond to a couple of things in this thread.
First of all, there were other brands of molded paper caps.
None of these had the consistent problems of the Sprague caps
of cracking and actually breaking. Also, I have disected
number of failed plastic caps but don't see the distorted
windings in others. Something went very wrong with these. The
early caps were coded with the JAN striped coding, hence the
name "Bumble Bee". The actual brand name was Black Beauty. The
650V versions were the oil filled ones, lower voltage were not
oil filled. The oil filled caps are often found with the oil
leaked out. The failure seems to be the seal of the filler
tube. The tube was also the lead on one side having a wire
soldered (maybe welded) into it. If the seal is disturbed by,
for instance, excessive soldering temperature, the oil will
leak out. The SP-600 seems to have had an especial problem
with this. Also, the property of dielectric absorption, which
causes a capacitor to retain some charge after being
discharged, can be a problem with timing and low frequency
circuits. One of the few virtues of paper capacitors is low
dielectric absorption. They are a better choice than mica and
much better than HI-K ceramic caps. Plastic film caps,
particularly of certain types have practically no DA and are
the best choice. I don't think the Black Beauty caps were
particularly low in DA but all paper caps are pretty good.
The Black Beauty line was advertised as a long life, high
quality brand. I think Sprague may have fixed the problems with
them eventually but they got a bad reputation quickly.
Hammarlund went to all ceramic caps and at least military
SP-600's were modified to replace all of the paper caps with
ceramic ones. Those are pretty much trouble free.
Whatever happened it caused physical distortion of the
windings of the caps. That could have come from shrinkage of
the case material as it cooled. It seems to be in both the oil
filled and non filled versions, at least the ones I've
dissected. On 11/5/2021 7:25 AM, greenboxmaven via groups.io
wrote:
Thanks for this very good explanation. In addition to the
points you made, I have read the oil fill was often complete,
and hydrostatic force would test the integrety of the plastic.
Shrinkage and loss of resilience of the case would increase
the chance of cracks and leaks. The late 1940s is a
fascinating time in history for me. There was a great deal of
technological progress made, often with over confidence in
new materials and techniques inspired by wartime successes
that performed very well in the short term but lacked long
term reliability. The "Bumble Bee" condensers were excellent
in one regard- they had very little residual charge in the
dielectric after being fully discharged. When used as a
coupling condenser, that can make a difference.

Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY



On 11/5/21 9:38, Chuck Harris wrote:
BB capacitors were molded as well as the technology of the
day would allow... That is not why they cracked.

The problem is the plastic they used, like most plastics,
shrinks slowly over time, and the wire leads, and especially
the solder sealed oil filler tube, that penetrate the
plastic, don't.

This can cause a crack to form at the weakest point, which is
usually at the mold line formed by slight misalignment of the
mold halves.

When you injection mold plastic, the plastic's internal bonds
stretch out to fill the mold. When the plastic cools, it is
frozen into a state where those bonds are stretched.

Over time, under the continuous stress of these stretched
bonds, the plastic will cold flow into a more relaxed
state... becoming slightly smaller.

The problem is if the plastic is constrained by something
inside of it that cannot shrink.... such as the wire leads,
a gear's hub, or an oil filler tube, something has to give.

If the plastic shrinks around a metal tube, the thickest
parts of the plastic will break the thinest parts forming a
crack, and a leak.

I was told by Deane Kidd, that in the early days, Tektronix
created a situation, ripe for failure with BB capacitors, by
putting them tightly fitted into ceramic or bakelite terminal
strips. When the capacitor's leads were soldered, the heat
traveling down the very short leads would melt the
capacitor's solder seal, allowing the oil to mix with the
solder, and make a leak. In the worst cases, the oil would
drool out leaving the capacitor incapable of withstanding
its rated voltage.

Not to mention it made a greasy dirty mess in their otherwise
very nice looking scopes.

-Chuck Harris

On Thu, 4 Nov 2021 14:40:42 -0400 "greenboxmaven via
groups.io" <ka2ivy@...> wrote:
Sprague "Bumble Bee" and "Black Beauty" condensers were
molded improperly, and they will crack, especially the oil
filled ones, and let in moisture. That seems to react with
the oil and make it conductive as well as corrosive. Once
this happens, leakage gets very bad, especially when the
condenser is heated by surrounding components. Many efforts
have been made to bake and otherwise restore them, but once
the problem begins it can not be reversed. The dielectric
charicteristic is perported to be superb for audio
circuits, and AudioPhools will freak out if these
condensers are replaced, that is until the power
transformer, rectifer, output tubes, and filter choke in
their amplifiers are all incinerated. Not only did
Hammarlund use them in receivers, Collins and National did
as well. Tektronix used them in their equipment, and too
many consumer electronics companies to recall all of them.

Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY

On 11/4/21 13:45, Richard Knoppow wrote:
Who made those? Some early advertising for Sprague Black
Beauty caps said they were plasticized paper. The main
problem with these is some sort of production problem they
had. I have dissected a number of "bumble bee" caps, these
are actually Sprague Black Beauty caps with striped value
markigns. I found the windings were distorted. I suspect
this happened during the encapsulation but don't know.
Some of these caps, the higher voltage ones, were oil
impregnated. The oil was introduced through a tube which
formed one of the leads. It is common for all the oil to
have leaked out due to a lack of sealing at the solder
joint between the tube and the lead. That may have been
due to excessive heat when the caps were installed. The
most notorious of the BB caps are those in the Hammarlund
SP-600, however, they were very widely used including in a
lot of -hp- gear. However, in the receiver it is common to
find cracked or split caps or even caps where part of the
casing has come off. I have not seen that in any other
make of equipment. Perhaps just a bad lot or perhaps some
difference in installation. Nonetheless, ALL paper caps
become degraded with age. The usual symptom is an increase
in series resistance. Leakage, which is another term for
parallel resistance, is sometimes a problem but not as
often. I don't think any of these caps, even the real oil
filled transmitting caps, was intended to have a lifetime
of over about ten years. The life problem was known and
described in some engineering texts. It was dependent
partly on voltage; the closer the voltage to the rated
voltage the shorter the life of the cap. Likely it was
some sort of electrolytic degradation of the paper. In any
case, paper caps should be replaced with modern plastic
film caps. These for the most part will last forever and
generally will improve performance perhaps beyond the
original. There is a good amount of information on the web
about the relative merits of various kinds of plastic
dielectrics. Polypropylene seems to be about the best
especially for RF use.

On 11/4/2021 9:33 AM, Dave Wise wrote:
Even the later plasticized-paper “Prokar” and “DiFilm”
versions can cause trouble in some applications – they may
not be leaky, but their Dielectric Absorption and
Dissipation Factor are “through the roof”.

Dave Wise

*From:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
[mailto:HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io] *On
Behalf Of *greenboxmaven via groups.io
*Sent:* Thursday, November 04, 2021 6:25 AM
*To:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
*Subject:* Re: [HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment] HP200CD
oscillator

ALL Sprague "Black Cat", "Black Beauty" and color striped
"Bumble Bee" condensers should be considered bad on sight.
Unfortunately, they are common in older equipment of all
makes and models. The 630V. polyester condensers are a
fine replacement. The only condensers that are polarized
are electrolytics, poyester condensers are not polarized.

Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY

On 11/4/21 8:51, Richard Merifield wrote:

My unit has Black Cat 0.5MFD 400v axial capacitors
for C8 and C9. Would 630v polyester unpolarised caps be ok
replacements?






--
Richard Knoppow
dickburk@...
WB6KBL












Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

I am impressed with the video and would love to add an LCD to my HP4192A Impedance Analyzer that has no CRT and expects an XYY analog pen plotter.
Anyone interested please contact me privately and maybe we can do something.
I also have a Tek 576 Curve Tracer but the CRT is good and I have a spare. I can see the advantages of updating it. Keep me in the loop,?I may be able?to contribute.
I updated my HP8753B with the Newscope LCD and am delighted with it. My HP8757C has a colour LCD and is excellent but a bit dim in bright lighting, as is my HP54542C DSO.
Getting a digital screen capture would be great as well. My 3 HP mentioned have ways to get a screen capture (John Miles 7470A emulator, Prologix USB/GPIB, and a USB floppy reader).
What language is the software written in? I am struggling with a decision to learn Python but have pretty well decided to stick to C which I use for programming PICs. Python would be a huge distraction and time burner for me.
Peter

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 12:49 PM green <hrgerson@...> wrote:

hi,

In the event of instrument CRT death, one might want to do a replacement having an LCD display:

The question is:
-- are there any existing modules ( or schematics, or projects )? that might be used for an HP older instrument having an XY (XYZ or Vector) type CRT that would allow replacement of the CTR with an LCD ( & also provide a laptop connection for data manipulation & saving ) ?

This question is for a Vector type XY or XYZ CRT?? found in some older scopes, ... & ? for example the Tek 576 Curve Tracer ( CT ) :

??? {??? Raster type CRT to VGA type modules can be had inexpensively on eBay for ~ $29,etc.? .... and is not the topic in this thread }

There has been some recent discussion about this for the Tek 576 CT on that Groups .io .... without a resolution as of yet,
but the same solution *might* be of use to older HP instruments as well ?

/g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
and
/g/TekScopes/topic/69490299#164207


Anyway, looking for a solution to this XY ( XYZ, Vector )? type CRT to LCD problem.
{ Not wanting to replace the CRT with another CRT ! }

There is an example of someone doing a retrofit add-on LCD module for an HP 141T 18GHz SA:



The individual did not make any further YouTube video upgrades to that project; but it is a start !
The discussed ST LCD module is not too expensive ( $55 to $130 ).


The video Arcade Game folks do have an expensive module that can do this for their Vector type CRT's,
... discussed in the Tek Curve Tracer CRT discussion : /g/TekScopes/topic/86718765
However, this Tempest module ( ~$525 !! ) & the NewScope modules are way too expensive !
-- So, would not be buying those at all !

So, looking for a less expensive module or schematics of such to attempt a DIY for the XY (XYZ or Vector) CRT to LCD replacement.

>> Anyone having specific detailed technical knowledge for an XY (XYZ, Vector) to LCD module, or schematics? to the above issue ?
? would be appreciated.

thank you,
rick


Re: HP200CD oscillator

 

Be careful when handling the oil in those old bathtub caps. The older ones are full of PCBs.

Dave Casey


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 1:15 PM Bob Albert via <bob91343=yahoo.com@groups.io> wrote:
Regarding reliability of oil filled capacitors, a while back a friend had the main filter capacitor of an HP410B fail.? It exploded.? It was an oil filled bathtub capacitor, maybe 4 microfarads.? As luck would have it (and has had it multiple times) I had an identical part in my stash and except for cleaning up the mess, it was a simple repair.? The new part had a 1947 date code and was older than the failed one.

Bob

On Saturday, November 6, 2021, 10:41:26 AM PDT, Richard Knoppow <dickburk@...> wrote:


?? I absolutely agree with this. However, all paper caps tend to
become degraded with time. The Sprague caps seem to have had a
peculiar problem and short time failures but all old paper caps
should be suspect.
??? Old oil filled transmitting caps seem to have a longer life
than the wax filled kind. My understanding is that one function
of the oil is to eliminate air which can cause oxidation of the
paper. This may also have been the reason for using a plastic
impregnant. I thought I saw advertising from Sprague saying that
the Black Beauty caps were plastic impregated but was not later
able to find it. The paper looks like it has a coating of something.
??? I would certainly be interesting to know the manufacturing
process used for these. It may be buried in the literature
somewhere. In any case really old paper caps of any make or type
should probably be replaced.

On 11/6/2021 6:57 AM, Chuck Harris wrote:
> Hi Richard,
>
> I have never seen anything that would lead me to believe
> an end cap was glued onto the body of the capacitor, but
> maybe that is what they did?? Or, maybe the capacitor was
> built in halves, and the mold line is really a glue line?
>
> Capacitors of all types ultimately boil down to a pair of
> plates, with a dielectric fill between them.
>
> If the dielectric sheet does not fill the space fully, it
> greatly reduces the effect of the dielectric on the capacitance.
> The oil's greatest contribution is in making an intimate
> contact with both plates, and eliminating any air between
> the plates.? This both improves the capacitor's stability,
> and its dielectric strength.
>
> All of my speculation is secondary to the message both of
> us should be (are) giving:
>
> Replace oil filled BB capacitors on sight!
>
> I know that ASCII art doesn't work well on these lists, but
> if you consider this line below a single axial slice of the
> capacitor, it shows the important observable characteristics
> of BB capacitors:
>
>
> ==========O(|||..||...)==========
>
> The "O" is a solder blob that seals the oil filler tube.
> The "==" is the capacitor's leads.
> The "(" and ")" are the domed ends of the capacitor's body.
> The "|||" are the color bands on the body...
> And, the "..." is just the black body.
>
> -Chuck Harris
>
>
> On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 22:08:12 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
> <dickburk@...> wrote:
>>? ?? I may be wrong about the voltage value, I am going by memory
>> of the advertising.
>>? ?? I have wondered the same thing about the oil filling. Its
>> possible the casings were cast and the winding inserted in it. I
>> don't think the windings were deliberately misshapen? but that
>> might be. I wonder what effect squeezing them would have on the
>> value. If the spacing remained constant the shape would have
>> little effect. My own experience in manufacturing is with
>> precision resistors, I have little idea how capacitors were made.
>>? ?? BTW, the Micamold paper caps seem to have a terrible
>> reputation. Every one I've encountered was very leaky but they
>> look find inside. Same with the Solar flat paper caps.
>>? ?? Both of these companies vanished shortly after WW-2, I have
>> never been able to find out what happened. Solar had space
>> reserved in an early "Radio's Master" catalog but no entry and
>> the next issue just was not there.
>>? ?? I've never seen any Micamold caps in -hp- stuff but lots of
>> Sprague, they must have had something going for them.
>>
>> On 11/5/2021 9:11 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
>>> Hi Richard,
>>>
>>> Bumble bee was a descriptive name based on the colorful
>>> bands used to indicate the capacitor's value and voltage
>>> rating.? It was certainly not a brand name.
>>>
>>> Tektronix used numerous 400V oil filled versions of this
>>> capacitor.? I replaced several dozen in my 513D, so I am
>>> certain that your statement about the 650V version being
>>> the only oil version is incorrect.? The 400V rating is one
>>> of the yellow bands that makes it look like a bumble bee.
>>>
>>> Every one that I replaced had the oil filler tube.
>>>
>>> I have observed that the capacitor "slug" is smaller than
>>> the cavity that it fits into.? It had to be, or they would
>>> not have been able to fill the capacitor with oil from the
>>> tube on the end.? How did they make that cavity?
>>>
>>> It is my impression that if the slug was misshapen, it most
>>> probably was built that way.? Perhaps to keep it from rattling
>>> about in the larger cavity that it fit into.
>>>
>>> Excepting where the solder sealed filler tube was damaged during
>>> the capacitor's installation, oil filled BB's lasted a very long
>>> time... easily more than 10 years.? The ordinary beeswax dipped
>>> paper capacitors became leaky after a year or two.
>>>
>>> -Chuck Harris
>>>
>>>
>>> On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 15:50:59 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
>>> <dickburk@...> wrote:
>>>>? ? ??? I want to respond to a couple of things in this thread.
>>>> First of all, there were other brands of molded paper caps. None
>>>> of these had the consistent problems of the Sprague caps of
>>>> cracking and actually breaking. Also, I have disected number of
>>>> failed plastic caps but don't see the distorted windings in
>>>> others. Something went very wrong with these. The early caps were
>>>> coded with the JAN striped coding, hence the name "Bumble Bee".
>>>> The actual brand name was Black Beauty. The 650V versions were
>>>> the oil filled ones, lower voltage were not oil filled. The oil
>>>> filled caps are often found with the oil leaked out. The failure
>>>> seems to be the seal of the filler tube. The tube was also the
>>>> lead on one side having a wire soldered (maybe welded) into it.
>>>> If the seal is disturbed by, for instance, excessive soldering
>>>> temperature, the oil will leak out. The SP-600 seems to have had
>>>> an especial problem with this.
>>>>? ? ?? Also, the property of dielectric absorption, which causes a
>>>> capacitor to retain some charge after being discharged, can be a
>>>> problem with timing and low frequency circuits. One of the few
>>>> virtues of paper capacitors is low dielectric absorption. They
>>>> are a better choice than mica and much better than HI-K ceramic
>>>> caps. Plastic film caps, particularly of certain types have
>>>> practically no DA and are the best choice. I don't think the
>>>> Black Beauty caps were particularly low in DA but all paper caps
>>>> are pretty good.
>>>>? ? ?? The Black Beauty line was advertised as a long life, high
>>>> quality brand. I think Sprague may have fixed the problems with
>>>> them eventually but they got a bad reputation quickly. Hammarlund
>>>> went to all ceramic caps and at least military SP-600's were
>>>> modified to replace all of the paper caps with ceramic ones.
>>>> Those are pretty much trouble free.
>>>>? ? ?? Whatever happened it caused physical distortion of the
>>>> windings of the caps. That could have come from shrinkage of the
>>>> case material as it cooled. It seems to be in both the oil filled
>>>> and non filled versions, at least the ones I've dissected.
>>>> On 11/5/2021 7:25 AM, greenboxmaven via wrote:
>>>>> Thanks for this very good explanation. In addition to the
>>>>> points you made, I have read the oil fill was often complete,
>>>>> and hydrostatic force would test the integrety of the plastic.
>>>>> Shrinkage and loss of resilience of the case would increase the
>>>>> chance of cracks and leaks. The late 1940s is a fascinating
>>>>> time in history for me. There was a great deal of technological
>>>>> progress made, often with over confidence in new materials? and
>>>>> techniques inspired by wartime successes that performed very
>>>>> well in the short term but lacked long term reliability. The
>>>>> "Bumble Bee" condensers were excellent in one regard- they had
>>>>> very little residual charge in the dielectric after being fully
>>>>> discharged. When used as a coupling condenser, that can make a
>>>>> difference.
>>>>>
>>>>>? ??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> On 11/5/21 9:38, Chuck Harris wrote:
>>>>>> BB capacitors were molded as well as the technology of the day
>>>>>> would allow... That is not why they cracked.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The problem is the plastic they used, like most plastics, shrinks
>>>>>> slowly over time, and the wire leads, and especially the solder
>>>>>> sealed oil filler tube, that penetrate the plastic, don't.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> This can cause a crack to form at the weakest point, which is
>>>>>> usually at the mold line formed by slight misalignment of the
>>>>>> mold halves.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> When you injection mold plastic, the plastic's internal bonds
>>>>>> stretch out to fill the mold.? When the plastic cools, it is
>>>>>> frozen into a state where those bonds are stretched.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Over time, under the continuous stress of these stretched bonds,
>>>>>> the plastic will cold flow into a more relaxed state... becoming
>>>>>> slightly smaller.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The problem is if the plastic is constrained by something inside
>>>>>> of it that cannot shrink.... such as the wire leads, a gear's
>>>>>> hub, or an oil filler tube, something has to give.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> If the plastic shrinks around a metal tube, the thickest parts of
>>>>>> the plastic will break the thinest parts forming a crack, and a
>>>>>> leak.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I was told by Deane Kidd, that in the early days, Tektronix
>>>>>> created a situation, ripe for failure with BB capacitors, by
>>>>>> putting them tightly fitted into ceramic or bakelite terminal
>>>>>> strips.? When the capacitor's leads were soldered, the heat
>>>>>> traveling down the very short leads would melt the capacitor's
>>>>>> solder seal, allowing the oil to mix with the solder, and make a
>>>>>> leak.? In the worst cases, the oil would drool out leaving the
>>>>>> capacitor incapable of withstanding its rated voltage.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Not to mention it made a greasy dirty mess in their otherwise
>>>>>> very nice looking scopes.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> -Chuck Harris
>>>>>>
>>>>>> On Thu, 4 Nov 2021 14:40:42 -0400 "greenboxmaven via "
>>>>>> <ka2ivy=verizon.net@groups.io>? wrote:
>>>>>>> Sprague "Bumble Bee" and "Black Beauty" condensers were molded
>>>>>>> improperly, and they will crack, especially the oil filled ones,
>>>>>>> and let in moisture. That seems to react with the oil and make
>>>>>>> it conductive as well as corrosive. Once this happens, leakage
>>>>>>> gets very bad, especially when the condenser is heated by
>>>>>>> surrounding components. Many efforts have been made to bake
>>>>>>> and otherwise restore them, but once the problem begins it can
>>>>>>> not be reversed. The dielectric charicteristic? is perported to
>>>>>>> be superb for audio circuits, and AudioPhools will freak out if
>>>>>>> these condensers are replaced, that is until the power
>>>>>>> transformer, rectifer, output tubes, and filter choke in their
>>>>>>> amplifiers are all incinerated. Not only did Hammarlund use
>>>>>>> them in receivers, Collins and National did as well. Tektronix
>>>>>>> used them in their equipment, and too many consumer electronics
>>>>>>> companies to recall all of them.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>? ? ?? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> On 11/4/21 13:45, Richard Knoppow wrote:
>>>>>>>> Who made those? Some early advertising for Sprague Black Beauty
>>>>>>>> caps said they were plasticized paper. The main problem with
>>>>>>>> these is some sort of production problem they had. I have
>>>>>>>> dissected a number of "bumble bee" caps, these are actually
>>>>>>>> Sprague Black Beauty caps with striped value markigns. I found
>>>>>>>> the windings were distorted. I suspect this happened during the
>>>>>>>> encapsulation but don't know. Some of these caps, the higher
>>>>>>>> voltage ones, were oil impregnated. The oil was introduced
>>>>>>>> through a tube which formed one of the leads. It is common for
>>>>>>>> all the oil to have leaked out due to a lack of sealing at the
>>>>>>>> solder joint between the tube and the lead. That may have been
>>>>>>>> due to excessive heat when the caps were installed. The most
>>>>>>>> notorious of the BB caps are those in the Hammarlund SP-600,
>>>>>>>> however, they were very widely used including in a lot of -hp-
>>>>>>>> gear. However, in the receiver it is common to find cracked or
>>>>>>>> split caps or even caps where part of the casing has come off.
>>>>>>>> I have not seen that in any other make of equipment. Perhaps
>>>>>>>> just a bad lot or perhaps some difference in installation.
>>>>>>>> Nonetheless, ALL paper caps become degraded with age. The usual
>>>>>>>> symptom is an increase in series resistance. Leakage, which is
>>>>>>>> another term for parallel resistance, is sometimes a problem
>>>>>>>> but not as often. I don't think any of these caps, even the
>>>>>>>> real oil filled transmitting caps, was intended to have a
>>>>>>>> lifetime of over about ten years. The life problem was known
>>>>>>>> and described in some engineering texts. It was dependent
>>>>>>>> partly on voltage; the closer the voltage to the rated voltage
>>>>>>>> the shorter the life of the cap. Likely it was some sort of
>>>>>>>> electrolytic degradation of the paper. In any case, paper caps
>>>>>>>> should be replaced with modern plastic film caps. These for
>>>>>>>> the most part will last forever and generally will improve
>>>>>>>> performance perhaps beyond the original. There is a good
>>>>>>>> amount of information on the web about the relative merits of
>>>>>>>> various kinds of plastic dielectrics. Polypropylene seems to
>>>>>>>> be about the best especially for RF use.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> On 11/4/2021 9:33 AM, Dave Wise wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Even the later plasticized-paper “Prokar” and “DiFilm”
>>>>>>>>> versions can cause trouble in some applications – they may
>>>>>>>>> not be leaky, but their Dielectric Absorption and Dissipation
>>>>>>>>> Factor are “through the roof”.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> Dave Wise
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> *From:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
>>>>>>>>> [mailto:HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io] *On Behalf Of
>>>>>>>>> *greenboxmaven via
>>>>>>>>> *Sent:* Thursday, November 04, 2021 6:25 AM
>>>>>>>>> *To:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
>>>>>>>>> *Subject:* Re: [HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment] HP200CD
>>>>>>>>> oscillator
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> ALL Sprague "Black Cat", "Black Beauty" and? color striped
>>>>>>>>> "Bumble Bee" condensers should be considered bad on sight.
>>>>>>>>> Unfortunately, they are common in older equipment of all makes
>>>>>>>>> and models. The 630V. polyester condensers are a fine
>>>>>>>>> replacement. The only condensers that are polarized are
>>>>>>>>> electrolytics, poyester condensers are not polarized.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> On 11/4/21 8:51, Richard Merifield wrote:
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? My unit has Black Cat 0.5MFD 400v axial capacitors for
>>>>>>>>> C8 and C9. Would 630v polyester unpolarised caps be ok
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? replacements?
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>? ? ?
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>?
>
>
>
>
>

--
Richard Knoppow
dickburk@...
WB6KBL







Re: HP200CD oscillator

Bob Albert
 

Regarding reliability of oil filled capacitors, a while back a friend had the main filter capacitor of an HP410B fail.? It exploded.? It was an oil filled bathtub capacitor, maybe 4 microfarads.? As luck would have it (and has had it multiple times) I had an identical part in my stash and except for cleaning up the mess, it was a simple repair.? The new part had a 1947 date code and was older than the failed one.

Bob

On Saturday, November 6, 2021, 10:41:26 AM PDT, Richard Knoppow <dickburk@...> wrote:


?? I absolutely agree with this. However, all paper caps tend to
become degraded with time. The Sprague caps seem to have had a
peculiar problem and short time failures but all old paper caps
should be suspect.
??? Old oil filled transmitting caps seem to have a longer life
than the wax filled kind. My understanding is that one function
of the oil is to eliminate air which can cause oxidation of the
paper. This may also have been the reason for using a plastic
impregnant. I thought I saw advertising from Sprague saying that
the Black Beauty caps were plastic impregated but was not later
able to find it. The paper looks like it has a coating of something.
??? I would certainly be interesting to know the manufacturing
process used for these. It may be buried in the literature
somewhere. In any case really old paper caps of any make or type
should probably be replaced.


On 11/6/2021 6:57 AM, Chuck Harris wrote:
> Hi Richard,
>
> I have never seen anything that would lead me to believe
> an end cap was glued onto the body of the capacitor, but
> maybe that is what they did?? Or, maybe the capacitor was
> built in halves, and the mold line is really a glue line?
>
> Capacitors of all types ultimately boil down to a pair of
> plates, with a dielectric fill between them.
>
> If the dielectric sheet does not fill the space fully, it
> greatly reduces the effect of the dielectric on the capacitance.
> The oil's greatest contribution is in making an intimate
> contact with both plates, and eliminating any air between
> the plates.? This both improves the capacitor's stability,
> and its dielectric strength.
>
> All of my speculation is secondary to the message both of
> us should be (are) giving:
>
> Replace oil filled BB capacitors on sight!
>
> I know that ASCII art doesn't work well on these lists, but
> if you consider this line below a single axial slice of the
> capacitor, it shows the important observable characteristics
> of BB capacitors:
>
>
> ==========O(|||..||...)==========
>
> The "O" is a solder blob that seals the oil filler tube.
> The "==" is the capacitor's leads.
> The "(" and ")" are the domed ends of the capacitor's body.
> The "|||" are the color bands on the body...
> And, the "..." is just the black body.
>
> -Chuck Harris
>
>
> On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 22:08:12 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
> <dickburk@...> wrote:
>>? ?? I may be wrong about the voltage value, I am going by memory
>> of the advertising.
>>? ?? I have wondered the same thing about the oil filling. Its
>> possible the casings were cast and the winding inserted in it. I
>> don't think the windings were deliberately misshapen? but that
>> might be. I wonder what effect squeezing them would have on the
>> value. If the spacing remained constant the shape would have
>> little effect. My own experience in manufacturing is with
>> precision resistors, I have little idea how capacitors were made.
>>? ?? BTW, the Micamold paper caps seem to have a terrible
>> reputation. Every one I've encountered was very leaky but they
>> look find inside. Same with the Solar flat paper caps.
>>? ?? Both of these companies vanished shortly after WW-2, I have
>> never been able to find out what happened. Solar had space
>> reserved in an early "Radio's Master" catalog but no entry and
>> the next issue just was not there.
>>? ?? I've never seen any Micamold caps in -hp- stuff but lots of
>> Sprague, they must have had something going for them.
>>
>> On 11/5/2021 9:11 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
>>> Hi Richard,
>>>
>>> Bumble bee was a descriptive name based on the colorful
>>> bands used to indicate the capacitor's value and voltage
>>> rating.? It was certainly not a brand name.
>>>
>>> Tektronix used numerous 400V oil filled versions of this
>>> capacitor.? I replaced several dozen in my 513D, so I am
>>> certain that your statement about the 650V version being
>>> the only oil version is incorrect.? The 400V rating is one
>>> of the yellow bands that makes it look like a bumble bee.
>>>
>>> Every one that I replaced had the oil filler tube.
>>>
>>> I have observed that the capacitor "slug" is smaller than
>>> the cavity that it fits into.? It had to be, or they would
>>> not have been able to fill the capacitor with oil from the
>>> tube on the end.? How did they make that cavity?
>>>
>>> It is my impression that if the slug was misshapen, it most
>>> probably was built that way.? Perhaps to keep it from rattling
>>> about in the larger cavity that it fit into.
>>>
>>> Excepting where the solder sealed filler tube was damaged during
>>> the capacitor's installation, oil filled BB's lasted a very long
>>> time... easily more than 10 years.? The ordinary beeswax dipped
>>> paper capacitors became leaky after a year or two.
>>>
>>> -Chuck Harris
>>>
>>>
>>> On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 15:50:59 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
>>> <dickburk@...> wrote:
>>>>? ? ??? I want to respond to a couple of things in this thread.
>>>> First of all, there were other brands of molded paper caps. None
>>>> of these had the consistent problems of the Sprague caps of
>>>> cracking and actually breaking. Also, I have disected number of
>>>> failed plastic caps but don't see the distorted windings in
>>>> others. Something went very wrong with these. The early caps were
>>>> coded with the JAN striped coding, hence the name "Bumble Bee".
>>>> The actual brand name was Black Beauty. The 650V versions were
>>>> the oil filled ones, lower voltage were not oil filled. The oil
>>>> filled caps are often found with the oil leaked out. The failure
>>>> seems to be the seal of the filler tube. The tube was also the
>>>> lead on one side having a wire soldered (maybe welded) into it.
>>>> If the seal is disturbed by, for instance, excessive soldering
>>>> temperature, the oil will leak out. The SP-600 seems to have had
>>>> an especial problem with this.
>>>>? ? ?? Also, the property of dielectric absorption, which causes a
>>>> capacitor to retain some charge after being discharged, can be a
>>>> problem with timing and low frequency circuits. One of the few
>>>> virtues of paper capacitors is low dielectric absorption. They
>>>> are a better choice than mica and much better than HI-K ceramic
>>>> caps. Plastic film caps, particularly of certain types have
>>>> practically no DA and are the best choice. I don't think the
>>>> Black Beauty caps were particularly low in DA but all paper caps
>>>> are pretty good.
>>>>? ? ?? The Black Beauty line was advertised as a long life, high
>>>> quality brand. I think Sprague may have fixed the problems with
>>>> them eventually but they got a bad reputation quickly. Hammarlund
>>>> went to all ceramic caps and at least military SP-600's were
>>>> modified to replace all of the paper caps with ceramic ones.
>>>> Those are pretty much trouble free.
>>>>? ? ?? Whatever happened it caused physical distortion of the
>>>> windings of the caps. That could have come from shrinkage of the
>>>> case material as it cooled. It seems to be in both the oil filled
>>>> and non filled versions, at least the ones I've dissected.
>>>> On 11/5/2021 7:25 AM, greenboxmaven via groups.io wrote:
>>>>> Thanks for this very good explanation. In addition to the
>>>>> points you made, I have read the oil fill was often complete,
>>>>> and hydrostatic force would test the integrety of the plastic.
>>>>> Shrinkage and loss of resilience of the case would increase the
>>>>> chance of cracks and leaks. The late 1940s is a fascinating
>>>>> time in history for me. There was a great deal of technological
>>>>> progress made, often with over confidence in new materials? and
>>>>> techniques inspired by wartime successes that performed very
>>>>> well in the short term but lacked long term reliability. The
>>>>> "Bumble Bee" condensers were excellent in one regard- they had
>>>>> very little residual charge in the dielectric after being fully
>>>>> discharged. When used as a coupling condenser, that can make a
>>>>> difference.
>>>>>
>>>>>? ??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> On 11/5/21 9:38, Chuck Harris wrote:
>>>>>> BB capacitors were molded as well as the technology of the day
>>>>>> would allow... That is not why they cracked.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The problem is the plastic they used, like most plastics, shrinks
>>>>>> slowly over time, and the wire leads, and especially the solder
>>>>>> sealed oil filler tube, that penetrate the plastic, don't.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> This can cause a crack to form at the weakest point, which is
>>>>>> usually at the mold line formed by slight misalignment of the
>>>>>> mold halves.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> When you injection mold plastic, the plastic's internal bonds
>>>>>> stretch out to fill the mold.? When the plastic cools, it is
>>>>>> frozen into a state where those bonds are stretched.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Over time, under the continuous stress of these stretched bonds,
>>>>>> the plastic will cold flow into a more relaxed state... becoming
>>>>>> slightly smaller.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The problem is if the plastic is constrained by something inside
>>>>>> of it that cannot shrink.... such as the wire leads, a gear's
>>>>>> hub, or an oil filler tube, something has to give.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> If the plastic shrinks around a metal tube, the thickest parts of
>>>>>> the plastic will break the thinest parts forming a crack, and a
>>>>>> leak.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I was told by Deane Kidd, that in the early days, Tektronix
>>>>>> created a situation, ripe for failure with BB capacitors, by
>>>>>> putting them tightly fitted into ceramic or bakelite terminal
>>>>>> strips.? When the capacitor's leads were soldered, the heat
>>>>>> traveling down the very short leads would melt the capacitor's
>>>>>> solder seal, allowing the oil to mix with the solder, and make a
>>>>>> leak.? In the worst cases, the oil would drool out leaving the
>>>>>> capacitor incapable of withstanding its rated voltage.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Not to mention it made a greasy dirty mess in their otherwise
>>>>>> very nice looking scopes.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> -Chuck Harris
>>>>>>
>>>>>> On Thu, 4 Nov 2021 14:40:42 -0400 "greenboxmaven via groups.io"
>>>>>> <ka2ivy=verizon.net@groups.io>? wrote:
>>>>>>> Sprague "Bumble Bee" and "Black Beauty" condensers were molded
>>>>>>> improperly, and they will crack, especially the oil filled ones,
>>>>>>> and let in moisture. That seems to react with the oil and make
>>>>>>> it conductive as well as corrosive. Once this happens, leakage
>>>>>>> gets very bad, especially when the condenser is heated by
>>>>>>> surrounding components. Many efforts have been made to bake
>>>>>>> and otherwise restore them, but once the problem begins it can
>>>>>>> not be reversed. The dielectric charicteristic? is perported to
>>>>>>> be superb for audio circuits, and AudioPhools will freak out if
>>>>>>> these condensers are replaced, that is until the power
>>>>>>> transformer, rectifer, output tubes, and filter choke in their
>>>>>>> amplifiers are all incinerated. Not only did Hammarlund use
>>>>>>> them in receivers, Collins and National did as well. Tektronix
>>>>>>> used them in their equipment, and too many consumer electronics
>>>>>>> companies to recall all of them.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>? ? ?? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> On 11/4/21 13:45, Richard Knoppow wrote:
>>>>>>>> Who made those? Some early advertising for Sprague Black Beauty
>>>>>>>> caps said they were plasticized paper. The main problem with
>>>>>>>> these is some sort of production problem they had. I have
>>>>>>>> dissected a number of "bumble bee" caps, these are actually
>>>>>>>> Sprague Black Beauty caps with striped value markigns. I found
>>>>>>>> the windings were distorted. I suspect this happened during the
>>>>>>>> encapsulation but don't know. Some of these caps, the higher
>>>>>>>> voltage ones, were oil impregnated. The oil was introduced
>>>>>>>> through a tube which formed one of the leads. It is common for
>>>>>>>> all the oil to have leaked out due to a lack of sealing at the
>>>>>>>> solder joint between the tube and the lead. That may have been
>>>>>>>> due to excessive heat when the caps were installed. The most
>>>>>>>> notorious of the BB caps are those in the Hammarlund SP-600,
>>>>>>>> however, they were very widely used including in a lot of -hp-
>>>>>>>> gear. However, in the receiver it is common to find cracked or
>>>>>>>> split caps or even caps where part of the casing has come off.
>>>>>>>> I have not seen that in any other make of equipment. Perhaps
>>>>>>>> just a bad lot or perhaps some difference in installation.
>>>>>>>> Nonetheless, ALL paper caps become degraded with age. The usual
>>>>>>>> symptom is an increase in series resistance. Leakage, which is
>>>>>>>> another term for parallel resistance, is sometimes a problem
>>>>>>>> but not as often. I don't think any of these caps, even the
>>>>>>>> real oil filled transmitting caps, was intended to have a
>>>>>>>> lifetime of over about ten years. The life problem was known
>>>>>>>> and described in some engineering texts. It was dependent
>>>>>>>> partly on voltage; the closer the voltage to the rated voltage
>>>>>>>> the shorter the life of the cap. Likely it was some sort of
>>>>>>>> electrolytic degradation of the paper. In any case, paper caps
>>>>>>>> should be replaced with modern plastic film caps. These for
>>>>>>>> the most part will last forever and generally will improve
>>>>>>>> performance perhaps beyond the original. There is a good
>>>>>>>> amount of information on the web about the relative merits of
>>>>>>>> various kinds of plastic dielectrics. Polypropylene seems to
>>>>>>>> be about the best especially for RF use.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> On 11/4/2021 9:33 AM, Dave Wise wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Even the later plasticized-paper “Prokar” and “DiFilm”
>>>>>>>>> versions can cause trouble in some applications – they may
>>>>>>>>> not be leaky, but their Dielectric Absorption and Dissipation
>>>>>>>>> Factor are “through the roof”.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> Dave Wise
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> *From:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
>>>>>>>>> [mailto:HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io] *On Behalf Of
>>>>>>>>> *greenboxmaven via groups.io
>>>>>>>>> *Sent:* Thursday, November 04, 2021 6:25 AM
>>>>>>>>> *To:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
>>>>>>>>> *Subject:* Re: [HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment] HP200CD
>>>>>>>>> oscillator
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> ALL Sprague "Black Cat", "Black Beauty" and? color striped
>>>>>>>>> "Bumble Bee" condensers should be considered bad on sight.
>>>>>>>>> Unfortunately, they are common in older equipment of all makes
>>>>>>>>> and models. The 630V. polyester condensers are a fine
>>>>>>>>> replacement. The only condensers that are polarized are
>>>>>>>>> electrolytics, poyester condensers are not polarized.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> On 11/4/21 8:51, Richard Merifield wrote:
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? My unit has Black Cat 0.5MFD 400v axial capacitors for
>>>>>>>>> C8 and C9. Would 630v polyester unpolarised caps be ok
>>>>>>>>>? ? ??? replacements?
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>>? ? ?
>>>>>? ? ?
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>?
>
>
>
>
>

--
Richard Knoppow
dickburk@...
WB6KBL







Re: New member intro

 

Chris; it depends on your hobby, What do you want to do?
One of my hobbies turned out to be fixing old HP test equipment because it was an excellent way to learn electronics. The manuals for the 1960s thru 1980s test equipment are excellent and will teach you more than any textbook.
I use my HP equipment for science experiments because I find it interesting. Impedance measurements interest?me and I built a dielectric test set because it cost $5000 to buy a used one. Lots of fun and great satisfaction from getting it working.
I keep a local business's two HP8753ES Vector Network Analyzers working because I can , the owner is a friend, and he gave me his old 8753B among other things. A challenge and also fun.
My other hobby is building a ROV, Robotic Arm, and Sonar. My HP equipment has been invaluable for that.
Many Radio HAMs measure their antennas, power, and build RF stuff.?
What you have can be quite useful for many things. The 8505A system would be difficult to get plots from. It has been done by me and others but I suggest you use a camera. If you have the money buy an HP8753B but make sure it works unless you are up for the challenge. My experience is to buy totally dead equipment cheap. Filter capacitors in the power supply are a common problem and an easy fix. Check the power supplies first using?a Digital Voltmeter AND A 'SCOPE. Never adjust anything until you have fixed the problem and got the box working. In the case of an 8753 go through the calibration procedure but don't set the save switch and don't adjust anything until you have found and fixed the problem. Adjustments just add a second (or 3rd, 4th...) fault. Sometimes pulling the boards and reinserting them will fix a problem (always unplugged!). Look for overheated?parts and bad solder connections. When at a dead end ask here but do your own share of troubleshooting first.?
For some items a second parts unit could be useful for swapping boards, Mark them first so you get them back where they came from unless you want to do a full adjustment on them.
Best of luck, Peter


On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 4:44 AM Chris Wilkson via <cwilkson=yahoo.com@groups.io> wrote:
Hello Group!

I'm trying to get a handle on my test gear and decided to start looking at my HP hoard.
I need to decide what to keep/fix/purge/replace and finally joining here seemed like a good first step.

I have at least the following items, maybe more hiding unseen in the various piles:

HP:
- several linear power supplies,
- K04-0980A Powerstat
- a gain phase meter (3575A?)
- 33120A function generator
- 3456A voltmeter
- a pair of 1662AS logic analyzers (with at least one keyboard and one mouse...more I think)
- 8505A vector network analyzer with 8501 storage normalizer and 8503A S-parameter kit

Agilent:
- 1147A scope current probe (for the 3034T 'scope below)
- 34410A multimeter
- and maybe a scope in storage?? I need to check on that.

Keysight:
MSOX-3034T oscilloscope

Tektronix:
- approximately 0.42 container ships full of big iron piled ceiling high in the living room

Random other MFG's:
- a pair of IBM Model M keyboards, one for work and one for home (they count as boat anchors too!)
- generally too much stuff !!!

The immediate goal is to get all of this off the floor and off the benches so I can at least check functionality of everything.
Longer term I want to eliminate redundant gear and fill some holes in the lab and then start playing with stuff again!

Cheers,
-Chris



Re: HP200CD oscillator

 

I absolutely agree with this. However, all paper caps tend to become degraded with time. The Sprague caps seem to have had a peculiar problem and short time failures but all old paper caps should be suspect.
??? Old oil filled transmitting caps seem to have a longer life than the wax filled kind. My understanding is that one function of the oil is to eliminate air which can cause oxidation of the paper. This may also have been the reason for using a plastic impregnant. I thought I saw advertising from Sprague saying that the Black Beauty caps were plastic impregated but was not later able to find it. The paper looks like it has a coating of something.
??? I would certainly be interesting to know the manufacturing process used for these. It may be buried in the literature somewhere. In any case really old paper caps of any make or type should probably be replaced.

On 11/6/2021 6:57 AM, Chuck Harris wrote:
Hi Richard,

I have never seen anything that would lead me to believe
an end cap was glued onto the body of the capacitor, but
maybe that is what they did? Or, maybe the capacitor was
built in halves, and the mold line is really a glue line?

Capacitors of all types ultimately boil down to a pair of
plates, with a dielectric fill between them.

If the dielectric sheet does not fill the space fully, it
greatly reduces the effect of the dielectric on the capacitance.
The oil's greatest contribution is in making an intimate
contact with both plates, and eliminating any air between
the plates. This both improves the capacitor's stability,
and its dielectric strength.

All of my speculation is secondary to the message both of
us should be (are) giving:

Replace oil filled BB capacitors on sight!

I know that ASCII art doesn't work well on these lists, but
if you consider this line below a single axial slice of the
capacitor, it shows the important observable characteristics
of BB capacitors:


==========O(|||..||...)==========

The "O" is a solder blob that seals the oil filler tube.
The "==" is the capacitor's leads.
The "(" and ")" are the domed ends of the capacitor's body.
The "|||" are the color bands on the body...
And, the "..." is just the black body.

-Chuck Harris


On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 22:08:12 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
<dickburk@...> wrote:
?? I may be wrong about the voltage value, I am going by memory
of the advertising.
?? I have wondered the same thing about the oil filling. Its
possible the casings were cast and the winding inserted in it. I
don't think the windings were deliberately misshapen? but that
might be. I wonder what effect squeezing them would have on the
value. If the spacing remained constant the shape would have
little effect. My own experience in manufacturing is with
precision resistors, I have little idea how capacitors were made.
?? BTW, the Micamold paper caps seem to have a terrible
reputation. Every one I've encountered was very leaky but they
look find inside. Same with the Solar flat paper caps.
?? Both of these companies vanished shortly after WW-2, I have
never been able to find out what happened. Solar had space
reserved in an early "Radio's Master" catalog but no entry and
the next issue just was not there.
?? I've never seen any Micamold caps in -hp- stuff but lots of
Sprague, they must have had something going for them.

On 11/5/2021 9:11 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
Hi Richard,

Bumble bee was a descriptive name based on the colorful
bands used to indicate the capacitor's value and voltage
rating. It was certainly not a brand name.

Tektronix used numerous 400V oil filled versions of this
capacitor. I replaced several dozen in my 513D, so I am
certain that your statement about the 650V version being
the only oil version is incorrect. The 400V rating is one
of the yellow bands that makes it look like a bumble bee.

Every one that I replaced had the oil filler tube.

I have observed that the capacitor "slug" is smaller than
the cavity that it fits into. It had to be, or they would
not have been able to fill the capacitor with oil from the
tube on the end. How did they make that cavity?

It is my impression that if the slug was misshapen, it most
probably was built that way. Perhaps to keep it from rattling
about in the larger cavity that it fit into.

Excepting where the solder sealed filler tube was damaged during
the capacitor's installation, oil filled BB's lasted a very long
time... easily more than 10 years. The ordinary beeswax dipped
paper capacitors became leaky after a year or two.

-Chuck Harris


On Fri, 5 Nov 2021 15:50:59 -0700 "Richard Knoppow"
<dickburk@...> wrote:
??? I want to respond to a couple of things in this thread.
First of all, there were other brands of molded paper caps. None
of these had the consistent problems of the Sprague caps of
cracking and actually breaking. Also, I have disected number of
failed plastic caps but don't see the distorted windings in
others. Something went very wrong with these. The early caps were
coded with the JAN striped coding, hence the name "Bumble Bee".
The actual brand name was Black Beauty. The 650V versions were
the oil filled ones, lower voltage were not oil filled. The oil
filled caps are often found with the oil leaked out. The failure
seems to be the seal of the filler tube. The tube was also the
lead on one side having a wire soldered (maybe welded) into it.
If the seal is disturbed by, for instance, excessive soldering
temperature, the oil will leak out. The SP-600 seems to have had
an especial problem with this.
?? Also, the property of dielectric absorption, which causes a
capacitor to retain some charge after being discharged, can be a
problem with timing and low frequency circuits. One of the few
virtues of paper capacitors is low dielectric absorption. They
are a better choice than mica and much better than HI-K ceramic
caps. Plastic film caps, particularly of certain types have
practically no DA and are the best choice. I don't think the
Black Beauty caps were particularly low in DA but all paper caps
are pretty good.
?? The Black Beauty line was advertised as a long life, high
quality brand. I think Sprague may have fixed the problems with
them eventually but they got a bad reputation quickly. Hammarlund
went to all ceramic caps and at least military SP-600's were
modified to replace all of the paper caps with ceramic ones.
Those are pretty much trouble free.
?? Whatever happened it caused physical distortion of the
windings of the caps. That could have come from shrinkage of the
case material as it cooled. It seems to be in both the oil filled
and non filled versions, at least the ones I've dissected.
On 11/5/2021 7:25 AM, greenboxmaven via groups.io wrote:
Thanks for this very good explanation. In addition to the
points you made, I have read the oil fill was often complete,
and hydrostatic force would test the integrety of the plastic.
Shrinkage and loss of resilience of the case would increase the
chance of cracks and leaks. The late 1940s is a fascinating
time in history for me. There was a great deal of technological
progress made, often with over confidence in new materials? and
techniques inspired by wartime successes that performed very
well in the short term but lacked long term reliability. The
"Bumble Bee" condensers were excellent in one regard- they had
very little residual charge in the dielectric after being fully
discharged. When used as a coupling condenser, that can make a
difference.

??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY



On 11/5/21 9:38, Chuck Harris wrote:
BB capacitors were molded as well as the technology of the day
would allow... That is not why they cracked.

The problem is the plastic they used, like most plastics, shrinks
slowly over time, and the wire leads, and especially the solder
sealed oil filler tube, that penetrate the plastic, don't.

This can cause a crack to form at the weakest point, which is
usually at the mold line formed by slight misalignment of the
mold halves.

When you injection mold plastic, the plastic's internal bonds
stretch out to fill the mold. When the plastic cools, it is
frozen into a state where those bonds are stretched.

Over time, under the continuous stress of these stretched bonds,
the plastic will cold flow into a more relaxed state... becoming
slightly smaller.

The problem is if the plastic is constrained by something inside
of it that cannot shrink.... such as the wire leads, a gear's
hub, or an oil filler tube, something has to give.

If the plastic shrinks around a metal tube, the thickest parts of
the plastic will break the thinest parts forming a crack, and a
leak.

I was told by Deane Kidd, that in the early days, Tektronix
created a situation, ripe for failure with BB capacitors, by
putting them tightly fitted into ceramic or bakelite terminal
strips. When the capacitor's leads were soldered, the heat
traveling down the very short leads would melt the capacitor's
solder seal, allowing the oil to mix with the solder, and make a
leak. In the worst cases, the oil would drool out leaving the
capacitor incapable of withstanding its rated voltage.

Not to mention it made a greasy dirty mess in their otherwise
very nice looking scopes.

-Chuck Harris

On Thu, 4 Nov 2021 14:40:42 -0400 "greenboxmaven via groups.io"
<ka2ivy@...> wrote:
Sprague "Bumble Bee" and "Black Beauty" condensers were molded
improperly, and they will crack, especially the oil filled ones,
and let in moisture. That seems to react with the oil and make
it conductive as well as corrosive. Once this happens, leakage
gets very bad, especially when the condenser is heated by
surrounding components. Many efforts have been made to bake
and otherwise restore them, but once the problem begins it can
not be reversed. The dielectric charicteristic? is perported to
be superb for audio circuits, and AudioPhools will freak out if
these condensers are replaced, that is until the power
transformer, rectifer, output tubes, and filter choke in their
amplifiers are all incinerated. Not only did Hammarlund use
them in receivers, Collins and National did as well. Tektronix
used them in their equipment, and too many consumer electronics
companies to recall all of them.

?? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY

On 11/4/21 13:45, Richard Knoppow wrote:
Who made those? Some early advertising for Sprague Black Beauty
caps said they were plasticized paper. The main problem with
these is some sort of production problem they had. I have
dissected a number of "bumble bee" caps, these are actually
Sprague Black Beauty caps with striped value markigns. I found
the windings were distorted. I suspect this happened during the
encapsulation but don't know. Some of these caps, the higher
voltage ones, were oil impregnated. The oil was introduced
through a tube which formed one of the leads. It is common for
all the oil to have leaked out due to a lack of sealing at the
solder joint between the tube and the lead. That may have been
due to excessive heat when the caps were installed. The most
notorious of the BB caps are those in the Hammarlund SP-600,
however, they were very widely used including in a lot of -hp-
gear. However, in the receiver it is common to find cracked or
split caps or even caps where part of the casing has come off.
I have not seen that in any other make of equipment. Perhaps
just a bad lot or perhaps some difference in installation.
Nonetheless, ALL paper caps become degraded with age. The usual
symptom is an increase in series resistance. Leakage, which is
another term for parallel resistance, is sometimes a problem
but not as often. I don't think any of these caps, even the
real oil filled transmitting caps, was intended to have a
lifetime of over about ten years. The life problem was known
and described in some engineering texts. It was dependent
partly on voltage; the closer the voltage to the rated voltage
the shorter the life of the cap. Likely it was some sort of
electrolytic degradation of the paper. In any case, paper caps
should be replaced with modern plastic film caps. These for
the most part will last forever and generally will improve
performance perhaps beyond the original. There is a good
amount of information on the web about the relative merits of
various kinds of plastic dielectrics. Polypropylene seems to
be about the best especially for RF use.

On 11/4/2021 9:33 AM, Dave Wise wrote:
Even the later plasticized-paper “Prokar” and “DiFilm”
versions can cause trouble in some applications – they may
not be leaky, but their Dielectric Absorption and Dissipation
Factor are “through the roof”.

Dave Wise

*From:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
[mailto:HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io] *On Behalf Of
*greenboxmaven via groups.io
*Sent:* Thursday, November 04, 2021 6:25 AM
*To:*HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment@groups.io
*Subject:* Re: [HP-Agilent-Keysight-equipment] HP200CD
oscillator

ALL Sprague "Black Cat", "Black Beauty" and? color striped
"Bumble Bee" condensers should be considered bad on sight.
Unfortunately, they are common in older equipment of all makes
and models. The 630V. polyester condensers are a fine
replacement. The only condensers that are polarized are
electrolytics, poyester condensers are not polarized.

??? Bruce Gentry, KA2IVY

On 11/4/21 8:51, Richard Merifield wrote:

??? My unit has Black Cat 0.5MFD 400v axial capacitors for
C8 and C9. Would 630v polyester unpolarised caps be ok
??? replacements?





--
Richard Knoppow
dickburk@...
WB6KBL


71910A surveillance receivers

 

Hi all?
I am trying to find out the sort of work People?are managing to do with the HP 71910A surveillance? receivers
It would also be nice to see how meany are out there and how many are actual working??
Please feel free to come back of line if? it is a bit delicate paul@...?
alternatively there is a dater base for such information? on the HP 70000 site

also keen to speak to anyone using a HP 71910A surveillance? receiver?in the UK

Best Regards Paul??


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

Unfortunately all analog displays cannot be replaced by LCD displays without a very important quantity of associated electronic. All is question of bandwidth first. On spectrum analyzers, SNA or VNA the display is enough slow sweeping horizontally that it could be possible to use in place an LCD display and vertical bandwidth is few kHz only. However on analog oscilloscopes it's really a challenge because the tube is directly reproducing the signal in vertical (several hundreds of MHz for high bandwidth scopes) and the sawtooth for horizontal deflection is also very fast (hundreds of kHz to 1 MHz for several very high priced tubes). Indeed, replacement of such tube with LCD can only be made with complete sampling oscilloscope, so in such conditions, it's better to directly buy a new sampling oscilloscope and it could be largely cheaper.
I guess that it's perhaps only for curves tracers that it could be possible to design a new LCD displays. But for that the most well placed should be Xu Wang from Simmconn Labs to reply such question.
Dan.


Re: Question: XY (XYZ or Vector) instrument CRT, replacement with an LCD ?

 

Hi just a bit of information?

we have a lot of the New scope literature in the?Catalogue's file on this site?

Regards Paul?


Re: Seeking advice for an HP-3336C

 

Fixed my attenuator problems using Joe's board.? The 3336C with the Aromat relays are not the same spacing as the 3325 so the PCB had to be sheared.?