Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
On 2024-01-11, Jim W7RY via groups.io wrote: >> Sure glad I can leave this group with just one click.
Myself, I am enjoying reading people's stories. We sure do have some high-powered folks here. - Jerry, KF6VB Me too! Aside: as a children's-charity volunteer I used to tremble watching F-4s thundering into the sky at DaNang. I only have a R-4B, but enjoy all the DRAKE postings. I discovered that I can delete postings I don't relate to with, yea, just one click :-) Michael 2E0IHW (UK)
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
On 2024-01-11 15:10, Jim W7RY via groups.io wrote: Sure glad I can leave this group with just one click. Myself, I am enjoying reading people's stories. We sure do have some high-powered folks here. - Jerry, KF6VB
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
On 2024-01-11 14:51, Bob Coffman via groups.io wrote: Airplanes, boats and yes, I have both the tube powered and the inline 6 powered TR-6¡¯s! *** Here: one airplane, a TR7, and a (Triumph) TR2. Don't have any Drake tube stuff, but my desk does sport a KWM-2 and a 30L-1. There's been a cold snap here, and the tube station makes a nice space heater on chilly mornings. - Jerry, KF6VB ( jerry@... ) My Elmer, an SK long ago, sold me his SP-600 receiver to pay for his new 1970¡¯s Yeasu. I got it at a steep discount, but I had to promise to keep it running. I still have it, it still runs, had to get rid of all the Sprague capacitors, etc! Hence my fascination with all things that glow in the dark. Bob Coffman, KJ7AJ 2drestoration@...
On Jan 11, 2024, at 5:34 PM, Steve Wedge, W1ES/4 via groups.io [1] <w1es@...> wrote: David, are you Acadian? Steve Wedge, W1ES/4 Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana. Sent with Proton Mail [2] secure email. On Thursday, January 11th, 2024 at 4:58 PM, Bob Coffman via groups.io [1] <2drestoration@...> wrote: David, Fascinating personal history! I flew F-4¡¯s and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in math and geology, University of Denver. Novice license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12. Dad¡¯s old regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal transmitter was about all I could afford in grade school/jr high! Bob Coffman, KJ7AJ 2drestoration@... On Jan 11, 2024, at 12:23 PM, David <david.w5xu@...> wrote: Michael Smith: I wish to thank you for your well crafted response. I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted. I was in the Mechanical and electrical consultant field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order. I apologize to you and to the like minded others. Some background may help to soften the automatic critical answers I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham. I think it started when one of the family radios went out. I was a freshman in high school then. My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio. My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper. I was 9 years old. The summers were spent with this. My first year of college (1964) I was astounded at the cost of the education. It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester! I had worked at a radio and tv repair shop for two summers. Used this to augment the radio repair hobby. After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans. I did that for three years. Cutting those years short: I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry. It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the Loyola HAm Radio Station. It was there that members of the club got me interested in Ham Radio. I was licensed in Dec 1964. After Loyola and after a few divergent course maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering. The summer after my first year I was drafted. The Army recruiter told me that I wouldn't be going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft. In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education. Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before. Except this one was how I financed my family. With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters in Electrical Engineering. My growing family, work and a career start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy. A typical day while still in school: First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry. Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off. Home, rest and repeat. When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm systems for buildings: my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada). THis job allowed me to give up the work of teaching and TV work. While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find a University that would hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths. All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years. When I was more or less settled (in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes. I was on the air. I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC. At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home. I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander. That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions. To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake. Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix. The peak of this menagerie is the TR7B (my nomenclature for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier. I plan to get these working but am severely hampered with a zero count of any documentation. I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork. The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started. None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams. And so, it will continue. So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere. Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that. If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching skills have withered. Again, Sorry. But I will continue to monitor, but will likely limit my participation in these realms. Thank you again for your kind comments and for your patience. I feel better already. David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via groups.io [3] <tw8kcabpilot@...> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª_ no one_ ignored you; it may seem that way, though. We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc. My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication. Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer. I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this. The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time. So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero. Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything. What is wrong?¡± My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating. I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem. As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing. Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can. Peace, 73, Michael, N4KZO Links: ------ [1] [2] [3] [4] /g/DRAKE-RADIO/message/75495 [5] /mt/103544827/243852 [6] /g/DRAKE-RADIO/post [7] /g/DRAKE-RADIO/editsub/243852 [8] /g/DRAKE-RADIO/leave/12260778/243852/767576506/xyzzy
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
Sure glad I can leave this group with just one click.
73 Ya'll
Jim W7RY
On 1/11/2024 4:51 PM, Bob Coffman via
groups.io wrote:
Retired American Airlines captain, retired ANG (I was only a
major, I had some enlisted time in the late 70¡¯s). ?Worked as a
physicist/project engineer at Hughes Aircraft Co in the Space and
Comm division. ?Now I tinker with boat anchors and some hybrids.
?Airplanes, boats and yes, I have both the tube powered and the
inline 6 powered TR-6¡¯s! ?
My Elmer, an SK long ago, sold me his SP-600
receiver to pay for his new 1970¡¯s Yeasu. ?I got it at a steep
discount, but I had to promise to keep it running. ?I still have
it, it still runs, had to get rid of all the Sprague capacitors,
etc! ?Hence my fascination with all things that glow in the
dark.
On Jan 11, 2024, at 5:34 PM, Steve Wedge,
W1ES/4 via < w1es@...>
wrote:
David,
are you Acadian?
Steve Wedge, W1ES/4
Time flies like an arrow.? Fruit flies
like a banana.
Sent
with secure
email.
On Thursday, January
11th, 2024 at 4:58 PM, Bob Coffman via < 2drestoration@...>
wrote:
David, Fascinating personal history! ?I flew F-4¡¯s
and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS
New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in
math and geology, University of Denver. ?Novice
license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12. ?Dad¡¯s old
regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal
transmitter was about all I could afford in grade
school/jr high!
Michael
Smith:
I
wish to thank you for your well crafted
response.? I am sorry to you and to all
if I overreacted.? I was in the
Mechanical?and
electrical?consultant?field for 45 years
and it is hard for me to see blatant
opposition for logic and order.? I
apologize?to you and to the like minded
others.
Some
background may help?to soften?the
automatic critical answers?I get:
I
started dabbling with radios before I
was a ham.? I think it started when one
of the family radios went out.? I was a
freshman?in high school then.? My summer
jobs varied, but with the newfound
interest, I directed it toward radio.?
My very first job was to deliver the New
Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was
9 years old.? The summers were spent
with this.? My first year of college
(1964) I was astounded?at the cost of
the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in
New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I
had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop
for two summers.? Used this to augment
the radio repair hobby.? After high
school I went to work (again, summer
time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV
in New Orleans.? I did that for three
years.
?
Cutting
those years short:? I graduated in 1967
with a degree in Physics and minors in
Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola
that in a search for a quiet place to
study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm
Radio Station.? It was there that
members?of the club got me interested in
Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec
1964.??
After
Loyola and after a few divergent
course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton
Rouge for graduate school in Electrical
engineering.? The summer after my
first?year I was drafted.? The Army
recruiter?told me that I wouldn't
be?going to Vietnam as I would likely
think before I pulled the trigger (a
quote) and they wanted someone who would
just pull the trigger, so I ended up in
the air force?fixing radios and radar in
fighter aircraft.
In
1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge
to continue my education.? Since I was
then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in
Baton Rouge essentially in the same role
as before.? Except this one was how I
financed my family.? With work and with
National Guard Service, I finally
graduated from LSU with a Masters?in
Electrical?Engineering.? My growing
family, work and a career?start in the
Consulting Engineering field kept me
busy.? A typical day while still in
school:? First was a class either at LSU
or Southern where I taught either Lab
work at LSU or at Southern, teaching
communications using my experience in
the TV industry.? Then I attended
classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when
the late night shift started at the TV
station, I went there and worked till
sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When
I got the fortunate opportunity to enter
into the Consulting field (I designed
HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire
protection and alarm?systems for
buildings:? my work was from coast to
coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job
allowed me to give up the?work of
teaching and TV work.? While I tried to
continue with a PhD program, I could not
find?a University that would?hire me for
teaching while working toward a degree,
so I was most fortunate to be given an
opportunity to change paths.
All
of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio
for a while and I was off the air for 19
years.? When I was more or less
settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a
small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and
pulled out my original radios, a Drake
R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew
linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I
was on the air.
I
attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid
1990's for the specific?reason to find a
Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the
convention I found 2 of them, bought one
and then (in those days) hand carried
both boxes on board the airplane and
brought them home.? I completely
restored both boxes and for the next
WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air,
barefoot with the tribander.? That
weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took
advantage of the wonderful band
conditions.
To
shorten further, this rewarding
restoring experience caused me to start
a collection of various ham stuff,
mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces
number around 35, most needing
restoration, with several Johnson and
Central Electronics boxes in the mix.?
The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B
(my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of
concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of
several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I
plan to get these working but am
severely?hampered with a zero count of
any documentation.? I have the radios,
they appear complete, but have no
paperwork.? The radios that I restore
are then "loaned " to new hams to get
them started.? None of these have ever
come back, but they have served to
launch several hams.? And so, it will
continue.
So,
thank you for your patience but I had
hoped that with my love of teaching, the
experience?of restoring old radios and
the willingness to share that experience
would have been rewarded with a more
open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply
put, I have been there and for the most
part done that.? If what I have to say
does not fit the formula and the wording
that is acceptable to those with the
questions, then my teaching?skills have
withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will
continue to monitor, but will
likely?limit my participation in these
realms.
Thank?you
again for your kind?comments and for
your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III
W5XU, VP8RXU
?
On Sat,
Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via ??<tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]>
wrote:
David,
Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to
be offended ¡ª?no
one?ignored
you; it may seem that way, though. ? We
all learn from all the posts, no matter
how much experience we have or training,
etc.? My estimate, one way or another,
most on this group are very
knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no
one is perfect, and sometimes
circumstances get in the way of complete
communication.? Expressions to the nth
degree (as n goes to infinity) that
Steve mentioned sums to form a
well-bounded series: in other words, the
composite is a well defined meaningful
answer.? I am planning on starting
restoration/repair or restart of some
Drake tube radios I have, and have been
contemplating just how to go about
this.? The composite of this topic
posting, including your comments, have
helped me to conclude on a process or
plan to bring up radios that have
sitting dormant a long time.? So, the
only part about your message that is
erroneous from my perspective is as
follows: your experience appears to be
high, your knowledge is significant, and
for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the
baloney increases in the denominator
without bound (goes to infinity) in the
limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this
situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried
everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire
day working as a medical-imaging systems
field engineer for many years as a young
man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡±
?Sometimes the problem was baffling,
sometimes just irritating.? I say this
because it is refreshing for me to get a
good chuckle (as intended) from
introductory comments like Steve¡¯s,
amidst dealing with a frustrating
problem.? As I have a good laugh at the
comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my
pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good
thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to
keep reading and contributing when you
can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
--
Thanks and 73, Jim W7RY
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
Retired American Airlines captain, retired ANG (I was only a major, I had some enlisted time in the late 70¡¯s). ?Worked as a physicist/project engineer at Hughes Aircraft Co in the Space and Comm division. ?Now I tinker with boat anchors and some hybrids. ?Airplanes, boats and yes, I have both the tube powered and the inline 6 powered TR-6¡¯s! ?
My Elmer, an SK long ago, sold me his SP-600 receiver to pay for his new 1970¡¯s Yeasu. ?I got it at a steep discount, but I had to promise to keep it running. ?I still have it, it still runs, had to get rid of all the Sprague capacitors, etc! ?Hence my fascination with all things that glow in the dark.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Jan 11, 2024, at 5:34 PM, Steve Wedge, W1ES/4 via < w1es@...> wrote:
David, are you Acadian?
Steve Wedge, W1ES/4
Time flies like an arrow.? Fruit flies like a banana.
Sent with secure email.
On Thursday, January 11th, 2024 at 4:58 PM, Bob Coffman via < 2drestoration@...> wrote:
David, Fascinating personal history! ?I flew F-4¡¯s and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in math and geology, University of Denver. ?Novice license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12. ?Dad¡¯s old regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal transmitter was about all I could afford in grade school/jr high!
Michael Smith:
I wish to thank you for your well crafted response.? I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted.? I was in the Mechanical?and electrical?consultant?field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order.? I apologize?to you and to the like minded others.
Some background may help?to soften?the automatic critical answers?I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham.? I think it started when one of the family radios went out.? I was a freshman?in high school then.? My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio.? My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was 9 years old.? The summers were spent with this.? My first year of college (1964) I was astounded?at the cost of the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop for two summers.? Used this to augment the radio repair hobby.? After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans.? I did that for three years. ? Cutting those years short:? I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm Radio Station.? It was there that members?of the club got me interested in Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec 1964.??
After Loyola and after a few divergent course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering.? The summer after my first?year I was drafted.? The Army recruiter?told me that I wouldn't be?going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force?fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft.
In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education.? Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before.? Except this one was how I financed my family.? With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters?in Electrical?Engineering.? My growing family, work and a career?start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy.? A typical day while still in school:? First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry.? Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm?systems for buildings:? my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job allowed me to give up the?work of teaching and TV work.? While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find?a University that would?hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths.
All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years.? When I was more or less settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I was on the air.
I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific?reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home.? I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander.? That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions.
To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix.? The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B (my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I plan to get these working but am severely?hampered with a zero count of any documentation.? I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork.? The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started.? None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams.? And so, it will continue.
So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience?of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that.? If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching?skills have withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will continue to monitor, but will likely?limit my participation in these realms.
Thank?you again for your kind?comments and for your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ? On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via ??<tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª?no one?ignored you; it may seem that way, though. ? We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc.? My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication.? Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer.? I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this.? The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time.? So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± ?Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating.? I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem.? As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
David, are you Acadian?
Steve Wedge, W1ES/4
Time flies like an arrow.? Fruit flies like a banana.
Sent with secure email.
On Thursday, January 11th, 2024 at 4:58 PM, Bob Coffman via groups.io <2drestoration@...> wrote:
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
David, Fascinating personal history! ?I flew F-4¡¯s and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in math and geology, University of Denver. ?Novice license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12. ?Dad¡¯s old regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal transmitter was about all I could afford in grade school/jr high!
Michael Smith:
I wish to thank you for your well crafted response.? I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted.? I was in the Mechanical?and electrical?consultant?field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order.? I apologize?to you and to the like minded others.
Some background may help?to soften?the automatic critical answers?I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham.? I think it started when one of the family radios went out.? I was a freshman?in high school then.? My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio.? My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was 9 years old.? The summers were spent with this.? My first year of college (1964) I was astounded?at the cost of the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop for two summers.? Used this to augment the radio repair hobby.? After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans.? I did that for three years. ? Cutting those years short:? I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm Radio Station.? It was there that members?of the club got me interested in Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec 1964.??
After Loyola and after a few divergent course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering.? The summer after my first?year I was drafted.? The Army recruiter?told me that I wouldn't be?going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force?fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft.
In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education.? Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before.? Except this one was how I financed my family.? With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters?in Electrical?Engineering.? My growing family, work and a career?start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy.? A typical day while still in school:? First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry.? Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm?systems for buildings:? my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job allowed me to give up the?work of teaching and TV work.? While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find?a University that would?hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths.
All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years.? When I was more or less settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I was on the air.
I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific?reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home.? I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander.? That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions.
To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix.? The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B (my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I plan to get these working but am severely?hampered with a zero count of any documentation.? I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork.? The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started.? None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams.? And so, it will continue.
So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience?of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that.? If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching?skills have withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will continue to monitor, but will likely?limit my participation in these realms.
Thank?you again for your kind?comments and for your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ? On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via ??<tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª?no one?ignored you; it may seem that way, though. ? We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc.? My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication.? Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer.? I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this.? The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time.? So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± ?Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating.? I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem.? As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
Well.? Looks like we had similar backgrounds all leading to Ham Radio.? Well, when I was fixing radios?in Jets, they were fro F 102s, F 100, A 37s and only one f4.? I remember that as I had to get a ladder! Blessings to you.
So, Bob.? What do you do now?? Thanks?for the flash of memories. David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Thu, Jan 11, 2024 at 3:58?PM Bob Coffman via <2drestoration= [email protected]> wrote: David, Fascinating personal history!? I flew F-4¡¯s and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in math and geology, University of Denver.? Novice license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12.? Dad¡¯s old regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal transmitter was about all I could afford in grade school/jr high!
Michael Smith:
I wish to thank you for your well crafted response.? I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted.? I was in the Mechanical?and electrical?consultant?field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order.? I apologize?to you and to the like minded others.
Some background may help?to soften?the automatic critical answers?I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham.? I think it started when one of the family radios went out.? I was a freshman?in high school then.? My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio.? My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was 9 years old.? The summers were spent with this.? My first year of college (1964) I was astounded?at the cost of the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop for two summers.? Used this to augment the radio repair hobby.? After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans.? I did that for three years. ? Cutting those years short:? I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm Radio Station.? It was there that members?of the club got me interested in Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec 1964.??
After Loyola and after a few divergent course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering.? The summer after my first?year I was drafted.? The Army recruiter?told me that I wouldn't be?going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force?fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft.
In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education.? Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before.? Except this one was how I financed my family.? With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters?in Electrical?Engineering.? My growing family, work and a career?start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy.? A typical day while still in school:? First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry.? Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm?systems for buildings:? my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job allowed me to give up the?work of teaching and TV work.? While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find?a University that would?hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths.
All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years.? When I was more or less settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I was on the air.
I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific?reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home.? I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander.? That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions.
To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix.? The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B (my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I plan to get these working but am severely?hampered with a zero count of any documentation.? I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork.? The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started.? None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams.? And so, it will continue.
So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience?of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that.? If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching?skills have withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will continue to monitor, but will likely?limit my participation in these realms.
Thank?you again for your kind?comments and for your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ? On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via ??<tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª?no one?ignored you; it may seem that way, though. ? We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc.? My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication.? Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer.? I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this.? The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time.? So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± ?Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating.? I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem.? As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
David, Fascinating personal history! ?I flew F-4¡¯s and F-15¡¯s in the Louisiana Air National Guard (NAS New Orleans) from 1980-1996, BS Physics, minored in math and geology, University of Denver. ?Novice license was WN7VTF in 1970-ish, I was 12. ?Dad¡¯s old regenerative receiver and matching 2 tube x-tal transmitter was about all I could afford in grade school/jr high!
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Michael Smith:
I wish to thank you for your well crafted response.? I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted.? I was in the Mechanical?and electrical?consultant?field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order.? I apologize?to you and to the like minded others.
Some background may help?to soften?the automatic critical answers?I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham.? I think it started when one of the family radios went out.? I was a freshman?in high school then.? My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio.? My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was 9 years old.? The summers were spent with this.? My first year of college (1964) I was astounded?at the cost of the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop for two summers.? Used this to augment the radio repair hobby.? After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans.? I did that for three years. ? Cutting those years short:? I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm Radio Station.? It was there that members?of the club got me interested in Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec 1964.??
After Loyola and after a few divergent course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering.? The summer after my first?year I was drafted.? The Army recruiter?told me that I wouldn't be?going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force?fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft.
In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education.? Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before.? Except this one was how I financed my family.? With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters?in Electrical?Engineering.? My growing family, work and a career?start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy.? A typical day while still in school:? First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry.? Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm?systems for buildings:? my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job allowed me to give up the?work of teaching and TV work.? While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find?a University that would?hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths.
All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years.? When I was more or less settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I was on the air.
I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific?reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home.? I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander.? That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions.
To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix.? The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B (my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I plan to get these working but am severely?hampered with a zero count of any documentation.? I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork.? The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started.? None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams.? And so, it will continue.
So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience?of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that.? If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching?skills have withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will continue to monitor, but will likely?limit my participation in these realms.
Thank?you again for your kind?comments and for your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ? On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via ??<tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª?no one?ignored you; it may seem that way, though. ? We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc.? My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication.? Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer.? I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this.? The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time.? So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± ?Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating.? I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem.? As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
|
Re: Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710
I bought one to interface a IC-7100 to a L7.? Works fine. ? ? 73 Dale AF7WH ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: [email protected] < [email protected]> On Behalf Of Howard VE7IGA Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2024 1:00 PM To: [email protected]Subject: Re: [DRAKE-RADIO] Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710 ? Try associatedradio on Ebay.? I bought their amp interface for my FTDX3000D to my L7 amp. Works great and simple PNP install. You can contact them through Ebay and ask them about your rig, he was very quick to respond. Here's picture of their interface for my yaesu, nice and compact work great. -------- Original message -------- Date: 2024-01-11 12:03 p.m. (GMT-08:00) Subject: [DRAKE-RADIO] Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710 I am preparing to interface my L-4B with an Icom M-710.? Any experience, insight, suggestions and help will be sincerely appreciated.
|
Re: Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710
Try associatedradio on Ebay.? I bought their amp interface for my FTDX3000D to my L7 amp. Works great and simple PNP install. You can contact them through Ebay and ask them about your rig, he was very quick to respond. Here's picture of their interface for my yaesu, nice and compact work great. Howard VE7IGA?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
-------- Original message -------- From: John AA0ES <hawkeye78299@...> Date: 2024-01-11 12:03 p.m. (GMT-08:00) Subject: [DRAKE-RADIO] Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710
I am preparing to interface my L-4B with an Icom M-710.? Any experience, insight, suggestions and help will be sincerely appreciated.
|
Thanks Rob for your comment.
In the coming days I will hookup my TR-4C and my IC-705 to my R&S CMTA to perform some proper sensitivity measurements on my rigs and see how they compare to your measurements. Will certainly share these results in this mail thread.
73 de Rob PA9Z
|
Drake L-4B interface to Icom IC-M710
I am preparing to interface my L-4B with an Icom M-710.? Any experience, insight, suggestions and help will be sincerely appreciated.
|
Re: R-4B AGC Issues, Part Trois
Michael Smith:
I wish to thank you for your well crafted response.? I am sorry to you and to all if I overreacted.? I was in the Mechanical?and electrical?consultant?field for 45 years and it is hard for me to see blatant opposition for logic and order.? I apologize?to you and to the like minded others.
Some background may help?to soften?the automatic critical answers?I get: I started dabbling with radios before I was a ham.? I think it started when one of the family radios went out.? I was a freshman?in high school then.? My summer jobs varied, but with the newfound interest, I directed it toward radio.? My very first job was to deliver the New Orleans Item afternoon newspaper.? I was 9 years old.? The summers were spent with this.? My first year of college (1964) I was astounded?at the cost of the education.? It was at Loyola Univ in New Orleans and it was $770 a semester!
I had worked at?a radio and tv repair shop for two summers.? Used this to augment the radio repair hobby.? After high school I went to work (again, summer time vacation fill in work) at WDSU TV in New Orleans.? I did that for three years. ? Cutting those years short:? I graduated in 1967 with a degree in Physics and minors in Math and Chemistry.? It was at Loyola that in a search for a quiet place to study, I found W5LJY, the?Loyola HAm Radio Station.? It was there that members?of the club got me interested in Ham Radio.? I was licensed in Dec 1964.??
After Loyola and after a few divergent course?maneuvers, I started LSU in Baton Rouge for graduate school in Electrical engineering.? The summer after my first?year I was drafted.? The Army recruiter?told me that I wouldn't be?going to Vietnam as I would likely think before I pulled the trigger (a quote) and they wanted someone who would just pull the trigger, so I ended up in the air force?fixing radios and radar in fighter aircraft.
In 1969, I married and moved to Baton Rouge to continue my education.? Since I was then married, I got a job at WAFB TV in Baton Rouge essentially in the same role as before.? Except this one was how I financed my family.? With work and with National Guard Service, I finally graduated from LSU with a Masters?in Electrical?Engineering.? My growing family, work and a career?start in the Consulting Engineering field kept me busy.? A typical day while still in school:? First was a class either at LSU or Southern where I taught either Lab work at LSU or at Southern, teaching communications using my experience in the TV industry.? Then I attended classes/ studied and at 5 PM or so, when the late night shift started at the TV station, I went there and worked till sign off.? Home, rest and repeat.
When I got the fortunate opportunity to enter into the Consulting field (I designed HVAC, lighting, plumbing, fire protection and alarm?systems for buildings:? my work was from coast to coast, from Aruba to Canada).? THis job allowed me to give up the?work of teaching and TV work.? While I tried to continue with a PhD program, I could not find?a University that would?hire me for teaching while working toward a degree, so I was most fortunate to be given an opportunity to change paths.
All of this meant I had to give up HAm Radio for a while and I was off the air for 19 years.? When I was more or less settled?(in Baton Rouge), I erected a small 40 ft. tower, a tribander and pulled out my original radios, a Drake R4B, Heathkit SB400 and a homebrew linear using a pair of 4-400 tubes.? I was on the air.
I attended a Dayton hamvention in the mid 1990's for the specific?reason to find a Sherwood modified R4C and T4XC.? At the convention I found 2 of them, bought one and then (in those days) hand carried both boxes on board the airplane and brought them home.? I completely restored both boxes and for the next WWDX?CW contest, put them on the air, barefoot with the tribander.? That weekend I worked DXCC (all CW) and took advantage of the wonderful band conditions.
To shorten further, this rewarding restoring experience caused me to start a collection of various ham stuff, mostly Drake.? Now the Drake pieces number around 35, most needing restoration, with several Johnson and Central Electronics boxes in the mix.? The peak of this menagerie?is the TR7B (my nomenclature?for the TR8 proof of concept radio), a TR8 (perhaps one of several) and the only L85 amplifier.? I plan to get these working but am severely?hampered with a zero count of any documentation.? I have the radios, they appear complete, but have no paperwork.? The radios that I restore are then "loaned " to new hams to get them started.? None of these have ever come back, but they have served to launch several hams.? And so, it will continue.
So, thank you for your patience but I had hoped that with my love of teaching, the experience?of restoring old radios and the willingness to share that experience would have been rewarded with a more open and friendly atmosphere.? Simply put, I have been there and for the most part done that.? If what I have to say does not fit the formula and the wording that is acceptable to those with the questions, then my teaching?skills have withered.? Again, Sorry.? But I will continue to monitor, but will likely?limit my participation in these realms.
Thank?you again for your kind?comments and for your patience.? I feel better already.
David Assaf III W5XU, VP8RXU ?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 2:21?PM Michael Smith via <tw8kcabpilot= [email protected]> wrote: David, Consider everyone¡¯s response, so not to be offended ¡ª no one ignored you; it may seem that way, though. ? We all learn from all the posts, no matter how much experience we have or training, etc.? My estimate, one way or another, most on this group are very knowledgeable, but keep in mind that no one is perfect, and sometimes circumstances get in the way of complete communication.? Expressions to the nth degree (as n goes to infinity) that Steve mentioned sums to form a well-bounded series: in other words, the composite is a well defined meaningful answer.? I am planning on starting restoration/repair or restart of some Drake tube radios I have, and have been contemplating just how to go about this.? The composite of this topic posting, including your comments, have helped me to conclude on a process or plan to bring up radios that have sitting dormant a long time.? So, the only part about your message that is erroneous from my perspective is as follows: your experience appears to be high, your knowledge is significant, and for the ¡°baloney¡± quotient, as the baloney increases in the denominator without bound (goes to infinity) in the limit, the quotient goes to zero.
Secondary, many of us have been in this situation, saying ¡°I¡¯ve tried everything.? What is wrong?¡± ?My entire day working as a medical-imaging systems field engineer for many years as a young man was spent with, ¡°What is wrong?¡± ?Sometimes the problem was baffling, sometimes just irritating.? I say this because it is refreshing for me to get a good chuckle (as intended) from introductory comments like Steve¡¯s, amidst dealing with a frustrating problem.? As I have a good laugh at the comment, because I¡¯ve been there, my pride factor diminishes greatly ¡ª a good thing.
Accept my suggestion, and of others, to keep reading and contributing when you can.
Peace,
73, Michael, N4KZO
|
This peaked my interest so I looked up my lab data for the SSB noise floor and sensitivity of the TR-4C and IC-705.? I don¡¯t measure AM sensitivity so I cannot
comment on that.? A legacy radio like a Drake in effect has a preamp (RF amplifier tube) in the circuit all the time.? The best comparison would be for the 705 with preamp 1 selected.? All measurement are with the SSB filter, 2.1 kHz for the TR-4C and 2.4
kHz for the IC-705. I can¡¯t find a spec for the TR-4C as to sensitivity on AM.
?
705 ??????? Noise Floor???????? Sensitivity
None???? -120 dBm???????????? 0.67 microvolts
Pre 1????? -131 dBm???????????? 0.20 microvolts
Pre 2????? -132 dBm???????????? 0.16 microvolts
?
TR-4C??? -124 dBm???????????? 0.40 microvolts
?
Rob, NC0B
?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
On Behalf Of Rob PA9Z
Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2024 1:06 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [DRAKE-RADIO] AM Reception TR-4C
?
Epilogue ?
Yesterday I hooked up my TR-4C to my R&S RF signal generator, and it turned out that the sensitivity in AM is not bad at all. ?It is even better that the sensitivity of my IC-705!
Case closed.
'73 de Rob PA9Z
|
Re: Nice-looking 2B with other gear
I was just talking to my Elmer about that globe scout yesterday, as a matter of fact. QTH must be monitoring my 2m rag chews.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Jan 11, 2024, at 9:06 AM, n4buq <n4buq@...> wrote:
?Saw this on QTH. No affiliation with the seller. Good thing I don't live in that area or I would have even more things in my shop!
Thanks, Barry - N4BUQ
|
Nice-looking 2B with other gear
Saw this on QTH. No affiliation with the seller. Good thing I don't live in that area or I would have even more things in my shop!
Thanks, Barry - N4BUQ
|
Epilogue ?
Yesterday I hooked up my TR-4C to my R&S RF signal generator, and it turned out that the sensitivity in AM is not bad at all. ?It is even better that the sensitivity of my IC-705!
Case closed. '73 de Rob PA9Z
|
And then you have SSB with carrier, H3E, which many modern transceivers call AM. That's a horse of a different color. There was a guy on Youtube not long ago who thought his newly acquired TR7 was broken because it was transmitting only one sideband on AM. I 'splained it to him. ,_reduced,_and_suppressed-carrier_SSB 73 -Jim NU0C On Wed, 10 Jan 2024 21:36:51 -0500 "Don Humphrey" <dscc1947@...> wrote: Richard your AM Analysis was very good. I would add AM distortion is in the ears of the beholder. Many
On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 4:32?PM Richard Knoppow <1oldlens1@...> wrote:
It is surprising to me (shouldn't be) how much confusion there is about AM. For one thing the term "distortion" means different things to different people. In almost prehistoric times, like the 1930s, distortion could mean any difference between the original signal and what comes out of the receiver, this included frequency response distortion. I think that is what was meant in the recent thread. However, more frequently "distortion" means a change in the waveform shape due to harmonics or intermodulation. The effect of a narrow bandpass on AM is to affect the frequency response. Simply, for a given signal bandwidth AM requires twice the bandwidth of SSB. By tuning to one side its possible to extend the bandwidth, however, the carrier is affected by the shape of the filter. If the filter does not have a flat pass band the carrier will be reduced resulting in harmonic and IM distortion. The effect is similar to overmodulation. So, how much bandwidth does one need? For intelligible speech probably at least six Khz and for music considerably more. Now, there are other sources of distortion, for instance intermodulation of the higher frequencies by the low frequencies due to to the AVC modulating the signal. If the AVC speed is high this will happen. You can hear the difference by turning off the AVC. There are other sources. Getting clean AM demodulation is not trivial. Anyway, one must be careful of terms to make sure everyone understands what one is talking about.
On 1/10/2024 1:01 PM, Rick W4XA wrote:
Rob, don't put too much effort measuring the sensitivity of your TR-4C and R-4C .
If you hear an obvious increase in the noise level when connecting the antenna to the TR-4C in the AM position, while it may not be as sensitive as the R-4C, it will still be "enough"!
Cheers!
Rick
//
On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 12:33 PM, Rob PA9Z wrote:
Thanks folks,
Indeed, the TR-4C doesn't seem to be the ideal rig for AM. Luckily I also have the 4C twins, and the R-4C does AM very well. I could accept the 'distortion' caused by squeezing AM through the SSB filter, but I also have the impression that the sensitivity of the TR-4C receiver in AM is significantly less then SSB. I will compare that with the R-4C. Meanwhile I think I need to accept the limited AM functionality of the TR-4C.
'73 de Rob PA9Z
--
/*73/Rick*/
//*W4XA **///Every post is created using Linux * */ -- Richard Knoppow Los Angeles WB6KBL SKCC 19998
-- 73 -Jim NU0C
|
The end of my previous message got deleted. I was going to say ,"many Audiophiles think no semiconductor can replace a big tube glowing in the dark."
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Richard your AM Analysis was very good. I would add AM distortion is in the ears of the
beholder. Many
On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 4:32?PM Richard Knoppow < 1oldlens1@...> wrote: ? ? It is surprising to me (shouldn't be) how much confusion there is
about AM. For one thing the term "distortion" means different things to
different people. In almost prehistoric times, like the 1930s,
distortion could mean any difference between the original signal and
what comes out of the receiver, this included frequency response
distortion. I think that is what was meant in the recent thread.
However, more frequently "distortion" means a change in the waveform
shape due to harmonics or intermodulation. The effect of a narrow
bandpass on AM is to affect the frequency response. Simply, for a given
signal bandwidth AM requires twice the bandwidth of SSB. By tuning to
one side its possible to extend the bandwidth, however, the carrier is
affected by the shape of the filter. If the filter does not have a flat
pass band the carrier will be reduced resulting in harmonic and IM
distortion. The effect is similar to overmodulation. So, how much
bandwidth does one need? For intelligible speech probably at least six
Khz and for music considerably more.
? ? ?Now, there are other sources of distortion, for instance
intermodulation of the higher frequencies by the low frequencies due to
to the AVC modulating the signal. If the AVC speed is high this will
happen. You can hear the difference by turning off the AVC. There are
other sources. Getting clean AM demodulation is not trivial.
? ? Anyway, one must be careful of terms to make sure everyone
understands what one is talking about.
On 1/10/2024 1:01 PM, Rick W4XA wrote:
> Rob, don't put too much effort measuring the sensitivity of your TR-4C
> and R-4C .
>
> If you hear an obvious increase in the noise level when connecting the
> antenna to the TR-4C in the AM position, while it may not be as
> sensitive as the R-4C, it will still be "enough"!
>
> Cheers!
>
> Rick
>
> //
>
> On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 12:33 PM, Rob PA9Z wrote:
>
>? ? ?Thanks folks,
>
>? ? ?Indeed, the TR-4C doesn't seem to be the ideal rig for AM. Luckily I
>? ? ?also have the 4C twins, and the R-4C does AM very well.? I could
>? ? ?accept the 'distortion' caused by squeezing AM through the SSB
>? ? ?filter, but I also have the impression that the sensitivity of the
>? ? ?TR-4C receiver in AM is significantly less then SSB.? I will compare
>? ? ?that with the R-4C.? Meanwhile I think I need to accept the limited
>? ? ?AM functionality of the TR-4C.
>
>? ? ?'73 de Rob PA9Z
>
>
>
> --
>
>
>? ? ? ? ?/*73/Rick*/
>
> //*W4XA
> **///Every post is created using Linux *
> */
>
--
Richard Knoppow
Los Angeles
WB6KBL
SKCC 19998
|
Richard your AM Analysis was very good. I would add AM distortion is in the ears of the
beholder. Many
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 4:32?PM Richard Knoppow < 1oldlens1@...> wrote: ? ? It is surprising to me (shouldn't be) how much confusion there is
about AM. For one thing the term "distortion" means different things to
different people. In almost prehistoric times, like the 1930s,
distortion could mean any difference between the original signal and
what comes out of the receiver, this included frequency response
distortion. I think that is what was meant in the recent thread.
However, more frequently "distortion" means a change in the waveform
shape due to harmonics or intermodulation. The effect of a narrow
bandpass on AM is to affect the frequency response. Simply, for a given
signal bandwidth AM requires twice the bandwidth of SSB. By tuning to
one side its possible to extend the bandwidth, however, the carrier is
affected by the shape of the filter. If the filter does not have a flat
pass band the carrier will be reduced resulting in harmonic and IM
distortion. The effect is similar to overmodulation. So, how much
bandwidth does one need? For intelligible speech probably at least six
Khz and for music considerably more.
? ? ?Now, there are other sources of distortion, for instance
intermodulation of the higher frequencies by the low frequencies due to
to the AVC modulating the signal. If the AVC speed is high this will
happen. You can hear the difference by turning off the AVC. There are
other sources. Getting clean AM demodulation is not trivial.
? ? Anyway, one must be careful of terms to make sure everyone
understands what one is talking about.
On 1/10/2024 1:01 PM, Rick W4XA wrote:
> Rob, don't put too much effort measuring the sensitivity of your TR-4C
> and R-4C .
>
> If you hear an obvious increase in the noise level when connecting the
> antenna to the TR-4C in the AM position, while it may not be as
> sensitive as the R-4C, it will still be "enough"!
>
> Cheers!
>
> Rick
>
> //
>
> On Wed, Jan 10, 2024 at 12:33 PM, Rob PA9Z wrote:
>
>? ? ?Thanks folks,
>
>? ? ?Indeed, the TR-4C doesn't seem to be the ideal rig for AM. Luckily I
>? ? ?also have the 4C twins, and the R-4C does AM very well.? I could
>? ? ?accept the 'distortion' caused by squeezing AM through the SSB
>? ? ?filter, but I also have the impression that the sensitivity of the
>? ? ?TR-4C receiver in AM is significantly less then SSB.? I will compare
>? ? ?that with the R-4C.? Meanwhile I think I need to accept the limited
>? ? ?AM functionality of the TR-4C.
>
>? ? ?'73 de Rob PA9Z
>
>
>
> --
>
>
>? ? ? ? ?/*73/Rick*/
>
> //*W4XA
> **///Every post is created using Linux *
> */
>
--
Richard Knoppow
Los Angeles
WB6KBL
SKCC 19998
|