Re: CPNC and Patents
In a message dated 05/08/2000 3:37:44 AM Hawaiian Standard Time,
tbarnard@... writes:
<< A patent is a legal right to sue !
TAB >>
Only while the Patent is in force. I think the maximum
By
ptengin@...
·
#7543
·
|
Re: CPNC
The only thing that bothers me is a brief note in response to to a question
in the Simple Step pdf. It's on the next to last page and is their FAQ.
-quote-
Q. How far can I move if your board can
By
Ray Henry <rehenry@...>
·
#7533
·
|
Re: Some pictures of a retrofit
I notice that those stepper motors were 150 ox in motors. I would suggest
300 oz inches would be better. I put those (300) on my retrofit and they
worked very well. One other thing you may want to do
By
Dan Mauch
·
#7534
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
You are correct. If the patent holder wishes, they could shut down everyone
you mentioned plus many more companies. It just depends if the patent holder
knows that the other companies exist and if
By
Tim Barnard <tbarnard@...>
·
#7532
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
As far as I know they did not. Please remember that Haas is in court all the
time for one thing or another. They have a law firm on retainer to handle
these type of problems. If it had been a one time
By
Tim Barnard <tbarnard@...>
·
#7531
·
|
Re: Digest Number 482
Re: PROJECTS STILL ON THE BURNER?
It now appears I can get my Beast (the 1984 Leadwell-Ramco) of a milling
machine to accept drip-feed input through its RS-232 port. I tracked down
the people who
By
Andrew Werby <drewid@...>
·
#7545
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
I have been following this thread this morning and have a real problem with
all this patent stuff. Sure people have a right to protect their designs
but if you come up with a new way to build your
By
John Guenther <jguenther@...>
·
#7530
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
Wow, that's cheap. Panels on IP law appear from time to time at
computer conferences, and the minimum price they report for an
innocent company to either defend their patent, or defend
By
Brian Bartholomew <bb@...>
·
#7529
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
For what I could find out, it cost around $200,000 to fight Hurco. About
half of what Hurco wanted to settle out of court.
TAB
By
Tim Barnard <tbarnard@...>
·
#7528
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
Most companies figured it was less costly to pay Hurco than to fight them in
court. Gene Haas had a different opinion.
TAB
By
Tim Barnard <tbarnard@...>
·
#7527
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
The judge said that Hurco's patents were based on PC technology that was
available at the time the were formulated. Since Hurco did not revise their
patents to keep up with the changes in the
By
Tim Barnard <tbarnard@...>
·
#7526
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
What conspiracy? It's front and center in the USPTO's press releases.
The USPTO has been reorganized to run as a business. Its tax funding
has been reduced to only partially cover its budget, and a
By
Brian Bartholomew <bb@...>
·
#7525
·
|
Re: Grizzly products
I hate to say this but I have not seen any machine tool come out of Taiwan that could be called great. Usable maybe.
Larry
Larry Edington wrote:
By
lawrence jackman <ljack70117@...>
·
#7524
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
And it cost the innocent defendant how many million dollars in legal
fees before justice was delivered?
Brian
By
Brian Bartholomew <bb@...>
·
#7523
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
Matt Shaver wrote:
Well, what happened with this suit? It makes claims almost as
outrageous
as Hurco, implying a vast conspiracy! I have some doubts that large
companies would pay off millions on
By
Jon Elson <jmelson@...>
·
#7522
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
Ron Ginger wrote:
Apparently, Haas didn't pay, and has been vindicated in court. I don't
know whether it was determined that the Haas product doesn't
infringe, or that the Hurco patents were
By
Jon Elson <jmelson@...>
·
#7521
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
From what I can tell, no.
1. Read this:
http://www.computerip.com/final.pdf
2. If you like, put my name in the README as the person to contact regarding
patent infringement issues and then
By
Matt Shaver <mshaver@...>
·
#7520
·
|
Re: CPNC and Patents
Nearly all of the patents in the software field are crazy, and whether
you'll be prosecuted depends on how much money you have to take.
Non-profit groups who don't challenge the powerful have
By
Brian Bartholomew <bb@...>
·
#7519
·
|
Re: Grizzly products
In that case, the Griz is a great mini mill for small parts. It's so much
better than a Sherline or Taig,
it's amazing. Real steel construction! I've got a PC with my CNC control
software sitting
By
Larry Edington <larrye@...>
·
#7518
·
|
Re: CPNC
thanks for the note, I pulled the docs on Friday and read them over. It
does indeed sound like a fine way to run steppers under windows. I think
I may order one and try to modify my current VB program
By
Ron Ginger <ginger@...>
·
#7517
·
|