开云体育

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

Lunar Rate


 

Hello Everyone, my first day here,
?
I want to photograph the Moon continuously for several hours and want to keep the Moon positioned (stationary) in the field of view.
?
I will select the Lunar Rate in the menu, but the Moon does not move at the same speed every day.
?
So how/where do I find out the speed of the Moon on a particular day, and can I match with the same speed in a C14?
?
Thanks for your insights.
?
Ajay Talwar



 

开云体育

Interesting question.? I didn't know about the variable speed Moon.? That's new to me, so I'm interested in the answer too.
?
Ray



From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Ajay Talwar via groups.io
Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 7:05 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [C14EdgeHD] Lunar Rate

Hello Everyone, my first day here,
?
I want to photograph the Moon continuously for several hours and want to keep the Moon positioned (stationary) in the field of view.
?
I will select the Lunar Rate in the menu, but the Moon does not move at the same speed every day.
?
So how/where do I find out the speed of the Moon on a particular day, and can I match with the same speed in a C14?
?
Thanks for your insights.
?
Ajay Talwar



 

开云体育

Hello Ajay,

Excellent question indeed !

I have an Astrophysics 1200 mount and I have been asking for years for having a true lunar tracking. Mount manufactures don't care at all. Probably because most people are only interested in deep sky imaging ?

First thing, the Moon has a motion in delta and alpha. Both motions, even the alpha motion, is not constant for one day to the other. This means that the alpha lunar tracking rate changes continuously.

You can get information here (sorry in French)

First, you choose the object (Lune = Moon) , then the period of time.

The columns of interest are :

- (3rd from right) delta alpha cos delta = tracking rate in alpha

- (2nd from right) delta delta : tracking rate in delta


So for now, I don't know of any mount having tracking rate according to the true lunar tracking rate.

As for myself, I am interesting in high resolution lunar imaging. For example :


Having a true lunar tracking would make acquisition much more comfortable.

If you need accurate long duration tracking, the most promising method is to use the auto-tracking mode of Firecapture (or other acquisition software). This solve the issue neatly.

Hope this helps

Christian Viladrich


Le 01/02/2022 à 15:04, Ajay Talwar via groups.io a écrit?:

Hello Everyone, my first day here,
?
I want to photograph the Moon continuously for several hours and want to keep the Moon positioned (stationary) in the field of view.
?
I will select the Lunar Rate in the menu, but the Moon does not move at the same speed every day.
?
So how/where do I find out the speed of the Moon on a particular day, and can I match with the same speed in a C14?
?
Thanks for your insights.
?
Ajay Talwar



 

开云体育

The orbit of the Moon "around" the Earth is not circular. In other words, Moon-Earth distance keeps changing, so the apparent speed of the Moon. This is not a big deal for usual observation

Christian

Le 01/02/2022 à 20:15, Ray Stann a écrit?:

Interesting question.? I didn't know about the variable speed Moon.? That's new to me, so I'm interested in the answer too.
?
Ray


From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Ajay Talwar via groups.io
Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 7:05 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [C14EdgeHD] Lunar Rate

Hello Everyone, my first day here,
?
I want to photograph the Moon continuously for several hours and want to keep the Moon positioned (stationary) in the field of view.
?
I will select the Lunar Rate in the menu, but the Moon does not move at the same speed every day.
?
So how/where do I find out the speed of the Moon on a particular day, and can I match with the same speed in a C14?
?
Thanks for your insights.
?
Ajay Talwar



 

Hello Christian,

Thanks for this information, quite useful. But I wonder if I can incorporate this in my mount - CGE pro (tracking rate).

The other suggestion was to guide on a feature on the Moon using Firecapture was indeed suitable (Thanks to the gentleman who suggested, I lost that email unfortunately).

Problem still not fully solved, as firecapture cannot use a DSLR. I may get to use a camera that firecapture recognises.

Best to All
Ajay Talwar

Nightscape Gallery:
TWAN Gallery:



On Wednesday, February 2, 2022, 02:07:37 AM GMT+5:30, christian viladrich <c.viladrich@...> wrote:


Hello Ajay,

Excellent question indeed !

I have an Astrophysics 1200 mount and I have been asking for years for having a true lunar tracking. Mount manufactures don't care at all. Probably because most people are only interested in deep sky imaging ?

First thing, the Moon has a motion in delta and alpha. Both motions, even the alpha motion, is not constant for one day to the other. This means that the alpha lunar tracking rate changes continuously.

You can get information here (sorry in French)

First, you choose the object (Lune = Moon) , then the period of time.

The columns of interest are :

- (3rd from right) delta alpha cos delta = tracking rate in alpha

- (2nd from right) delta delta : tracking rate in delta


So for now, I don't know of any mount having tracking rate according to the true lunar tracking rate.

As for myself, I am interesting in high resolution lunar imaging. For example :


Having a true lunar tracking would make acquisition much more comfortable.

If you need accurate long duration tracking, the most promising method is to use the auto-tracking mode of Firecapture (or other acquisition software). This solve the issue neatly.

Hope this helps

Christian Viladrich


Le 01/02/2022 à 15:04, Ajay Talwar via groups.io a écrit?:
Hello Everyone, my first day here,
?
I want to photograph the Moon continuously for several hours and want to keep the Moon positioned (stationary) in the field of view.
?
I will select the Lunar Rate in the menu, but the Moon does not move at the same speed every day.
?
So how/where do I find out the speed of the Moon on a particular day, and can I match with the same speed in a C14?
?
Thanks for your insights.
?
Ajay Talwar