¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

Looking for an off axis guider recommendation


 

I have a CGE1400 and am interested in purchasing an off axis guider.? I have an Orion Starshoot and a Canon T3i.? What would be the recommended OAG for my setup?? Thanks in advance!

Mike



 

I don't really have a specific brand recommendation but here are some issue that I've encountered or am aware of:


An OAG will?add to?the back-focus distance and?the effect of that?depends on the scope (Edge-HD or Classical?), external optics (reducer?), filter wheel, etc.??In particular, a?reduced Edge-HD is very particular about that distance and it may be difficult/detrimental to insert another gadget into the imaging train.


Also, the mechanics of an OAG can range from simple to sophisticated, particularly the ability and ease of camera rotation and pick-off mirror distance and rotation. Also the focusing mechanism for the guide camera can range to virtually non-existent (simply slide the cam in/out) to fine-control.? And some OAG have integrated or compatible filter-wheels, etc. There are motorized OAG.? Obviously these issue dictate the cost.


Top-end OAG are heavy.?The C-14 is heavy enough that it probably won't be an issue. But it does potentially stress the mechanical imaging chain and?might induce flexure, which is not good.


It can be a real pain to locate guide stars and if you rotate the entire unit (incl camera) then you have to take new flats.? So it is important to pre-plan all imaging fields prior to imaging.?Use "The Sky" to?map your shots.


There are some reasons that DSLR does not?benefit much (or at all) from long sub-exps (e.g. even in a dark sky the sub-exp can become dark-current limited, similar to sky limited; also the uncontrolled temp can be problematic for long sub-exps).?If your mount alone (or with a modest external guider) can handle a?minute or so?then an OAG might not?make much of an improvement.


Stan


 

I tried using an OAG with my C14 EdgeHD and found it impossible to calibrate and use my autoguider (Loadstar and PHD).? This had to do with marginal seeing causing way too much drift during calibration. Long focal length autoguiding is not for the faint of heart.? Some people have success with this configuration but I've chosen to use a 1000mm fl guidescope and have had great success with it.


 

You might want to consider the ONAG XT On-Axis Guider.? I use one on my old C8, and it works very well.



Tim Lahey