¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Bind threading


 

Even to from cover of this site the compound is 90¡ã.?

Dave?


 

And that means exactly nothing.? It is rotatable and just happens to be in that position.? It rotates so that it CAN be used in different positions.? Not to be put in that position and left there forever.

Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer

On Friday, January 26, 2024 at 07:33:13 AM PST, davesmith1800 <davesmith1@...> wrote:


Even to from cover of this site the compound is 90¡ã.?

Dave?


 

¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

??? ??? Thats what the thread stop is for , the 2nd purpose . It was desgined for that purpose , not a " if " .

??? animal

On 1/25/24 8:50 PM, Charles Kinzer wrote:

I can see how that can be confusing.

If you are threading using ONLY the cross slide, the "thread stop" can be used as a limit for the depth of the thread cut.? That's pretty straight forward.

But there is another purpose.? If using the compound at an angle, it is typical to use the cross slide to retract the tool, move it for the next cut, and then move it back in (returns tool bit to starting position at the last cutting depth) while leaving the compound position alone.? In this case, the "thread stop" can be used so that when you return the cross slide for the next cut, it always returns to the same place.? (You don't have to read the handwheel - and it keeps you from making mistakes.)? Then you move the compound in further for the next cut.? In this case, it isn't really being used as a thread stop, but just as a cross slide stop so you always return it to the same place..

If you wanted a thread stop on the compound to limit motion to the maximum thread depth, you would have to rig something up for that unless somebody sells such a thing.? Most everything you can think of probably exists somewhere, but I'm not aware of a commercial stop for the mini lathe compound.

Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer

On Thursday, January 25, 2024 at 07:07:41 PM PST, davesmith1800 <davesmith1@...> wrote:


Here photo of almost the lathe one.
But not compound angle also a thread stop for same lathe can only be straight in. This where it gets confusing new at using a lathe.

I use the compound at 90¡ã so I can make fast changes using the carriage stop.?

Dave?

Attachments:


 

Actually, the original design was for neither of those purposes.? It was for setting each increment when using just the cross slide to cut threads.? Not as a full depth stop if moving in at increments with the cross slide handwheel, and not as a cross slide repeatability stop if using the compound.

The South Bend booklet "How to Run a Lathe" was most certainly an industry standard (and I think most would consider it authoritative), and this is from that book.??

Inline image

However, I have never seen anyone use the stop in the manner described in this booklet.? But just because I haven't doesn't mean people don't use one that way.? I have only seen the 29.5 (or 29) degree angle scheme mostly using, and the straight in sometimes used.

I think its original goal was to help prevent mistakes.? With cross slide threading, you withdraw a lot and then return to the starting point (often off the end of the workpiece being threaded).? Then you have to turn the handwheel back in remembering where it last was, and then adding whatever more you want for the next cut.? Easy to make a mistake, especially setting too deep of a cut.? Using the stop as they described would mitigate that.

One other point of confusion that some might have is that the term "thread stop" or "threading stop" also has a completely different meaning.? And that is for schemes that stop the longitudinal motion of the thread cutting at the end of the thread.

Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer

On Friday, January 26, 2024 at 10:57:25 AM PST, mike allen <animal@...> wrote:


??? ??? Thats what the thread stop is for , the 2nd purpose . It was desgined for that purpose , not a " if " .

??? animal

On 1/25/24 8:50 PM, Charles Kinzer wrote:
I can see how that can be confusing.

If you are threading using ONLY the cross slide, the "thread stop" can be used as a limit for the depth of the thread cut.? That's pretty straight forward.

But there is another purpose.? If using the compound at an angle, it is typical to use the cross slide to retract the tool, move it for the next cut, and then move it back in (returns tool bit to starting position at the last cutting depth) while leaving the compound position alone.? In this case, the "thread stop" can be used so that when you return the cross slide for the next cut, it always returns to the same place.? (You don't have to read the handwheel - and it keeps you from making mistakes.)? Then you move the compound in further for the next cut.? In this case, it isn't really being used as a thread stop, but just as a cross slide stop so you always return it to the same place..

If you wanted a thread stop on the compound to limit motion to the maximum thread depth, you would have to rig something up for that unless somebody sells such a thing.? Most everything you can think of probably exists somewhere, but I'm not aware of a commercial stop for the mini lathe compound.

Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer

On Thursday, January 25, 2024 at 07:07:41 PM PST, davesmith1800 <davesmith1@...> wrote:


Here photo of almost the lathe one.
But not compound angle also a thread stop for same lathe can only be straight in. This where it gets confusing new at using a lathe.

I use the compound at 90¡ã so I can make fast changes using the carriage stop.?

Dave?

Attachments:


 

Charles Kinzer
8:06am? ?
And that means exactly nothing. It is rotatable and just happens to be in that position

When first lath my father had a less experience that most have here.
So trial and error learning. We set compound to 29.5¡ã and that how we did threading.?

When I got Mori Seki Lathe in 1976 on the compound was large you want to straight in. Work great.

The South Bend Lathe cross slide stop was for production work. I hate to see the thread quilty.?

Dave?


 

I operated a 10 inch South Bend Precision Model for a long time.? Threading results were superb.

The thread stop doesn't mean you take a single cut.? You still take multiple cuts.? All it does is define the thread depth, and make it repeatable part to part, if doing straight in tool movement with the cross slide.? Or it gives you a repeatable reference, within the threading of a part, and part to part, for returning the cross slide to the exact same position ready for the next advance of the compound.? On a South Bend anyway, the thread stop means you get a very consistent position of the cross slide.

Also, saying "works great" doesn't mean much without saying material type, size, speed of threading, etc.? I have already mentioned there are cases that are tolerant of straight in threading, and cases where that would not be a good idea.

I might be beating a dead horse, but there are REASONS why using the angled compound for threading are taught in machine shop classes and have been widely used by machinists for longer than I've been alive.

Charles E. "Chuck" Kinzer

On Friday, January 26, 2024 at 01:43:48 PM PST, davesmith1800 <davesmith1@...> wrote:


Charles Kinzer
8:06am? ?
And that means exactly nothing. It is rotatable and just happens to be in that position

When first lath my father had a less experience that most have here.
So trial and error learning. We set compound to 29.5¡ã and that how we did threading.?

When I got Mori Seki Lathe in 1976 on the compound was large you want to straight in. Work great.

The South Bend Lathe cross slide stop was for production work. I hate to see the thread quilty.?

Dave?